Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Three From The Legion” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Three From The Legion

(Legion of Space #1-3)

Jack Williamson

3.72 · Rating details · 78 ratings · 4 reviews

The legion of space -- The Cometeers -- One against the legion.

Get A Copy

Paperback, Omnibus, 534 pages

Published April 1st 1980 by Pocket Books (first published April 1st 1979)

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Three From The Legion, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Three From The Legion

Lists with This Book

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

Showing 1-55

Average rating 3.72 ·

Rating details

· 78 ratings · 4 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of Three From The Legion

Jul 16, 2014 Rafeeq O. rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Having already written a review of The Legion of Space https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... before realizing that this novel also is collected in Three from the Legion, now I will finish up with the full omnibus trilogy.

Although I had harped on some nagging features of the first Legion novel, the following works in the series struck me as noticeably better, which was a pleasant surprise. Yes, we are still reading space opera from the Golden Age of science fiction, so good is good, and bad is Having already written a review of The Legion of Space https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... before realizing that this novel also is collected in Three from the Legion, now I will finish up with the full omnibus trilogy.

Although I had harped on some nagging features of the first Legion novel, the following works in the series struck me as noticeably better, which was a pleasant surprise. Yes, we are still reading space opera from the Golden Age of science fiction, so good is good, and bad is bad, with non-humans such as aliens from outside the Solar System or mad-scientist-created androids being the latter, and the flinty-eyed, usually tall officers of the mighty Legion of Space guarding the former. Fair enough for the genre. Still, the characters and the points of view brought by these succeeding books pull a series that began for me in the two-to-three star region into the neighborhood of more like four stars.

Whereas John Star of The Legion of Space (1935) does not seem very well developed, even for the 1930s, his son, Bob Star, the protagonist of The Cometeers (1936), is more conflicted, more human, and hence more interesting. Bob is young and very capable, but he is less sure of himself than was his father at that age, and secretly vulnerable. In striving to beat the grades of the number-one student at the Academy, an upperclassman who has it out for Bob and hazes him mercilessly, the boy has worked himself to the edge of a nervous breakdown. Now after graduation his parents have tried to keep him at home, shielded from the peculiar news brewing at the edge of the Solar System, so that he might rest up before receiving his first space assignment. Such treatment galls...and the throbbing beneath the scar on his forehead, a reminder of the torture--literal torture--of rival Stephen Orco never goes away either. Still, when a strange green comet-like object sails in from interstellar space like a dreadnought, the youngster at last will have the chance to prove himself--oh, yes, and save the Solar System and find himself a girlfriend, too.

When Williamson revisits the series almost a decade and a half later in One against the Legion (1950), the protagonist is another firm-jawed young officer aching for his first assignment, only here the youngster is framed for murder and the theft of a top-secret device, and he is imprisoned, convicted as a traitor, and even tortured by Legion interrogators before finally escaping. This time, therefore, the once-infallible Legion of Space is fallible indeed, and as the deeply wronged Chan Derron tries to find out why a super-criminal calling himself the Basilisk is framing him for crime after crime, he will have to get to the bottom of another threat to all humanity.

Finally, although Nowhere Near (1967) is listed as being part of One against the Legion, it is a completely separate novella, taking place years after and light years away from the previous tales. This one is told in first-person point of view rather the sometimes-pompous third person, and it is...well, let us say a decade and a half more sophisticated. Cosmological speculations on the age of the universe and whatnot happen to be rather dated now, but the piece is so much more modern and subtle than even the 1950 book. The narrator, the commander of a space station near a strange spacetime anomaly, is experienced and a little weary, and he is not immediately swept to breathless admiration by the waddling entrance of the Giles Habibula, the now-famous gourmand/lockpick/incipient alky of the previous novels, nor even by the flourishing of the name of the distinguished Star family. And when some grizzled-veteran-meets-girl occurs, even that is made almost tolerable by its less cliched execution.

While the first installment of the Legion of Space saga does not age especially well, the ensuing works get better and better, slowly shedding their histrionics across the decades, and even growing quite palatable indeed. I only wish Williamson had not begun the series with a "found manuscript" narrative frame that he then seems to forget and never close... ...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Nov 02, 2017 Liam rated it liked it

