I just finished The Education of Little Tree. I'd heard about it for ages, but everyone said it was wonderful, so I avoided it—I have little stomach fI just finished The Education of Little Tree. I'd heard about it for ages, but everyone said it was wonderful, so I avoided it—I have little stomach for "wonderful" books. Then I heard it was racist and Oprah had disowned it, so I got curious: How could a racist write a book that many people of many races would love? Writers can write from perspectives that are not their own, but that calls for empathy, and racists have little empathy for anyone they do not identify with.
Still, it stayed low on my priorities until I saw it on a "Do not read! Racist!" list. So I read it.
I looked hard for the racism. Most of the characters are Cherokee. They're good people. Only one black shows up in a very minor role, but he's good people. A Jew shows up, and he's good people. Some of the whites are not good people, and some of them are. The book isn't racist in its depictions of races.
Now, it has no good people who identify as Christian and several bad ones who do, so the book may be racist against the Christian race. But some of the good people in it seem to be Christian. Given the setting, it's extremely likely they are. I don't think any Christian who gets Christianity would be upset by its portrayal of Christian hypocrites.
But it may be racist in one way: none of the greedy people are good people. The store owner is decent, but there's a general sense that the race of greedy people screw up life for the rest of us.
Which may be why Oprah decided to disavow this book. If you're a Christian living in a fifty million dollar mansion, you might be glad to denounce a book that suggests rich people are part of the problem.
I don't know how accurate this book is. I've lived in the Deep South, and I've lived next to an Ojibway reservation in Ontario, and I didn't see anything that was insulting to southerners or Indians. If you're hoping to learn about Cherokee ways, this is not a good book to read—it's about a kid and his grandparents who live in the mountains, far from other people. But if you're hoping to learn that Indians are good people who were horribly treated by whites, this is a fine book to read. I can't do better than the Atlantic's reviewer: "“Some of it is sad, some of it is hilarious, some of it is unbelievable, and all of it is charming.”
Sherman Alexie said, "Little Tree is a lovely little book, and I sometimes wonder if it is an act of romantic atonement by a guilt-ridden White supremacist, but ultimately I think it is the racial hypocrisy of a White supremacist." I think Alexie's a great writer, but he over-estimates the literary abilities of white supremacists. It's true the characters are idealized, but the list of books with idealized characters is long: some stories are realistic, and some are romanticized. The Education of Little Tree is drawn with broad strokes, but so is The Boondocks.
I read this when I was a proto-hippie, perhaps when I was fourteen. I don't know what I would think of it now--I suspect I would think it was what itI read this when I was a proto-hippie, perhaps when I was fourteen. I don't know what I would think of it now--I suspect I would think it was what it is, a promising first novel by an extremely talented young man of his time--but I'll never forget it....more
If the review system had more options, I would give this four stars for technique and five for audacity. It's not a history--he puts some historical cIf the review system had more options, I would give this four stars for technique and five for audacity. It's not a history--he puts some historical characters onto the scene who were not there--but it's a great use of fiction to present history that's often ignored....more
I saw a reviewer say she didn't like Blubber because the ending did not make it clear that bad things are bad. That's because Blume knows to trust herI saw a reviewer say she didn't like Blubber because the ending did not make it clear that bad things are bad. That's because Blume knows to trust her readers. As many children's book writers have noted, children usually can figure out things their parents don't understand.
The following is from my blog:
When Judy Blume wrote Blubber, I wasn't interested in kids' books. But when Robert N. Lee wrote, "I've said for years and years that everybody should be issued this book before they get online," I decided I needed to read it.
Blume is at least as good as her fans say she is, and she may be better. I know a lot of writers, myself included, who could learn from her style, her sense of structure, her pacing, her attention to scenes, her humor, her acceptance of human shortcomings, and her ability to tell a moral tale without a hint of preaching.
Will-Bob gives it four and a half stars.
I might've given it four stars on goodreads if I hadn't seen the comment by someone who gave it two. I think the ending is a little rushed, but that's a minor quibble....more
I was surprised by how different this is from the movie. Here, the main story focuses on a group of Romans after Spartacus has been defeated, and theI was surprised by how different this is from the movie. Here, the main story focuses on a group of Romans after Spartacus has been defeated, and the story of Spartacus is told in memories and flashbacks....more