To answer questions about
Unbroken: A World War II Story of Survival, Resilience, and Redemption,
please sign up.
Julie Davis
I answered a similar question in these Q & A's. I agree it depends on the child.
J. A.
Bought my daughter the Y.A. version because I think some of the brutality would disturb her (13 yrs). However, the story is so good, I want her to be able to finish. She's not found it too rough to read. She likes it "a lot" and quotes Louie around the house!
Lorena Mendes
The best answer would be "Maybe".
The story is real and so are the characters and their struggles, losses and suffering, as well as their bravery, compassion and comradery, enlightment and growth.
So it will definitely add to anyone´s life´s perspectives and lessons, in a remarkable, amazing and even spiritual way, not necessarily in the religious sense; but it is still a war and prisioner story, depicting the hardships they were put through and their consequences.
Albeit there are marvelous lessons and grownth to be taken from the book and inspiration to any person who wishes to learn from Louie´s resilience, survival, strength, redemption and unbroken-ness, it depends much on the reader´s maturity to be able to see and read through the dark side of the silver lining it achieves.
In short, you would have to know if the 12-year-old in question is mature at this moment to deal with the dark parts in order to comprehend the light parts (as in enlighting, not as in easier or less maturity-demanding).
I would say ages 15 and up are sure to profit from this book, either personally and/or academically and historically, so little is told about the Pacific part of World War II and Hillenbrand fills in this gap with mastery.
But as for between 12 and 15, I would say it depends on the reader and whoever considers introducing this book to them, should read it first and be available to help with questions that may rise about human nature.
Hope to have helped.
The story is real and so are the characters and their struggles, losses and suffering, as well as their bravery, compassion and comradery, enlightment and growth.
So it will definitely add to anyone´s life´s perspectives and lessons, in a remarkable, amazing and even spiritual way, not necessarily in the religious sense; but it is still a war and prisioner story, depicting the hardships they were put through and their consequences.
Albeit there are marvelous lessons and grownth to be taken from the book and inspiration to any person who wishes to learn from Louie´s resilience, survival, strength, redemption and unbroken-ness, it depends much on the reader´s maturity to be able to see and read through the dark side of the silver lining it achieves.
In short, you would have to know if the 12-year-old in question is mature at this moment to deal with the dark parts in order to comprehend the light parts (as in enlighting, not as in easier or less maturity-demanding).
I would say ages 15 and up are sure to profit from this book, either personally and/or academically and historically, so little is told about the Pacific part of World War II and Hillenbrand fills in this gap with mastery.
But as for between 12 and 15, I would say it depends on the reader and whoever considers introducing this book to them, should read it first and be available to help with questions that may rise about human nature.
Hope to have helped.
IzzyISH
There is a young adult version of this book. I bought it for my son who was 12 but is now 13. He hasn't read it yet. I am only about 1/3 of the way through the regular book and I keep telling him he needs to read the one I bought him.
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more