A Monster Calls in Mock Newbery 2026

Nov 21, 2011 Elizabeth K. rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: 2011-new-reads

The funny thing is that I went into this expecting it to be sad, in fact, I planned on it, and held on to the book until I knew I had a night home alone so I could sufficiently wallow in it and thoroughly enjoy the sadness. But what happened is that I read that book about the slaves at Monticello while I was waiting for my Night of Reading and Kleenex to come up, and it turns out that real life slavery is fairly distressing on its own, which I think put some of my wallowing in perspective.

This ...more

Like · see review

Dec 31, 2011 Hilary rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: grades-5-6, grades-7-8, contemporary-fiction, teen, realism

A monster calls to Conor at 12:07 a.m. And informs him that it is going to tell Conor three stories, and after the third story, Conor must tell the monster his truth. Conor doesn't want to hear the monsters stories and he knows he doesn't want to tell his truth (the nightmare) to the monster, or anyone, for that matter. At first Conor dreads visits from the monster, but as his mother continues to get sicker and a bully continues to harass him at school, he begins to anxiously await the monsters ...more

Like · see review

Mar 24, 2013 Steph rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

I actually read ‘A Monster Calls’ some time ago, but have since taught it and read it once again. Twice in about 3 months! Was it worth it? YES!!!! This is the best YA book if not the best book I have read this year and there have been a few. I don’t often cry at books. I cried when I read this, cried when I read it a second time and had to restrain myself when I read it to me rather rambunctious Year 8 class. So having delayed my review, I am still not sure where to begin. It is just brilliant I actually read ‘A Monster Calls’ some time ago, but have since taught it and read it once again. Twice in about 3 months! Was it worth it? YES!!!! This is the best YA book if not the best book I have read this year and there have been a few. I don’t often cry at books. I cried when I read this, cried when I read it a second time and had to restrain myself when I read it to me rather rambunctious Year 8 class. So having delayed my review, I am still not sure where to begin. It is just brilliant writing – subtle, sensitively written and deeply emotive without sentimentality. Even if you do not like YA, you should read ‘A Monster Calls’! and I have endlessly recommended it to friends. I don’t even know how to classify it: perhaps somewhere between fairy tale and ‘Tuesday’s with Morrie’ (another fabulous novel),but for a younger audience.

The novel is actually based on an idea by Siobhan Dowd, a great children’s novelist who sadly died and was then taken up by Patrick Ness. It is therefore very different to his ‘Chaos Walking’ series so do not think you are going to experience the same dystopian alien world. This is a novel painfully grounded in reality.

Conor has been suffering the nightmare for a long time so when the monster appears in his dream, he is not even afraid only a little frustrated and then hopeful… because this is not the nightmare, this is just a tree and a tree who has come walking not to terrify, not to destroy, not to launch him into a new hellish world…but to tell him stories. However, the tree also demands a deal: he will tell Conor three stories, stories based on the Yew tree’s thousands of years of experience, but at the end of the three stories, Conor will tell him his own story – the fourth tale and this, must be the truth. Easy, no big deal – it’s a story! However, what the tree teaches us and Conor is that stories are ‘wild things’ they have teeth and can ‘bite’ and the truth is the most painful of all…

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8-psq...]

Ness intersperses the tree’s visits and the stories he tells, with a secondary narrative – Conor’s real life, which in many regards is more terrible and painful than any story he can deliver: Conor lives with his mother, who has cancer; he does not get on with his interfering and fastidious grandmother and his father has abandoned them for a new family in America and barely knows how to address his own son any more. Moreover, Conor’s only recourse has been to retreat into himself so school is ever more painful, a place where if he is not bullied, he is invisible. So when the tree comes walking, Conor is not afraid because all he can see, all he can imagine, all he can envisage is hope.

What makes this novel so great?

This is a novel that deals with a very difficult, emotional subject and yet does so with sensitivity and not sentimentality, which is ultimately what makes it so moving.
This is also a novel that teaches us about the power of stories – not merely those we invent, but our own.
This is a novel that superbly mixes fantasy and reality: there is a terrible brutality about Conor’s waking life and yet the interweaving of the tree’s fairytalesque narratives is seamless and beautifully mirrors what is occurring in his real life.
This is a novel with a moving message for any individual suffering loss.
This is also a novel that draws wonderfully on pagan mythology through the image of the yew tree and its healing properties as well as references to the green man and Herne the hunter. It is through myth and story that the tree teaches Conor just as myth and story teach us. There also feels as if (and it maybe my own pagan tendencies) there is a message about the natural process of things and the need to accept both the beauty and effulgence of nature at the same time as its cruelty. It is a novel full of ambiguities that defies definition and simple happy endings just as it defies categorisation either of its form or characters.
Lastly, a word has to be given for the illustrations. There are two versions of this book that you could buy. One is your standard novel; the other is an illustrated version with images by Jim Kay. I am very, very lucky in that when I chose to teach this novel, by Head of Department agreed to invest in the illustrated version (a class set of 30, which is no mean expense – thank you Petey!). It is worth it! Jim Kay’s wonderful illustrations really enhance the narrative. Their monochrome quality reflects the melancholic nature of Conor’s existence; mirrors the imprisoning nature of his circumstances especially at school and compliments the nightmarish world established by the yew tree. They are so evocative and vivid that the text springs to life.

This is a book that moves you: it deals with grief better than almost any I have encountered and it is simultaneously a work of art. How it has not received more attention and more awards I do not know. It is magnificent. Read it, love it, cry over it because you undoubtedly will! Haunting, heart breaking and yet full of hope – ‘A Monster Calls’ is simply wonderful! ...more

Like · see review

Jan 10, 2012 LauraW rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: young-adult, tween

As I finished this, I kept thinking: this really isn't a book for kids. It is too powerful and too sad. I know that kids have to go through experiences like this, but it is hard to envision giving them this book, before they need to know this kind of pain. And yet... To know these experiences is to know what humans are.

I still don't know if I would give this book to most kids. I do know, however, that I will not willingly read it aloud. I can't get through Where the Red Fern Grows, either. ...more

Like · see review

Aug 21, 2012 Caroline Rose added it · review of another edition

I do not say this lightly: never has a book moved me as this painful, tender one did.

1 like · Like · see review

Dec 16, 2011 Margaret rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

mock newberry blog. - loved it! Very sad, but probably okay for 6th

Like · see review

Dec 13, 2011 Brenda Kahn rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: weepie, mothers-and-sons, death-and-dying

How does one say one really loved a book that tore one's guts out? ...more

Like · see review

Oct 03, 2011 Inoli rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: do-not-own-yet, best-great, recommend, fantasy-horror, study-psych

A masterful piece of imagery. I've never read anything like this and really have no idea how to categorize it. I think I need to put Mr. Ness on the top of next read list. ...more

3 likes · Like · see review