Interview with Tana French

Posted by Goodreads on July 5, 2010
Irish novelist Tana French may write about detectives, but she's anything but hard-boiled. She uses an emotional approach to craft psychological murder mysteries. All of her Dublin Murder Squad books are lightly connected, but each title stands firmly on its own and uses a different narrator. Her first book, In the Woods, won the 2008 Edgar Award for Best First Novel and introduced troubled detective Rob Ryan. She next turned to Ryan's sharp-minded partner, Cassie Maddox, in The Likeness. Now she leaves her star-crossed detectives behind for a new central character in Faithful Place. Frank Mackey is hardened by years of undercover work and will blithely use lies, coercion, or trespassing to get his man. French chatted with Goodreads about what gives her the courage to write.

Goodreads: So far, each of your books has used a different narrator. After Rob Ryan in In the Woods and Cassie Maddox in The Likeness, many readers expected you to use another detective on the murder squad, Sam O'Neill, for your third book. Instead you turned to Cassie's undercover mentor, Frank Mackey. What inspired you to write about Frank?

Tana French: I actually thought about [using Sam] a lot! It was going to be him for a while, but it didn't work out that way.

When I get halfway through [writing] a book, my brain starts trying to do anything else, anything in the universe. "I know, let's clean the oven!" or "Let's cut the cat's fur into interesting patterns!" I was about halfway through writing The Likeness, and I started thinking over what I would write for book three. Frank I found interesting because his moral sense is not like most people's. Cassie and Rob have moral senses that are more acceptable in that they don't always do everything right, but they accept when they've done something wrong. Frank would do absolutely anything to anyone else or to himself in order to get the person he's after. The end absolutely justifies the means. Mystery, especially psychological mystery, is a genre very much based on morality.

GR: Your characters often come to intense psychological crossroads. Rob Ryan confronts a childhood trauma; his partner, Cassie Maddox, struggles to find where she belongs. What is Frank Mackey's psychological obstacle in Faithful Place?

TF: That is actually what I'm interested in writing about—those enormous turning points that you only get a couple times in your life. When you're crossing some borderline into a different country, and you'll never be able to be who you would have been if you'd chosen the other way. These moments strip people down to their essentials: You get to find out what you're really made of and what is really important to you.

For each of the books, the basic premise hits at the character's core. With Frank, the idea came while I was walking home one day. In front of a house being gutted I saw a huge dumpster. Among all of these horrible broken lamps and rolls of ripped up, moldy wallpaper there was a battered old blue suitcase. I started thinking, "I wonder how that got there and how long it'd been in that old house and what's inside it?" That tied in with how I'd been thinking about Frank. What would be so crucially important to him that he would be backed into a corner? I thought the discovery of a suitcase [could reveal] that his first love, Rosie—who he thought had run away on him—may not have left him after all. Frank thought he had left home and family behind. Then he starts to be drawn back by this discovery.

GR: Frank returns to his familial roots on the street, Faithful Place, in a historically working-class Dublin neighborhood, the Liberties. What did you want to capture about that unique setting?

TF: Faithful Place, by the way, isn't actually a real street. A hundred years ago there was a place called Faithful Place, but it was on the other side of the river, and it's long gone. It would be really cheeky of me to put this fake story on top of some real street that has its own history. But it's too interesting a street name for it to go to waste.

I'm not actually from the Liberties, but my husband is, so I have a slight insight into how it works. It's an inner-city Dublin neighborhood that has a reputation that goes back hundreds and hundreds of years. This tiny neighborhood used to have its own charter; it had separate laws from the rest of the city. That's where it gets its name, the Liberties. It went its own way and made its own rules. It's been changing, but there is a very strong sense of the old community. There are people living there who have been there for more generations than they can trace back, and they know everything about each other. It's a very tightly packed neighborhood—it was mostly tenements up until quite recently when people stopped wanting to live in two rooms for an entire family. Because of that it was extremely tight-knit and everyone knows everything, not just about each other but everything about each other's great aunts. I've always been fascinated by that kind of neighborhood because I grew up moving around an awful lot, so the idea of somebody from a deeply rooted background I find incredibly powerful. That is what I wanted to write about. What happens if you leave it all behind the way Frank does?

