Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Shooting Kabul” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Shooting Kabul

N.H. Senzai (Goodreads Author)

3.93 · Rating details · 4,031 ratings · 764 reviews

In the summer of 2001, twelve-year-old Fadi's parents make the difficult decision to illegally leave Afghanistan and move the family to the United States. When their underground transport arrives at the rendezvous point, chaos ensues, and Fadi is left dragging his younger sister Mariam through the crush of people. But Mariam accidentally lets go of his hand and becomes los ...more

Get A Copy

Or buy for

Hardcover, 272 pages

Published June 22nd 2010 by Simon & Schuster/Paula Wiseman Books (first published June 22nd 2009)

More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Shooting Kabul, please sign up.

Lists with This Book

2010 Debut Authors (Young Adult & Middle Grade Literature)

288 books — 2,067 voters

2013 Rebecca Caudill Nominees

25 books — 72 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Rating details

Sort: Default

Filter

Jun 21, 2017 Michael Finocchiaro rated it it was amazing

Shelves: young-adult, fiction, novels, american-21st-c

Shooting Kabul is an absolutely great book for kids in 3rd grade and up. It is the story of Fadi and his battle with his conscience after he loses his sister Mariam as his family is fleeing to Pakistan from their native Afghanistan terrorized by the Taliban. Particularly now, with the issues of Syrian refugees taking headlines, this is an important demonstration of the values of challenging banalized racism, adapting to a new country (Fremont, CA is where Fadi's family is welcomed by their cousi ...more

flag 51 likes · Like · see review

Jul 01, 2012 Brian Kelley rated it really liked it

After reading multicultural titles Bamboo People, by Mitali Perkins; The Red Umbrella by Christina Gonzalez; and Inside Out and Back Again, by Thanhha Lai, I started to become critical of the books I made available to my students. I took stock of my classroom library--several hundred titles--it was lacking in variety. Where were the multicultural books? Where were the books that appeal to boy readers? Where were the books that could challenge my best readers? For each category I could think of, ...more

flag 21 likes · Like · see review

Dec 18, 2010 Vehlers rated it it was amazing

As a jh reading teacher who is trying to cover a multi-cultural classroom, I am going to teach this as a unit. This book covers stereotypes, bravery, family love and loyalty in a refreshing book for teens. Thanks N.H. Senzai for giving me a platform that will definitely impact students (EVEN boys!). By the way....I NEVER cry....I was crying!!!! That is quite the accomplishment. I couldn't put the book down and finished it in a few hours.

flag 9 likes · Like · see review

Mar 15, 2012 Ashleigh Rose rated it it was amazing

As a middle school English teacher, I found this book so impressive, especially for the audience for which it is written. The book covers issues of racism, classism, bullying, guilt, and loss (to name a few.) The story was incredible and while this is a short read for an adult I loved every moment of it and can't wait to share it with my high-readers!

flag 7 likes · Like · see review

Nov 10, 2015 Miu Miu rated it it was amazing

Shelves: favorites

This book is about a family fleeing from a chaotic situation, but lost their beloved sister Mariam along the way. Fadi is heartbroken and is trying to find every way possible to get his sister back, and along the way there were huge accidents that affected both him and his family. Will he find his sister, or live his entire life without her? Loving, amazing, well-written true immigrant experience. - Miu Miu :D

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Sep 26, 2013 Maggie rated it it was amazing

Recommends it for: Everyone

Shooting Kabul by N.H. Senzai is an enthralling story -- based off a true one -- about the strength of bonds between siblings and a family, hope, and perseverance against all odds. It is a truly inspiring, amazing book, and I would recommend it to almost anyone.

The story begins in Kabul, Afghanistan, home of the main character, Fadi, and his family -- younger sister Mariam, older sister Noor, and his mother and father. His family had left Afghanistan for America so his father could get a PhD, bu Shooting Kabul by N.H. Senzai is an enthralling story -- based off a true one -- about the strength of bonds between siblings and a family, hope, and perseverance against all odds. It is a truly inspiring, amazing book, and I would recommend it to almost anyone.

