Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Bible, Gender, Sexuality: Reframing the Church's Debate on Same-Sex Relationships” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Bible, Gender, Sexuality: Reframing the Church's Debate on Same-Sex Relationships

James V. Brownson

4.09 · Rating details · 439 ratings · 77 reviews

Grapples conscientiously with biblical texts at the heart of the church's debate over same-sex relationships

This thought-provoking book by James Brownson develops a broad, cross-cultural sexual ethic from Scripture, locates current debates over homosexuality in that wider context, and explores why the Bible speaks the way it does about same-sex relationships.

Fairly prese ...more

Get A Copy

Paperback, 312 pages

Published February 3rd 2013 by Eerdmans

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Bible, Gender, Sexuality, please sign up.

Lists with This Book

God and the Gay Christian by Matthew Vines

What the Bible Really Says about Homosexuality by Daniel A. Helminiak

Same-Sex Unions in Premodern Europe by John Boswell

LGBTI-affirming Christian

245 books — 70 voters

We Were Spiritual Refugees by Katie Hays

The Best of Queer Theology

36 books — 3 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 4.09 ·

Rating details

· 439 ratings · 77 reviews

Sort order

Start your review of Bible, Gender, Sexuality: Reframing the Church's Debate on Same-Sex Relationships

Dec 30, 2013 Emily Timbol rated it it was amazing

I have not recommended any book to friends, family, and fellow church-goers as much as this one, and for three good reasons:

1)It is the absolute best book out there that I've read (and I've read a lot of them) that deals with the issues of homosexuality and the Bible. This book answers all of your questions, and even ones you didn't know you had.

2) It's written by someone who has the knowledge, wisdom, and experience to speak to multiple generations of people with questions about the Bible. Thi ...more

flag 13 likes · Like · see review

Nov 14, 2017 Joel Wentz rated it really liked it

Persusing reviews for books like this can be frustrating. Frequently those who are uncomfortable with Brownson's argument immediately lump it in the 1-star category, while there are those on the "other side" who are equally-simply looking for a smart argument that affirms their own desire to affirm same-sex unions in the church and slap it with 5-stars (or whatever the appropriate rating system allows). What both seem to miss is interacting with the substance of the argument laid out in the work ...more

flag 9 likes · Like · see review

Nov 21, 2018 Will Dominique rated it really liked it

Shelves: christianity, reviewed, academia

This was well-written in a way that really facilitated understanding for me. I am not very familiar with Christianity, and I often feel lost when trying to read exegeses and academic takes on the Bible. When using examples and quotations from the Bible, Brownsen illustrates their significance, their relations to one another, and their relevance today in a way that is clear and logical. It could have been easy for me to get lost with so much information, but Brownsen simplifies and sums up his ma ...more

flag 7 likes · Like · see review

Oct 20, 2013 Joan rated it did not like it

I read this book because the author is a professor at a seminary of the denomination I grew up in. The denomination is considering the ordination of practicing gays and this book is a move in that direction. The author had written at least one position paper opposing such a move. Then his son announced he was gay. Now the author has rethought the issue and is very accepting of loving, committed same sex relationships. His arguments are complex, looking at early Greek literature for use of words, ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Sep 04, 2015 Thomas Reeves rated it it was ok

The value of this book for me was to get acquainted with some of the exegesis, reasoning, and applications of those arguing for the appropriateness of life-long, lasting, same-sex relationships.

The book is thoughtfully written in an academic sense (and the author writes very well), but bias seems evident throughout. There is a "bone" thrown to the "traditional view of marriage", but like so much of modern Protestantism (conservative and liberal alike), the exegesis is approached from an individu The value of this book for me was to get acquainted with some of the exegesis, reasoning, and applications of those arguing for the appropriateness of life-long, lasting, same-sex relationships.

The book is thoughtfully written in an academic sense (and the author writes very well), but bias seems evident throughout. There is a "bone" thrown to the "traditional view of marriage", but like so much of modern Protestantism (conservative and liberal alike), the exegesis is approached from an individualistic hermeneutic with seemingly few sensitivities to the realities of "the informing traditions" that we all have vying for our attention. Modern context, life experience, and "fine-sounding arguments" abound; the reality of a transcendent and necessary Christian tradition (although, often falibly understood) seems arbitrary to the book. There is little in the book that leaves room for other, more historic interpretations of scripture.