GR: A tension between old-fashioned culture and modern progress is a motif in your books. The "Move the Motorway" campaign in In the Woods tries to preserve an archaeological site. The residents of the Liberties in Faithful Place are mistrustful of outsiders who might threaten their way of life. Is this a tension that's playing out in Ireland today?

TF: Hugely! Ireland is a really young country as a nation. It's under 100 years old, and because we come from a past with a lot of oppression and hideous poverty, I think with the economic boom of the last 15 years (well dead now, but there was one) there was a tendency to want to bury the past. Get rid of it and pretend it never happened. Our past is considered quite embarrassing. Now we're modern, we're hip, we're happening. We've got triple-foam Frappuccinos now; we're not living on potatoes and cabbage. I think that led to a really dangerous idea that the past and the future are somehow incompatible. If you want the future, you have to completely ignore the past. There is very little acknowledgment that the two can and should be valued. It's not a choice. They're not mutually exclusive. This shows up in all of my books.

We went from being a pretty broke country in a recession in the '80s to boom!—all of a sudden we were this incredibly successful, booming economy, and there was money everywhere. I don't think people coped very well with that. And here we are now, broke again. That tension between past and future and how to assimilate all the changes is playing itself out every day.

GR: Goodreads member Melinda says, "You carry many of your characters through each story, shifting them into the primary role. Do you ever find after you've spent time in each one's head that you wish you had written them a little differently in a prior book—or have you written each with no regrets?"

TF: That's a fascinating question! For the most part, no regrets, but there are several places where when I start writing from a character's perspective, I realize that some of the stuff I wrote about that character in a previous book was actually inaccurate.

At the moment I'm writing book four from the perspective of Scorcher Kennedy, who is Frank's semi-friend, semi-rival. I'm realizing that a lot of what Frank says about him in Faithful Place is either inaccurate, biased, or doesn't match Scorcher's perception of himself. Frank is missing a lot of information about him. That doesn't make me regret how I wrote him in Faithful Place because that was accurate to Frank's perception of him. It was informed by Frank's own prejudices and the way he needs to see Scorcher in order to justify some of his own actions. There are some points where I've gone, "Damn, I wish I would have done that differently in a previous book," but there are also points where I've gone, "Oh God, the previous narrator really didn't have a clue."

GR: That would be especially true of Rob's perception of Cassie, considering the intensity of both their professional relationship as partners and personal relationship as best friends.

TF: Exactly, and I think that's interesting. Switching from Rob to Cassie was difficult because Rob has such strong feelings about Cassie, so it was interesting working out how much of that was the actual truth and how much was purely Rob's own needs projected onto her. Switching from Rob to Cassie was really strange. Really strange.

One of the things that has struck me while switching narrators is that the more highly charged the feelings that one character has for another, the less objective they become and the more things they could miss. Frank wasn't a big switch, because Cassie didn't have particularly strong feelings for him in The Likeness, so her take on him wasn't particularly strongly biased and he was accurately portrayed in her eyes. Whereas switching from Frank to Scorcher is a very big leap, because Frank's feelings for Scorcher are fairly charged up.

GR: Many Goodreads members wrote in to ask if you are planning to return to the characters of Rob and Cassie. And whether you would ever resolve the notoriously unsolved mystery at the end of In the Woods.

TF: [mock angry voice] "What is this woman doing with the ending of In the Woods?!" [laughs] I know. All three of the narrators I've written so far I would love to go back to. I'm hoping that if people want to keep reading, I'll keep writing about the same general batch of main characters for quite a while. I'm not sure exactly from what perspective or in what way, but I'm very much hoping that I'm not done with either Rob or Cassie. Again, I'm not sure. It all depends on how things go. I got interested in them. I'd like to find out what comes next.

