A reminder here that I try for no spoilers, but don’t read on if you’re worried I may give something away. I haven’t had any complaints yet, but I knoA reminder here that I try for no spoilers, but don’t read on if you’re worried I may give something away. I haven’t had any complaints yet, but I know I’m the type of reader who wants to know virtually nothing about the storyline of the next book in a series I’m reading. There’s your fair warning.
Sanderson had hundreds of main characters, and hundreds of story arcs, to cover in this one. A close friend and I have discussed how this series would end for years and neither of us could comprehend how Sanderson could put the finishing touches on this one. While there were a couple small areas we complained about after finishing the series, the rest of the story was amazing enough that it didn’t change the way we felt one bit. The Wheel of Time series is, and will continue to be, one of the greatest epic fantasies ever told.
I didn’t think it was possible, but Sanderson kept an unbelievable pace throughout the entire novel. The chapters and sections were shorter than in previous WoT (Wheel of Time) books, but not only did it work well, I believe it was needed in this case. The reader is all over the map at first as we’re brought into the state of mind of all the characters and reminded where we’re headed: Tarmon Gai’don, the final battle, possibly the end of all things.
The final battle isn’t just one battle, but many. Some on a larger scale and some that are small yet lead to larger fights that may or may not be known by the other characters. Matrim, Perrin, Rand, Egwene, Nynaeve, Lan, Tam, and I could go on, all have their part to play, and they’re each significant.
Best Aspects of the Book
Sanderson keeps to the storyline and to Jordan’s vision of an epic story while continuing to focus on the individuals and their actions that brings us to the final climax.
Again, THE PACING! I swear my heart was racing through almost every page of this darn book. Not just the battle scenes, but with every decision the characters made bringing us closer to the end of the world, and the book.
The epic battle scenes. Sorry for using the word “epic” again, but it’s the only word that encompasses the breadth of this story. The tactics, the blood, the soldiers, the individuals; they all play significant roles in the final battle. Another reviewer said something similar, but the way the scenes played out it was as if Sanderson had first hand knowledge of that battle, as if he were there copying down what he saw.
Many may not see this as a positive, but it made the book more realistic in my opinion. Characters are dying all over the place in this one. It makes sense considering it was the final battle. If we’d had this grand battle to only have a few characters die, not only would it not have been as realistic, but the reader wouldn’t be on the edge of their seat wondering when their other favorite characters were going to “wake up from the dream,” as the Aiel would say.
Sanderson completed so many story arcs in one this one book that it was simply amazing. In a recent conversation with the friend I mentioned above, we discussed how Sanderson could have easily written another four or five books in the series with each of those story arcs being a story of their own.
The Negative Aspects
With how much I loved this story, it’s hard for me to say anything negative. However, I try to keep an unbiased tone when I write a review, though that’s pretty much impossible in this situation. While I say some of these things are negative, it’s only my opinion and other readers may disagree.
Where was Thom Merrilin? No, he wasn’t removed from the story, and he played an important role, but I loved his character and I wanted more. With the how big of a part of the story he was throughout, I thought there would be more.
There were some parts that were 100% Sanderson, particular lines especially. He sticks to a Jordanesque style throughout the previous two books he wrote, yet in this one, I felt there were times when the things he wrote were something Jordan probably would have done so differently. Of course, we’ll never know, and I’ve no doubt that Sanderson did the better than any other author could have in his position. My argument against this is that I’m not sure Jordan could have completed this series the way Sanderson did, and that’s saying a lot, because I love Jordan’s writing. Before this book, I wasn’t completely sold that Sanderson could finish the WoT series the way it should have been. Now, I can see that Robert Jordan and his wife picked the perfect author to finish this epic story.
This part goes with one of the positive aspects. I mentioned that Sanderson completed so many story arcs above, but there were some I wish he’d spent more time on. “Wish” is the key word there. We all wish we could read more of our favorite book or series, but that’s just not possible. I won’t mention which one, but there was one point that had been alluded to almost since the first book, and then when we reach the actual moment, it’s over in less than two pages. I can’t complain too much, the story arc was completed, even if not in the way that I had imagined.
The actual ending. I could probably put this in both the positive and the negative. In my mind, it fit perfectly. So why does it go in the negative section? Because, in my mind, there were just enough questions left that the ending read like the final line was a precursor to the next book in the series, which of course we won’t have. I think my brain is still working on what exactly I think about everything.
I give A Memory of Light by Robert Jordan and Brandon Sanderson five of five stars, and the series itself, five of five stars. If you’re looking for a true epic fantasy with an epic story line, an epic cast, and now an epic ending, the Wheel of Time is for you....more
Of the original seven books in the Dark Tower series, book four, The Wizard and the Glass, was my favorite. This surprised me even at the time I readOf the original seven books in the Dark Tower series, book four, The Wizard and the Glass, was my favorite. This surprised me even at the time I read it because it read like a western rather than a sci-fi fantasy like the rest of the books in the series. I’ve never had much interest in the western book genre.
When I heard TWTK (The Wind Through the Keyhole) brought back young Roland soon after he became a gunslinger, I was ecstatic. I couldn’t wait to get my hands on the next book in the Dark Tower Series.
Almost Gave it Four Stars
About halfway through the book, I felt I’d been had, that I was tricked into buying this book I thought involved young Roland. He is involved, but only for ten to fifteen percent of the book at most.