Beyond some grand idea of the "love of God" (which seems to avoid counter-cultural thinking or anything that would be "tough" on those being loved), Gospel and Kingdom teaching seemed to have little bearing on the outcomes of the author's interpretation. There is no sense of the place of suffering, the complexities of our own penchant toward self-idolatry and self-destruction, and the blindness we have as finite and sinful creatures (redeemed or not).

In my mind, this author has little hesitancy taking huge philosophical leaps, basing crucial decisions in the text using arguments from silence, and constantly engaging "possible" interpretations of the text as the "likely" interpretations with the wave of an individualistic magic wand.

That said, it does seem that the author is trying to deal with the scriptures seriously, and is interacting with the key sources in regards to the discussion at hand in the Protestant church (and Biblical theology as a whole). Thus, this book is less reactive and concentrated more on the exegesis of scripture than many other tomes. I did find some of his work in various sources helpful and thought-provoking.

However, the author's need to find "what he is looking for" in the Biblical text betrays him, thus, giving the book a strongly eisegetical flavor. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Apr 15, 2013 Ranoordam rated it it was ok

This book is written not so much with an open mind but by a loving father who wants to make sense of his son's sexual orientation. If what the bible seems to say conflicts with this preconceived idea, the words of the bible are taken apart and fit together again so they fit in the box. Maybe dr. Brownson should write about this subject again in 20 years. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Sep 05, 2018 Sara rated it it was amazing

I don’t normally review nonfiction, but this book is too good to not talk about. If you follow Christianity and are in, or know someone in the LGBT+ community, I highly recommend you read this book. Brownson takes time to examine commonly used Biblical passages down to the original languages, and provides the cultural content of those passages. He also does his best to examine arguments on both sides of the debate—acknowledging their best and worst logic. He also provides a framework for Christi ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Jul 31, 2020 David rated it it was amazing

Shelves: bible-general-bible, lgbtq

James Brownson’s argument in this book is that when the Bible writers do not condemn same sex committed monogamous relationships and thus there is no reason for Christians to do so today. This is probably the best book I have read on the subject (David Gushee’s is probably more approachable for the laymen, this one is a little heavier in the Bible and theology department).

Brownson argument focuses on Romans 1 because that is really the primary passage that this entire debate centers on. Romans James Brownson’s argument in this book is that when the Bible writers do not condemn same sex committed monogamous relationships and thus there is no reason for Christians to do so today. This is probably the best book I have read on the subject (David Gushee’s is probably more approachable for the laymen, this one is a little heavier in the Bible and theology department).

Brownson argument focuses on Romans 1 because that is really the primary passage that this entire debate centers on. Romans 1 condemns same sex relationships, calling them unnatural. This is clear. The question Brownson forces us to ask is, why are such relationships condemned? What does it mean to say they are unnatural?

Whether we agree with Brownson’s conclusions or not, this is a vital point of biblical interpretation. It is unhealthy to just glance at a verse, read it at surface level and take it at so-called face value. Our assumptions, cultural norms, values, scientific understanding and much else shape what we mean by “face value” after all. As Brownson points out, to the writers of the New Testament, long hair was “unnatural.” So too was women in leadership. Further, a face value interpretation of the Bible can easily be seen to support slavery (and was seen that way through the Civil War in America). Interpretation is hard, as is questioning long-held beliefs. But it must be done.

Brownson’s argument is too long and detailed to get into here (and why should I do your work for you?). He basically argues Paul’s condemnation focuses on self-centered lust. Men who were married to women were so filled with lust they would seek sex with men. Included in this was, at times, temple prostitution and pedarasty (men with younger boys). In a hierarchical culture, women were seen as lower on the scale, so it was unnatural and shameful to take the female position in a male-male relationship. There are more arguments in here. Through all of this, the key point Brownson makes is that same-sex committed monogamous relationships are not condemned. They were rarely, if ever, even in view.