GR: Goodreads member Edwin says, "The pacing of your novels is so well done that after only a few pages, they achieve 'can't put down' status. The inability to stop reading until completion has led my friends and I to refer to your books as 'paper crack.'"

TF: That's brilliant! I think that's one of the best compliments ever!

GR: Edwin asks, "How do you balance this breakneck, thrilling pace with such vivid detail?"

TF: I listen to my editors, a lot. [laughs] I think the genre is absolutely crucial to being able to balance pace, writing, character, and depth. Writing mystery gives you a basic framework: You can mess with it, you can bend it, stretch it any way you want to, but basically someone gets killed and someone else finds out whodunit. So everything you do, every scene you write, whether it's on one level or four, has to in some way feed into that plot arc. It's one of the reasons why I stick to mystery. It demands utility; it demands that every scene has a use and a purpose. If I weren't writing this genre, I'd be writing books that go on for 4,000 pages and never get anywhere, so I have no intention of switching genres. One of my worries is, "Is it too long?" So it's wonderful to hear that someone is saying, "Nope, I'm still reading!"

GR: Goodreads member Lori says, "I am especially taken with the psychological suspense and uncertainty in Tana's characters and plot lines. There are some fascinating and chilling mind games at work in her stories, and the characters seem very realistically flawed. Does Tana have any background in psychology?"

TF: No, not at all. I did one course in social psychology in college. I think my theater background was the training there. If you are serious about acting, you spend a lot of time observing the way people work. There are some actors that have a great career of playing themselves, but if you're not one of those—and I never was—if you're a character actor, then it's all about understanding people who aren't you and understanding how they work and how different factors come together to make this incredibly complex thing that is human behavior.

GR: Describe a typical day spent writing and any unusual writing habits.

TF: It used to be that my main essentials for writing were a lot of coffee and long walks with a spaced-out look on my face. Other people have a muse; I have coffee. Although not anymore, because when you have a small baby, the long walks become a small luxury and the caffeine is out as well. I was pregnant for most of Faithful Place. But for the first two-and-a-half books, my now-husband and I were living in a small flat, so I got used to him slaughtering zombies on the Xbox six feet away. You do what you got to do. I just sit down with a notebook or a computer and refuse to let myself go goof off until I've got something done. Coming from a social thing like acting, where you all go to rehearsal together and then go to the pub after, it's a hard switch, because with writing it's basically you and a pen.

GR: What authors, books, or ideas have influenced you?

TF: Josephine Tey, who wrote very strange mysteries. She broke a lot of what we would consider the genre rules. One of her books, The Franchise Affair, has no murder. The worst crime in there is either perjury or wasting police time. You know from very early on in the book who the villain is, and yet it's this gripping, chilling book and a horrific portrait of a young sociopath in action.

Books like that where all of the rules get broken—those are the books that fascinate me. The books that blur the genre borderlines. Possibly the best thing I've ever read is To Kill A Mockingbird. Some parts of it can be seen as courtroom drama, and some parts can be seen as coming-of-age, but it's so much more than that, and all the lines blur. I think those books are probably the ones that have influenced me. God knows I'm not in any way putting what I do in the same category, but just saying that these books give me the courage to go write. Maybe you don't have to write the formula unless you want to. Maybe you can use the formula as the question rather than the answer.

GR: What are you reading now?

TF: Unfortunately, I'm not getting a chance to do very much reading right now. I tend not to read mystery when I'm writing because I don't want it getting into my head and influencing me too much. Your mind is a magpie, and it picks up little shiny things, and I don't want to go picking up little shiny things. When I'm writing the first half of a book, weirdly enough, I also tend to avoid anything with too strong a narrative voice, because I'm still working on finding it. The last thing I want is someone else's sliding in there and getting into my ear. Up until a couple days ago, I was rereading Barbara Kingsolver's The Poisonwood Bible, which I think is an amazing book. Now there is an example of strong narrative.

