113 books
—
154 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Economy of Cities” as Want to Read:
The Economy of Cities
by
The thesis of this book is that cities are the primary drivers of economic development. Her main argument is that explosive economic growth derives from urban import replacement. Import replacement occurs when a city begins to locally produce goods that it formerly imported, e.g., Tokyo bicycle factories replacing Tokyo bicycle importers in the 1800s. Jacobs claims that im
...more
Get A Copy
Paperback, 268 pages
Published
February 12th 1970
by Vintage
(first published 1969)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Reader Q&A
To ask other readers questions about
The Economy of Cities,
please sign up.
Be the first to ask a question about The Economy of Cities
Community Reviews
Showing 1-30
Start your review of The Economy of Cities
"It blows cobwebs from the mind," wrote Christopher Lehmann-Haupt when he reviewed the book for the NY Times back in 1969. Forty-four years later (and just after completing a two-year masters program in urban planning), I would say that it made my brain explode (in spite of how un-academic that sounds).
Jacobs is best known for her 1961 book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, which sharply critiques the planning practice at the time. In the face of urban renewal in general and Robert M ...more
Jacobs is best known for her 1961 book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, which sharply critiques the planning practice at the time. In the face of urban renewal in general and Robert M ...more
In this book, Jane Jacobs brings her creative mind and sharp wit to bear on the question of how cities grow economically. While there's a lot of wisdom here, it demands an unusual style of reading. Jacobs was not a scientist or economist in a formal modern manner; rather, she had more in common intellectually with the natural philosophers of an earlier era. That is, rather than proposing a hypothesis and testing it against econometric analysis, Jacobs observes, keenly, and discerns a mechanism t
...more
OK, Jane Jacobs, while she is a landmark American thinker is not an academic economist or anything of the sort. Of course, that doesn't preclude her from being able to write about economic subjects, but keep that in mind. I was intrigued by her examples, but I'd like to see some more empirical, data-driven arguments that go either for or against her thesis. Something tells me something is not quite right.
...more
Jane Jacobs has established herself as an accidental expert on urban theory. Her "Death and Life of Great American Cities," meant to be a defense of her Greenwich Village neighborhood from the designs of Robert Moses, over time revealed itself to be an anatomy book for the city as a being.
Jacobs takes her pedestrian but profound musings to describing the workings of a city's economy. She approaches economics twice, in "Cities and the Wealth of Nations" and this, her earlier book, "The Economy of ...more
Jacobs takes her pedestrian but profound musings to describing the workings of a city's economy. She approaches economics twice, in "Cities and the Wealth of Nations" and this, her earlier book, "The Economy of ...more
Aug 28, 2007
Cate
rated it
really liked it
Recommends it for:
those interested in economics, urban studies, etc.
Jacobs begins this book countering the claims of accepted anthropology/archeology theory that cities are built on a rural economic base. Jacobs instead suggests that much of what is considered "rural work", and what rural economies have to offer, is in fact exported from cities to the hinterland. This is no small claim since practically everyone disagrees with her. She illustrates her thesis well with specific examples throughout history ranging from the ancient Turkish city Catal Huyuk to the i
...more
Another great read from Jane Jacobs. Jacobs continues developing her unique views on human nature and society, exploring concepts like spontaneous order, the centrality of trade (be it ideas, goods, ect.) to human life, and how our natural habitat - the city - works. As in "The Death and Life of the Great American Cities," she takes what may seem like a dry subject (in this case, urban economics) and makes it downright engrossing. With insights on subjects ranging from class conflict to early ur
...more
illuminating at points and clearly written but also kind of unimaginative and conservative. plus as a city person I feel dirty for liking a book that is 80% "sorry guys but the country as we know it is an economic and cultural backwater that exists to support the real centre of human life, the city, and I can prove it"; she makes a convincing case, but I also feel like it panders to my biases and I should go read something about the decadence of the cities for a real intellectual challenge.
...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jan 02, 2012
Paul
marked it as to-read
From Richard Florida, Author of "The Rise of the Creative Class"
http://www.fastcompany.com/1742367/ri...
"I have so many favorite books, but there are three people that really influenced me. The first and most important is Jane Jacobs and her book The Economy of Cities, which I think everyone who works in business has to read. What the farm and agricultural land was for our first great American economy, what the industrial company was to the great Industrial age, what the Great American corporati ...more
http://www.fastcompany.com/1742367/ri...
"I have so many favorite books, but there are three people that really influenced me. The first and most important is Jane Jacobs and her book The Economy of Cities, which I think everyone who works in business has to read. What the farm and agricultural land was for our first great American economy, what the industrial company was to the great Industrial age, what the Great American corporati ...more
A good read, with an interesting and persuasive argument, but tended to get too bogged down in case studies showing the same thing over and over again in a different way. The thesis was defended well enough half-way in and the rest of the book was just more of the same I felt.
Good arguments, not excellently written.
Good arguments, not excellently written.
Nov 30, 2011
Melissa Balkon
added it
Although this book has some really great information, it was much too wordy. It could have been 150 pages and still provided the same information.
Human progress and the growth of economy is driven by cities. Even agriculture is first born in cities and then transferred to rural areas.
