Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Counterpoint (Song of the Fallen, #1)” as Want to Read:
Counterpoint (Song of the Fallen, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Read eBook


(Song of the Fallen #1)

3.76  ·  Rating details ·  3,341 ratings  ·  374 reviews
It is the twilight of mankind. Depleted by generations of war with a dark race, the human kingdoms and their ancient alliance stand on the brink of extinction. The outlands are soaked with the blood of the fallen. The midlands are rotting with decadence and despair.

Elfkind, estranged by past crimes, watches and waits for nature to run its course.

And then the two collide.

ebook, 2nd edition, 414 pages
Published December 27th 2011 by Riptide Publishing (first published July 31st 2010)
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Counterpoint, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Counterpoint

Captive Prince by C.S. PacatCaptive Prince by C.S. PacatLuck in the Shadows by Lynn FlewellingStalking Darkness by Lynn FlewellingKings Rising by C.S. Pacat
Best Gay Fantasy Romance
630 books — 1,368 voters
Captive Prince by C.S. PacatDuck! by Kim DareBloodraven by P.L. NunnCaptive Prince by C.S. PacatConcubine by Jill Knowles
Best Gay Slaves
267 books — 1,019 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 3.76  · 
Rating details
 ·  3,341 ratings  ·  374 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Counterpoint (Song of the Fallen, #1)
Lyn❤Loves❤Listening #AUDIOBOOKADDICT
Audio - 4 stars
Story - 4 stars

Not as dark as I thought an enemies to lovers, captive/enslaved story would be. Ayden is an elf. He and his sister are captured by humans and taken to Prince Freyrik. As far as captors go, Freyrik is very accommodating. Ayden is resentful and insolent. I loved him. He had me laughing up a storm. It takes a long while, but Freyrik eventually wins him over. Even so, their love is forbidden, and they can't consider a life long relationship.

Enjoyable story. There's good
Elise ✘ a.k.a Ryder's Pet ✘
⋰⋱⋰⋱⋰⋱*Might Contain Spoilers*⋰⋱⋰⋱⋰⋱

The book centers around human Crown Prince of Farr, Freyrík ‘Rík’ Farr (29) and elfkind, Ayden Vaska (800). When Ayden gets captured in battle, he becomes Freyrik's slave. But for his sister's sake, Ayden must endure his slavery and hide his hatred for the humans. Freyrík plans to use Ayden in the Surge, what he did not plan however, was to actually start to care for the elf. Overall, the book wasn't bad per se, though the ending scenes ((view spoiler)
MsMiz (Tina)
Oct 02, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: glbt-all
Lent to me - Kindle

Dearest Rachel - Hmmm lets see - it is late right now. I could not put the book down. I had to know how the story unfolded as I was unable to plot its course while reading. Therefore, I may not make complete coherent sense. So let me try:

1. I was deep into the story and the characters. I hated them, I loved them, I wanted to scratch their eyes out, I wanted to hold them. I am a character driven reader. I need to know and feel who they are or the story is just a story and to me
Vivian ♪(┌・。・)┌
The first kiss--

Bloody fucking swoon


Review edited 16/4/2013

I know that this review is going to be a huge jump from my previous review and rating (which started off from a perfect 5 till I weaned it down to 4, now 3.5).

I think that previously, I was a worried (and perhaps a bit scared) about having a different review amongst what seemed to be the raving masses. Nowadays however, it bugs me every time I see this review. So now I've just decided to adopt a 'fuck t
Sep 07, 2010 rated it it was amazing
The begin of the book is soooooooo great and I adore this first part, when you will be introduced to the elf Adyden.

With his uncontrollable hair and wild spirit Ayden is perfect. I love this character, and was astonished by his bravery. Trying to save his sister from humans he will be captured, finishing in the hands of the king's brother, the Prince Freyrik.

Freyrik is desperate fighting against ferals, and will see in Ayden the weapon against those magical perverted animals. Indeed the elf is t
Sep 22, 2011 rated it liked it
I have mixed feelings about this book. it takes place in a world where humans are at odds with elfkind (& every other species it seems). Ayden and his sister are captured by humans and Ayden is then made into a slave for Prince Freyrik Farr, who is running the kingdom in his brother's absence.

The good in the book is the character of Ayden. He's defiant, funny, snarky & gives the book most of its energy. Freyrik is immediately attracted to him and keeps him as his slave. The two of them have som
Oct 22, 2016 rated it really liked it
Recommended to Ezinwanyi by: ~Melissa~
3.5 stars

I enjoyed this audio. Ayden and Freyrik had a lot of tension, but Freyik eventually wore Ayden down.

Ayden and his sister are elves who were captured by humans (all the humans in the book were terrible!) and Ayden was so worried that his sister would be raped that he consented to be a sex partner for the prince.
Prince Freyrick was ruling the country in his brother's absence but he was a much kinder ruler.

Ayden was so distrustful of humans, but prince Frey eventually earned his trust. How

Counterpoint is one of those epic love stories, that completely engages the reader and makes you fall in love. I was completely caught up in the characters, and the world created. I will say honestly that I wanted to read this book, because the cover is just so impressive. It drew my eye, and it turned out that this book is more than just a pretty cover (pffft, pretty cover, more like a sexy cover).

