“You baked cookies,” I acknowledged, a budding smile on my face. She remembered my birthday. “Yes, I did.” Gracie set the hot tray in her hand on the kitchen counter, dusting the flour off her hands. I looked at them—warm chocolate chip. A little of my excitement fizzled. I wasn’t a big fan of chocolate—not since I was a little girl. Gracie knew this. The next thing Gracie said let me know who those cookies were really for. She said, “Marcel’s favorite.” My smile faded.