The story begins in Kabul, Afghanistan, home of the main character, Fadi, and his family -- younger sister Mariam, older sister Noor, and his mother and father. His family had left Afghanistan for America so his father could get a PhD, but they came back to Afghanistan afterwards, at first to help the Taliban. However, the Taliban quickly became over-controlling and overly zealous, and when they asked Fadi's father -- more like demanded -- to become a part of them, he knew he couldn't turn down their offer without forsaking his family's safety. So instead, they used up their entire savings paying for professionals to take them out of the country. In the confusion, though, Mariam's hand slips from Fadi's and their vehicle drives away at full speed from the approaching Taliban. Fadi's family's attempts to stop it are in vain, and Mariam is left behind in war-torn Afghanistan while the family reaches America.

But even once they've finally escaped Afghanistan, things are only getting more difficult. Penniless, Fadi's family has to live with their relatives, and they are embarrassed to be taking such advantage of their courtesy, though they insist they don't mind. Fadi is bullied at school and has to deal with the terrible guilt that Mariam's loss is his fault. It isn't, of course -- and the whole family is dealing with the same feelings, each shouldering the guilt for themselves and obstinately refusing to believe it isn't their fault.

In the midst of this chaos of guilt and horror at the loss of Mariam, when it seems like things can't get any worse, comes 9/11. Now the bullies at Fadi's school have a new thing to fight him over, and he's surrounded by prejudice and accusation because of where he came from.

But then, at school, he finds a photo contest. The prize? A trip to India, from which he could reach Afghanistan and find his missing sister. Photography is Fadi's special talent, his true love in life, and he's confident and certain he just has to win.

(view spoiler)

Overall, Shooting Kabul was an amazing and intriguing book, told through the eyes of an earnest, hopeful child that really helped me relate to it, even if I didn't have the same experiences as him. It taught me a lot about 9/11 and the Taliban, a different side to them I'd never really thought about. The book flowed easily and was excellently written, and the ending was sweet and very clever. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good, suspenseful, and often surprising read. ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Feb 21, 2011 Shazzer rated it really liked it

Shelves: 2010-middle-grade, middle-grade

As posted on Outside of a Dog:

There are some books that carry so much weight, it’s miraculous they get off the ground at all. It can be story weight or character weight, or outside weight from press or advertising. Mockingbird was a very weighty book. Katherine Erskine had to juggle Asperger’s Syndrome, a dead sibling and a community recovering from a school shooting, and I think that the weight of it all put together caused the book to drag its feet on the ground, unable to hold it all in. Shoo As posted on Outside of a Dog:

There are some books that carry so much weight, it’s miraculous they get off the ground at all. It can be story weight or character weight, or outside weight from press or advertising. Mockingbird was a very weighty book. Katherine Erskine had to juggle Asperger’s Syndrome, a dead sibling and a community recovering from a school shooting, and I think that the weight of it all put together caused the book to drag its feet on the ground, unable to hold it all in. Shooting Kabul, by N.H. Senzai is another heavy book, but what a difference the right touch can make.

In Shooting Kabul, young Fadi and his family make a daring escape from Afganistan and the Taliban to seek asylum in the United States. But before they can make it out of the city, Fadi is separated from his little sister Mariam, and she is left behind. The family finally lands in Fremont, California, and they try to make themselves a new home while back in Afganistan, the seach is on for the missing Mariam. Fadi blames himself, you see, for letting go of his little sister’s hand in the confusion, and knows he must help bring her back, no matter what it will take. That’s an extraordinary weight to lay on a child, but it does not stop there. Fadi also has to deal with post-9/11 prejudice, especially from a pair of bullies at his new school. He finds hope and a creative outlet in the school’s photography club, which just might offer him a chance of returning to look for his sister.