The growth of cities themselves are driven by innovations. Jane Jacobs used a fantastic formula to describe this process: D+A+nET-->nD. Where D represents divisions of labors, A means additional activities, nET is many errors and trials to innovate, and finally, nD means more divisions of labors and more work. The innovations add new work to old work, and ma ...more
The growth of cities themselves are driven by innovations. Jane Jacobs used a fantastic formula to describe this process: D+A+nET-->nD. Where D represents divisions of labors, A means additional activities, nET is many errors and trials to innovate, and finally, nD means more divisions of labors and more work. The innovations add new work to old work, and ma ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This is the first book I have read by Jane Jacobs, and it will not be the last. I have know of her work since studying architecture in college, particularly The Death and Life of Great American Cities, but never sat down to read anything. As this one was available at my local library branch, it seemed like a good a place as any to start. Despite the density of the topics covered I found her prose to be quite accessible, and the theories she expounded upon interesting and logical.
Jacobs examines ...more
Jacobs examines ...more
Outlines how economic development originates in cities, not in rural agriculture as previously assumed, in 5 steps. 1. The city establishes itself supplying an expanding market in an older city 2. Local businesses set up to support exports begin exporting their own work 3. Imports are replaced by local workers causing a growth explosion as the economy diversifies and create new work that was neither imported nor exported prior to growth 4. New work becomes new exports and the composition of impo
...more
Jacobs makes a convincing case for the urban ecosystems that incubate intensive economic growth. She rightly moves the economic discussion from extensive growth (e.g., divisions of labor in pin making from Adam Smith) to intensive growth (the development of this new product called a "pin" from the existing industry of making the spines in wool carders). Perhaps the book's major fault is that it lacks insightful policy prescriptions like those found in "The Death and Life of Great American Cities
...more
Jane Jacobs was a fascinating thinker, economist, urban studies and public policy theorist. Her work addresses the growth of cities and their economies.
Only criticism: lack of empirical data in a lot of her work.
Here are some interesting ideas she poses in her work The Economy of Cities:
Why adding new work to old work is crucial to growing an economy (instead of merely dividing existing work more)
Why loosely structured and inefficient economies are better suited to survive change.
Why cities pre ...more
Only criticism: lack of empirical data in a lot of her work.
Here are some interesting ideas she poses in her work The Economy of Cities:
Why adding new work to old work is crucial to growing an economy (instead of merely dividing existing work more)
Why loosely structured and inefficient economies are better suited to survive change.
Why cities pre ...more
This isn't as well known as her classic The Death and Life of Great American Cities, but perhaps it should be. I have always been curious if further scholarship since its writing in the late '60s proved her hypothesis that agriculture came after settlements. She makes a convincing argument, based on archaeology of the time, that at trading posts/meeting places de facto seed trials might occur as well as the domestication of animals. Another interesting idea covered in the book is the role of imp
...more
A little out of my areas of interest, this book turns the argument that cities arise out of rural areas on it's head. The author's argument is that the city needs must come first and the rural agricultural fringe arises from and benefits from the needs and production of the city. This leads to all sorts of corollaries that are too much to discuss here. The author also gets into what makes a city vibrant and growing. It is interesting reading and still relevant despite that the book was written i
...more
My first Jane Jacobs book, and what a book. It has reframed the way I think about cities, about rural regions, about poverty, and about economic development. I'll be pondering this and likely re-reading it.
The style and format of this book reminded me very much of Eric Hoffer's The True Believer: Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movements . ...more
The style and format of this book reminded me very much of Eric Hoffer's The True Believer: Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movements . ...more
Jane Jacob’s argument was that cities, which in the early days were just small trading and administrative posts, generated agriculture, not vice versa. Cities are where the ideas all come from, where all the wealth comes from. They are also much more environmentally friendly because you use much less energy if you live in the city than if you live out in the countryside. Read the full interview here: http://thebrowser.com/books/interview...
...more
Excellent Writer. I should have read this long ago. Reminded me of A Pattern Language by Christopher Alexander, but with patterns observed, not patterns imposed.
...more
After reading her best known book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, I really looked forward to reading what insights she had about municipal government.
It is difficult to get into and it's obvious that she isn't an economist. At this time, I will respectfully put this back on the shelf and I'll attempt again in the near future. ...more
It is difficult to get into and it's obvious that she isn't an economist. At this time, I will respectfully put this back on the shelf and I'll attempt again in the near future. ...more
i wasn't wowed by this. i'm not an economist however and have very little understanding of these things. supposedly revolutionary, but ultimately just a bunch of common sense to me. if you have to choose, read "death and life of great american cities" instead.
...more
Interesting look at the day to day of how cities create wealth among the population. I don't think that most of this was common sense, sometimes the very direct understanding is overlooked, this brought a lot of good things to light.
...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| urban economy | 2 | 17 | Sep 01, 2011 09:48PM |
Jane Jacobs, OC, O.Ont (May 4, 1916 – April 25, 2006) was an American-born Canadian writer and activist with primary interest in communities and urban planning and decay. She is best known for The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961), a powerful critique of the urban renewal policies of the 1950s in the United States. The book has been credited with reaching beyond planning issues to inf
...more
News & Interviews
The new year has arrived. The clock has been reset. Now is the time to tackle the really ambitious reading challenges–those massive books that...
48 likes · 27 comments
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Cities are not ordained; they are wholly existential. To say that a city grew “because” it was located at a good site for trading is, in view of what we can see in the real world, absurd. Few resources in this world are more common than good sites for trading but most of the settlements that form at these good sites do not become cities.”
—
1 likes
“The primary economic conflict, I think, is between people whose interests are with already well-established economic activities, and those whose interests are with the emergence of new economic activities.”
—
1 likes
More quotes…



