This book as I said before is epic, epic fantasy that is. Its pure fi
Heather C
OH.MY.GODS!!! I loved this book!!!

This book was picked for me to read as a challenge and I dove in without reading the blurb or any reviews. I really didn't know what to expect other than that this was m/m fantasy and it had a cliffhanger. It also has one of the most beautiful covers I have ever seen.

I found the World very interesting with the song and abilities of the elven people, the barbarism and prejudices of the humans, and the madness of the Ferals/Darkers. There was a bit of world buildi

It was so far beyond five stars I don't think I can even count that high.

It didn't have the level of darkness I expect from Rachel Haimowitz darkness (which ended up being preferable) but it was perfect. The scope of everything, the creativity of the characters, the beauty of the love affair, and the emotion behind the whole thing - it was truly incredible.

The audio was fantastic!
I loved this book. I was putting it off because of the cliffhanger everyone was talking about but after finishing it, I'm really glad I read it. The cliffhanger wasn't as bad as I was anticipating, though. Or maybe because I knew it was coming that I didn't have such a problem with it. To me, it felt as if it was just a not so subtle warning that there will be a sequel to Counterpoint. And how glad I am about that. This book had everything in it that pushes my buttons. Hostage situation, slavery ...more
My thoughts right now?

(view spoiler)
Just loved this book! Read this in one fell swoop, all 414 pages (apart from a quick dog walk). I'm a sucker for the combination of fantasy and m/m especially from author Rachel Haimowitz. The elf Ayden agrees to his master Freyrik's terms in order to save his sister fellow-captive Ella's honour. Straight on to book two..
'When Ayden looked back up, there was steel in his eyes of a kind Freyrik knew well: a warrior's commitment to a hopeless battle.
"If you keep her safe," he continued, "I will d
Emanuela ~plastic duck~
I loved this book. I would have finished in a couple of days if real life had stopped interfering with it.

The world building is compelling and lyrical, so is the writing. The musical theme was present throughout the book, weaving the world, the characters and the words together. What is expressed and the way it is expressed always fit and you are really taken to another world.

The relationship between the elf Ayden and the human Freyrik is beautiful and precious. Freyrik is immediately attracted
I have been trying to get to this series for a good couple of years and I'm annoyed at myself for putting it off for so long. This is the kind of series just perfect for me - fantasy, slave, elves, soldiers, nice bit of angst and sex scenes that are well worth the wait! Ayden and Freyrik took a while to realise exactly what they meant to each other and that their feelings ran deep but I really do enjoy a slow burner! Moving straight on to Crescendo

Brian Johnson
I fell asleep so many times during the audiobook that I just can't give it more than two stars. As a fantasy, it is serviceable but not particularly gripping. There are humans and elves at war, and some third race of dangerous animals. There is a m/m romance, sort of: the human king has eyes for his elf prisoner and there is some kind of hazily-imagined slavery kink going on that was not my thing at all. A highlight was the book's depiction of magic, which had to do with music. Overall, the writ ...more
❧A Bookish Berkeley Girl❧
May 20, 2012 rated it really liked it
Counterpoint 4 Stars

I liked it, but, I'm left hanging...
Jo * Smut-Dickted *
Just fantastic. I'm not sure a review could do this book justice. I loved it - from Ayden's struggles not to submit to his feelings or Freyrik all the way to Freyrik's dual role of leader and lover. One of the best realized worlds with outstanding dialogue you just get swept away in the story. I cannot recommend it highly enough. It was worth every penny I spent and is a definitive re read for me (probably multiple times) not for its erotic content which is there but not huge but for it's story ...more
No. No. No! NO!! I couldn't put this one down for anything. The thanks I get for that is a cliff hanger ending. Too much pain and suffering at the end, no hope of an HEA or even an HFN. I knew there was another book, but it didn't occur to me this one would end so wrong. This was well on the way to 5 stars but I just cannot stand this type of ending. I'm done.
Eva Müller
First of all: this book had actually good things. The author cleary tried to write not your typical 80s cliched fantasy-novel, there were glimpses of moral ambiguity: at one point Ayden sits at court with Freyrik and is shocked when a thief is condemned to death. Freyrik explains that the punishment for theft is not always death but this men had stolen rations that they kept for the case of a siege, meaning he had stolen from the most vulnerable. Ayden even admits that if he'd met this man (or a ...more
Oct 24, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: kindle
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
*P*u*r*p*l*e* Masochist
~Arc Provided Via Netgalley In Exchange For Honest Review~

Yay! Can't wait to read this!!!

3.5 wanna-be-4 stars

This review is posted on Way Too Hot Books.

“All the world seemed suddenly dream, for in what waking world would a prince deceive his own people for the benefit of a slave?"

