Chrissie's Reviews > Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny
Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny
by Alexandra Lapierre
by Alexandra Lapierre
Chrissie's review
bookshelves: bio, great-britain, france, usa, arts, scotland, samoa, 2012-read
Jun 04, 2010
bookshelves: bio, great-britain, france, usa, arts, scotland, samoa, 2012-read
Read from February 20 to March 03, 2012
I HAD NO IDEA!!! This is continually how I reacted when I read about the life of Fanny Stevenson (1840-1914), the wife of Robert Louis Stevenson, the famed novelist, poet and travel writer (1850-1894). It was with continual wonder and surprise that I read the pages of this book. Beginning in the 1860s she traveled the world in a fashion that sounds imaginary. She traveled from Indianapolis, where she was born, to New York, then boat to the Panama Isthmus, on to San Francisco and then Nevada. The transcontinental railroad was not yet complete. To top it all off she traveled alone with her baby daughter, just a jingle of change and a few notes in her pocket. She traveled back a few years later. All her life she was a vagabond. Fed up with the antics of her first skirt-chasing husband she traveled again alone with her two young children to study art in France. Later, married to R.L.S., they sailed the South Pacific. Travel she did, and not always in luxury.
Usually she was fighting somebody or something – people or illness. She was a tremendously strong woman, clearly not an easy woman to live with. She broke society’s rules over and over again. She was one determined lady, set to do exactly what was necessary to achieve her goals. I did not find her goals selfish. Once married to the interminably sick Robert she had one goal, that being to keep him alive and aid him with his writing. Here again is another artist plagued by consumption. All medical authorities said living up in the mountain air would help. They tried Switzerland; he only grew sicker. So the warmth of the South Seas drew them, finally building their own home on a jungle covered island in Samoa. Does that sound like a dream world? Well, she built the pig-pens, planted the gardens, braved cyclones alone, continually caring for the health and career of the acclaimed author. It was a characteristic of her personality to defend the weak. And R. L.S. was the same.
She broke every rule of propriety. R.L.S. was eleven years her junior. After the author’s death she had other affairs, lived with another man, almost forty years her junior, who married her daughter when she herself died! She broke all rules.
Following travels around the world, the reader is not only given the details of family disputes, tumults and joys but also the politics of the domicile nations. As a famed couple they could pull strings and did not hesitate to do so. Fanny and R.L.S took on the fight for the underdog. They supported the machinations of Hawaiian King Kalakaua against American powers. They sought to help the lepers on Molokai. The history of the leper colony is given. R.L.S. risked his own health to visit the island, attempting to change their conditions and the public view of lepers. . They involved themselves in the civil war and international disputes of the Samoan Islands. History is detailed. To enjoy this book the reader must be interested in such history. The artist colonies in France at the turn of the century, the growth of Impressionism, the European cultural climate in art and writing at the turn of the 19th Century - all of this is covered.
This book is written a s a biography. The author separates herself from the individuals described in the pages. Fanny Stevenson is honored by some and disclaimed by others. To seek the truth, the author has thoroughly analyzed and documented her sources. In this way the reader sometimes observes rather than empathizes with the individuals. At the back of the book the sources are discussed in detail, chapter by chapter. Rather than using quotes, the lines from prime sources are put in italics in the central portion of the book. I found the numerous and lengthy sections in italics visually difficult to read, although they were skillfully woven into the narrative. For my part, the critical analysis and detachment displayed in the writing style detracted from the book’s punch.
I enjoyed learning about Fanny’s personality, her life with Robert Louis Stevenson, the blossoming world of art in France, the political climate in Hawaii, the Molokai leper colony and finally life and political tensions in Polynesia, all at the turn of the 20th Century. For this reason I give the book four stars.
Usually she was fighting somebody or something – people or illness. She was a tremendously strong woman, clearly not an easy woman to live with. She broke society’s rules over and over again. She was one determined lady, set to do exactly what was necessary to achieve her goals. I did not find her goals selfish. Once married to the interminably sick Robert she had one goal, that being to keep him alive and aid him with his writing. Here again is another artist plagued by consumption. All medical authorities said living up in the mountain air would help. They tried Switzerland; he only grew sicker. So the warmth of the South Seas drew them, finally building their own home on a jungle covered island in Samoa. Does that sound like a dream world? Well, she built the pig-pens, planted the gardens, braved cyclones alone, continually caring for the health and career of the acclaimed author. It was a characteristic of her personality to defend the weak. And R. L.S. was the same.
She broke every rule of propriety. R.L.S. was eleven years her junior. After the author’s death she had other affairs, lived with another man, almost forty years her junior, who married her daughter when she herself died! She broke all rules.
