I'm only giving this a second star because I thought the first half was pretty good. I did not like the second half of the book. I like a good mystery, which I thought this was going to be. It wasn't.
The first story with Tom, Emerald, Earl, and all that I found was great. Like how it ended with a question but still felt complete. I loved all the questions about family and what the man in each family did wrong but they could've still been forgiven.
~~~~possible mild spoilers~~~~
I really did not like the big reveal for the second story, Final Cut. I felt like the big reveal at the end came out of nowhere. There wasn't any hint/foreshadowing to what the reveal was gonna be. Like, the whole red herring of the guy being alive and was still doing everything was great. But, then when it's revealed that he isn't alive and can't be the one behind this, there weren't any clues as who it could actually be.
And, the big reveal felt more like a villain giving his big speech to the hero and revealing his master plan than like a reveal of how everything comes together. It left me disappointed.
Also, I don't like Christopher Chance. I just find him very unlikable. You're coming in for a job about a missing boy and all you can think is how beautiful the man's wife is? Come on, man. I mean, I've liked some womanizing men before but I was under the impression that Chance was supposed to be a professional. There's nothing professional about that. And, it continues.
~~~~end of possible spoilers~~~~
So, I did not like Final Cut. I did not like Christopher Chance. The only reason I didn't DNF was because this was a comic book I could finish quickly. Next time, I'll just DNF.