We start with Roland Deschaine as an adult, traveling with Eddie, Susannah, Jake, and Oy. Expected since that’s who Roland had with him at this point in the series. I assumed he’d tell a story about his younger days as a gunslinger, and he did. But this is the part when I became a little upset.
Young Roland goes on to tell a story of his own. We end up three levels deep in this story. The storyteller tells of a storyteller telling a story! It was easy to follow, so that wasn’t an issue, but I bought TWTK to read about young Roland Deschaine, Gunslinger of Gilead.
I’ve been a Stephen King fan for years so I stuck it out and I’m glad I did. The story young Roland tells is in fact, a great story. After I got past my little whine fest, I thoroughly enjoyed the book.
There are lessons to be learned, magical elements, a new race of “muties,” and as always, the beam. We learn the story of a young man (eleven years old, I believe) whose father was recently killed by a dragon of some sort. He and his mother fight for survival in a harsh world.
Just when they believe they’ve found their savior, King throws a twist in there to mess everything up. The young man’s journey to save his mother, and himself, take us on a wild adventure filled with magic, terror, and suspense.
Even with my previous complaint, TWTK is one of the better Stephen King novels I’ve read.
I give The Wind Through the Keyhole by Stephen King, book 4.5 in the Dark Tower Series, five out of five stars.
I still wish we’d seen more of young Roland. Who knows? Maybe King will add yet another book to the Dark Tower Series one day....more
Many indie author publishing and promotional guides share similar information. At this point in my indie author career, it's all about finding bits ofMany indie author publishing and promotional guides share similar information. At this point in my indie author career, it's all about finding bits of information not already in the multitude of other books written on the subject.
Aggie Villanueva's book didn't disappoint. She doesn't tell you what categories you should list your book under, but she explains how to find better categories, and how to change them step-by-step. She explains how Amazon uses your ranking within these categories to promote your work.
I've since implemented many of her ideas and noticed a tremendous difference. My debut novel, The Fall of Billy Hitchings, spent three weeks on the bestseller list in July, and has currently been there the last three days. Since making changes she suggested, my book has also been on the Amazon UK bestseller list for almost two months!
Understand that this book won't tell you how to put your book on the bestseller list, only how to make it easier using Amazon's built in promotional system with categories.
There were details I didn't expect to get from her book revolving around little known rules Amazon has about sharing reviews on other sites. She discusses these rules in detail and shares links that explain those rules more clearly.
I agree with a few other Amazon reviews on some of the negative aspects, but I can also argue those negatives were needed.
One complaint is that she uses this book to promote others she has written. This is a common practice, and some author's go overboard in this respect, but I didn't feel that as much in this case. Though there was quite a bit of self-promotion, Aggie used much of it to show the reader how her techniques improved those individual books, and to show that she was a bestseller herself.
I read another complaint about the usage of too many links. This is both a good thing and a bad thing. Most of the links take the reader back to her blog and bonus information in regards to her book. This bothered me in that I felt if there was information to be found, why not place it in the book itself?
Here's the problem. Aggie Villanueva implements a growing trend with informational books in that it's a living thing. Whenever she finds new or pertinent information, she adds it to her website. She could have entered the new information in her book, but then those readers who bought her book before the implemented changes wouldn't have access to the latest information.
Definitely worth the money, but it would have been nice if the newer information was instilled within the book rather than on her site....more
Ever seen the movie Ocean's Eleven? Or any of the sequels for that matter? You'll get a similar feeling when you begin Nobility. The reader is introduEver seen the movie Ocean's Eleven? Or any of the sequels for that matter? You'll get a similar feeling when you begin Nobility. The reader is introduced to a gang of pickpockets preparing for their next take. Each member brings unique capabilities to the team and it's these capabilities, along with their physical attributes, that gives them their nicknames based on Roman mythology.
MacRath keeps the pacing tight throughout most of the book. Each chapter is composed of short sections told from a different perspective, both the good guys and the bad, though that line isn't clearly drawn until later.
I have two complaints, and one relates to the above paragraph. Yes, the pacing was fast and the short sections improved that pacing, but it didn't fit in my opinion.
Let me explain. The depth in MacRath's writing is impressive. The myriad of ideas and thoughts running through his character's heads is realistic and he does well putting this on paper. My issue is many of these thoughts seem out of place in the midst of the quick pacing. As if we go from a lyrical masterpiece to an action sequence and back, with little transition.
How could this have been done different? I'm not sure, but this brings me to the other complaint. This book felt like two stories wrapped into one. We have the pickpockets, and we have Ray, another main character. While both were needed with this plot, either of those ideas on its own could have made up its own story, especially with the depth in MacRath's writing.
My thoughts on the two complaints.
MacRath could have used his depth of thought to create two completely separate novellas, or novels. One with the gang of pickpockets, fast pace, their ups and downs, their big takes, etc. And one with Ray and his personal life and issues. Maybe slower paced, but with the great attention to inner feelings and emotion that MacRath writes so well.
The one aspect I truly admire in MacRath is his wordplay. I wish I could explain this better. The way he puts things together, the way the words can have multiple meanings, it's quite amazing. His book is almost lyrical at times. I've heard of writers who could do this, but I've never actually read one... until now.
As with all book reviews, these are my opinions. If you check out the other awesome reviews, other readers may not feel the same.
What I know is that Reb MacRath is a talented writer and I look forward to more of his work. His writing style is unique and will no doubt draw readers based on that simple fact. I said this multiple times earlier, but he writes with such depth and emotion I can't help but wonder what he'll bring to the writing world in the future....more