Usually I'll read any genre as long as it's really, really good. I think when you are writing something as big as a novel, it's kind of like running a marathon. You want good nourishment, so I tend to read good stuff.

GR: Scorcher Kennedy will narrate your next book. What can you reveal about the plot?

TF: It's Scorcher Kennedy this time, and it's set on a ghost estate. During the housing boom, developers were given permission to build huge estates with sometimes hundreds of apartments and houses in areas where there was absolutely no demand. Now that no one can afford to buy anything, they are basically abandoned. You'll have four or five families living in a development of 40 homes, and the rest is just left to go to seed. These poor families are now stuck with absolutely no facilities or infrastructure. They're lucky if they have working sewage systems and streetlights. They usually don't. The book is set on one of those estates.

GR: It was lovely talking with you. Thank you.

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Elyse (new)

Elyse  Walters GREAT interview! ....I will read the next book...[I'm enjoying Tana French: including liking 'her' as a human being ---as it comes through in her writing]....

but I a *dying* for her to bring ROB back. He has by 'far' been my favorite character!
I have many friends....'waiting'...

Tana French is going to make a lot of people 'happy' when ROB RYAN returns---[yet we are fans anyway:]

message 2: by Lori (new)

Lori I am thrilled to have had the opportunity to ask a question of Tana for this interview. Goodreads is such a wonderful connection between readers and writers. My day is further made with Tana French's assurance that there will be more books involving these fascinating characters in the future. All of them have come thoroughly to life for me. I will second the motion about a continuation of Rob's story. I am still very haunted (in a good way) about what transpired In the Woods.

message 3: by Elyse (new)

Elyse  Walters Hi Lori! Thanks for sharing ----It must have been great being with Tana. ---
And....You've got me smiling....
Into those woods again....."WITH ROB"..... :)

Hugs new friend!

love elyse

message 4: by David (new)

David As Tana's father, I keep pretty close track of her interviews (including the one yesterday on "All Things Considered"). This is the best I've seen - excellent, excellent questions. Thank you! - David

message 5: by Elyse (new)

Elyse  Walters Hi *DAD*, *DAVID*! We think its a great interview too. I look forward to meeting your daughter some day--[maybe she will speak at Kepler's Books in Menlo Park:] the Bay Area.... :) ----

You must be a proud Dad!

elyse (a proud 'mom') ---I have two daughters, also! One is an actress/singer/and dancer---who also enjoys writing. The other is a successful tattoo artist.

message 6: by David (new)

David Fellow proud parent: I thought I'd read somewhere that Kepler's had closed down a while back. Glad to see it's still there. (It was my bookstore when I was at Stanford a few decades ago.) Viking/Penguin like to get Tana to independent bookstores, so it's a logical place if they can ever convince her to go on tour again (she'd rather stay in Dublin and play with her one-year-old and write books)!

message 7: by Mark (new)

Mark I read Into the Woods...fabulous read! Can't wait to catch up on the next two.

message 8: by Lynda (new)

Lynda Love the interview...I'm a Cassie fan..I hope she is resurrected in the future..can't wait to read Faithful Place..I also loved Poisonwood Bible...playing with a one year old and writing books would be far more rewarding ....enjoy Dublin

The Book Whisperer (aka Boof) Fabulous interview! I am reading The Likeness right now and loving it so I'm looking forwrd to Faithful Place coming out too.

message 10: by Ev (new)

Ev Bishop Fascinating interview, thanks! I adored In the Woods and The Likeness and am frantically awaiting my preordered copy of Faithful Place.

When I discovered Tana's novels about a month ago I was out of my mind with book loving glee--I'd been in a phase of reading a lot of "pretty good" books, but nothing that really reached out, grabbed me and made me take notice. I love her plots, her amazing characterization, the questions, themes and thoughts she triggers and explores--and her writing itself. She's great at the craft.

