Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Challenger's Hope (Seafort Saga, #2)” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Challenger's Hope

(Seafort Saga #2)

David Feintuch

3.88 · Rating details · 1,734 ratings · 65 reviews

In the aftermath of an alien attack and an admiral's traitorous desertion, Commander Nicholas Seafort is left in charge of a doomed ship that carries arrogant colonists, violent street children, and dwindling supplies. ...more

Get A Copy

Paperback, Aspect science fiction, 407 pages

Published May 1st 1995 by Warner Books

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Challenger's Hope, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Challenger's Hope

Lists with This Book

Best Military Science Fiction Books

659 books — 816 voters

Military Science Fiction

782 books — 1,111 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 3.88 ·

Rating details

· 1,734 ratings · 65 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of Challenger's Hope (Seafort Saga, #2)

Apr 07, 2014 Lara rated it it was ok

Shelves: space-adventures, science-fiction

Decent space opera, but wow, Nicholas Seafort suffers from as bad a case of Protagonist Syndrome as I've ever seen. Everything bad happens to him. Every excruciatingly difficult decision rests solidly upon his just-turned-21 shoulders. Everything that goes wrong is somehow his fault (or he feels that it is). And even when he miraculously gets the ship and passengers home safely, his dad's response is "Nice job, son--however, since you broke your oath to that one batshit insane officer when he es ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jul 20, 2017 K.M. Weiland rated it really liked it

Tight and compelling all the way through, but not quite as good as the first book, if only because Seafort manages to cross the line to sincerely unlikable several times.

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jul 06, 2018 Charles van Buren rated it it was ok

Not as good as the first volume

By Charles van Buren on June 8, 2018

Format: Kindle Edition

I did not really like the first book in this series, MIDSHIPMAN'S HOPE. However, I had already purchased the first three volumes as a discounted set, so I decided to try this one. Maybe it would be an improvement as the author garnered experience. No hope. Seafort displays even more of the characteristics of a manic depressive. As in the first volume, it seems as though he is determined to alienate everyone ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Aug 15, 2014 Thorbjørn rated it it was ok

Obviously Horatio Hornblower in space, and that's not bad. I was, however, already tiring of the protagonist's whining during the otherwise entertaining Midshipman's Hope (book 1). His flagellation only becomes worse in Challenger's Hope. It is extremely annoying. HE is extremely annoying. I am currently reading book 3, and it goes on. I almost threw down my Kindle when he once AGAIN sighs inwardly, realising that AGAIN he has alienated this and that young officer after having thrown a tantrum. ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Jul 23, 2020 sigaloenta rated it did not like it

Shelves: evil-space-empire, sff, science-fiction, im-not-proud, boats

In the grim darkness of the future, there is only rum*, giant malevolent space goldfish, and the lash**

*I need to remind you that the distilled intoxicant of choice in this universe is called "goofjuice."
**Actually just the cane, and it turns out that only junior officers are subject to being beaten with it. Which seems like a weird line in the sand to draw in a system where miscreants can be literally hanged by the neck until dead for infractions such as striking the captain, and in a series wh In the grim darkness of the future, there is only rum*, giant malevolent space goldfish, and the lash**

*I need to remind you that the distilled intoxicant of choice in this universe is called "goofjuice."
**Actually just the cane, and it turns out that only junior officers are subject to being beaten with it. Which seems like a weird line in the sand to draw in a system where miscreants can be literally hanged by the neck until dead for infractions such as striking the captain, and in a series where so. much. time. is spent calculating demerits and logging how often various midshipmen get caned and whether or not it will break them or make them stronger or teach them an important lesson about not beating up other people. Corporal punishment is clearly a key piece of Feintuch's interest in doing the Age of Sail In Space, yet he restrained himself from introducing a space!cat o' nine tails? No one is going to get keelhauled in vacuum?