Well. This was a ride.
Book 1: Legion of Space: 3 Stars
This one starts out interesting and fast paced. Though no masterpiece, the first half of this book is a top example of good writing style leading to a nice and easy read. Too bad that it stalls and loses focus in the second half of the book, pushing it's rating down to 3 stars. I might have been more inclined to forgive it, but it already held flaws such as somewhat arbitrary characterization.
Book 2: The Cometeers: 2 Stars
Much like the previo Well. This was a ride.
Book 1: Legion of Space: 3 Stars
This one starts out interesting and fast paced. Though no masterpiece, the first half of this book is a top example of good writing style leading to a nice and easy read. Too bad that it stalls and loses focus in the second half of the book, pushing it's rating down to 3 stars. I might have been more inclined to forgive it, but it already held flaws such as somewhat arbitrary characterization.
Book 2: The Cometeers: 2 Stars
Much like the previous, starts off strong but weakens in the latter section. This one makes clear attempts to improve characterization, replacing generic John Star with the more nuanced Bob, and giving more detail to characters who were one-dimensional in the first, such as Hal and Giles. However, I count it as the worst of the trilogy as it drops its momentum earlier than the first. Also, it has quite possibly the most arbitrary romantic pairing of all time, even worse than the previous, as not only have the two characters involved barely spoken to each other they don't speak the same language and thus never had an intelligible conversation. It was clear that the romance was simply shoved into the end as a standard finale requirement, added with all the passion of a mark on a checklist.
Book 3: One Against the Legion: 4 Stars
This one manages to keep focus through the whole book, and furthermore fleshes out Giles into a major character. In addition the new characters are a nice addition the cast. Not too much to say here, as there were no obvious flaws that hadn't been discussed in the previous books already. If only the rest of the series had been like this.
Book 3.5: Nowhere Near: 3 Stars
An added novella that ignores all the improvements the author made in the third book and regressed to all the painful errors of the first book, such as losing steam halfway through and occasionally arbitrary characterization. Not really required reading for the series but if one enjoyed the first two this one is better put together and a quick read.
Overall: 3 Stars ...more

flag Like · see review

Jul 20, 2018 Joseph Loehr rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Entertains Space Opera. Cringe-worthy, in spots, but worst reading. Pulp-style, and started in the mid-30s, I can almost picture Buster Crabbe in Legion livery

flag Like · see review

Aug 15, 2013 Dragonlady-sci-fi-fantasy rated it it was amazing

Shelves: sci-fi

Read this many, many years ago. A great space adventure!

flag Like · see review

Austin rated it liked it
Sep 22, 2019

John Loyd rated it it was amazing
Apr 07, 2015

Shane Lewis rated it liked it
Oct 16, 2020

Jo Bråtesveen rated it liked it
Feb 12, 2018

Jonathon rated it really liked it
Feb 04, 2011

Marco Guarda rated it it was amazing
Mar 13, 2013

Andrew rated it it was amazing
Jun 14, 2012

John Torpey rated it really liked it
Aug 20, 2019

Curt R rated it liked it
Jan 26, 2016

Edward rated it it was amazing
Dec 19, 2012

Mac rated it liked it
Mar 21, 2015

Kevin rated it it was ok
Apr 09, 2013

Mary Fan rated it really liked it
Jul 19, 2012

Cm2dude rated it it was amazing
Jun 29, 2010

GUY FORTIN rated it it was ok
Jun 19, 2018

Jack Cornelius rated it it was amazing
Sep 09, 2012

Maurice rated it liked it
Mar 11, 2016

Rudy rated it liked it
Nov 30, 2011

Ben rated it it was ok
Sep 01, 2014

Steve rated it it was amazing
Sep 21, 2012

Kris rated it liked it
Mar 17, 2011

Takino rated it it was amazing
Aug 11, 2014

Andy Sheets rated it really liked it
May 22, 2017

D. E. rated it it was amazing
Jan 24, 2018

David Lauritzen rated it really liked it
May 24, 2012

Chris Gardner added it
Feb 25, 2008

Eric rated it really liked it
Mar 28, 2008

Patrick added it
Jul 26, 2008

Crystal marked it as to-read
Aug 19, 2008

Adam rated it liked it
Feb 02, 2009

Ann aka Iftcan rated it it was amazing
Nov 28, 2009

James Hurley rated it liked it
Feb 10, 2010

Cgradis rated it really liked it
Mar 01, 2010

Red Head marked it as to-read
Mar 18, 2010

Twyla marked it as to-read
May 23, 2010

Jennifer Baker marked it as to-read
Jun 22, 2010

Sid rated it really liked it
Aug 21, 2010

Theron marked it as to-read
Aug 30, 2010

Brian Williams rated it really liked it
Sep 22, 2010

William Shunn added it
Oct 21, 2010

Steve added it
May 05, 2011

Vern Parvin added it
May 28, 2011

Rick Coy rated it liked it
Jul 24, 2011

Becky marked it as to-read
Aug 08, 2011

Charles Baker marked it as to-read
Aug 16, 2011

Kent Hyam rated it liked it
Oct 23, 2011

Steven Oaks rated it really liked it
Nov 18, 2011

Laura Reeve added it
Nov 21, 2011

William marked it as to-read
Nov 27, 2011

Eliza added it
Dec 28, 2011

Trevor marked it as to-read
Jan 18, 2012

« previous 1 2 3 next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Recommend It | Stats | Recent Status Updates

Readers also enjoyed

See similar books…

Genres

Science Fiction

13 users

Fiction

3 users

Science Fiction Fantasy

2 users

See top shelves…

About Jack Williamson

Jack Williamson

109 followers

John Stewart Williamson who wrote as Jack Williamson (and occasionally under the pseudonym Will Stewart) was a U.S. writer often referred to as the "Dean of Science Fiction".
...more