It's been a long time since I full on raved about an author, but what can I say? I just really, really loved her stories!

message 11: by Lynn (new)

Lynn I teach a course on learning about other countries through mystery novels and I used In The Woods in the class. I only use books I really like - my students shared my enthusiaam for Tana French. I tried to buy Faithful Places yesterday and was told it wasn't coming out until today - can't wait!

message 12: by Merty (last edited Jul 13, 2010 04:33PM) (new)

Merty I loved In The Woods, currently reading Faithful Place and I still have The Likeness to look forward to. I love that Ms. French gave us a sneak peek in regard to the fourth book. I agree, her novels are like paper crack, indeed. I love Tana French one of my favorite authors.

message 13: by Merty (new)

Merty Thanks Goodreads for this great and interesting interview!

message 14: by Janet (new)

Janet Totally agree with Tana's Dad, these were excellent questions and also answers. I purchase Tana's books for our library and will be reading one of them soon for my enjoyment.

message 15: by Grandma (new)

Grandma Thanks to all of you above. I'm now about to order and read Tana's "In the Woods." Your positive comments convinced me to read her writings.

message 16: by Pinknorth (new)

Pinknorth that good

message 17: by Hussien (new)

Hussien good

message 18: by Michael (new)

Michael Alderete Having read all three of the Dublin Murder Squad books now (in rapid succession!), I would be most interested in reading more of Frank Mackey. I loved Cassie, but Frank is the most _interesting_ of the various narrators, so far.

message 19: by Ann (new)

Ann I totally agree with Michael. I read Faithful Place first and think Frank is the most interesting...I ADORE FRANK MACKEY!!! After Franks book I went on to read In the Woods and then The Likeness. Enjoyed Franks's part in The Likeness. Very much looking forward to Scorcher Kennedy's book. A book about Sam and Cassie would possibly be a good one in the future. Anyone have an idea on when the fourth book will be released? Anxiously awaiting.

message 20: by Lizzie (new)

Lizzie Lovely interview and interesting comments on genre. I'm always awed by how well French immerses readers in the characters' worlds and how lyrical she can be in descriptions--sort of like Ondaatje. I find Frank fascinating as well and hope to see more of his interactions with Cassie and Sam and maybe Rob!

message 21: by Thi (new)

Thi MUST WRITE IN ROB'S AND CASSIE'S P.O.V AGAIN!!!! Shouldn't let go of Cassie, sam, and especiall not Rob Ryan. <3

message 22: by Thi (new)

Thi Elyse wrote: "GREAT interview! ....I will read the next book...[I'm enjoying Tana French: including liking 'her' as a human being ---as it comes through in her writing]....

but I a *dying* for her to bring ROB ..."

YES and I am a BIIG Rob Ryan FAN!
Awesome interveiw too.

message 23: by Matt (new)

Matt Smith Having just spent the last few weeks reading "In the Woods" and "The Likeness" back-to-back, I definitely need more Rob and Cassie. It's a true testament to the author when the reader is both physically and emotionally exhausted at the end...and even a bit haunted, as I am. Even though "The Likeness" puts a sort of finality on that particular relationship, I don't doubt Tana French's talent in being able to resurrect it in some way. Keeping my fingers crossed for that...

message 24: by Elizabeth R (new)

Elizabeth R now that i'm thinking of it, i'm not sure how much i would like rob without cassie! interesting thought....but i'll take more of all of them, please and thank you.

message 25: by Mark (new)

Mark i found "The Likeness" on a community bookshelf while I was in Afghanistan and immediatley fell in love with Tana's writing style. I couldn't wait to read "In the Woods," and read it as soon as i returned. I gave both to my wife who also loves Tana's work and we both just recently finished "Faithful Place." Anxiously awaiting book four, keep up the great work! And bring back Cassie...

message 26: by Magalway (new)

Magalway I have not been able to put Rob and Cassie's relationship out of my mind since reading IN THE WOODS, which I read after LIKENESS and FAITHFUL PLACE. I want them to re-connect in some way. I
feel as though we were left hanging, somehow. They never had the conversation they (and we) truly needed.

message 27: by Magalway (new)

Magalway And, I want Tana to go back into the woods. What happened to Jamie and Peter, finally? I raced through the end of the book, and although I was thrilled and frustrated by Damien's and Rosalind's
role in Katy's death, I wanted to know more about Rob's past.

message 28: by Donna (new)

Donna Croce There are some parts of "In The Woods" that are so beautiful, they bring tears to my eyes.