I was not able to bring myself to give a star rating to the first book in this "saga" on the grounds it was too outrageously, aggressively, dumb that it defied the logic of a book-rating system. This second installment, which you will notice I did manage to rate, puts into perspective what my problems were. Unlike the first book, this book has a fairly strong plot/crisis that dominates the whole book: our hero is dumped on a disabled ship light years from home with only his least likable midshipman (whom he and his officers basically terrorized into a nervous breakdown in the previous book), a skeleton crew of troublemakers, a handful of aging passengers, and a gaggle of feral street children dumped on an orphan train-to-space. Seafort has to try to make a functional crew that can keep everyone alive and figure out how to deal with the impossible position he's in, at the head of a sealed-community with almost no hope of rescue, no way to get home, and dwindling rations. This provides plot with stakes to scaffold the stuff that Feintuch cares about, namely, having Seafort yell at everyone, alienate everyone because the naval regs require him to do so, angst around self-hatingly, and then reluctantly accept that his harshness has in fact made him a hero because it's What Needed To Be Done, and What Teenaged Boy Doesn't Need A Good Beating Now And Again To Teach Him Manners. But here there are, stakes that relate directly to whether or not Seafort's rigid sense of duty and naval hierarchy will save his ship or destroy it. (In the first "book" this social drama was basically all there was, except for occasional thrilling Incidents like taking out the manual and figuring out how to reprogram the ship's computer for three chapters.)

So I can consider this A Novel. In fact, it's a novel with a pretty good plot, as milscifi standard plots go. Things are tense! I genuinely needed to know how they would get out of this one! To Feintuch's (small) credit, the subplot with the feral urchins was not treated entirely cheaply (but see below): as you would expect, Seafort finds a few Worthy Individuals Who Want To Better Themselves among them, but there's no overnight integration of the more privileged passengers and the lowlife teenage gangmembers, and even Seafort's protegés for the most part have not become settled in the "civilized" world of the Navy after the six months of so that the novel covers.

That said.
-The final plot resolution is an unabashed deus ex machina, and that sort of spoils it.
-I've mostly avoided talking in detail about this whole subplot because it's just BAD, but it needs to be said: everything involving the feral street urchins is extremely racist in implication and execution. This is a novel written in the mid-90s, and the Clinton crime bill and its racist scaremongering about "super-predators" are all over it.
-I don't even know where to start with the treatment of female character's/Seafort's romantic life. But it's bad. Really bad.

If it weren't for these last two elements, I could probably give this book two stars on the grounds that although terrible on any objective level, it's tolerable as mindless fun. But because of them, I have to give it but one star. And 13 demerits. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

May 16, 2017 Erin Penn rated it it was ok · review of another edition

I did not like this book, through it does meeting the qualifications of a well-written military sci-fi space opera and I finished reading the book, hence the 2-star rating.

The main character, Nick Seafort, is throughably unlikable. His temper surges and takes over - making him beat and insult people plus constantly has him making decisions he later has to apologize for, and he is a Captain.

The universe is setup for a military based on the strictest authoritarian structure I have ever seen. It wo I did not like this book, through it does meeting the qualifications of a well-written military sci-fi space opera and I finished reading the book, hence the 2-star rating.

The main character, Nick Seafort, is throughably unlikable. His temper surges and takes over - making him beat and insult people plus constantly has him making decisions he later has to apologize for, and he is a Captain.

The universe is setup for a military based on the strictest authoritarian structure I have ever seen. It wouldn't work; while it would make an interesting short story exploration and did make a okay first novel, the culture is unsustainable as a series. Military not only needs a strong "you will follow my orders even until death", but also needs a respect of specialists. Mr. Seafort, on occassion, teaches his midshipmen about respect and trust of officers and seamen, he never shows it. Military's power comes from a group acting as one - to do that the "head" needs to gather information from the specialists and the Captain never draws information for decisions from his officers - people drawn from the intellectual elite of the several worlds. At first I thought maybe because he had jumped from midshipman to captain he never had time for training, but the book never mentions an "officer school". It does goes into him entering the Academy. One assumes the academy would include courses on how to be part of a captain's staff and/or admiral's staff. In addition, one of the first thing any officer gets taught (in the real world - naval or army) is to listen to the OLDER enlisted men and take their advice.