Ever since a little kid I had a huge crush on fantasy movies, shows and books and even now, 26 years later, that still hasn't changed. It's just that nowadays my preferences expanded, this time on mm genre. Elves/ f
♆ BookAddict  ✒ La Crimson Femme
I didn't like this book too much. I enjoyed another book of Ms. Haimowitz, but this one didn't do it for me. The 300+ pages filled with hatred, biogry and ignorance only caused me to be pissed, not engaged. As much as I would like to know what happens in the second book, I'm going to have to ask someone else to tell me what happens.

I liked the Prince and the elf here. I really do. I didn't like Kona the cunt nor did I like Ella the imbecile. I'm not sure why Ms. Haimowitz wrote in such despicabl
Wow, what a ride with two strong men (oops, I mean 1 man and 1 elf. An emotional roller coaster with heights so beautiful and lows so draining. I don't know how I can wait till the fall when the sequel comes out. But I bet it will be a series and the ending of the next book will be equally mad making. The setting reminded me a little of Lord of the Rings without it being the same at all. A great fantasy, the romance is tied up in there but there is so much more as well. Recommended for those who ...more
Oct 17, 2010 rated it it was amazing
Ok I just wanted to say that after reading this book I was mad and hurt... I was mad that I had to wait almost a whole year until the next one comes out. This book is a great story of Understanding, Patience and in the end love with some other stuff in the middle. I was caught hook, line and sinker and could not put it down. I swore after reading the ending I heard the dramatic music of supise and possible pending doom. Or was it..............
Aug 18, 2010 rated it liked it
Counterpoint is book one of a two book epic story. The ending of this story is a cliffhanger with a few unresolved issues and definitely no happy ending in sight. This is perhaps why I had such a tough time with the story. On the one hand, the fantasy world is lovingly crafted with an eye for detail. On the other, I didn’t particularly enjoy the story’s focus on moderate violence, manipulation, humiliation, and hatred. This is a darker fantasy story that plays on the classic push/pull dynamic of ...more
Jeff Erno
Dec 28, 2010 rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: gay-fantasy
Ayden is an eight-hundred year-old elf living in a world where his race is at war with humans. He follows his sister into enemy territory where he’s confronted by human soldiers. He fends off his captors by killing sixteen of them, but ultimately is captured, along with his sister, and they become prisoners of war.

Prince Freyrik is the ruler of the human territory where Ayden was captured, and the prince is immediately attracted to the elf. He decides to enslave Ayden, and claims him as his per
Audio Review

This is my second encounter with the story, but it has been awhile. This time around was a cleaned up newer addition and the audio format.

A gripping fantasy romance of two bitter enemies brought together when elf, Ayden, crosses the border into human lands to keep his sister from capture only to be captured right alongside her. Ayden becomes the human prince, Freydrik's personal slave. It is an intense battle of wills as well as a battle for understanding as the pair navigate their
When I finished this book, my reaction was, "Hmmmmm." I kept trying to decide if I liked it or not, and the answer really is, "I have no idea."

I Liked:

-Ayden, our elven MC... for the most part. I got a little annoyed with his belligerence, but I didn't really blame him for it, either. If I were in his place, I would have been the same, if not worse. It just dragged on too long, but that's on the author, not the character.

-The key plot elements. I'm interested enough in the storyline to want to
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Female characters in M/M novels? 4 27 Jun 03, 2015 06:14PM  

Readers also enjoyed

  • Bloodraven (Bloodraven, #1)
  • Prisoner (Kria, #1)
  • Lord of the White Hell, Book 1 (Lord of the White Hell, #1)
  • Lord of the White Hell, Book 2 (Lord of the White Hell, #2)
  • The Pedlar and the Bandit King (Scarlet and the White Wolf, #1)
  • The High King's Golden Tongue (Tales of the High Court, #1)
  • Sebastian (Family of Lies, #1)
  • Iron & Fire (Silk and Steel, #2)
  • Blood & Ice (Silk and Steel #3)
  • The Emperor's Wolf
  • Consorting With Dragons
  • Gaven (Gaven, #1)
  • Silk & Steel (Silk and Steel #1)
  • Sacred Fate (Chronicles of Ylandre #1)
  • Tournament of Losers
  • The Pirate of Fathoms Deep (Tales of the High Court, #2)
  • Duck! (Avian Shifters, #1)
  • Captive Prince (Captive Prince, #1)
See similar books…
M/M erotic romance author, freelance writer and editor, sadist with a pesky conscience, shamelessly silly, proudly pervish. I'm a twitter addict (@rachelhaimowitz), and I blog every M/W/F at Fantasy Unbound. To learn all about my current and upcoming projects, please stop by my website. I love to hear from folks, so feel free to drop me a line anytime at metarachel (at) gmail (dot) com. ...more

Other books in the series

Song of the Fallen (2 books)
  • Crescendo (Song of the Fallen, #2)

Related Articles

This June, as we observe LGBTQ Pride—the annual celebration of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer/questioning communities—we wa...
36 likes · 13 comments
“Now you die while we live on, and you’ve no one to blame but your selves. So do not speak of betrayal behind my back, humans. For the Great Betrayal is your shame, not mine. ~ Ayden” 13 likes
“All the world seemed suddenly dream, for in what waking world would a prince deceive his own people for the benefit of a slave?
~ Ayden”
More quotes…