Four stars might be overstating it a bit, as this compilation of short Conan Doyle adaptations by a bunch of different artists and writers is pretty mixed, but the stories themselves are almost all pretty entertaining, and while there are a couple of Holmes stories included, there are many more that don't feature ACD's most famous character. Rick Geary's version of "The Copper Beeches" is one that does, and it's as wonderful as all his stuff, one of my favorites in the book, along with J.B. Bonivert's "The Los Amigos Fiasco" and Antonella Caputo and Nick Miller's "The Castle of Gloom." Unfortunately, some of the adaptations, while the stories don't suffer all that much, are pretty poor, muddying what's actually happening and just generally contributing to a lot of annoyance. John W. Pierard's "Captain Sharkey" is an example. Good story, full of pirates and dastardliness, but the art and panel plotting are a mess. I suppose that's what happens when you select a bunch of comics people who seem to smoke a fair amount of weed. Still, I'd recommend the book, and I'm interested to read a bunch more in the series. I like the short format, and I've discovered some new artists.