But instead this military is totally reactive with about half the officers, including Mr. Seafort, suffering from all the signs of PSTD. The beatdowns and hazing happening between 13 and 17 while the potential officers are cadets and midshipman cross the line all the time. Several of the midshipman have shown to have nervous breakdowns. And the officers above them are all suffering from PSTD - unexpected anger lashing out, physical abuse of those weaker than them, nightmares & flashbacks, few loving feelings and inability to express them, and inability to trust others.

Further Mr. Seafort's relationship with his wife is totally unbelievable. The sheer contempt he treats her opinions and beliefs would have any (older) educated woman running away, unless he totally isolated her. The relationship is completely unhealthy for both of them. And the author's ill-use of women in the book grated on my nerves over time. Everything from black eyes to insanity, from "coltish" attempts at seduction to "being rough up a bit but they will get over it".

The world is bleak, the politics heavy-handed, the military impossible as a functioning institution, the "love" relationship disgusting, and the treatment of humans on all respects unbelievable in an environment when people will need to be highly educated. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Nov 26, 2008 Mary JL rated it it was amazing

Recommends it for: any sf fan but especially military sf fans

Recommended to Mary JL by: Familiar with the series

Shelves: main-sf-fantasy

This is the second book of the Seafort Saga and it is even a bit better than book one. One of the most interesting aspects to me was the introduction of the "trans-pop" culture.

In the futre Fentuch envisions, in some large cities, the elite live in shielded buildings and much of the city below is deserted. The "transient population" lives amidst the rubble of the old cities and has a great mistrust of the the "Uppies". The "trannies" appear here for the first time. They are a violent., gang like ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Sep 05, 2020 Robert rated it it was amazing

Shelves: x2019-20-season

A fine continuation, where our lead stretches his wings against fate and circumstance, and all of the lesser characters get a chance to shine as well. Similar to the first volume in tone, but much darker in execution.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

May 03, 2018 Nooilforpacifists rated it liked it

Shelves: naval-fiction, science-fiction

The guilt and shear improbably begin to overwhelm.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 31, 2015 Nick rated it really liked it

Shelves: science-fiction-fantasy, seafort-saga

Great follow-up to an amazing first novel. Challenger's Hope continues to follow Nicholas Seafort and his knack for getting into seriously crappy situations. Weird aliens, mutiny, weak minded superiors, slow death by starvation, this book has it all! As some of the other reviewers have noted, Nick continues to throw himself a pity party through a lot of the book, however considering the dire situations he ends up in, as well as certain lives that are lost, one has a hard time blaming him for pit ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jul 19, 2014 Ian Anderson rated it did not like it · review of another edition

Shelves: reviewed, sci-fi, series, used-to-own, space-opera

I read this 3-4 years ago and character and plot haven't left any lasting impression on me.

This series reminds me of Horatio Hornblower in space. Instead of a career as an officer in the British Royal Navy during the Napoleonic Wars, Nicholas Seaforth is an officer in the United Nations Naval Service. While technology has progressed enormously, society has regressed to the 18th century Royal Navy. (David Weber's Honorverse is based on a similar scenario). I guess David Feintuch uses the familiar ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Jul 25, 2014 A. Roy King rated it it was amazing

"Challenger's Hope" is the second in the excellent Seafort Saga, a space opera series authored by David Feintuch, who sadly died in 2006. The series is said to be based on C.S. Forester's Horatio Hornblower novels. I see also some reflection of Patrick O'Brian's Aubrey/Maturin novels. The Seafort series focuses on the adventures of a starship captain, Nicholas Seafort. Feintuch does an excellent job of transferring the ambiance of the 18th and 19th century naval life onto the interstellar travel ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