Paul, and the ancient writers of scripture in general, had no concept of sexual orientation as we understand it today. People are born inclined to be attracted to men or women and there is little to no evidence that this can be changed (even organizations that existed to help people change their orientation admit at most like 15% actually change). The church has challenged those with same-sex attraction to go against their natural inclination and marry someone of the opposite sex. But if orientation rarely changes, this sets them up for broken marriages and families. The church also challenges all same-sex attracted people to just be celibate. Yet celibacy has always been a special calling, not something for whole groups of people. The best thing the church could do for same-sex attracted people is to ask them to not go against their natural inclination (and marry a person of the opposite gender or to be celibate) but to marry someone they desire to marry.

In this, the calling to self-sacrificial love and lifelong commitment would be the same that it is for heterosexual couples.

Brownson’s argument is probably the strongest you will find for this view. Of course, if you desire, you can find arguments for the traditional view.

I guess that’s the thing. Throughout the history of the church, you could find arguments for and against a whole lot of things. In the 1100s it was obvious the Bible supported holy war against the Muslims, in the 1800s it was obvious the Bible supported slavery and up until recently it was obvious all Jews were guilty of the killing of Jesus. People had chapter and verse and everyone took such ideas for granted.

Until they didn’t. But they often didn’t change through studying the Bible more. Slavery ended with the Civil War and after that we all learned to read the Bible through an abolitionist lens. I imagine the same will happen with our gay and lesbian brothers and sisters. As more people see same-sex couples who love Jesus, serve others, are kind and demonstrate the same sort of self-sacrificial love for one another as heterosexual couples do, this will continue to force us to dig deeper into the scriptures, past the surface level that merely confirms our traditions.

I guess only time will tell. For now, I am thankful for books like Brownson’s because whether you disagree or agree with his argument, he offers a strong one to be reckoned with. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Feb 11, 2019 Spenceface Klavan rated it it was amazing

Committed Christians who experience same sex attraction must navigate the influence of two equally pernicious interest groups. On the one hand there is a reflexive legalism which disguises cultural prejudice behind ahistorical and quite flimsy exegesis, using selective readings of decontextualised passages to lay intolerable burdens upon troubled souls (see Matthew 23:4; Luke 11:46).
Yet those gay people who react against such bigotry run the risk of abandoning entirely the robust commitment to Committed Christians who experience same sex attraction must navigate the influence of two equally pernicious interest groups. On the one hand there is a reflexive legalism which disguises cultural prejudice behind ahistorical and quite flimsy exegesis, using selective readings of decontextualised passages to lay intolerable burdens upon troubled souls (see Matthew 23:4; Luke 11:46).
Yet those gay people who react against such bigotry run the risk of abandoning entirely the robust commitment to scriptural authority and divine sovereignty which is the Christian's only hope in discerning and obeying the will of God. Christians who long for loving same-sex relationships too often lose their faith and fall victim to forces within the LGBTQ movement which offer liberation at the cost of senseless libertinism. For all its many achievements, this branch of the gay rights movement has not yet furnished a serious framework for any sort of ennobling or sanctified sexual ethic.
Thus, though there are loving voices on both sides of this debate, those are sadly not the voices which tend to prevail: having been putatively disbarred from Christian orthodoxy as unfairly monopolized by the worst kind of conservatism, gay people often find themselves at the mercy of the worst kind of liberalism.
Against this backdrop Brownson is a breath of magnificent fresh air. He takes the Bible seriously as God's revealed word and seeks to make it his absolute authority, while still forming answers to the major modern questions of sexuality which are neither flippant nor blinkered. Those who find themselves seeking to think prayerfully about God's will for their lives on this issue -- even those who are not themselves same-sex attracted -- could hardly do better than Brownson for a companion, guide, and interlocutor.
This is therefore a book that anyone who is interested in thinking seriously about a faithful Christian approach to modern sexuality must read. Many will not accept Brownson's arguments and maintain, lovingly and sincerely, that celibacy is the only godly lifestyle for gay Christians. I believe in the good faith of such people and embrace them entirely as my brothers and sisters and Christ, though I disagree with them. But they too will find their minds sharpened and expanded by engaging with, and formulating responses to, Brownson's wonderful book. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Aug 08, 2019 Lincoln Reynolds rated it it was amazing

4.75/5 stars.

