Seemita’s review of The Brothers Karamazov > Likes and Comments
204 likes · Like
My beloved D through Seemita's eyes... I can't wait! I hope you enjoy this masterpiece.
Totally looking forward to the rendezvous, Flor! :))
Terrific review. You've made me want to read it again.
Very compelling review, Seemita. I really must get to this book soon!
Stellar review, Seemita. For you to finish it in the wee hours of the morning tells me how powerfully captivating D is in The Brothers K. A book that keeps beckoning to be read for sure.
Brava Simi, brava! From the opening para till the last quote, this is as fine a tribute to D's psychological and spiritual meanderings as there can be. What I most remember about this mammoth of a masterpiece was that after all the conflicting emotions, the jealousy, the betrayal, the repentance...compassion was the triumphant victor. Alyosha's positive thinking wins over skepticism, prejudice and selfishness, and D's playful discourse matches that of a certain Bard I am very fond of... so a win-win for any reader. Can't think of better ways to meet the late hours than with this gentleman's company! :)))
Fantastic review, Simi. I have no opinion on that Dostoyevsky yet but still remember my feeling after reading Crime and Punishment. I was overwhelmed by throng of ideas, depth of psychological and philosophical insights. Hopefully will make my opinion on TBK soon too.
A brilliant review Simi, and a timely reminder that I should read this magisterial work.
After your splendid review of Ulysses, you have once again managed to make me consider a classic of freightening proportions as a tome I could dare hope to approach. In fact, I can't wait to begin. Beautiful review, Seemita! It's always a joy to read your rich and beautiful toughts.
Would it even be conceivable not to desire to re-read TBK after reading your sublime write-up on D, Seemita? Simply brilliant.
Violet wrote: "Terrific review. You've made me want to read it again."
Thank you, Violet. I do know what that temptation is like :)
Fernando wrote: "Hats off to you, Seemita"
Why, thank you much, Fernando!
Edward wrote: "Very compelling review, Seemita. I really must get to this book soon!"
The book is hundred times more compelling, I assure you, Edward. I would love to hear your thoughts once you get privy to the Karamazovs; they make a unique bunch :)
Marita wrote: "I enjoyed reading your eloquent review, Seemita!"
And pleasure is entirely mine, Marita! Thank you.
Laysee wrote: "Stellar review, Seemita. For you to finish it in the wee hours of the morning tells me how powerfully captivating D is in The Brothers K. A book that keeps beckoning to be read for sure."
I can't recommend the book enough, Laysee. The length and breadth of this work is so extensive that I am certain it has something to offer to every soul that is willing to give it, time. I hope your thorough eye meets D's soon so that we can benefit from a rich treat of thoughts and reflection :)
Dolors wrote: "Brava Simi, brava! From the opening para till the last quote, this is as fine a tribute to D's psychological and spiritual meanderings as there can be. What I most remember about this mammoth of a ..."
Oh you do remember our wonderful Alyosha well, D! Indeed, the finale! (view spoiler) His choice to embrace compassion, despite the bleak fates of his dear ones hovering dangerously close, was a numbing way to highlight priorities that a progressive world must pursue. In application of thoughts from drastically opposite schools and in applying them consistently like a master over numerous outings, D is certainly a kin of the Bard. No wonder the latter held a considerable influence on the former. Thanks a ton for lending your motivating hurrah to my ramblings which, in a way poured without restraint. Your patience is like Alyosha's :)
All I can say Seemita is your reviews are majestic and beautiful to read
Maybe if you put your reviews in a book am sure many will love reading it
Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that much more beautiful and compelling. Splendid review, Simi! :)
A review befitting the book -- substantial, insightful, and well-written -- a tremendous achievement, Seemita!
Exquisite thoughts for an exquisite novel, Simi. Brava!
Aaaah, dear Seemita, such a joy to read your wonderful review! Yes, you give honor to the book!
