Miranda’s review of Stardust > Likes and Comments

306 likes · 
Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jayson (new)

Jayson Great review! I may have to pick up the illustrated edition one day, I've so far only read the original. Also, I concur: the movie was better.


message 2: by Audrey (new)

Audrey It seems everyone agrees the movie is better.


message 3: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Jayson wrote: "Great review! I may have to pick up the illustrated edition one day, I've so far only read the original. Also, I concur: the movie was better."

I just love a book with pictures. My inner child gets giddy


message 4: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Audrey wrote: "It seems everyone agrees the movie is better."

I haven't found one that thought the book was better :p


message 5: by Melki (new)

Melki (For the record, the movie = better).

Well, I've seen the movie, so I guess I don't have to bother with the book. Awesome!


message 6: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Ha :) for the record, the book was still fun, just not as good :P


message 7: by Molly (new)

Molly Mortensen I thought this one was great too! My first Gaiman book and so far still the best! I liked the movie better too. Mostly because of DeNero, fo figure.


message 8: by Audrey (new)

Audrey Gaiman's Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don't feel like reading his other stuff.


message 9: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Molly wrote: "I thought this one was great too! My first Gaiman book and so far still the best! I liked the movie better too. Mostly because of DeNero, fo figure."

Sweet :) It's def among my Gaiman Faves :)


message 10: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Audrey wrote: "Gaiman's Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don't feel like reading his other stuff."

He wrote Dr. Who Episodes??? (quickly googles) Ahh, yes...those episodes... I agree totally with those being not the best Dr Who episodes :P

His work is such a hit-or-miss for me. Love it or loath it.


message 11: by Molly (new)

Molly Mortensen Miranda wrote: "Audrey wrote: "Gaiman's Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don't feel like reading his other stuff."

He wrote Dr. Who Episodes??? (quickly googles) Ahh, yes...those episodes... ..."


Except for the Doctor's wife. That episode rocked!


message 12: by Audrey (new)

Audrey The Doctor's Wife was a decent story, but it still felt really slow to me.


message 13: by KAS (new)

KAS Glad you enjoyed and was a great audible version ;) Wonderful review, Miranda!!


message 14: by NisharC.I (new)

NisharC.I It seems everyone agrees the movie is better.


message 15: by NisharC.I (new)

NisharC.I (For the record, the movie =better).


message 16: by NisharC.I (new)

NisharC.I Gaiman's Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don't feel like reading his other stuff.


message 17: by NisharC.I (new)

NisharC.I Miranda wrote:"Audrey wrote:"Gaiman's Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don't feel like......


message 18: by Audrey (new)

Audrey NisharC.I wrote: “Gaiman’s Doctor Who episodes are among my least favorite, so I don’t feel like reading his other stuff.”

Same here – I’ve been reluctant to read his books because of that.


message 19: by Tatevik (new)

Tatevik Najaryan Oh, I started the audiobook, but then though I would love the book if I read it instead of listening :)


message 20: by Misty (new)

Misty This sounds positively magical! Great review.


message 21: by Bharath (new)

Bharath Great review! Sigh - how many books can I really read? If only I was half as good as you are at it.....!


message 22: by Rajeswari (new)

Rajeswari Roy Reading it was like reading some kind of ancient tale...💞


message 23: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Tatevik wrote: "Oh, I started the audiobook, but then though I would love the book if I read it instead of listening :)"

The audio is really well done too!


message 24: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Misty wrote: "This sounds positively magical! Great review."

It truly was


message 25: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Bharath wrote: "Great review! Sigh - how many books can I really read? If only I was half as good as you are at it.....!"

Haha, thank you!


message 26: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Rajeswari wrote: "Reading it was like reading some kind of ancient tale...💞"

Yes yes yes! So good!


message 27: by Paula (new)

Paula Kalin Lovely review, Miranda🎄


Jen/The Tolkien Gal/ジェニファー Gorgeous review, Miranda. It's awesome that Gaiman himself narrates it.


message 29: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Paula wrote: "Lovely review, Miranda🎄"

Thank you!


message 30: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Jennifer (Jen/The Tolkien Gal/ジェニファー) wrote: "Gorgeous review, Miranda. It's awesome that Gaiman himself narrates it."

Totally agree! It's such a treat to listen to him


message 31: by Anahita (new)

Anahita Great review Miranda! :)


message 32: by Miranda (new)

Miranda Reads Thank you!


message 33: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Miller I liked that scene lol


back to top