This book was everything that “God and the Gay Christian” should have been (see my review of GatGC for context).

It’s obviously important that Brownson, unlike Matthew Vines, is actually a scholar of Christianity. Brownson does what Vines was totally unable to do in GatGC and dives waaaay deep into anthropology and language to make his arguments. His arguments are much more fleshed-out, and he does a much better job of saying everything about most arguments, rather than saying some a 4.75/5 stars.

This book was everything that “God and the Gay Christian” should have been (see my review of GatGC for context).

It’s obviously important that Brownson, unlike Matthew Vines, is actually a scholar of Christianity. Brownson does what Vines was totally unable to do in GatGC and dives waaaay deep into anthropology and language to make his arguments. His arguments are much more fleshed-out, and he does a much better job of saying everything about most arguments, rather than saying some about every argument. Brownson’s writing is much better for someone who has “done their reading” on the traditional interpretations. This book is a well-researched piece of evidence, while Matthew Vines’ book sounds like a rebellious teenager desperately and naïvely trying to defend themselves when mom and dad “just don’t understand.”

Any time I raised a question or thought, “well, what about...” Brownson immediately answered, or promised to answer in a later chapter (and followed through).

The only major complaint I have, and why I more accurately give a 4.75 star rating, is Brownson’s lack of diverse sources for the traditional viewpoints. Almost every single traditional argument comes from Robert Gagnon, an author who frankly I had never heard of before reading this book (and I have been a traditionalist my whole life). He uses phrasing like “many traditionalists,” then in the footnotes cites only Gagnon, who he has cited for most traditional interpretations throughout the book. For traditional interpretations to be the overwhelming majority among Christians historically and today, Brownson seems to have much difficulty finding other traditionalist authors....

All in all, the book has given me a LOT to think about, and was incredibly insightful and thought-provoking about other topics in addition to same-sex relationships (e.g. women in the church and general Christian theology/hermeneutics). I would highly recommend to any Christian or person interested in the topic. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Aug 11, 2013 Slindsay rated it it was amazing

Shelves: re-read

After years of reading from various research texts and books concerning LGBT people and the church I have finally read a comprehensive book that provides a sound theology and articulate response for Christians that does not require us to abandon our faith. James Brownson writes with a discerning heart and mind that engages an open forum toward the investigation of LGBT people and their place in Christianity. Others like Gagnon and Hays write from one-sided perspectives and do a disservice to rea ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Dec 22, 2014 Alex rated it it was amazing

A book that delves into the extremely complex and convoluted debate regarding homosexuality and the Bible's admonishment of homosexuality and homosexual acts. The book looks at a variety of factors influencing the original intent of the authors, but also relates it to the culture at large today as well as with motifs seen throughout the development of the Bible. Though by no means "complete," the book is thorough and, I think, provides an articulate and responsible reading of what - particularly ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jul 31, 2020 Rick Lee Lee James rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Scholarship with humility on a very divisive subject.

This is the most exhaustive work of scholarship I personally have read on the subject of God, Gender, and Sexuality. Any Christian who is seeking to understand the Biblical and ethical implications of same-sex marriage would do well to read this book. With holiness as his goal, and the heart of a father with a gay son, the author dives deep into scripture seeking context for the very few verses that address the topic. I suggest the reader brin ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Oct 16, 2018 Jenn rated it really liked it

This was exactly the book i had hoped and expected it to be.

The author came from and looked toward the same place i was coming from and looking toward.

I begin with this bias: I actually want the Bible to tell me that the non-heterosexual people in my life are fully acceptable, and NOT “love the sinner, hate the sin.” I was comfortable with that position for a long time, until the issue got too close and i felt like my choice became either push a sinner you love away from you in an unloving mann This was exactly the book i had hoped and expected it to be.

The author came from and looked toward the same place i was coming from and looking toward.

I begin with this bias: I actually want the Bible to tell me that the non-heterosexual people in my life are fully acceptable, and NOT “love the sinner, hate the sin.” I was comfortable with that position for a long time, until the issue got too close and i felt like my choice became either push a sinner you love away from you in an unloving manner, or call what is bad good. I couldn’t live with either choice.

