When God Says War Is Right: The Christian's Perspective on When and How to Fight

by Darrell Cole

Across the centuries, how have Christians who follow the Prince of Peace responded to the recurring reality of war? And what guidance do they offer for believers today–in the midst of global conflict?

In When God Says War Is Right, Dr. Darrell Cole offers thorough and highly readable answers. His expert examination focuses on these topics:
·Relating the character of God with the use of force
·Determining when and how Christians ought to fight
·Understanding why Christian virtues are vital when using force
·Using nuclear weapons for deterrence
·Learning lessons from World War II, Vietnam, and the 1991 Gulf War
·Responding to today’s war against terrorism

Dr. Cole focuses on Romans 13, where Paul commands us to “do what is right” (or “good” or “noble”) in regard to our governing authorities, who have legitimate war-making authority. In the case of war, what is “right” for the Christian? This book answers that essential question. In today’s war-stricken world, Dr. Cole provides timely, trustworthy, and vitally needed guidance for Christians.

Genres: Theology, Politics, Military Fiction, Nonfiction

176 pages, Paperback

First published August 20, 2002

Reviews

[Derrick Jeter · Rating 3 out of 5]

Darrell Cole is workman-like in this overview of the Just War Theory, particularly as articulated by Augustine and John Calvin. As an ethicist and scholar, Cole provides the moral underpinnings and ethical case for war — if the cause and persecution of war meets the classic definition of Just War (jus ad bellum): (1) proper authority must declare and wage war, (2) just cause to engage in war, (3) right intention of force to advance good and avoid evil, (4) last resort to right wrongs after other reasonable measures have failed, and (5) reasonable hope of success to avoid sacrificing lives in a lost cause. But Cole goes beyond articulating the long theological and moral history which developed the Just War Theory, as well as unpacking the meaning of the five points of the theory. He also discusses how warriors are to ethically engage in warfare — a chapter I found helpful. He concludes with case studies of World War II, Vietnam, and the Gulf War; and provides themes in thinking about nuclear warfare and terrorism. Since this volume was published in 2002, he did not (could not) provide a case study of Afghanistan or Iraq. The one issue that stuck like a chicken bone in my mental throat, however, was the thesis that just war can be an act of love. As a philosophical concept I agree, but wished Cole had spent more time developing this theme and illustrating it from Scripture and from practical combat engagements. I'd give the book a 3.5 stars.

[Robert Joslin · Rating 4 out of 5]

I read this many years ago. It provides references to history and biblical theology on understanding the reasons behind war, in particular the just war stance. The author challenges the pacifist standpoint held by some of early Christianity instead of looking at war as a lesser of two evils. Does a good Christian stand by and let atrocities occur even when all efforts to overcome a conflict by peaceful means fails? Well worth the read.

[Lance Gabrielson · Rating 4 out of 5]

A interesting view of Christian ethics, a must read for people who wonder about religion. The views may been seen as controversial and I suspect that plays a part into its low rating, but dont be deceived! It is an amazing book for all.

[Madison Boboltz · Rating 2 out of 5]

Bad scholarship. I would like to read an argument for just war theory that takes a more christocentric approach. Cole relied way too much on Aquinas and Calvin, did not respond to actual pacifistic claims, and his use of scripture is problematic.

[Sean McGowan · Rating 4 out of 5]

Very good over view and application of the traditional "just-war" theory.

[Kari McDowell · Rating 3 out of 5]

Good, simple explanation of the concept of “just war,” which is so lacking today!

[Chris Bloom · Rating 2 out of 5]

DISCLOSURE: I served in the Navy for six years, all the time believing I was serving God as well as country. I no longer hold that view.

That said, Cole does a good job of working within his thesis; if you start with the assumption that war can be just, then his arguments are solid. I do not, though, as I cannot perform the mental gymnastics necessary to get "Kill your enemy" from "Love your enemy". This is a useful book for understanding the current American evangelical pro-military mindset, but otherwise it's just misleading and antithetical to what Jesus actually said. Not recommended.

[Jason · Rating 1 out of 5]

If you happen to be looking for a book where the author used to serve in the military and is attempting to use the Bible to justify and promote war, then this is the book for you! At one point he even argues that killing your enemy in battle can actually be an act of love toward that enemy. Truly ridiculous and blasphemous.

[Megan · Rating 2 out of 5]

I used this as a textbook in a class on the ethics of nonviolence, to counterbalance the other texts we used. Cole presents a logical and well-reased defense of the Just War theory. It was actually an enjoyable read,and well-argued. I don't agree with all of, or most of, his points, but I won't say that he didn't make me think.