Misty's Reviews > What Would Mr Darcy Do?: A Pride and Prejudice Variation

What Would Mr Darcy Do? by Abigail Reynolds
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Apr 08, 2011

really liked it
bookshelves: janeite, arc-or-galley, review-copy-solicited, literary, read-in-2011, own
Read 3 times. Last read June 18, 2011 to June 19, 2011.

Though I was familiar with Abigail Reynolds and her Pride and Prejudice/Pemberley "variations" series (and had even seen this book with a different title, From Lambton to Longbourn ), I had never actually read anything by her.  I'm not sure why, maybe it was the covers or that there were just so many of them I was afraid they were churned out and passionless.  Whatever the reason, I didn't pick them up, and I see now that I need to rectify that.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book.  Did I enjoy it unreservedly on the level of Austen?  No, and I doubt I ever will of any Austen fanfic.  But did I enjoy it more than I generally do a fanfic?  Absolutely.  Reynolds captured the language and, more importantly, the feel and tone of Austen really well.  I actually felt like her Darcy and Lizzie were quite close to the Darcy and Lizzie I know and love, which is one of the tests for me: too many times, I barely recognize my Darcy and my Lizzie in fanfics, or their brightness shines through only sporadically.  This not only felt more authentic to who they are as Austen set them out, but it also expands on their characters rather nicely.  I was pleased with her treatment of Darcy, especially.  There were things revealed about him that made me actually reconsider Austen's Darcy in a new light, which is a rarity.  I felt that my knowledge and understanding of him was expanded, and I found myself rethinking some of the events of Pride and Prejudice and saying, You know, that kinda makes sense...  This was especially impressive to me because it was unexpected and doesn't really happen.  Reynolds showed great insight into the story and the chararacters, and human nature in general.

Another thing I really enjoyed was that it takes one teeny, tiny line from a pivotal moment and expands out down a path of "what-if?" in ways that seem realistic and make sense.  Reynolds stays true to the original story, working in key moments as if they are fixed, but also creates a new timeline and interactions and stays true to the path she sets out to explore.  With the fixed points, readers don't miss out on some of their favorite tension filled and/or swoonworthy moments; they just see them come about in a different way.  I especially liked that the path Reynolds took means that we see more of a struggle for Lizzie.  Knowing that Darcy spends months upon months in the original in the pain of love, it is nice to see some of that visited on Lizzie, and feel that they are on equal footing when it comes to overcoming obstacles and working and desiring each other on the same level.

For a more modern sensibility, Reynolds has given us some sexytime, which I have to say, I am always very hesitant about when it comes of Austen fanfic.  Not only does it bother me from the standpoint that a makeout sesh is wholly historically inappropriate for their stations, and would have been grounds for some duelage, but it also often just devolves into one smexy-but-meaningless encounter after another.  And though I don't mind that in other books (dotdotdot) I do mind it in my Austen.  Part of what I love about Austen is that things are kept so close to the vest, and that passion, no matter how strong and hard to restrain, is restrained (if only barely).  I love the struggle and the tension and the anticipation.  But many authors are writing from and to modern sensibilities, which often demand some sexytimes, and that can be disastrous.  Fortunately, Reynolds does a pretty good job with this.  There is good tension and the stirring up of butterflies, and some naughty but not too naughty make-out seshes that take it far enough without making the reader say "Really?"  There's also a sense of fun about it, too, that makes it work.

Needless to say, I will be reading more from Abigail Reynolds.
2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read What Would Mr Darcy Do?.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading (ebook Edition)
April 8, 2011 – Shelved
April 8, 2011 – Shelved as: janeite
April 8, 2011 – Shelved as: arc-or-galley
April 8, 2011 – Shelved as: review-copy-solicited
April 8, 2011 – Shelved as: literary
June 18, 2011 – Started Reading
June 19, 2011 – Shelved as: read-in-2011
June 19, 2011 – Finished Reading
October 13, 2011 – Shelved as: own
March 5, 2013 – Started Reading (ebook Edition)
March 5, 2013 – Finished Reading (ebook Edition)
March 6, 2013 – Shelved (ebook Edition)
March 6, 2013 – Shelved as: read-in-2013 (ebook Edition)

No comments have been added yet.