May 07, 2016 JV Findlay rated it it was amazing

Shelves: sci-fi, military

David Feintuch's Seafort Saga is true military sci-fi. It begins with Nicholas Seafort's second year in the UN's space navy as a midshipman and follows on with Challenger's Hope where Commander Nick Seafort has his own starship taken from him by a cowardly admiral in the middle of a battle with the alien fish. When Nick is left with a damaged ship and a crew full of misfits and unwanted passengers, he takes it upon himself to get everyone back home or die trying.

True military, space navy, alien ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Apr 17, 2019 Alyssia Cooke rated it really liked it

Shelves: science-fiction, navy

Now Commander of a military vessel, the Seafort saga continues as our young protagonist sets off on a voyage to find a set of highly aggressive alien lifeforms. For some strange reason included in the convoy of Navy ships are not only crew but also passengers and indeed Nick's heavily pregnant wife. Ordered to investigate and engage if needed, Seafort's ship takes the lead point in the phasing, before waiting for other ships to pass and then taking point again.

Mixed into this, he also has an add Now Commander of a military vessel, the Seafort saga continues as our young protagonist sets off on a voyage to find a set of highly aggressive alien lifeforms. For some strange reason included in the convoy of Navy ships are not only crew but also passengers and indeed Nick's heavily pregnant wife. Ordered to investigate and engage if needed, Seafort's ship takes the lead point in the phasing, before waiting for other ships to pass and then taking point again.

Mixed into this, he also has an additional passenger load of transpops; lower class, uneducated children that the government is trying to place in more affluent worlds. Bunked six to a cabin, it is clear from the offset that this is problematic as trying to mix upper class paying passengers with 'trannies' who have never even used indoor plumbing and behave like small savages is fraught with complications. It's worth noting that the word 'trannie' here is used as a derogatory, but has nothing to do with gender or sexuality. This was published a good decade before the phrase was exclusively used as a derogatory in that sense. Rather, in this strictly Conservative cultural set-up, they are the massed unwashed, uncultured bottom feeders in a society that cares little for those without money and influence.

Feintuch isn't recommending this as a model society by any stretch, in fact his characterisations of these youngsters is instrumental in showing that everyone can have a place and purpose throughout. The friction between the upper class passengers and the food throwing savages is both telling and poignant at points. Seafort's character shines in how he treats all his passengers as equal and tries to integrate rather than segregate. The inequal distribution of wealth and the absurd sense of priviledge is also cleverly shown through many interactions between crew and passengers.

The hazing continues and is actively unpleasant with a revenge sub-plot taking place among the Midshipmen. Seafort's naval discipline forces him to turn a blind eye to what is right in front of his face, despite knowing that what is going on is wrong and has gone too far. Thankfully, Feintuch uses this as a form of crucible for his characters and there is the potential for growth and development here rather than abuse simply for the hell of it. It is noticeable though that this isnt a 'listening' Navy. Its a top down service paying little but lip service if that to specialists, whilst the Captain plays God. This is reasoned out but many of the destructive decisions have their roots in this totalitarian system.

Seafort's wracking guilt and self flagellation continues as well, but this annoyed me less here than previously. This is largely because Feintuch puts him through such hell that I really can't blame the boy for his moping. He is put through the absolute ringer from near enough day one, and let's be honest, that can and will break a man. There are some gut wrenching moments here as well as some heart-breaking ones. Feintuch succeeded in putting tears in my eyes more than once, and that doesn't happen all too often. A lot of the book is drama and space opera, but when the action comes it is high speed and dramatic, testing the mettle - and the Navy discipline - of all concerned.