This book is a small miracle. Senzai is cooking with every burner, and the heat is on high. Considering the unfamiliar (to me) Arabic vocabulary and the extremely heavy subject matter, this book reads like a dream. I ran through it in less than a day, and I don’t feel like I missed anything or shorted myself in any way. I felt thoroughly rewarded by the book, and that is a rare experience. The moment when the truck rolls away, leaving Mariam behind is truly heartbreaking. It made me gasp. Everything that followed was graceful and believable, and handled with a deft touch. If this is how Senzai juggles, I can’t wait to see what else she might have up her sleeve.
...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jan 28, 2016 Brooke H rated it it was amazing

What was the biggest decision in your life? How difficult was it? Was it as difficult as leaving everything behind and not knowing if you'll be alive the next day?In the book, Shooting Kabul
by N. H. Senzai, Fadi's parents made a very difficult decision to leave their past life behind in Afghanistan and start a new chapter in their life in America. Fadi's mother is sick and needs better health care, and the Taliban wants Fadi's father to join their group. On the day of their escape, they go throu ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

Aug 30, 2010 Angela rated it liked it

Shelves: middle-grade

My Kid/Teen Critics say to read this one.

I really loved this book. It was about a boy and his family escaping from Afghanistan before 9/11. Everything is going well, until his little sister gets lost in the scramble to get on a bus out. Once they get to America, the boy tries to figure out a way to get his sister back, while suffering teasing at school. I highly recommend it to anyone older than ten.
Reviewed by: Anne Age:13

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Jul 22, 2016 Alison Strandell rated it really liked it

This story opened my eyes to some of the culture and people of Afghanistan, including in this case a family who came to America for a safer life. The theme that all members of our diverse human race deserve a fair chance at happiness and success is so important. Also, the novel kept me guessing and had a clever ending.

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Oct 13, 2014 Joeben rated it really liked it

Fadi was just a normal kid with a normal life in afganistan, when the Taliban arrives they flee to america. But when 9/11 happens, every thing goes downhill as the search for his little sister gets a lot more complicated.

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

May 21, 2017 Biblio Curious rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: taught, cultural-diffusion, lit-middle-east

It's a great book for starting a conversation with children, 8-12 about the complexities of Afghanistan people and the surrounding issues. It covers topics at an age appropriate level for racism, 'immigration experience,' Islam, war, Pashtun Code of Ethics, culture shock, family tensions and even teen dating. The oldest daughter takes on an after school job to help out financially, so you could also branch out into socio-economic issues.

My spoiler free review:
http://www.biblioatlas.com/2017/04/ ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Nov 10, 2018 Josie rated it did not like it

I hated this book. We were forced to read it in ELA, or English Language Arts, and it was the worst! Fadi is one of the dumbest narrators ever, thinking that he can just sneak onto a plane without getting caught, and find Mariam among all the fleeing immigrants. Ughhhh! And don't get me started on that sketchy scene with Noor and that guy in the alley. I do not recommend it.

flag 1 like · Like · see review

Dec 18, 2017 Tiffani Shannon rated it it was amazing

I read this book aloud to my 5th graders and it was wonderful. While they were skeptical at the beginning on whether they were going to enjoy it, by the end they couldn't get enough of it! The book evoked a strong range of emotions from my students and provided us with rich and powerful discussions about prejudice, racism, fear, anger, bullying, and love.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Feb 04, 2017 Kendrew Mao rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Although I had been attracted to this novel due to having previously read The Kite Runner, Shooting Kabul by N.H Senzai is its own uniquely captivating story of a family's struggle, hope, diversity, and cultural prejudice.

The story begins in Kabul, Afghanistan where the protagonist Fadi lives with his father Habib, mother Zafoona, and siblings Noor and Mariam. Fadi’s family had previously left Afghanistan so Habib could complete his Ph.D. in agriculture, but had returned to help the Taliban and Although I had been attracted to this novel due to having previously read The Kite Runner, Shooting Kabul by N.H Senzai is its own uniquely captivating story of a family's struggle, hope, diversity, and cultural prejudice.

