David Bordwell, Jacques Ledoux Professor at the University of Wisconsin, is arguably the most influential scholar of film in the United States. The author, with his wife Kristin Thompson, of the standard textbook Film Art and a series of influential studies of directors (Eisenstein, Ozu, Dreyer) as well as periods and styles (Hong Kong cinema, Classical Hollywood cinema, among others), he has also trained a generation of professors of cinema studies, extending his influence throughout the world. His books have been translated into fifteen languages.
بوردول بخش زیادی از مباحث این کتاب رو در 《هنر سینما》و 《تاریخ سینما》به یه نحو دیگه آورده، اما همچنان خوندنش به غایت جذابه؛ بخصوص جلد دوم که درباره سینمای هنری و پارامتری و گدار حرف میزنه.
Not necessarily worth reading unless you're really interested in storytelling in movies, but pretty accessible for the non-film student. You'll obviously want to skip the chapters where Bordwell refutes existing strains of film theory, but the chapters where he actually breaks down how films tell stories (Chapters 3-10, about 200 pages) helped me to understand film in a way that no other book has.
بردول با نقد و شرح انواع نقدهای فیلم و نوع دیدن فیلم، به یک نظریه شخصی میرسد که همانطور که خود در پایان بیان میکند قصد ندارد برای همه فیلمها آن را عرضه کند. در مجلد اول به شرح و بسط آن میپردازد و در مجلد دوم با بیان ۴ ژانر سینما به نقد فیلمها میپردازد. ۳۱ اردیبهشت ۱۴۰۲
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A superb primer not only for understanding how film narratives work, from Griffith to Godard, but an excellent study of the narrative process in all media. Uses modern cognitive research to shape its ideas about the process of viewing, as well. Typically outstanding work by Bordwell, not a book for those with a casual interest in the subject.
Film narratology has become, for me, the most intriguing aspect of cinema studies. Bordwell is the godfather of the subject, and this text is an essential gateway.
David Bordwell nos entrega un libro que quiere ser exhaustivo y que quiere crear una teoría que se diferencie de otras teorías de la narración a través de la forma en que el espectador recibe codificaciones que le permiten (re)construir la historia a través de los elementos entregados por el cineasta: el argumento y el estilo, que dan forma a la película. Siendo un libro interesante, completo, con análisis brillantes, finalmente decepciona porque ese objetivo que se había marcado no se aborda directamente, la función del espectador, y se examina más la función del estilo y del creador... que desestimada la figura del sujeto de enunciación acaba redundando en una figura cercana a la del criticado "autor".
I think film enthusiasts of all levels will find this book invaluable. Not only is Bordwell's theory of narration convincing and fairly easy to apply to your own viewing activities, but he is also a fantastic summarizer. The beginning chapters of the book which recount various theories of narration are great because they condense and explain, in relatively straightforward terms, very complexly communicated theories. This provides a great jumping off point for narrational research, as you will already have an expert, albeit slight, background in whatever literary or filmic narrational theory you might be interested in.
In regards to the full extent of Bordwell's theory, I am not such an expert summarizer as he, so I will limit my comments to say that it achieves specificity while maintaining broad applicability.
An utterly fascinating book, explaining/arguing how film tells story: you may think it's obvious, but this book makes it clear that it's not (and the argument probably holds true for novels, short stories and stage plays as well).
Reading this while watching Mike Flanagan's The Haunting of Hill House on Netflix shows how influential it is: a lot of the films contained within I had never seen (or indeed heard of) but it still explains them in an utterly followable way.
Per capire la narrazione dei film. Un testo fondamentale, per me, per capire come funziona la narrazione filmica. Molto interessante, ne ricordo ancora gran parte del contenuto.
Perhaps it's my mood, but man, this book is tedious. I'm interested in the subject matter, but I find that Bordwell's insistence on the cognitivist approach gets a little tiring. Still, I appreciate the effort to challenge the methodologies that consider cinema in terms of linguistic categories.
Pocitově mi to zabralo snad rok a půl, jak hutné a obsáhlé na informace Narration in the Fiction Film bylo. Jedná se ale o skutečně precizně sepsanou knihu srozumitelným (byť dosti odborným) jazykem, snažící se představit jeden ze základních principů analýzy narace narativních filmů.