How We Got to Now: Six Innovations That Made the Modern World

by Steven Johnson

Scott got to the idea of recording audio through the metaphor of stenography: write waves instead of words. That structuring metaphor enabled him to make the first leap, years ahead of his peers, but it also may have prevented him from making the second. Once words have been converted into the code of shorthand, the information captured there is decoded by a reader who understands the code. Scott thought the same would happen with his phonautograph. The machine would etch waveforms into the lampblack, each twitch of the stylus corresponding to some phoneme uttered by a human voice. And humans would learn to “read” those squiggles the way they had learned to read the squiggles of shorthand. In a sense, Scott wasn’t trying to invent an audio-recording device at all. He was trying to invent the ultimate transcription service—only you had to learn a whole new language in order to read the transcript.