A Goodreads user asked:
Hey, how good is this book? Please no spoilers!
Christine This book is great. It takes place not too long after the Great Battle. Lots of questions get answered here, lots of character development, and plenty of moments personally had me tearing up. Oh, not to mention a cute manga at the end :). Definitely worth the read if you consider yourself a Warriors fan.
Jada m. well, i think it is amazing. she wrote what came to her mind, as i would of. she is a very talented writer. but, hey, that's your opinion!
Isabella Not one of the best warriors book, it kind of leads to questions after the plot of the story. Erin Hunter's seventh super edition is not the best she can do. It has disappointment in it, as it focuses mainly on ThunderClan and ShadowClan, and it doesn't seem to be as interesting. If you liked Firestars Quest, then you will enjoy this book. It doesn't seem like a lot of effort was put into the making, though. But the manga at the end is adorable. Don't read it first though. I made that mistake. It has a spoiler if you don't read the book first.