All in all, I enjoyed this far more than its predecessor and found the inclusion of the transpops to allow for further world building opportunities, despite spending most of the time aboard ship. I found the characters have grown and developed well by and large, whilst many new characters had a spark and a verve to them. The tension doesn't fail to the last, making this a mighty fine read indeed. ...more

flag Like · see review

Sep 02, 2020 Denis rated it liked it

A better book than the first, but marginally so, and not enough to continue with the series. I continued to appreciate the immersion into starship life and the action elements were a definite highlight. The fight for survival on the abandoned Challenger felt real and the stakes were apparent. But, ultimately, the book's undoing was the same as in the first: Seafort is an uninspiring and, worse, infuriating lead, with authoritarian tendencies, capricious treatment of his often well-meaning office ...more

flag Like · see review

Apr 19, 2020 Michael McCullar rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

What is duty?

Challenger's Hope, to me, is one of the best novels ever written about the meaning of duty. What is duty? How does one follow their duty, honor their oath, in the face of overwhelming odds? It's an easy thing to speak of in good times, when things are easy. It's when the going gets tough, when you are looking into the face of certain death, that your true character is exposed. It's then when you find out what duty really means. ...more

flag Like · see review

Jun 29, 2019 Lucas Grant rated it really liked it

Really like the series. I grew up on Kirk who had no problem skirting rules and regulations to get the job fine while Seafort beats himself up about doing the right thing when,it goes against regulations. It is an interesting concept. There is nothing deep or profound in this series but for a quick action sci fi read this series is great.

flag Like · see review

Jan 19, 2018 Rob Markley rated it it was ok

Shelves: scifi

I got why he had to be so tough in the first book, but why did he have to turn into a harsh monster in this one. I thought we might seesaw and volume three come back to solid ground.... nope

flag Like · see review

May 26, 2018 Clint the Cool Guy rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Great story! The second book in the series. I liked it a lot. Not quite as good as the first to me, but still really good. Recommended!

flag Like · see review

Apr 02, 2019 LordOfDorkness rated it really liked it

This stuff just never gets boring. Like goddamnit David. Let me read other books alreaedy

flag Like · see review

Jul 31, 2019 Janet Sibbersen rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Riviting

Book 1 was great. This, book 2 was so rivitinf, I spent too many hours continuously reading to the end. Anticipating book 3

flag Like · see review

Jul 29, 2020 Wolfiesara rated it it was amazing

I'm completely addicted to this series. ...more

flag Like · see review

Mar 16, 2017 Jon rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Heart-wrenching tale of deep space, abandonment, loss, betrayal and the human spirit. Excellent story. Nick Seafort is our inscrutable protagonist, one who's moods can swing faster than a misaligned N wave. He fails to recognize who his friends are, even though his command would be strengthened by building upon relationships. Instead he's a hard disciplinarian, resorting to torture and cruelty for even the most minor infractions of protocol. Really hoping he gets a clue into how human relationsh ...more

flag Like · see review

Feb 03, 2013 Benjamin Espen rated it really liked it

Shelves: library

The last time I read through David Feintuch's Seafort Saga, I stopped here. The second time, I forged through to Fisherman's Hope, the fourth book in the seven [eight] book series. I can at least recommend that anyone who is interested in this series persevere that far. I hope to finish the last three books soon. There was an eighth in the pipeline when Feintuch died, but I don't know if it will ever see the light of day.

I liked Seafort the least in Challenger's Hope. I blame his youth, and his

I liked Seafort the least in Challenger's Hope. I blame his youth, and his unexpected, but unrelinquished, authority. At the august age of twenty, he is insufferable in command, although other fictional Captains I have known have done better at that age. However, this is the crucible where he forges his character, for better, well actually for worse, and the rest of the series would be incomprehensible without it.

I think the hardest part of this book for me is how I find Seafort a little too much like myself. Seafort suffers from the spiritual malady a Catholic would call scrupulosity. James Chastek at Just Thomism recently penned this bit about scruples:

-Scruples: They are a trick that keeps us from seeing our true faults. We obsess and worry over dramatic faults and wonder if we have fallen into something that we have no real love for or even temptation towards, when in fact what we need to work on – the evils we are much more attached to – go unnoticed.