The story begins in Kabul, Afghanistan where the protagonist Fadi lives with his father Habib, mother Zafoona, and siblings Noor and Mariam. Fadi’s family had previously left Afghanistan so Habib could complete his Ph.D. in agriculture, but had returned to help the Taliban and his country prosper. Slowly, the Taliban had evolved from heroes that had defeated the Soviets, to a controlling and dangerous group. One day, the Taliban come knocking at Fadi’s home, requesting Habib to become the Taliban’s ambassador to the UN. Realising that his family's safety would be at risk if he declined the offer, Habib and his family are forced to flee Afghanistan. Using their savings, they are able to pay for smugglers to bring them out of Afghanistan into neighbouring Pakistan. The plan was to wait for the truck at a designated spot. During their escape, Fadi is stopped by Mariam to place Mariam's doll into his backpack. All was going to plan until the Taliban unexpectedly appeared. During the ensuing commotion, Fadi lost grip of Mariam's hand, leaving Mariam behind in Kabul. Despite multiple attempts to find Mariam, Fadi and his family were forced to take asylum in the United States without Mariam before the window closed.

Life isn't easy in Fremont. Habib is forced to take a job as a cab driver, and Noor works at McDonald's to help with the bills. Guilt about leaving Mariam behind follows the family like a shadow but hits Fadi especially hard. Fadi and his family plan a way to find Mariam, going as far as hiring private investigators. Fadi starts middle school and is encouraged to join the photography club. Unexpectedly, Fadi discovers an opportunity to redeem his honor in the form of a photography contest. A contest with the grand prize of a new digital camera and a plane ticket for two to either India, China, or Kenya. Realizing how close India was to Afghanistan, Fadi commits his efforts to win the contest in hopes of gaining an opportunity to find Mariam and regain his honour.

Shooting Kabul was an interesting novel that carried with it a heavy subject and important lesson. The lesson of the novel is to never lose hope. What I enjoyed about this book is its ability to turn a complicated history lesson into understandable story. Many things are to be learned through this book such as the history of Afghanistan and the Taliban. In addition, the utilisation of Arabic language with a glossary created an intriguing and realistic cultural element to the novel. Moreover, as a reader, I had felt that the characters in the novel are easily relatable. The character I related to the most was Fadi, who felt overwhelming guilt and had blamed himself for what happened. It would be a lie to say that guilt has never caused me to blame myself. Shooting Kabul by N.H Senzai is a novel I would suggest to readers who enjoy historical fiction, or readers who seek a captiavting story. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Oct 27, 2016 Cesar Cruz is currently reading it

The story, " Shooting Kabul" is a about a boy and his family. THis book goes through the sad adventure and the struggels they went through. 11-year-old Fadi and his family gently and silenty board a truck.THey did this to begin their escape from Afghanistan. When they were geting onto the tall truck, His six-year-old sister, Mariam lets go of her brother's hand and is tragically left behind. This part in the story made me have empthay for the poor girl. How frightend she would be. How she would The story, " Shooting Kabul" is a about a boy and his family. THis book goes through the sad adventure and the struggels they went through. 11-year-old Fadi and his family gently and silenty board a truck.THey did this to begin their escape from Afghanistan. When they were geting onto the tall truck, His six-year-old sister, Mariam lets go of her brother's hand and is tragically left behind. This part in the story made me have empthay for the poor girl. How frightend she would be. How she wouldnt know what to do.
Their plan was to leave Afghanistan and get to America. But their plan went horrible. Their arrival in San Francisco is very bad. They are all too concerned about Mariam to appreciate their hard work , and that there no war here. That it is all nice and peacefull at times.
All the boy is worried about getting his sister back .He begins middle school with the memeroy and the guilt that leaving Mariam behind was his fault, and he will do anything to get her back. But one tragic thing that they had to see , was the tragic nine-eleven. Since this was done by talliban, the kids from his school made his life more misarable. They made fun of him and they called him names. They had no respect for him. They didnt know how hard his life been already.
One of the things he does remeber about her is pictures. He looks at pictures remebr how she looks. One of the things he try to do is join the photography club at his school. he club will be entering a contest where the first place winner gets a new camera and a trip to China, Kenya, or India. Realizing how close India is to Afghanistan, Fadi tells himself he must win in order to return and find Mariam.
The author of this book sets a new type of theme. She puts a theme that is sad, happy, and guilty. She does this by making us feel bad about Miraim, 9/11, and the family. This is a book that is easy to remeber because of how she put her own mind into . This book makes me think that the author has had this pain before because she make it feel so real. ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jul 27, 2011 bjneary rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: historical-fiction, multicultural-fiction, ya

