Kenny Joe's Reviews > Sign of the Moon

Sign of the Moon by Erin Hunter
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
U 50x66
's review
May 11, 2011

it was ok
Read in May, 2011

Warrior cats warrior cats......
First of all let me just say about the series. I started with the first series when i was about 12, and i liked them. Now i'm 15 almost 16. I keep reading these books because hey i can't just stop after all this time. I'm hoping they'll at least finish out strong, but i honestly don't enjoy them at all anymore. Around the 3'd series "Power of Three" they started to decline rapidly. By the time the 4th series "Omen of the Stars" it really lost it's merit for me. There was much less violence then before, and the love story's have already been done in the first 18 books. I wish Erin would have found a better way to end it sooner. I don't think it's just that I've grown up, the're actually getting much worse...

About this book, "Sign of the Moon" there were no fights in the whole thing which i thought was strange and a little boring. Yea the darkforest is rising great do we really have to kill these cats AGAIN Erin? nothing notable happens within it's pages. I mean yea the plot comes a little bit further along, but not much. I think it could have been summed up much quicker. I pretty much feel that after I read it that I'm at the same place i started the book. I'ts like their prolonging the battle for the 6th book in the series and there finding completely RANDOM things to write about until then. I don't think they thought of any of this before they were writing these last couple books. They'll just be like oh hey maybe I'll make this happen because i randomly felt like it. Ever since we found out Lionblaze Hollyleaf and Jayfeather weren't actually Squirrelflights kids it felt like they were making up this stuff as they go along. So i'm just like what?
I'll finish out this series, but it better be the last one.


2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Sign of the Moon.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-3 of 3) (3 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tori (new)

Tori Honestly, I agree comletely with most of these reviews but yours shows the most truth in it.


♥SugarFlower♥ I think they need to see history before they fight. Just they the way in Harry Potter, he had to learn about Voldemort.


Luna Wolf U STARTED AT 12??!!!!! I STARTED WHN IS WAS TEN AND IM TEN NOW! SERIOUSLY, U TOOK A LONG TIME TO READ THEM. ITS ONLY BEEN ABOUT TWO MONTHS FOR MEH…
BURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRN.


back to top