Those who suffer under scruples are eaten alive by them, but it helps to see them as impediments to moral growth. Whether by subconscious connivance or a trick of the devil, they are smokescreens that keep us from getting to the things that we really need to work on and change. We continually fantasize about dramatic moral improvements when in fact the real real improvements we need to make are at once more obvious and harder for us to see in the face of scruples.

Nicholas Seafort's faults are many, but they are precisely not the things he worries the most about: being a poor leader, and being damned for breaking his oath. I blame his father for that. His father did do well, by his own lights, but he did poor Nick a disservice by passing onto him a strict interpretation of the creed his personality could not sustain. It helps to be a Catholic, rather than a Protestant. Especially an English Protestant. After Henry VIII made a mockery of religious oaths, the Jesuit order in particular helped push away from the inspirational, but very literal interpretation of oaths that was popular in Christendom pre-Reformation. So much else the English non-conformists tossed away, but this thing they kept, and cherished, and polished to a bright hue. And by this thing, Nicholas Seafort felt himself damned, when he is really the most dutiful, and honor-bound man in the United Nations Naval Service.

Nick can forgive anything, except himself. What he really needs to do, is admit that he is a great man. Nicholas Seafort inspires men to die for him. Of course, he makes mistakes, loses his temper, and makes a general mess of things. In fact, I think I hated him here. So did many others. However, he inspires greatness in others, precisely because he expects more of himself than he does of anyone else. And because he really is incorruptible. No one cares less for their career, or their life, than Nicholas Seafort. Of course, Feintuch makes him suffer for it. Everything Seafort does advances his career, no matter how hard he tries to resign. Providence reigns in his life. There is something else he needs to do.

...more

flag Like · see review

Oct 15, 2016 Mark Zodda rated it liked it · review of another edition

Brutal, honest and engaging. David Feintuch is a very good author who overcomes the limits of his genre to manipulate my emotional responses to his situations and characters. Recommended.

flag Like · see review

May 21, 2014 Pat Cummings rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: reviewed

Book 2 of the Seafort Saga is a thrilling blend of action and internal struggle, triumph over despair, and refusal to surrender even in the face of overwhelming odds. Its ending, which leaves Commander Seafort further burdened with his own grief and self-recrimination, sets the reader up for the next novel, but read with Midshipman's Hope, the two are complete on their own.

Too young to be confirmed as Captain in his own right, the still-teenaged Nicholas Ewing Seafort is given Commander rank, an Book 2 of the Seafort Saga is a thrilling blend of action and internal struggle, triumph over despair, and refusal to surrender even in the face of overwhelming odds. Its ending, which leaves Commander Seafort further burdened with his own grief and self-recrimination, sets the reader up for the next novel, but read with Midshipman's Hope, the two are complete on their own.

Too young to be confirmed as Captain in his own right, the still-teenaged Nicholas Ewing Seafort is given Commander rank, and placed in command of the UNNS Challenger, which is part of a fleet of ships under the command of Admiral Tremaine. Their goal is to find and confront the aliens Seafort's former ship, UNNS Hibernia, confronted in the space around Hope Nation.

At the outset, Admiral Tremaine is opposed to the young commander: he starts by moving his flag (and flag captain) to Seafort's ship, transferring Commander Seafort to the smaller UNNS Portia. Then he organizes the fleet to make short hops—seven or more—between Earth and Hope Nation, with Seafort's somewhat faster ship preceding the rest of the fleet and then remaining in place until all the others have passed.

What none of them know is that the Fuse drive they use is calling the alien "fish"; Seafort's ship will be exposed more than any of the others.

Further complicating the command he has been given is the crowd of "trannies"; transient street people or transpops, that have been loaded on to his ship. These ill-educated children, none of them out of their teens, are expected to bunk six to a cabin. Even worse, the regular passengers object to sharing a dining room with them.