I sooo loved this book! A great book for middle/jr high as well as high school for its depiction of a Muslim family fleeing the Taliban in Afghanistan after 9-11. Fadi and his family have tried to stay in their beloved country but the war has driven them from their home. Fadi's father, Habib, has paid the last of their money to flee their homeland. Fadi's family is close-knit, loving, and care deeply for each other. Fadi's mother, Zafoona, is ill and his sister, Noor, is helping her escape and F ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 14, 2018 Jannet rated it it was amazing

You should read this book because it focuses on world problems that are happening currently.Their mom is extremely sick and their dad doesn’t earn much money. Their older sister Noor works at Mcdonalds. Fadi, the main character, does many things to try to find their sister Mariam. Mariam got left behind when the family was trying to leave Afghanistan to America.
Fadi had a lot of trouble of making new friends but then he met this girl who had become his friend the girl name was Anh. Anh and Fad ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Dec 13, 2013 Meaghan rated it really liked it

Shelves: childrens-young-adult-fiction, read-in-2013

I think 9-to-12s would really like this story, although it wasn't the best young adult novel I'd ever read. For the criticisms:

1. I think the ending would have been much more effective without the epilogue, which just seemed anticlimatic to me.
2. Fadi should have been showing a lot more culture shock -- for a kid raised in Afghanistan moving to San Francisco, he acts with remarkable aplomb. Even making allowances for his Western-influenced family, I found it unbelievable. The same applies to the ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Sep 20, 2010 Zayn Singh rated it it was amazing

Shelves: friendship, history, love, family

Shooting Kabul is probably one of the most loving and compassionate novels I have ever read. A family living in Afghanistan during the time when the Afghans and the Soviet Union were at war. With the Taliban threatening everyone, Fadi's family decides to leave Afghanistan illegally. They travel to Jalalabad to catch a ride to Peshawar, Pakistan. When the truck arrives to take them to Peshawar, Maraim, Fadi's little sister, is left behind, due to Fadi's mistake of letting go of her hand. The rest ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Oct 18, 2014 Per-Nik rated it really liked it

Fadi is a boy stuck in Afghanistan and all he wants to do is get out, but when his family tries to escape the Taliban attack the meeting point for the traffickers and his little sister is left behind. So when he gets to the US, Fadi tries multiple times to try and find solutions to finding his sister. One day he discovers a photography competition and enters hoping to get the grand prize which is a trip to India. A chance to find his sister. He doesn't receive the prize in the end, but when he g ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 02, 2017 Jenny Zimmerman rated it really liked it

I loved this book. It's a good sort of entry-level novel to the topic of Afghanistan for my students. I could see students reading this one first and moving on to Kite Runner and other stories from there. I think the story is powerful and important. I am excited for my students to read this novel. It is one of the books I recently got funded for my classroom on Donors Choose. Students will be able to choose this one for literature circles, and I think they'll like it. I hope it opens their eyes ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Oct 25, 2016 Daelin rated it it was amazing

N.H. Senzai is one of my favorite writers. She is an expert at capturing and communicating the emotions of the characters in her stories. I could feel their feelings as if they were my own. I cried over her descriptions of the tragedies in Afghanistan. The story teaches an important lesson about blaming yourself for things you had no control over, and how that can affect people's lives. I would recommend this book to anyone over age 10. It night be too intense and sad for younger kids.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 03, 2017 Mirabelle rated it it was amazing

Shelves: 2nd-quarter

"Shooting Kabul" was one of the best books I have ever read! The story line is amazing, the characters are interesting and the whole situation just sucks you in. I literally became addicted to that book because you get to feel what immigrants and people who don't fit in feel like. I really learned a lot from that book about feelings and Afghanistan. On top of that, N.H. Senzai does an amazing job portraying the characters! This is definitely a must-read!

