The Second Edition of this award winning text introduces managers and aspiring managers to this personally relevant and professionally exciting field. In Human Resource Management in Public Paradoxes, Processes, and Problems , authors Evan M. Berman, James S. Bowman, Jonathan P. West, and Montgomery Van Wart take a critical approach to exploring core management functions by stalking, contesting, and seeking resolution of paradoxes in all stages of employment - from recruitment through termination.
Contains a lot of practical information. Appreciated the emphasis throughout the text of paradoxes- this highlights the dichotomy that often occurs between HRM in theory and practice.
This text generally did what it set out to do: provide a good overview of human resource management in a public work environment. However, much as I may sympathize with the authors' point of view, it too often devolved from an education text to a polemic, always taking an explicit pro-government worker position.
It's a missed opportunity. Certainly a manager needs to understand, appreciate, and value their employees. But managers must also be capable of understanding the political environment in which they find themselves, which yes, may be actively hostile. Excoriating political actors for treating the civil service poorly doesn't help a future manager do their job better. It provides no tools. It holds no lessons.
"They suck" (in so many words) may be cathartic for the authors, but it is insufficient for a book that purports to teach current or future managers how to be better at their complex job.
I was underwhelmed with this textbook. I thought it was written in more of a lecture type format and although there were sections including real life examples or historical details but I felt like those sections were too small of a percentage of the overall material. As a school textbook, I felt like the format and material was harder to process than many other textbooks I've read.
Read for PAD 505 - Human Resources Management. Overall a very informative text, good case analysis exercises, and thorough in its covering of HR topics.
As far as textbooks go, this one was well-written, and the content easy to understand. I read the book for my public administration course and feel I took away a few nuggets of information.