Seafort's wife and infant son are along. He also has the entire chain of command in which he has been placed in loco parentis. Seafort, whose own childhood was disturbingly lonely and without demonstrations of paternal love, must find a way to be father, commander and pastor to his entire crew—especially after they are all transferred back to the hopelessly damaged UNNS Challenger and abandoned to the fish.

Other reviewers have found Seafort's character irritating. To me, the self-questioning and obsessively dutiful dilligence make him ring true. Like many true leaders, he leads by example, by doing what he deems right. He must not care (or must not appear to care) too much what others' opinions about him are. He makes his right choices despite his critics—his own voice the harshest amongst them—and persists.

It is that, not his triumph, that makes him the hero he is. ...more

flag Like · see review

Nov 26, 2011 Julie Davis rated it really liked it

Having devoured the first book, Midshipman's Hope, I eagerly went on to this which is in the same volume lent by my friend.

Now a Commander, Nicholas Seafort, is married and has his own command. Sadly, the Admiral he reports to has taken a distinct dislike to him which does not bode well as the task force to seek out alien life sets out. Let us note that this is definitely hostile alien life so to take one's extremely pregnant wife along, as well as passengers, seems like folly.

At any rate, many ...more

flag Like · see review

Jul 30, 2016 Julie rated it it was amazing

Shelves: science-fiction, military, royal-navy, aliens, reread

Probably not fair to give a book I have re-re-read several times in my lifetime 4 stars, so I upped it to 5. I do like the first book in this series better. This one can be emotionally tough to read in spots, but that was fine with me personally. It reads more sexist than the previous book though. You kind of have to read carefully to spot when it's _not_ being sexist. Like, one of the fleet Captains is female, but it's literally one pronoun in the entire book to let you know that. All the other ...more

flag Like · see review

Feb 21, 2015 Tim Burgess rated it it was amazing

Unfortunately, I think the first edition of this series got a poor one-star rating from one of the first reviewers on Goodreads - which now comes up on that page. That and the poor cover art of the original book probably would have made me think 'pass' if I had come across it on Goodreads. But it is a great read and deserves much better than a lowly one star rating. I came across it in Scribd and after an initial read of the first book's initial chapters, I was hooked.

If you liked HornBlower, Ma ...more

flag Like · see review

Oct 21, 2009 Ed rated it liked it

Recommends it for: Space adventure fans

Shelves: in-inventory-portland, reviewed, sci-fi-fantasy

This is the second book in the Nicholas Seafort Saga, most likely more appropriate for a juvenile reader but sometimes I just can't resist a space opera.

Seafort is assigned to a convoy going to a deep space colony. His passenger list is made up of arrogant colonists and violent street children. On the way, his ship is attacked by aliens and he is betrayed by his Admiral. Left stranded on a ship damaged beyond repair and short of food and fuel he, an inexperienced Commander at that, tries to kee ...more

flag Like · see review

« previous 1 2 next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Recommend It | Stats | Recent Status Updates

Readers also enjoyed

See similar books…

Genres

Science Fiction

125 users

Fiction

26 users

Space > Space Opera

23 users

War > Military Fiction

19 users

Science Fiction > Military Science Fiction

9 users

Adventure

6 users

Science Fiction Fantasy

6 users

Space

4 users

Science Fiction > Aliens

4 users

Fantasy

3 users

See top shelves…

About David Feintuch

David Feintuch

106 followers

David Feintuch (1944–2006) was the author of the award-winning military science fiction Seafort Saga series, which spans Midshipman’s Hope, Challenger’s Hope, Prisoner’s Hope, Fisherman’s Hope, Voices of Hope, Patriarch’s Hope, and Children of Hope. Feintuch came to writing late, previously having worked as a lawyer and antiques dealer. In 1996, at the age of fifty, he won the John W. Campbell Awa ...more