I saw this fine review out of the corner of my eye yesterday, Seemita. Today it had disappeared! I'm glad I took the time to seek it out - it was more than worth it.
Agnieszka wrote: "Fantastic review, Simi. I have no opinion on that Dostoyevsky yet but still remember my feeling after reading Crime and Punishment. I was overwhelmed by throng of ideas, depth of psychological and ..."
Thank you, dear Agna! Yes, I suppose the philosophical and psychological slant in both C&P and TBK would be on par, and there is a sense of fullness in TBK that is very rare in any book. I really can't explain well, pardon my inabilities, but the book is like a huge tide that sweeps the entire shore of life and washes away the spectator with all the good and bad. You take it all because that is how it is supposed to be. I will be really keen to hear your thoughts on TBK!
Abubakar wrote: "A brilliant review Simi, and a timely reminder that I should read this magisterial work."
Thank you, Abubakar. I hope you enjoy the very many themes of this rich book whenever you get to it.
Jean-Paul wrote: "A stunning and stellar review, Seemita, of a book, which touched my heart and soul deeply."
I am with you on this, JP; it leaves deep marks on one's soul and one becomes aware, almost immediately, of their permanence. Thank you for validation, my friend.
Matthias wrote: "After your splendid review of Ulysses, you have once again managed to make me consider a classic of freightening proportions as a tome I could dare hope to approach. In fact, I can't wait to begin...."
Now doesn't that make me happy or what! I am super glad to take you a tad closer to this tome, Matt and I am hopeful that this growing proximity will gift you an experience that you shall relish for a long, long time. And yes, you can well dare to approach it; my acquaintance with you tells me you are well equipped for the plunge :)
Ilse wrote: "Would it even be conceivable not to desire to re-read TBK after reading your sublime write-up on D, Seemita? Simply brilliant."
Ah! You indulge, dear Ilse! Thank you very much :) And I quite know I will re-read it myself, some other time in future; and the work will still have something profound to tell me then. What a masterpiece!
Ina wrote: "All I can say Seemita is your reviews are majestic and beautiful to read
Maybe if you put your reviews in a book am sure many will love reading it"
Thank you for that lovely compliment, Ina. I am glad the reviews find consistent endorsement from generous readers like you.
Anuradha wrote: "Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that much more beautiful ..."
Dostoevsky is one of my utter favorites too, Anu! And you madame, have showered way more applause on me than I deserve, for you are well aware what this gigantic saga holds in its bosom and near impossibility of capturing its essence in a few paragraphs. But well, thank you so much for sharing my enthusiasm and admiration for D; we are a club :))
Steve wrote: "A review befitting the book -- substantial, insightful, and well-written -- a tremendous achievement, Seemita!"
Coming from a reviewer of your calibre, I will lap up the compliment without delay, Steve! Thank you much :)
Cheryl wrote: "Exquisite thoughts for an exquisite novel, Simi. Brava!"
I was at a loss of words after finishing this novel, Cheryl but I felt so full that I had to pour myself out. Thanks a whole lot for being the lovely, patient listener, that you always are :)
Hanneke wrote: "Aaaah, dear Seemita, such a joy to read your wonderful review! Yes, you give honor to the book!"
Awww, Hanneke! Now that's something precious you have said. Thank you lots! I feel honored to have read the book though; what a life-changing experience!
Fionnuala wrote: "I saw this fine review out of the corner of my eye yesterday, Seemita. Today it had disappeared! I'm glad I took the time to seek it out - it was more than worth it."
And I am glad to know the review resonated with you, Fio! Many thanks :)
Seemita wrote: "Anuradha wrote: "Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that muc..."
Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, Dostoevsky lovers unite! :D
On another note, I saw this review of the book recently. I found it very funny, so I'm just linking it. :P
Anuradha wrote: "Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, Dostoevsky lovers..."
That's hilarious! Thanks for sharing, Anu! In fact just about a week ago I saw the 'gangsta' going on Pride & Prejudice and it was a riot! Have you checked that one out too? Here!
