Helia's Reviews > The Selection

The Selection by Kiera Cass
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
May 20, 2016

did not like it
bookshelves: romance, age-young-adult

I predicted from the beginning that The Selection and I just weren't meant to be, but I wanted to give it a chance before I dismissed it for another romance masquerading as a dystopia.

I'll start by saying I've never been a fan of stories about royalty. To me, all of them can be summed up as: a court of catty airheads + poor new girl + Mr Oh-So-Dreamy making her forget about the boy back home (case and point: Red Queen). And although I tried to go in with an open mind, The Selection had every one of the above qualities.

Honestly, it all seemed very shallow. Everything about this book screams artificial. Half the girls in the country seem prepared to marry a stranger just for his looks and fame rather than to support their families financially, apart from special snowflake America who is so superior to everyone even though she insists she doesn't know it. I just cannot believe that everyone aside from our protagonist could lack that kind of self respect.

All the girls criticise each others appearances (one girl even tried to tear someone else's dress off out of jealousy, which is quite frankly stupid), and America is no better. For someone who claims not to care about looks, it's literally all she talks about. Even before entering, America's main worries consist of her appearance, clothes, makeup, and secret boyfriend, whereas if her world were as bad as she made it out to be I can't understand why she wouldn't be doing more to support her family.

As for the world, it was incredibly weak. I not once sensed America's suffering. It was mentioned a couple of times how difficult it was to be in one of the lower castes, but it was never really shown.

America has no curiosity when it comes to the rebel attacks that were dotted throughout the book when the pace was going particularly slowly, nor did she seem to acknowledge there being finer and more complex details to palace life. Sure, the plot is so weak that there isn't much to talk about, but it's like she has no goals or interests, which makes her worse than the other girls. At least they all have the motive of wanting to marry Maxon.

Every single one of the characters felt bland and two dimensional. I would have accepted the lack of storyline if the characters were interesting or if the romance wasn't such an exhausting generic love triangle where not one of the three characters had any appeal.

Even the higher powers seem really dull and idiotic. Maxon's theory about the rebels is so obviously correct and yet his father refuses to believe him. I cannot understand how their country survives when the king is more stupid than a prince who creepily calls everyone 'my darling'.

This book had two rebel attacks with no explanation of motive and people actually compare it to The Hunger Games. To me, The Selection is nothing more than The Bachelor in a castle and has nothing more to it. No substance. Nothing. It can barely count as a dystopia because there's no world building or sufficient information. It drags itself out over no story and still somehow feels like it ends in the middle. The only praise I can give it was that the writing wasn't painful, otherwise reading this would've been sheer torture.

An ebook copy of this book was provided to me via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Read this review and more on Astronomical Books

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Selection.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 20, 2016 – Shelved
May 20, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
June 12, 2016 – Started Reading
June 13, 2016 –
20.0% "Is there even any substance to this book? Because so far it's literally The Batchelor with an added bonus of a castle."
June 14, 2016 –
37.0% "Kinda want to punch Maxon in the face already and America just met him. Speaking of America, I kinda want to punch her in the face too."
June 14, 2016 –
51.0% "Half way through and literally nothing has happened. I can't believe half the girls in the country lack enough self respect to be part of the Selection. Also the king not believing Maxon's theories about the rebel attacks? Idk how this country survives when the king is more stupid than a Prince who creepily calls everyone 'my darling'."
June 16, 2016 – Shelved as: romance
June 16, 2016 – Finished Reading
July 2, 2017 – Shelved as: age-young-adult

Comments (showing 1-1 of 1) (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Ellie I read this book when I was pretty new to young adult fiction and so I really liked it. However, looking at it from my perspective now, loads of things you said in your review I completely agree with. I don’t think I hate the book, but I certainly don’t hold it in high esteem which is a shame as I did like it before. Oh well – reading tastes change, I suppose

back to top