Unexpectedly, i found that the first parts of the book deepened my understanding of biblical heterosexual life and marriage, which was an enriching and thought provoking experience.

The author’s conclusions on what a broad, cross-cultural vision for the center of Christian Sexual Ethics was strong and convincing.

I would say that in the exploration of the boundary language of romans 1:24-27, the author was less convincing. However, the extensive thought put into the interpretation of the words used on this passage did reveal that they may not be as clear and straightforward as i had previously believed. Words are tricky, and this section was enough for me to admit i may not know what i thought i knew.

And at that point, he presented what seem like two choices available to the church, one of which i feel i can fully embrace, with the new humility to say, maybe have not but still do not understand God’s view of this issue, and maybe that is ok.

The author did NOT force me to conclude that homosexuality is part of God’s plan for humanity, but rather gave me the option of this humility. I feel i can move forward in life, seeing this as one of very many aspects of human life that are broken in this fallen world. But this brokenness does not have to hold a special place amongst all the other broken bits of us, as it long has. Instead, it can be yet another place in which God uses the broken things, the unacceptable things of this world, and brings great good, beauty, and healing.

This is exactly what i needed. I think a lot of other Christians need it too. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Sep 20, 2013 Lianne Simon rated it really liked it

For a long while I have been interested in formulating a Reformed position on intersex. It was with that in mind that I read this book.

James V Brownson is Professor of New Testament at Western Theological Seminary, "an evangelical and ecumenical community of faith and learning in the Reformed tradition"

The author also has a son who, although he's never had sexual relations, is gay. That is a large part of what prompted a closer look at a Biblical view of homosexuality.

It's obvious to anyone who ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jul 12, 2013 Larry Koester rated it liked it

The author does refocus the whole same sex eroticism in needed ways, it in some ways muddies this issues. It leave once feeling the need to examine individual motives and intention. The institution of marriage isn't defended by denying same sex marriage. What damages the institution of heterosexual marriage is the apparent lack of commitment so many of them seem to be bringing into their marriages. Anyway, valuable reading of this issue. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jun 06, 2016 Brian rated it it was amazing

Shelves: paper

Pounded through this one pretty fast. The format lent itself to a quick study, but provided much to chew on for more in depth study. This is a book I plan to purchase and read again. An excellent reference.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Apr 09, 2015 Wade Stotts rated it did not like it

Shelves: gender-issues, theology

Very bad. If you'd like a good discussion on same-sex relationships and the Bible, I'd recommend "Can You Be Gay and Christian?" By Michael Brown. ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 15, 2020 Sherrie rated it it was amazing

I was raised with the understanding that the 7 texts in the Bible that explicitly discuss same-sex relationships were crystal-clear in condemning homosexuality. As my understanding of the Bible and of God has matured, I've realized very little is as straightforward as it seems, and I've also been bothered at the seeming contradictions or torturous logic at the foundation of many Christians' response to LGBT+ people - "Love the sin, hate the sinner" mindsets, or expecting lifelong celibacy. I kno I was raised with the understanding that the 7 texts in the Bible that explicitly discuss same-sex relationships were crystal-clear in condemning homosexuality. As my understanding of the Bible and of God has matured, I've realized very little is as straightforward as it seems, and I've also been bothered at the seeming contradictions or torturous logic at the foundation of many Christians' response to LGBT+ people - "Love the sin, hate the sinner" mindsets, or expecting lifelong celibacy. I know several gay people in long-term committed relationships that seem healthy and flourishing. Are they really violating God's will? And it also seems absurd that, while Christians are lamenting the decline of marriage in general, they're fighting against the desire of gay people to marry.

I've mostly dealt with this by ignoring the whole thing - 1) Because I truly believe the church's focus on same-sex relationships is a straw man created by Satan to distract Christians from the huge problems that marriage in general is facing in our society, and 2) I had this vague belief that it's everyone's own problem to deal with on their own with God, not mine to dictate or judge. But I was also aware this is a cop-out, and that this is an issue causing enormous conflict in churches and denominations around the globe.

