Colin Personally I liked TIWHLK more. (I gave it 5 stars while I gave this 4 stars.) But some people complained about TIWHLK being boring and cliche, so I think some people will find TGOYAM better, depending on how they found the previous book. :)
Margaux I liked it a lot better. The travel aspect of it as well as the idea that they're mostly struggling internally seemed to make this more realistic. Plus her writing seems to have developed a lot when it comes to writing realistic teen romance.