Magnificent review. Really amazing. Your brain and your heart seem totally in sync as you compose. I read half of this back a few years ago and then was completely diverted away . I need to return. Thanks for your inspiration.
Seemita wrote: "Anuradha wrote: "Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, ..."
I love his reviews. I've watched every Thug Note made. The man is a genius. :'D
Sue wrote: "Magnificent review. Really amazing. Your brain and your heart seem totally in sync as you compose. I read half of this back a few years ago and then was completely diverted away . I need to return...."
Thank you, Sue! I am not quite sure if my heart and brain were in sync when I stared at the uphill task of writing a review of this expansive book. But it may suffice to say that I wrote without restraint and I am glad you found the picture coherent :) And I am further happy to have sent you a little nudge in the due course, and quite, certainly, will await your thoughts once you are done with this rendezvous. Good luck!
Anuradha wrote: "I love his reviews. I've watched every Thug Note made. The man is a genius. :'D"
Satya vachan ;)
Yes! What an outstanding review!
s.penkevich wrote: "Yes! What an outstanding review!"
Glad you thought so, Steve! And it's so good to see you around. Now keep us company, won't you? :)
And do read this review! What a delicious conversation with our multifaceted friend D I just had the pleasure of reading. I'm so glad you enjoyed this masterpiece and that it inspired such a gem of a review, which analyzes so brilliantly the many aspects of this psychological and philosophical journey. One of the most perfect illustrations of human nature. Ah, splendid. I'm happy now. ;P
Dostoevsky has this way of insinuating thoughts into you slowly and piercingly which persists! Those thoughts and your eloquence makes up for a majestic read. This is beautiful, Seemita!
Florencia wrote: "And do read this review! What a delicious conversation with our multifaceted friend D I just had the pleasure of reading. I'm so glad you enjoyed this masterpiece and that it inspired such a gem of..."
And the madame, herself, speaks! Thank you, dear Flor :) It was quite a journey indeed; fraught with ups and downs but never, never a dull moment. The book was a perfect concoction of our virtues and vices, and our fluidity and rigidity in dealing with them. Ah! How am I tempted to jump into another of D's works, right away! But I must resist temptations, as the sage says himself ;) Glad to have perked you up, my friend :)
Ritwik wrote: "Dostoevsky has this way of insinuating thoughts into you slowly and piercingly which persists! Those thoughts and your eloquence makes up for a majestic read. This is beautiful, Seemita!"
You got that bang on, Ritwik! D seizes us by the throat and reaches all the way to our souls, to leave thoughts that dance for near perpetuity. His impact is so far-reaching, so precise. I am glad you found some merit in the review and further gladder to see this on your TBR. I await a Midnight's Children like review when you are done with it! :D And it is good to hear from you! Hope things are all good at your end.
imperious review as ever. +1 for maniacal
Ray wrote: "imperious review as ever. +1 for maniacal"
Thank you much, Ray! Ah yes, their father was quite the good-bad daddy!
Wow... wonderful review Seemita. I delighted in reading this so much and it reminded me a bit of all the reasons why I liked the only book by D. that I've read (Crime and Punishment) which means you did hell of a good job considering I read Crime and Punishment around 14 years ago.
Deea wrote: "Wow... wonderful review Seemita. I delighted in reading this so much and it reminded me a bit of all the reasons why I liked the only book by D. that I've read (Crime and Punishment) which means yo..."
Whoa, Deea! You read C&P 14 years ago? I suppose I wasn't even aware of D that many years back! You obviously deviated towards quality literature much before me and your reading choices and thoughts are testimonial to the same. And thus, I am quite glad that you had a little stream of memories trickling down while reading this review. I was quite blown away by his deep, and not to mention, vast understanding of human psyche, as per usual. Such a master!
back to top
message 1:
by
Florencia
(new)
Oct 23, 2016 06:53AM
My beloved D through Seemita's eyes... I can't wait! I hope you enjoy this masterpiece.
reply
|
flag
*
Totally looking forward to the rendezvous, Flor! :))
Terrific review. You've made me want to read it again.