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Dec 29, 2016 Eliza Abady rated it really liked it

LOVE this book!

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Nov 21, 2016 Ben Trammell rated it it was amazing

Very emotional and thought provoking. great for younger kids in book clubs (I read it with my daughter for a book club.)

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 12, 2017 Victoria Ventura rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Moving

This book is shows the true meaning of love, hope, fear, and what family true is. Five stars across the boards!

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 15, 2010 Edward Sullivan rated it really liked it

Shelves: young-adult-novels, afghanistan

Appealing story about Afghan refugees who escape the oppression of the Taliban shortly before the September 11th attacks.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jun 16, 2018 Juan Almonte rated it really liked it

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. A book called “Shooting Kabul” is about a boy named Fadi(he is 12 years old) he and his family has to flee to The United States of America from Afghanistan. They had to flee because of a group called the Taliban. During the the fleed Fadi lost his sister called Mariam, which they were devastated. When the family reach America the tragic event of 9/11 accorded and the family has been discriminated because they’re Muslim. Fadi gets bullied because he is Muslim, and tries to get back Mariam back b A book called “Shooting Kabul” is about a boy named Fadi(he is 12 years old) he and his family has to flee to The United States of America from Afghanistan. They had to flee because of a group called the Taliban. During the the fleed Fadi lost his sister called Mariam, which they were devastated. When the family reach America the tragic event of 9/11 accorded and the family has been discriminated because they’re Muslim. Fadi gets bullied because he is Muslim, and tries to get back Mariam back but can't. Fadi tried to get on a plane to find Mariam but that didn’t go well. Fadi tired to win the photography to take tickets and go to India but Fadi bullies broke his camera. Fadi feels that Mariam left back in Afghanistan was all his fault and kept beating himself that he will find a way. Fadi makes friends and feels that he is somewhat safe. Around the end of the book, Fadi goes and meet the winner of the photography contest, where he meets one of the judges. Fadi looking at the judges own photography he saw Mariam in one of them. They quickly finds her location because Faid knew the place. They were able to find her in a refugee camps. They brought her to America but Fadi noticed that she changed a bit but that didn’t mattered for Fadi.
The book had a lot of emotions which felt so real and could relate to. These characters were really detailed and had real depth personalities. The main character(Fadi) was especially very detailed because you could read how he is feeling in the time, and place which brings the book alive. The author, N.H Senzai wrote, “ He felt as though he were hidden behind a camera lens, watching another world whirl past in shattered fragments”. Which proves that Senzai really wrote Fadi feelings very detailed which not a lot of books has them. Senzai wrote, “ ‘ Got you, you little terrorist ‘ “, this racist and discriminatory are still used in America and some people just say that is just a joke. This seems very real or “realistic” despite being part fiction. I can’t connect with this but I have Muslims friends that could connect with this. That’s what I love about this book that people could relate to this and connect. The author doesn’t jam everything into one chapter but really spread the details across the book.
Here, I will talk about the things that I personality disagreed. Some parts of the book were too serious which killed the mood. Also you could really guess what’s going to happen and you could lose interest. Sometimes the book could be confusing and doesn’t really understand. Towards the end of the book it was really confusing. The author Senzai wrote in Chapter 11, “Failure”. I was really confused what that really mean. I couldn’t tell what was happening at the end of the book. So therefore I had to re-read chapter 10 and 11 and now I could understand it. This shows that this book could be very complex if you are not a close reader. Their were some characters that were also rushed to. For example, Senzai wrote, “ He was attacked because he was Muslim”. This was the 2nd time we meet Mr. Singh, and the first time we meet him was not very memorable. This shows that the author just rushed the “character” and just put a meaning to it.
Overall I think the book was really good but there were some bumps put that didn’t really mess up the full book. I don’t really recommend this book for 11 years old but at least 12-16 years old because this book talks about things that are still discussed till this day. Personally, I don’t really connect this book but I have close friends that could indeed connect with the book. The book is kinda inconsistent but the plot is very interesting plots this could be a book for you. If you want a book that you could really connect with this book is right for you. Overall that’s why I gave this book a 4/5.

