From the Bookshelf of Audiobook Junkies…
Find A Copy At
Group Discussions About This Book
No group discussions for this book yet.
What Members Thought
At the end of A Feast for Crows, GRRM excitedly warned readers that it and the subsequent A Dance With Dragons were actually a single book, separated due to length. He promised that missing characters would be present in Dragons and that the stories would catch up and proceed onwards. For this reason, I will often be referring back to Crows.
I feel that separating the books was an unfortunate decision and Dragons suffered for it. I wanted to give this book three stars, but I feel like reading it ...more
I feel that separating the books was an unfortunate decision and Dragons suffered for it. I wanted to give this book three stars, but I feel like reading it ...more
★★★½ I can’t believe I’m rating this book the same as AFfC, but it doesn’t deserve four stars, IMHO. Maybe I should lower AFfC to just an even three. Why so low for ADwD?
First: I didn’t like the layout of these two books, but that was GRRM’s decision, not mine. The timeline was too discombobulated with book #4 and book #5 really being one gigantic book – with basically opposing sides presented in each volume. GRRM occasionally threw in another POV character, but it didn’t sustain the oomph of th ...more
First: I didn’t like the layout of these two books, but that was GRRM’s decision, not mine. The timeline was too discombobulated with book #4 and book #5 really being one gigantic book – with basically opposing sides presented in each volume. GRRM occasionally threw in another POV character, but it didn’t sustain the oomph of th ...more
I feel like you can't trust certain things in this series, mostly when people die. I seem to be shocked at certain deaths, get mad at the author, and then they are back and I am not sure how I feel about that. Sometimes they are so changed that death would have been better.
A lot of the characters try so hard to do the right thing, but then are manipulated into doing other things. If they would listen to their first thoughts things would be so much better.
I do love it when the "bad" characters ge ...more
A lot of the characters try so hard to do the right thing, but then are manipulated into doing other things. If they would listen to their first thoughts things would be so much better.
I do love it when the "bad" characters ge ...more
Sep 24, 2011
Secret Realm Reviews&Services
rated it
it was amazing
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
my-favorite-novels