Very compelling review, Seemita. I really must get to this book soon!
Stellar review, Seemita. For you to finish it in the wee hours of the morning tells me how powerfully captivating D is in The Brothers K. A book that keeps beckoning to be read for sure.
Brava Simi, brava! From the opening para till the last quote, this is as fine a tribute to D's psychological and spiritual meanderings as there can be. What I most remember about this mammoth of a masterpiece was that after all the conflicting emotions, the jealousy, the betrayal, the repentance...compassion was the triumphant victor. Alyosha's positive thinking wins over skepticism, prejudice and selfishness, and D's playful discourse matches that of a certain Bard I am very fond of... so a win-win for any reader. Can't think of better ways to meet the late hours than with this gentleman's company! :)))
Fantastic review, Simi. I have no opinion on that Dostoyevsky yet but still remember my feeling after reading Crime and Punishment. I was overwhelmed by throng of ideas, depth of psychological and philosophical insights. Hopefully will make my opinion on TBK soon too.
A brilliant review Simi, and a timely reminder that I should read this magisterial work.
After your splendid review of Ulysses, you have once again managed to make me consider a classic of freightening proportions as a tome I could dare hope to approach. In fact, I can't wait to begin. Beautiful review, Seemita! It's always a joy to read your rich and beautiful toughts.
Would it even be conceivable not to desire to re-read TBK after reading your sublime write-up on D, Seemita? Simply brilliant.
Violet wrote: "Terrific review. You've made me want to read it again."Thank you, Violet. I do know what that temptation is like :)
Fernando wrote: "Hats off to you, Seemita"Why, thank you much, Fernando!
Edward wrote: "Very compelling review, Seemita. I really must get to this book soon!"The book is hundred times more compelling, I assure you, Edward. I would love to hear your thoughts once you get privy to the Karamazovs; they make a unique bunch :)
Marita wrote: "I enjoyed reading your eloquent review, Seemita!"And pleasure is entirely mine, Marita! Thank you.
Laysee wrote: "Stellar review, Seemita. For you to finish it in the wee hours of the morning tells me how powerfully captivating D is in The Brothers K. A book that keeps beckoning to be read for sure."I can't recommend the book enough, Laysee. The length and breadth of this work is so extensive that I am certain it has something to offer to every soul that is willing to give it, time. I hope your thorough eye meets D's soon so that we can benefit from a rich treat of thoughts and reflection :)
Dolors wrote: "Brava Simi, brava! From the opening para till the last quote, this is as fine a tribute to D's psychological and spiritual meanderings as there can be. What I most remember about this mammoth of a ..."Oh you do remember our wonderful Alyosha well, D! Indeed, the finale! (view spoiler) His choice to embrace compassion, despite the bleak fates of his dear ones hovering dangerously close, was a numbing way to highlight priorities that a progressive world must pursue. In application of thoughts from drastically opposite schools and in applying them consistently like a master over numerous outings, D is certainly a kin of the Bard. No wonder the latter held a considerable influence on the former. Thanks a ton for lending your motivating hurrah to my ramblings which, in a way poured without restraint. Your patience is like Alyosha's :)
All I can say Seemita is your reviews are majestic and beautiful to read Maybe if you put your reviews in a book am sure many will love reading it
Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that much more beautiful and compelling. Splendid review, Simi! :)
A review befitting the book -- substantial, insightful, and well-written -- a tremendous achievement, Seemita!
Exquisite thoughts for an exquisite novel, Simi. Brava!
Aaaah, dear Seemita, such a joy to read your wonderful review! Yes, you give honor to the book!
I saw this fine review out of the corner of my eye yesterday, Seemita. Today it had disappeared! I'm glad I took the time to seek it out - it was more than worth it.