...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

May 01, 2018 Barbra R rated it it was amazing

Shelves: historical-fiction

My initial reaction after reading the book was that I felt I gained a deeper understanding of how countless families from Afghanistan could have been affected by the turmoil in the area. Also, while I liked the ending I did think about all the less-happy endings that families have faced and continue to face because of war, occupation, and politics. While reading the book I felt suspense and sadness for the family’s plight of losing their youngest child and subsequent suffering. The telling of th My initial reaction after reading the book was that I felt I gained a deeper understanding of how countless families from Afghanistan could have been affected by the turmoil in the area. Also, while I liked the ending I did think about all the less-happy endings that families have faced and continue to face because of war, occupation, and politics. While reading the book I felt suspense and sadness for the family’s plight of losing their youngest child and subsequent suffering. The telling of this story did feel realistic and accurate from an eleven-year-old’s perspective, what would be important to him.
About the Muslim faith, I learned that Job was a spiritual person for Muslims. It seemed very realistic to life how the family held their faith as very central to their lives while also being private and humble in regards to their spiritual practices and faith, and natural that people’s faiths are different and all could be accepting of a diverse community. I feel at times Western culture thinks that those with Muslim faith are very radical and extreme, and not tolerant of other faiths which is certainly not true.
The racism in the book did seem realistic, and the actions of the two bullies that ofa community that had biases and doubts. This was a good device in that kids do not generally seed racism within themselves, it is much more likely to be something they pick up from adults or these days, social media.
Regarding gender roles, because I do not know much about traditional gender roles, I did some internet research to find that the Quran does not delineate specific roles that some institutions do, and that men and women are spiritual equals. The conversation Habib and Zafoona have on pp. 87-89 express this, as the adults have no shock or scorn for this heated reaction from Zafoona, and it is treated as normal.
I believe the Barbie and photography represent the beliefs and social norms of modern Muslim families, and make a good example for representing the bans that the Taliban enforce, and the struggle against this oppression that families endure while trying to live their lives.
If assigning this book to students I would reference the glossary before having students do the reading so that the students know they can refer to it when words come up they need to know. I would ask students to make note of the map in the beginning of the book or I would present one for them.
Furthermore, I would refer to the author’s website where there is a reading guide, (http://www.nhsenzai.com/wp-content/up...) as well as the companion book, Saving Kabul Corner, N.H. Senzai.
Another suggestion for in class use would be to have a guest speaker in class who has experience immigrating to the Unites States, or a Muslim family member to discuss any pertinent experiences.

...more

flag 1 like · Like · see review

« previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 … next »

new topic
Discuss This Book

topics	posts	views	last activity
Book Reviews Site	1	13	Feb 07, 2014 05:00PM

Readers Also Enjoyed

Genres

Historical > Historical Fiction

84 users

Young Adult

68 users

Realistic Fiction

56 users

Fiction

40 users

Childrens > Middle Grade

39 users

Cultural

33 users

See top shelves…

About N.H. Senzai

N.H. Senzai

114 followers

I grew up speaking two languages, balancing life lived on the edge of two cultures, and, happily, two cuisines—tandoori chicken and hot dogs, grilled side by side on the 4th of July. I got on a plane for the first time at two months, in Chicago, IL, where I was born, and have been travelling ever since. I grew up in San Francisco, Jubail, Saudi Arabia, and attended boarding school in London, Engla ...more