So I read this book mostly with the desire to have some sort of well-researched, academically defensible point of view that was not based on ideology or politics. The book more than delivered that. This is one of the best pieces of academic writing I've read - well-researched, cogently argued and clearly written. The scholarship is impressive, yet Brownson's writing is easy to understand and his points are easy to follow. I was skeptical after reading in the intro that he began this book after coming to a similar conclusion as I about the need for a more well-thought-out point of view, in his case driven by the discovery that his son is gay. I immediately suspected the whole thing was an attempt to justify excuses for his son. But if that's the case, he does an excellent job. I did not feel like it was written with a predetermined opinion that he then was flailing around for evidence to support. Instead, I felt like it was thoughtful, objective, balanced and carefully considerate of opposing viewpoints.

I highly recommend this for any Christian wanting a deeper and more accurate understanding of the 7 texts and same-sex relationships in Biblical times, taking into account cultural and language nuances I would not otherwise have known. ...more

flag Like · see review

Jan 15, 2019 Spencer rated it really liked it

Shelves: sociology-social-issues, theology-and-philosophy

While I think this book is necessary for the Christian faith, particularly the fundamentalist/evangelical/conservative branches of the faith that ascribes to Biblical literalism, I found it to be very heteronormative. The author does mention, at the end of the book, that he did not address bisexuality and gender identity and that was not his point.

His framing, again I do believe it is necessary for many individuals just not for where I'm at in my own faith journey, of replacing a committed hete ...more

flag Like · see review

Feb 15, 2019 Curby Graham rated it it was ok

Read this for an ethics class and it is perhaps the best attempt from a "Christian" writer for legitimizing same sex relationships. Having said that the author does not make a compelling case. I read this with a jaundiced eye when he admits he rethought the issue because his son came out as a homosexual. The book is a sophisticated exercise in eisegesis. That is, reading into the Bible what you want to find, rather than what it actually says in context. He obviously has his pre-determined conclu ...more

flag Like · see review

Apr 07, 2019 John rated it it was amazing

Shelves: non-fiction, religious, education, culture-and-sociology

I spent over a year reading this book. I knew and read quite a few others on the topics of Gender and Sexuality in ancient times. This book is by far the best. The pages on my copy are filled with notes, underlinings, circles, and questions. I simply couldn't read more than 4 pages a day because then I would need other 2-3 days of thinking and researching and trying to make sure I understood the implications Brownson, was making and really unpack those. I also fact-checked him a lot on the concl ...more

flag Like · see review

Oct 07, 2019 James rated it really liked it

This is as good a defense of committed, same-sex relationships as any, I think; in fact, it may even be definitive. The author cites John Boswell, though who, while brilliant, had apparently misinterpreted same-sex bonding rituals of the church (as a very thorough, well-written Wikipedia article points out). Don't go after me for reading Wikipedia--I find it to be great for light research. Anyway, the Bible is a rich and complex series of books that many Christians on both the Left and Right ove ...more

flag Like · see review

Jul 18, 2017 Rob Barry rated it really liked it

I really appreciated the way the author organized this book. His thesis, supporting analysis, conclusions, and bibliography were extremely clear and flowed exceptionally well. I wish all books on "wicked problems," such as the issues wrestled with in this book were organized and argued as well as this one.

Fascinating exploration of questions and core issues involving the interpretation of scripture regarding gender -- particularly same-sex relationships. However, the book also energizes discussi ...more

flag Like · see review

Aug 01, 2020 MK Wildeman rated it really liked it

Shelves: seminary-recommendations, relationships

Before reading Brownson's book I assumed many affirming arguments would treat scripture poorly and merely read their own theology and preference into the text. However, Brownson's argument uses scripture with care and asks many questions I tend to take for granted.
This book is textbook material that does not read like a textbook. If you are delving into this topic, this is a great resource for the affirming argument seen in a fair light.
When diving into LGBTQ+ matters and theology, we need to he ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 11, 2018 Amanda rated it really liked it

