What a trilogy of festive misery!
I'd wanted to read Gift of the Magi for years, so I thought let's have it sandwiched between two other yuletide stories. I wish I never bothered.
The Cop and the Anthem - a dreary story of a homeless man who wishes to be locked up over the winter as it's warmer than being on the streets. Sadly, there was ne'er a tear to be jerked over this story of how incompetent the NYPD are, and how homeless people are criminals.
Gift of the Magi - I knew of the story, so was expecting the melancholic tale to be just that. What I didn't expect was that it would be dull as well. When two people give up what means the most to them for the other, it should be captivating. Alas, I was unmoved by the two characters. If I was Della and got a lovely chain for Jim's watch, I'd expect something more thoughtful than a set of combs in return.
The Last Leaf - picture the headline "pompous bohemian gets pneumonia and thinks she's going to die but doesn't because another pompous bohemian paints a leaf on a wall", and you have a synopsis of the story. The next headline would be "doctor suggests woman will have more chance of survival if she talks about mean and handbags". Oh how I miss the old days.
All in all, I had a much better time writing this review than I did hearing these stories.