3.5 stars
Hmm...
It was good.
Almost junk-food, but not quite.
Let's take this a step at a time.
SETTINGS: Super! I loved the house and Zander's garage. And I loved the house (I know I said that twice).
PLOT: Hmm... It was well done I guess. I mean, yes. It was well done. It had a beginning, middle, end.
But it was of cliche. Girl loses mom. Dad and girl move to aunts house. Girl is sad, dad seems ok. Girl goes to school, next door neighbor is a cute guy. Nobody else understands, girl and guy get close. Go to party, girl hears gossip, girl and guy fight. Girl's dad has accident, girl and guy make up. Dad is ok. The end.
CHARACTERS: my favorite part of the book. Emily was ok, she didn't think she was pretty, but it wasn't like for real. I feel like the author put it in just because its stereotyped that girls never think they're pretty? I don't know.
I appreciated her heartache over losing her mom, but I was sort of confused about her "not being able to pray." Umm, as in she didn't hear God answering? "The words didn't come" was used several times... but how does that happen? What does it mean?
Zander was fun. He wasn't the gorgeous blond hair, blue eyes Angel. But he was his own.
Yes, Emily's "watching him through the window" before she even know who he was was odd, annoying even. But if we push her aside and look at him as a character, he was really well done.
I appreciated his "Christian outside of church" and his honesty, his sarcasm and I had such a blast reading their little bantering comments between Emily and him.
I also appreciated the fact that he wasn't a jock. (What!? The MC's gorgeous boyfriend isn't a jock?!)
What I didn't like was his attitude towards his dad. He was going to do what he was going to do and his dad was just going to "have to get over it or die ticked off." Yeh, I didn't like that.
I'm not saying he should do everything his dad wants, but that's not the way I would have liked the situation handled.
The faith thread was well woven I think... it was actually the most steady part of the book, the least cliche. The verses quoted, the points made, they aren't the ones that are always used, and I found that super refreshing. So that's well done. However the gospel was not at all explained or portrayed, so it's written assuming the reader knows/ is a Christian.
When I reached for this, I was in need of a sappy boyfriendish book that wasn't yucky. And it was perfect, however I probably won't ever read it again. (despite the fact that I'm going to finish the trilogy).
Language: not really any. No cursing. Emily does yell at her dad and her aunt though, which made me frown.
Violence: Non, but *spoiler!* Emily's dad does have an accident and ends up in the hospital and blood is mentioned, as well as surgery *end spoiler*
Lust: yeh... nothing serious. Emily finds Zander's muscles attractive. Mention of girls in bikinis, Zander in tight jeans. A couple of kisses, not detailed, mention of being "hot and heavy" but it didn't actually happen.
3.5 stars. Not really important to your TBR, but if you come across it and are in need of a clean junk-food, you might like it.