Re Passionate Relationship - PJ has the honour of the 1000th HP but sadly not all the magic lurve club mojo or PJ's considerable skill at a love scene can make this one really work well.
While not as outrageously wrecky as some of the PJ's more infamous stories like Rules of the Game or Island of the Dawn, Passionate Relationship is just missing the believability factor that makes a real HPlandia HEA.
The story starts with our orphaned h finding out that her grandmother lied to her, while her mum did indeed die at her birth, the h's father was not killed a few weeks later in a car accident as the woman always claimed. In fact, the h finds out from reading the personals in the newspaper that her father died quite recently in Portugal and his lawyers are looking for her as he apparently left her some sort of inheritance.
So it is off to Portugal we go and there the h meets the family her father married into. The dad apparently became a famous painter and became quite wealthy and supposedly spent years trying to track the h down. Sadly he never managed it cause when the h's grandmother died as a teenager, she went into foster care.
Since the dad was in London looking for a job when the h was born, the grandmother gave the h her own last name and apparently the dad had not thought to trace her via her mother's maiden name. The grandmother eventually wrote to the dad and told him everybody had died, so the dad went to Portugal where he became rich, married a gold-digging Contessa and supported her two children - one of whom is the H.
The dad purchased the Contessa's villa and left it to the h along with the surrounding land. When he met the Contessa, she was a widow who had two kids and was very poor so she snaffled him up fast. The H and his sister lived very well on the h's father's money and the h's father poured a lot of cash into restoring the H's ancestral family lands.
It is pretty safe to say that things would be very different for the H had not the H's mum married the h's dad and they wouldn't be nearly so well off. The h's father eventually heard via some old neighbors of the h's grandmother that the h had survived. So in spite of all his wealth, he supposedly could never track down the h cause she was using her mum's maiden name. Right.
The h shows up at the H's house and he is horribly rude and obnoxious, he basically calls her an opportunistic tart and then makes a pass at her. He is arrogantly sure she just held off on meeting her father until she learned she was going to inherit and he is quite nasty in his accusations and his punishing kisses. The h spends the night at the H's and his mother's home and the next morning the h finds out her father left her the H's mum's family home that he bought from her.
The h is willing to return the villa, and decides to stop by it to say a little private goodbye to the dad she never knew. The h does have a pretty high powered career as a contract negotiator but she is remarkably deficient in self-esteem thanks again to her bitter grandmother.
The H shows up and pretty much absconds with the h back to his family home, cause now he insists that he is in love with her. (He has plenty of encouragement from his mother, who may seem sweet but I found to be really manipulative in keeping the h's father's wealth in her own family.)
The mother keeps telling the h the H loves her, and the H keeps berating her for not jumping into bed with him from his smoldering seduction techniques, then berating the h again when she agrees to hop the tower of power.
We also get to meet the H's lover, who goes out of her way to make sure that the h knows she and the H are still going at it like minks. The H does manage to deny he is currently sleeping with the OW, but he sure seems cozy with the lover's dad in business. Finally the H gets his mum to walk in on him and the h during a staged seduction scene.
The mother insists on marriage immediately while the h had been planning on returning to England and sorting out her life. She thinks she loves the H, but it has only been a week or two and that is a bit fast for a lifetime marriage as Portugal has no divorce or something.
The H and his mother bully the h into marriage. Then the H's lover shows up and tells the h that the H married her for his mother's villa - he did not trust the h would turn it over to him as she said she would and his mother wants it back badly, (tho the OW tells the h that the H wants to use the land as a resort development,) so he married her to get control of it.
(Apparently Portugal has archaic property marital laws too, or at least PJ's version of it does.) The h knew something was badly off, so she decides not to consummate the marriage and get an annulment. The H tries all sorts of bullying seduction attempts and the h manages to hold him off.
Then she and the H's mother see the H and OW going up to the woman's hotel room together. The h leaves the mother and goes to pack. The H shows up and there is a long seduction scene and the H berates the h for not trusting him. It seems the H's mum had him paged before he and his girlfriend could complete their love in the afternoon experience, so he can say he did not lurve club his lover that day.
The h and H have a lurve club mojo effect and now the h is berating herself for not trusting the H. She wants to stay with him and there is a lot of inner monologue about how sorry she is to be leaving him and how horrible she was not to trust him. He seems to be determined to separate, so the h is moping around and the H is mean and distant and then the h gets the lawyer to draw up the papers giving him the villa (which was what he wanted to begin with,) and the h begs to stay.
The H reluctantly agrees cause he isn't done sexxing it up with her yet, but it is a fair bet he will be back with his lover as soon as the h turns up preggers - even tho he claims the lover is a tart, he seems to like them that way and complains when the ladies aren't.
The h is happy that she can stay, cause by now she is obsessed with the lurve club mojo and the HEA is the H and h mojoing it up with the hope of creating mini H's to continue the family fortunes and line.
PJ's big mistake was actually setting up a coherent reason for the H and mother to coerce the h into marriage and then not providing a realistic reason why they did not manipulate her into believing the H is telling the truth when he says he loves her.
PJ relies too much on the PJ latitude of "PJ said it in the story so it must be so" plot point and the power of the lurve club to make the HEA happen. Having the H berate the h for NOT sleeping with him and then having him berate the OW to the h FOR sleeping with him really makes him a very unreliable H.
I believe the h was overwhelmed with someone paying attention to her and the H's well practiced seduction techniques. I also believe the H and his mother (who really was a gold-digger IMO, albeit a type of poor aristocratic trash with class one) really worked overtime to manipulate the h and play on the emotions she felt for missing getting to know her father.
I also have to question the father's inability to track the h down, the town she lived in wasn't that big and surely the father remembered his first wife's maiden name - I suspect either he did not look that hard or the H and H's mum team were hindering the investigation.
Then there the is whole trust issue which PJ blows off as the h's being insecure - however the H did nothing to earn any trust. While he was good in bed, the overt avariciousness and problems with authority that he continually expresses he had with father figures, makes me figure he just wanted to score on his stepfather by using and robbing his daughter and keeping all his money in the H's own family. The fact that she appears to be healthy breeder no doubt adds to his satisfaction, he wouldn't want his lover to ruin her figure.
I only recommend this PJ for drinking games (drink every time the word insecure is used and you will be wasted by chapter three.) Or if you are a die hard PJ fangirl (which I am, but that doesn't mean my brain stops working in the interim. )
Sadly this outing for HPlandia wasn't a big success for me, but fortunately there are a lot more to come and PJ does have a talent for the lurve scenes and also more happy reading to come.