The Plot Against America in The Complete Idiots Guide to the Ultimate Reading List

Aug 22, 2010 Lisa (Harmonybites) rated it did not like it

Shelves: historical-fiction, literary-fiction, novels, fiction, popular-fiction, ultimate-reading-list, before-i-die

Given eminent literary critic Harold Bloom names Roth along with Delillo, McCarthy and Pynchon as the four greatest American authors of his time, I expected to hate this book. Well, I did, but not for stylistic reasons--I liked Roth's style, which was eminently readable; I'd even describe the novel as a page-turner. The book's premise is fascinating: an alternate history where Charles Lindbergh defeated Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1940 to become president of the United States and came to an acc Given eminent literary critic Harold Bloom names Roth along with Delillo, McCarthy and Pynchon as the four greatest American authors of his time, I expected to hate this book. Well, I did, but not for stylistic reasons--I liked Roth's style, which was eminently readable; I'd even describe the novel as a page-turner. The book's premise is fascinating: an alternate history where Charles Lindbergh defeated Franklin Delano Roosevelt in 1940 to become president of the United States and came to an accommodation with the Nazis. I also rather liked Roth's central narrative conceit. The book is written as if it were a memoir of an alternate Philip Roth looking back at his experiences from age seven to nine years old, covering the time from Lindbergh's nomination for president to October of 1942. There's a wealth of evocative (if sometimes twisted) historical detail used to ground Roth's vision and some really nice touches, such as having Lindbergh campaign by barnstorming America. That's enough to earn it two stars.

The problem is the workings of Roth's plot, his characterizations of historic Republican politicians and of the anti-war movement reminds me far too much of loony leftist fantasists like Michael Moore and Oliver Stone. Maybe the title should have warned me. Given some of the descriptions of the "laconic" Lindbergh, his mastermind vice-president Wheeler and the publication date of 2004, I suspect we were supposed to see George W Bush and Dick Cheney in his depiction.

But there's a rather savage irony here. The most sinister governmental act in Roth's tale is the forced relocation of 245 Jewish families to the heartland. Ironic, because in reality, exactly at the time Roth sets this, a far vaster racially motivated forced relocation and internment, of Japanese-Americans, was occurring--enacted by Roth's hero, FDR. An injustice not alluded to in Roth's novel or even his historical "postscript" listing the real FDR's acts. Someone who really wanted to write a powerful indictment of tyranny should have pointed that event up, not ignored it. But that wouldn't have suited Roth's simplistic partisan fable. ...more

9 likes · Like · see review

Nov 30, 2011 Roseann rated it really liked it

In a world where Lindberg becomes president instead of FDR getting his third term, Hitler's fascism and anti-semitism slinks into our country. I usually do not like "alternate history" stories, but this one is beautifully written and well worth the read. ...more

Like · see review

Jul 01, 2010 John Parker rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

I loved this book! It's one of the most creative, unique, out-of-the box stories I've read in a while. Or maybe I should say "Listened to" in a while, because this was the audiobook version, which was narrated by Ron Silver (rest his soul), who is probably my favorite reader of all times, and whose voice is so infectious (in a good way) that I found him narrating the various thoughts in my head, even when they had nothing to do with the book, Philip Roth, or Lindberg's America. I would recommend ...more

Like · see review