So, I was strolling through Barnes and Noble with my daughter, looking for a new story time book. We usually have a system to this; as it is a big treat to go to book store, usually she picks out a book and I pick out one. This way whatever her current interest is, she can keep it going and I can pick out something that (a) won't frustrait me to reread over and over and also (b) sometimes recapture something I remember reading as a child or at least pick something that I think may make her think a bit more than some of her choices.
I saw this book sitting there. The 50th anniversary edition with the original artwork and I was instantly transported back. When I was a kid this was one of my favorite books. I loved how the character took every word literally, and while it was very funny, it ingrained in kid Tim a knowledge that words could be taken multiple ways (something of a complex thought at 3 or 4). I had never seen the original artwork, and while it wasn't what I remembered, I found it charming and of course picked it up.
That night at story time, my daughter instantly went for the book she chose. That's fine, I expected it. We read it and she enjoyed it. Then we went with my choice… and much to my delight she was laughing so hard I actually had to catch her as she almost rolled off her bed. This was the story that got the "again, again!" that night.
Really, I cannot recommend this one enough. If the child likes plays on words, they will likely find this to be hilarious. Honestly, it's still amusing even to me as an adult. 4/5 stars