Brett Williams's Reviews > The Spirit of American Government

The Spirit of American Government by James Allen Smith
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

really liked it
Read 2 times. Last read January 5, 2014 to January 30, 2014.

While historically relevant, Smith's no match for the Founders.

Smith’s book is of value for a variety of reasons: He challenges common assumptions; his work marks initiation of the “progressive movement” leading in part to modern liberalism (as opposed to classical liberalism); he has some exceptional insights on changes in production between early and modern (1907) capitalistic systems; emancipation was for him a business-driven cost savings, as hiring freed labor was cheaper than buying slaves and housing them; and his arguments against the Founders—for most cases—show how right they were.

Influenced by the abuses of Robber-Barons in the late 19th century, Smith is an angry voice looking for someone to blame. His book is said to be the first revisionist spin on our Constitution and Founders, perhaps too sacred before Smith’s antagonist position (which was already in the air). In the end, Smith wanted a different form of governance, a form the Founders made explicitly clear they opposed, though Smith almost always makes their position one of subversion and ulterior motives. Smith’s suspicions appear initiated by the Convention’s secrecy, even underhandedness by the Federalists, and this sets the tone of his entire view. While Smith raises a number of valid arguments, much of his book merely postulates or reads the minds of the Founders and their “true” intent. Then as is so over-worn today, he repeats this muse over and over. Like torturing a lie long enough until it claims to be the truth. Often, however, Smith correctly states the Founder’s intent, then recasts it as evil: “[Their aim was] to eliminate as far as possible the direct influence of the people on legislation and public policy.” Thankfully.

Thus does Smith display time-after-time how naïve he is to the ills of true democracy—e.g., the immediate servicing of its passions, resulting in society-wide grief exemplified by the union of Socrates and hemlock. An approximation to this being Congress’ failure to dutifully follow the Constitution while the Executive deified it in the 2003 Iraq debacle. Cooler heads realized too late both the purpose of Constitutional delays and cost of circumventing them. For Smith, these Constitutional blocks are only to protect a rich and powerful minority, thwarting majority rule. He confuses concerns for long-term stability with the selfish concerns of a few. His position that wealth or influence of the Founders denied them any capacity to see past their own concerns is like saying Teddy Kennedy legislated only for the rich. Resolving errors in excess capitalism with a medication of pure democracy would be to apply the wrong prescription, only to make the patient worse. Smith asks if the Framer’s intent was to check the government or the people. He ignores the answer was both.

Painfully lacking are comparisons of a republic (which is what we have) to a democracy, the Bill Of Rights, and Federalist / Anti-Federalist debates over central issues. Through these debates, we see the brilliance, and occasional absurdity on both sides, with intelligent compromise and shortcomings resulting in the final work. Above all, though highly charged and followed by real animosity between some, unlike 2020 America, rational thought prevailed in 1787. Smith, on the other hand, sounds too much like modern American liberalism and religious fundamentalism (add Trumpism) where emotion trumps rationale in appeals not to be investigated.

At the very end of his book, Smith takes a turn for the more radical, redefining democracy. He writes, “[Democracy] demands control of the state so the end product of industry may be equally distributed.” Noting this is not “a mere scheme for redistribution of wealth… It is fundamentally a theory of social progress.” Given Smith died in 1926, he had no opportunity to read Hayek’s 1944 “Road To Serfdom.”
2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Spirit of American Government.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading (Kindle Edition)
January 5, 2014 – Started Reading
January 30, 2014 – Finished Reading
August 15, 2014 – Shelved
April 16, 2020 – Shelved (Kindle Edition)

Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Pat (new) - added it

Pat Rolston Brilliant review that offers a deeply informed perspective worthy of publication.

back to top