Agnieszka wrote: "Fantastic review, Simi. I have no opinion on that Dostoyevsky yet but still remember my feeling after reading Crime and Punishment. I was overwhelmed by throng of ideas, depth of psychological and ..."Thank you, dear Agna! Yes, I suppose the philosophical and psychological slant in both C&P and TBK would be on par, and there is a sense of fullness in TBK that is very rare in any book. I really can't explain well, pardon my inabilities, but the book is like a huge tide that sweeps the entire shore of life and washes away the spectator with all the good and bad. You take it all because that is how it is supposed to be. I will be really keen to hear your thoughts on TBK!
Abubakar wrote: "A brilliant review Simi, and a timely reminder that I should read this magisterial work."Thank you, Abubakar. I hope you enjoy the very many themes of this rich book whenever you get to it.
Jean-Paul wrote: "A stunning and stellar review, Seemita, of a book, which touched my heart and soul deeply."I am with you on this, JP; it leaves deep marks on one's soul and one becomes aware, almost immediately, of their permanence. Thank you for validation, my friend.
Matthias wrote: "After your splendid review of Ulysses, you have once again managed to make me consider a classic of freightening proportions as a tome I could dare hope to approach. In fact, I can't wait to begin...."Now doesn't that make me happy or what! I am super glad to take you a tad closer to this tome, Matt and I am hopeful that this growing proximity will gift you an experience that you shall relish for a long, long time. And yes, you can well dare to approach it; my acquaintance with you tells me you are well equipped for the plunge :)
Ilse wrote: "Would it even be conceivable not to desire to re-read TBK after reading your sublime write-up on D, Seemita? Simply brilliant."Ah! You indulge, dear Ilse! Thank you very much :) And I quite know I will re-read it myself, some other time in future; and the work will still have something profound to tell me then. What a masterpiece!
Ina wrote: "All I can say Seemita is your reviews are majestic and beautiful to read Maybe if you put your reviews in a book am sure many will love reading it"
Thank you for that lovely compliment, Ina. I am glad the reviews find consistent endorsement from generous readers like you.
Anuradha wrote: "Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that much more beautiful ..."Dostoevsky is one of my utter favorites too, Anu! And you madame, have showered way more applause on me than I deserve, for you are well aware what this gigantic saga holds in its bosom and near impossibility of capturing its essence in a few paragraphs. But well, thank you so much for sharing my enthusiasm and admiration for D; we are a club :))
Steve wrote: "A review befitting the book -- substantial, insightful, and well-written -- a tremendous achievement, Seemita!"Coming from a reviewer of your calibre, I will lap up the compliment without delay, Steve! Thank you much :)
Cheryl wrote: "Exquisite thoughts for an exquisite novel, Simi. Brava!"I was at a loss of words after finishing this novel, Cheryl but I felt so full that I had to pour myself out. Thanks a whole lot for being the lovely, patient listener, that you always are :)
Hanneke wrote: "Aaaah, dear Seemita, such a joy to read your wonderful review! Yes, you give honor to the book!"Awww, Hanneke! Now that's something precious you have said. Thank you lots! I feel honored to have read the book though; what a life-changing experience!
Fionnuala wrote: "I saw this fine review out of the corner of my eye yesterday, Seemita. Today it had disappeared! I'm glad I took the time to seek it out - it was more than worth it."And I am glad to know the review resonated with you, Fio! Many thanks :)
Seemita wrote: "Anuradha wrote: "Dostoevsky is my favourite author ever, Simi! And what excellent praise he has received from you! Your stunning imagery and scene setting only makes the book and the story that muc..."Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, Dostoevsky lovers unite! :D
On another note, I saw this review of the book recently. I found it very funny, so I'm just linking it. :P
Anuradha wrote: "Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, Dostoevsky lovers..."That's hilarious! Thanks for sharing, Anu! In fact just about a week ago I saw the 'gangsta' going on Pride & Prejudice and it was a riot! Have you checked that one out too? Here!