Rob is clearly effed up; but his inner ramblings after losing Cassie are just heart wrenching. I so wanted more of this relationship.

And I had no problem with the ending. Sometimes it's better not to know and to keep wondering.

Can't wait for the next book, have read #1 through #3 twice, need more Tana French!!!

message 29: by Heather (new)

Heather Aside from Ryan being an interesting character, I want an answer to his mystery PLEASE!!!

message 30: by Nicole (last edited Sep 08, 2012 01:58PM) (new)

Nicole Thi wrote: "MUST WRITE IN ROB'S AND CASSIE'S P.O.V AGAIN!!!! Shouldn't let go of Cassie, sam, and especiall not Rob Ryan. <3"

OOO how about Sam's POV working with Rob who is still on the murder squad albeit as a floater. In The Woods Again :D

message 31: by Caroline (new)

Caroline What a lovely and informative interview. Well done! Love the insight from Tana French and the thought provoking questions that were asked. Yes, her books are definitely "paper crack". Thanks goodreads! Yes, I too want to get back to Rob and Cassie as well^-^

message 32: by Jake (new)

Jake I hope Mrs. French somehow finds a way to bring Rob back into the picture. He, although messed up, is defined by heartbreak, but I feel like at the end of "In The Woods", he accepts his past. He says something to the extent of realizing that the wood is actually beautiful and colorful, and was once his safe haven. I just hope Rob (Hopefully he is not the killer either lol) finds a way to have the much needed talk with Cassie. He has to find out that Cassie went to England to abort the child, he has to assert why he left her after essentially using her, and in return, Cassie has to air out some of her feelings because I feel like she is not over him (although she says she is at the end of the Likeness). There is so much to be gained by touching on Rob's P.O.V once again. HOPING!!!! All of the books are awesome too!

message 33: by William (new)

William Bonney Amazing, I'm now reading Faithful Place, got Broken Harbor on my desk and what no one has mentioned is that Ms. French is laughing out loud funny. Outstanding dialogue and I love the idea, mentioned in another interview, that one character may not have all the facts about another one and that is amplified in another book. Ms. French definitely spans a couple of genres IMHO. Will be looking for her next few.

message 34: by Arie (new)

Arie I honestly don't think there's a character I wouldn't like to read the point of view of! But dying to find out what really happened to Rob's friends. Also hope Cassie and Rob could reconcile for when she marries Sam... Would to cool to hear Sam's perspective.

How funny would a short story from Quigley's POV be?!

Susan (the other Susan) Reading this interview over a year after the fact (new to GR) and dying for the next novel. Dying, you hear me? There's a murder mystery in the making right there.

message 36: by Matt (new)

Matt Smith Susan wrote: "...dying for the next novel. Dying, you hear me? There's a murder mystery in the making right there."

Yup. The Secret Place is a Faithful Place one-off. But I'm holding out for a Rob Ryan-Cassie Maddox reunion. It'll happen. Probably'll happen. Better happen.

Susan (the other Susan) Whatever she writes, I don't doubt that she'll top our expectations. I wasn't expecting to care so much about Frank, who was such an ass in Cassie's story, but Faithful Place turned out to be my favorite by this author.

message 38: by Boris (new)

Boris Tana's books are great, all, byt special In the Woods. In the Woods is my favorite, mysterie,murder,love story Cassie and Rob...

back to top