Clare Cannon's Reviews > Birthmarked

Birthmarked by Caragh M. O'Brien
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 24, 2011

it was amazing
bookshelves: young-adult, adults, 13-15yrs, favorites
Recommended to Clare by: Rated Reads
Recommended for: 13 years - adults
Read from May 29 to June 05, 2011

*Read my review of all 3 books in the series before deciding whether to read this!

I cannot wait for the sequel! I thought this would be a heavy read, but I was so wrong. It is everything a gripping dystopian should be, but has wonderful characters who grow through adversity and whose experiences afford powerful insights into what is most important in life.

A dark future world is divided between those who live inside the wall, and those - like sixteen year old Gaia Stone - who live outside. Gaia was trained as a midwife by her mother, and it's now her job to "advance" a quota of infants from poverty into the walled Enclave. Gaia has always been an obedient citizen, but when events reveal new information about the Enclave Gaia is determined to find out the truth and protect those she loves.

Gaia had a wonderful upbringing; her parents' depth and wisdom nourished her character so that she was ready to face difficulties with courage and selflessness. I loved the flash-backs to her childhood which show a beautiful relationship with both parents and the profound moral wisdom they passed on to her. On one occasion someone has stolen their animals, and her father surprises her by not being angry but forgiving the thieves, who "must have been very hungry". On another Gaia's mother is regretting having given her first two children to the Enclave as required by law; Gaia would excuse her for not having had a choice but her father corrects her: "You always have a choice, Gaia, you can always say no."

After ploughing through the self-serving false heroism of The Hunger Games series I felt like shouting this advice to the four winds. If only we heard it more often.

With a bad physical scar from a childhood accident, Gaia struggles to not only accept her appearance, but to acknowledge that the pity she loathes in others' eyes may in fact be sympathy; she sees she must learn to trust herself to others and not keep a barrier around herself.

There's a beautiful respect for life, maternity, newborn babies and children, and for so many other qualities like the dignity of work, of relationships, and the rich beauty of a multitude of characters choosing what is right.

The relationship between Leon and Gaia is realistic but perfect: their love grows for all the right reasons, they learn so much about each other and their flawed but earnest characters are the antithesis of Edward/Bella sentimentalism and Katniss/Peeta falseness. These two truly demonstrate sacrifice.

Younger readers should be aware of a few slightly confronting birth scenes (one right at the start), though I considered the realism a fitting setting for the weighty themes, giving life-like depth to the characters. There are also references to a serious occurrence in Leon's past that requires maturity and objectivity and may be misunderstood by younger readers. The context shows that Leon's actions were not culpable but there were still serious consequences including the suicide of a mentally ill young teen. Yet I thought even this event was treated with delicacy and dignity, and stimulated further growth in the characters.

The story itself is original, tightly written and moves at a fast pace, and truth be told it's impossible to put down. Once finished, the long wait for the sequel begins. What a surprise to find a contemporary dystopian that's rich and deep and inspires such hope in adversity.
52 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Birthmarked.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

05/29/2011 "I thought I couldn't handle another dystopian novel, but this one is un-put-downable!"
40.0% "So well written, and so many things to think about... not what I expected from a YA dystopian"
show 1 hidden update…

Comments (showing 1-15 of 15) (15 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by joy (new) - rated it 4 stars

joy *the clean-reader extraordinaire* i made the awful mistake of reading this one when it was first released -- march 2010! talk about a wait -- there wasn't even a title or publishing year available for the sequel!

Clare Cannon I know! My only consolation has been getting friends to read it and talking about it with them, so I keep re-living how good it is :)

message 3: by joy (new) - rated it 4 stars

joy *the clean-reader extraordinaire* my friends -- particularly those i'm related to -- tend to get angry when i recommend a fabulous book whose sequel is not yet available. i am not particularly popular right now, since Crossed doesn't come out for another couple months. ;)

Clare Cannon yes, that can be a bit difficult, but then they seem to deal with it the same way, by convincing their friends (and their students if they are teachers) to read it too... maybe shared agony is easier to bear?!

message 5: by Caragh (new) - added it

Caragh Can I sneak in here to say "Hi"? And thanks for the nice review?

Clare Cannon Hi Caragh :)
You're most welcome... and thanks for your stories!

message 7: by Caragh (new) - added it

Caragh My pleasure!

message 8: by joy (new) - rated it 4 stars

joy *the clean-reader extraordinaire* oooh... we've been graced by celebrity. :)

message 9: by Alicia (new) - added it

Alicia Great review. It makes me want to read this. I agree with what you said about the hunger games. I'm looking forward to trying this book!

message 10: by Erin (new)

Erin Does it have any romance?

Clare Cannon Yes :) that would be between Leon and Gaia - it's really good in this book

message 12: by Erin (new)

Erin Ok thanks!

message 13: by Emily (new)

Emily Adams Sorry to bring up old reviews I was wondering if you have read the second book and is it as good x

Clare Cannon Hi Emily, you can see my review of the second book here

message 15: by Emily (new)

Emily Adams thank you

back to top