Magnificent review. Really amazing. Your brain and your heart seem totally in sync as you compose. I read half of this back a few years ago and then was completely diverted away . I need to return. Thanks for your inspiration.
Seemita wrote: "Anuradha wrote: "Can Dostoevsky ever be captured in a few paragraphs? :') However, it does require a skilled reader and writer to try and succeed so, Simi, and your review does just that! And yes, ..."I love his reviews. I've watched every Thug Note made. The man is a genius. :'D
Sue wrote: "Magnificent review. Really amazing. Your brain and your heart seem totally in sync as you compose. I read half of this back a few years ago and then was completely diverted away . I need to return...."Thank you, Sue! I am not quite sure if my heart and brain were in sync when I stared at the uphill task of writing a review of this expansive book. But it may suffice to say that I wrote without restraint and I am glad you found the picture coherent :) And I am further happy to have sent you a little nudge in the due course, and quite, certainly, will await your thoughts once you are done with this rendezvous. Good luck!
Anuradha wrote: "I love his reviews. I've watched every Thug Note made. The man is a genius. :'D"Satya vachan ;)
Yes! What an outstanding review!
s.penkevich wrote: "Yes! What an outstanding review!"Glad you thought so, Steve! And it's so good to see you around. Now keep us company, won't you? :)
And do read this review! What a delicious conversation with our multifaceted friend D I just had the pleasure of reading. I'm so glad you enjoyed this masterpiece and that it inspired such a gem of a review, which analyzes so brilliantly the many aspects of this psychological and philosophical journey. One of the most perfect illustrations of human nature. Ah, splendid. I'm happy now. ;P
Dostoevsky has this way of insinuating thoughts into you slowly and piercingly which persists! Those thoughts and your eloquence makes up for a majestic read. This is beautiful, Seemita!
Florencia wrote: "And do read this review! What a delicious conversation with our multifaceted friend D I just had the pleasure of reading. I'm so glad you enjoyed this masterpiece and that it inspired such a gem of..."And the madame, herself, speaks! Thank you, dear Flor :) It was quite a journey indeed; fraught with ups and downs but never, never a dull moment. The book was a perfect concoction of our virtues and vices, and our fluidity and rigidity in dealing with them. Ah! How am I tempted to jump into another of D's works, right away! But I must resist temptations, as the sage says himself ;) Glad to have perked you up, my friend :)
Ritwik wrote: "Dostoevsky has this way of insinuating thoughts into you slowly and piercingly which persists! Those thoughts and your eloquence makes up for a majestic read. This is beautiful, Seemita!"You got that bang on, Ritwik! D seizes us by the throat and reaches all the way to our souls, to leave thoughts that dance for near perpetuity. His impact is so far-reaching, so precise. I am glad you found some merit in the review and further gladder to see this on your TBR. I await a Midnight's Children like review when you are done with it! :D And it is good to hear from you! Hope things are all good at your end.
imperious review as ever. +1 for maniacal
Ray wrote: "imperious review as ever. +1 for maniacal"Thank you much, Ray! Ah yes, their father was quite the good-bad daddy!
Wow... wonderful review Seemita. I delighted in reading this so much and it reminded me a bit of all the reasons why I liked the only book by D. that I've read (Crime and Punishment) which means you did hell of a good job considering I read Crime and Punishment around 14 years ago.
Deea wrote: "Wow... wonderful review Seemita. I delighted in reading this so much and it reminded me a bit of all the reasons why I liked the only book by D. that I've read (Crime and Punishment) which means yo..."Whoa, Deea! You read C&P 14 years ago? I suppose I wasn't even aware of D that many years back! You obviously deviated towards quality literature much before me and your reading choices and thoughts are testimonial to the same. And thus, I am quite glad that you had a little stream of memories trickling down while reading this review. I was quite blown away by his deep, and not to mention, vast understanding of human psyche, as per usual. Such a master!