Following travels around the world, the reader is not only given the details of family disputes, tumults and joys but also the politics of the domicile nations. As a famed couple they could pull strings and did not hesitate to do so. Fanny and R.L.S took on the fight for the underdog. They supported the machinations of Hawaiian King Kalakaua against American powers. They sought to help the lepers on Molokai. The history of the leper colony is given. R.L.S. risked his own health to visit the island, attempting to change their conditions and the public view of lepers. . They involved themselves in the civil war and international disputes of the Samoan Islands. History is detailed. To enjoy this book the reader must be interested in such history. The artist colonies in France at the turn of the century, the growth of Impressionism, the European cultural climate in art and writing at the turn of the 19th Century - all of this is covered.
This book is written a s a biography. The author separates herself from the individuals described in the pages. Fanny Stevenson is honored by some and disclaimed by others. To seek the truth, the author has thoroughly analyzed and documented her sources. In this way the reader sometimes observes rather than empathizes with the individuals. At the back of the book the sources are discussed in detail, chapter by chapter. Rather than using quotes, the lines from prime sources are put in italics in the central portion of the book. I found the numerous and lengthy sections in italics visually difficult to read, although they were skillfully woven into the narrative. For my part, the critical analysis and detachment displayed in the writing style detracted from the book’s punch.
I enjoyed learning about Fanny’s personality, her life with Robert Louis Stevenson, the blossoming world of art in France, the political climate in Hawaii, the Molokai leper colony and finally life and political tensions in Polynesia, all at the turn of the 20th Century. For this reason I give the book four stars.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Fanny Stevenson.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
| 07/05/2016 | marked as: | read | ||
Comments (showing 1-18 of 18) (18 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Virginie
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 22, 2011 05:33AM
Chrissie, I loved this book so much! Unputdownable .I know this is one of these books I will have to re-read one day
reply
|
flag
*
It came in the mail today! :0) It is you that suggested it to me! The author is suppose to be fabulous.
I could not make up my mind last night..... I felt bad about quitting two books! I actually returned to River in the Sea. I want to know what happens but I do not think the book is well written. I am furthermore mad at myself for not liking Uncle Tungsten, but I must acknowledge that my chemistry is lacking. It certainly is essential to get the most out of this book. I DO think the family was fantastic - their view of knowledge was exciting and one cannot help but understand how someone living in such a family would become special. It made you want to do chemistry experiments and look at pinecones and sunflowers and fool with different lightbulbs...... Maybe I should go back to this one too. But to do it properly one should do some of the experiments he did. I felt like I could not remember everything if I didn't have a backup of hand-on experience.
The author of Stevenson's bio is very popular currently in France.
Excellent review, Chrissie, now I want to read the book more than ever. I wonder if I will like the detached style you describe, because for me, sometime such a style works very well in a non-fiction book and sometimes, it distracts and infuriates. I should check if the library has it (otherwise, I might buy a copy from Indigo, still boycotting Amazon a bit, but it's a pain for German books, sigh).
It is an absolutely excellent book. I can highly recommend it. I was simply not as attached to the characters as I would have wished to be. I believe this was due to the author's manner of writing.It is easier to get a hold of this book in French. She author is highly praised there. She has written many biographies.Gundula, maybe you can get your hands on a German copy. I had to order mine from ABe Books. It still has the pocket for a library card in it. I am glad you appreciated the review.
Chrissie wrote: "It is an absolutely excellent book. I can highly recommend it. I was simply not as attached to the characters as I would have wished to be. I believe this was due to the author's manner of writing...."I will definitely check ABE Books, but I find going to their website very dangerous for my pocket book, ha, ha, ha.
So, my library did not have this particular book, Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny, but it had another one that sounds really promising and also features Fanny Stevenson, among three other "good wives" Good Wives? by Margaret Forster from the 19th century to the present (looks promising, and I decided to request it).
Gundula wrote: "So, my library did not have this particular book, Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny, but it had another one that sounds really promising and also features Fanny Stevenson, among t..."Gundula, that book look great, too. I have read some books by Margaret Forster, especially Lady's Maid, that I really liked. She really gives you a feel for how things were for women back then. Now, sigh, I have to add ANOTHER book to my huge TBR.
Susan wrote: "Gundula wrote: "So, my library did not have this particular book, Fanny Stevenson: A Romance of Destiny, but it had another one that sounds really promising and also features Fanny St..."I also added Lady's Maid to my tbr pile (I always say I won't add more but that never happens, just yesterday, I added about 25 current German literature books I got as recommendations). I am looking forward to reading Good Wives?.
It will be interesting to see what you learn about Fanny through another author's eyes. I am being very restrictive about adding books to my shelves. Basically because I have just so many I am dying to read. So many are like us now. It was wasn't like this when GR began.
Barbara wrote: "I HAD NO IDEA!! Wonderful review, Chrissie. This is an amazing, intriguing tale."I was hoping you would see the review, since we have in the past discussed Stevenson. I am so glad you liked the review.
You might enjoy her diary, titled for publication "The Cruise of the Janet Nichol Among the South Sea Islands."