Shelves: nonfiction

Brownson provides a thoughtful, detailed, and carefully articulated exploration of the underlying moral logic that informs scripture's engagement with issues of same-sex relationships. His perspective and approach are quite refreshing. By going beyond what scripture says about this issue in the relatively few passages where it is addressed, and asking the question, 'What underlying moral logic is at play', he creates a space where contemporary Christians can have a more nuanced conversation abou ...more

flag Like · see review

Dec 24, 2020 Andrew Huff rated it really liked it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

flag Like · see review

Oct 17, 2017 Joel rated it it was amazing

I've read pretty much everything to come out of both the traditionalist and affirming camps in the last three decades. In terms of scholarly articulation, Brownson's work outstrips anything on the traditionalist side by a mile, including Gagnon's dated work so commonly cited as the authoritative voice in this discussion. He doesn't bother with matters settled long ago (the terms arsenakoitai and malakos barely get a mention), rather he wisely focuses on Romans 1 and it's underlying logic. While ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 29, 2018 Herb Kraker rated it did not like it

Dr. James Brownson has been a well-respected theologian for a good number of years. I have studied this book extensively over the last five years. I have emailed over 3,500 pastors in the Reformed Church in America (Dr. Brownson's denomination) and the Christian Reformed Church (a sister church to Dr. Brownson's). The results of that work can be seen at:

http://www.dialogos-studies.com/same-...

The conclusion I came to is that there are 15 major errors in this book. You are very welcome to visit t ...more

flag Like · see review

Oct 30, 2019 Liz rated it liked it · review of another edition

Other reviewers give more comprehensive theological interactions with Bronson's claims, and so without getting into the gritty details, I'd say this is probably the most academic and researched reformed view on sexuality that I've read. However, I think his attempt to show that cleaving to another person is about kinship, and that Paul's main concerns about homosexuality being unnatural are tied to gender complementarity in Genesis 2, are lacking. His approach, disproving Gagnon's argument and t ...more

flag Like · see review

« previous 1 2 3 next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Recommend It | Stats | Recent Status Updates

Readers also enjoyed

See similar books…

Genres

Nonfiction

22 users

Religion > Theology

21 users

Religion

21 users

LGBT

19 users

Religion > Christianity

17 users

Sexuality

15 users

Christian

7 users

Religion > Faith

6 users

Spirituality

4 users

LGBT > Gay

3 users

See top shelves…

About James V. Brownson

James V. Brownson

3 followers

Books by James V. Brownson

The Promise of Baptism: An Introduction to Baptism in Scripture and the Reformed Tradition

Speaking the Truth in Love: New Testament Resources for a Missional Hermeneutic

StormFront: The Good News of God (Gospel & Our Culture)

More…

News & Interviews

Goodreads Editors (and CEO) Share Their Mystery Picks

Die-hard mystery fans are always on the hunt for their next supremely satisfying whodunit. To help you stock that Want to Read shelf, we asked...

Trivia About Bible, Gender, Se...

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Quotes from Bible, Gender, Se...

“We do not interpret rightly any single passage of Scripture until we locate the text within this larger fabric of meaning in Scripture as a whole.” — 0 likes

“Should the moral logic that informs the condemnation of same-sex erotic activity in the “seven passages” apply categorically to all committed same-sex relationships today? The evidence suggests that there are no forms of moral logic underpinning these passages that clearly and unequivocally forbid all contemporary forms of committed same-sex intimate relationships.” — 0 likes

More quotes…

See a Problem?

Preview — Bible, Gender, Sexuality by James V. Brownson

Bible, Gender, Sexuality: Reframing the Church's Debate on Same-Sex Relationships

Get A Copy

Friend Reviews

Reader Q&A

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

Readers also enjoyed

Genres

About James V. Brownson

Books by James V. Brownson

News & Interviews

Trivia About Bible, Gender, Se...

Quotes from Bible, Gender, Se...

See a Problem?

Preview — Bible, Gender, Sexuality by James V. Brownson

Bible, Gender, Sexuality: Reframing the Church's Debate on Same-Sex Relationships

Get A Copy

Friend Reviews

Reader Q&A

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topicDiscuss This Book

Readers also enjoyed

Genres

About James V. Brownson

Books by James V. Brownson

News & Interviews

Trivia About Bible, Gender, Se...

Quotes from Bible, Gender, Se...

new topic
Discuss This Book