From the Bookshelf of Mock Newbery 2026…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought
This is sort of a junior version of "The Tell-Tale Heart" by Edgar Allen Poe. Penny takes a marble she find in the grass and then feels sick with guilt that she may have stolen it.
The ending isn't quite as cute as Penny and Her Doll, but this book is definitely another shining example of Henkes' gift for writing great stories for very young readers where every word counts. ...more
The ending isn't quite as cute as Penny and Her Doll, but this book is definitely another shining example of Henkes' gift for writing great stories for very young readers where every word counts. ...more
We get to see even more of Penny's world here as she begins by walking through her neighborhood. When Penny finds a marble, the temptation is too great and she scoops it up to take home. Penny's experience with guilt is very understandable, but the setup doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. If Mrs. Goodwin wanted someone to have the marble, why in the world would she leave it in her grass instead of just giving it to someone? Kind of weird honestly. Otherwise this is pretty good. I love that
...more
Penny pushes her doll Rose up and down the block, and one day she finds a blue marble in front of Mrs. Goodwin’s house. She picks it up and plays with it all day. However, she starts to feel bad about taking the marble without asking Mrs. Goodwin. She can’t sleep that night, so the next day she drops the marble back in Mrs. Goodwin’s yard. Before she can run away quick enough, Mrs. Goodwin asks why Penny doesn’t want the marble. You see, Mrs. Goodwin put the marble in the lawn hoping some child
...more
I love this book! It captures feelings of guilt and the reluctance of children to tell their parents about their emotional world. Although Penny simply took home a marble that she found, she starts to wonder whether the marble belongs to her neighbor. Her stomach aches, she can't sleep and in the end she decides on her own to rectify the situation. It's a beginner reading level, but it would make a nice read-aloud too.
...more
2014 Theodor Seuss Geisel Honor Book (for the most distinguished book for beginning readers)
Sweet little reader about Penny and the struggle she has about taking a beautiful marble she finds when she is not sure she should have.
Sweet little reader about Penny and the struggle she has about taking a beautiful marble she finds when she is not sure she should have.
Penny feels guilty about taking something that is not hers and does the right thing. Henkes gets it just right. I love Penny's imagination.
...more
The new readers that this book is intended for will empathize with Penny's dilemma and want to keep reading to find out what happens!
...more
Penny and her marble had the perfect mix of imagination, inner conflict, and beautiful illustrations. A perfect read aloud for young children.
We love Penny at our house. She's sweet, but a little impulsive. In this latest installment, Penny finds a marble during her morning walk.
...more
Aug 11, 2012
Sarah
marked it as to-read
Nov 12, 2012
Shawn
marked it as to-read
Mar 18, 2013
Rachel
marked it as to-read
Sep 10, 2013
Brandy
marked it as to-read
