Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.

Start by marking “Eminent Historians: Their Technology, Their Line, Their Fraud” as Want to Read:

Other editions

Enlarge cover

Rate this book

Clear rating

1 of 5 stars 2 of 5 stars 3 of 5 stars 4 of 5 stars 5 of 5 stars

Open Preview

Eminent Historians: Their Technology, Their Line, Their Fraud

Arun Shourie

4.22 · Rating details · 469 ratings · 52 reviews

Shourie has the anecdotal reasoning of Nirad Chaudhuri married to the writing style of Robert Ludlum. Both are in ample evidence in this book.' - India Today

In this incisive commentary, Arun Shourie documents the ways in which our history textbooks have been doctored by leftist historians. Thoroughly researched and riveting, this study brings to light the techniques and ...more

Get A Copy

Hardcover, 271 pages

Published by ASA (first published November 1st 1998)

More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Eminent Historians, please sign up.

Lists with This Book

Our Moon Has Blood Clots by Rahul Pandita

Indian History (including post 1947 India)

285 books — 41 voters

Awakening Bharat Mata by Swapan Dasgupta

The Indian Conservative by Jaithirth Jerry Rao

Understanding India and South Asia

270 books — 19 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30

Average rating 4.22 ·

Rating details

· 469 ratings · 52 reviews

More filters

Sort order

Start your review of Eminent Historians: Their Technology, Their Line, Their Fraud

Sep 01, 2015 Nandakishore Varma rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Arun Shourie, BJP ideologue and Hindu apologist, is at his aggressive best in this "expose" of the leftist historians in India: Irfan Habib, Romila Thapar, Bipan Chandra, Satish Chandra et al. His attack is two-pronged. One: the official historians at the ICHR (Indian Council of Historic Research) consumed millions of rupees in public funds with precious little output to show for it. Two: they purposefully distorted Indian history by not mentioning the atrocities of Muslim invaders against ...more

flag 75 likes · Like · see review

Aug 24, 2009 Anant Singh rated it it was amazing

Shelves: indian-non-fiction

I feel that Mr. Shourie should have been given somehting like BHARAT RATNA for this piece of work , but as its not in my hand i can just say thanks to Mr. Shourie . Classic work and an eye opener. Some points which touched me :

1. Reference to the work of ICHR which is like hell and there books are like dust.
2. The on going tampering of Indian History by so called leftist and its impact.
3. Even the russian are fair in your history then these eminent historians.

I think its the time for leftist ...more

flag 34 likes · Like · see review

Oct 21, 2018 Ashish Iyer rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: read-2018, information, favorites, history, indian-politics, non-fiction, indian-author

Brilliant book. This book is an eye opener for me. Everyone should read it. This book show how leftist with the help congress distorted our Indian history. You can see how ICHR (Indian Council of Historical Research) are corrupted to the core. These eminent historian charge money in the name of so called "honorary and they took so much money in the name of project which they haven't completed or even submit any progress. In India, our history is never written in neutral point of view. It is ...more

flag 37 likes · Like · see review

Nov 16, 2012 Nikhil Koul rated it it was amazing

For any parent in India who sends his kids to school today thinking that he/she is giving the best of education of the past needs to do a rethink....these eminent historians of marxist/communist background distorted history so much that it has emerged as a monster which gobbles the truth up every time an Indian identity surfaces....we are being taught to loathe ourselves and it is these historians that need to be held guilty in a Nuremberg trial of sorts IMHO...An excellent companion piece with ...more

flag 16 likes · Like · see review

Mar 02, 2013 Vijai rated it really liked it

Shelves: thoughtprovoking

Is our national identity flawed? and is it by design? who is to blame?

These are a few fundamental questions Mr. Shourie is trying to answer in this book.

I must confess, while going through the first 50 or so pages, I had almost decided that Mr. Shourie had written this book to settle a personal score with a few from some organization. How wrong I was!

It is only when I almost finished the book did it dawn upon me that what Mr. Shourie had done was an immaculate display of case presentation to Is our national identity flawed? and is it by design? who is to blame?

These are a few fundamental questions Mr. Shourie is trying to answer in this book.

I must confess, while going through the first 50 or so pages, I had almost decided that Mr. Shourie had written this book to settle a personal score with a few from some organization. How wrong I was!

It is only when I almost finished the book did it dawn upon me that what Mr. Shourie had done was an immaculate display of case presentation to the reader in answering these tough questions.

You see, one's notion of national identity/ nationalism ebbs from what he or she knows about his country's history, its origins, its cultural DNA. More often than not, for most of us, this education begins and ends with what our textbooks tell us in that regard unless of course you pursue history itself as a career. However, for those that prefer to venture into greener pastures seldom give thought to accuracy of the history lessons we were taught.

This is where Mr. Shourie begins his attack; content of the history books of various grades in schools and other important literary works. Are our children (were we for that matter) being told the history as it was or is vote bank politics polluting historical accuracy in an effort to appease certain sections in our country? Mr. Shourie citing exhaustive amount of sources very effectively argues that it is indeed so the case.

This book touches so many points that this review could alone run into various pages if I were to cite even a few to provide my opinion on them. However, I will say this that more than being a book filled with excellent case presentation, this is an important wake-up call for every serious thinker to ponder about how our Indian nationalism is molded in poor taste through systematic insertion of false positive data in our history sources and where it will all lead to.

Four stars as the language is sometimes way too complicated (I had a dictionary close-by when reading this book) and makes the reading pace really difficult for the average person.

P.S - I am quite apprehensive that this book may end up being marked as an "your versus me" argument around religion. It is NOT that; At least in my opinion. So, unless you can judge an argument only by its merit and not by the subjective emotions it evokes, worse yet with religious context, you are better off avoiding this book. ...more

flag 13 likes · Like · see review

Feb 11, 2014 Vikas Lather rated it liked it

I think one should not waste much energy to read his defence for Right-wing Indian fascism of Hindutava, but that must be poured to graduate with double curiosity his extremely well-investigated attack on Islamic disturbances.

I think, one day Arun Shourie, writer of good skills, will learn that as much as he hates homicidal and fanatical Islamic forces; we do hate, we identify his cause but we also go on step further, where he fails, to destroy his cult of Hindutava by using his own logic :)

flag 13 likes · Like · see review

Oct 14, 2013 Vamsi rated it it was amazing

"If you do not know where you come from, then you don't know where you are, and if you don't know where you are, then you don't know where you're going. And if you don't know where you're going, you're probably going wrong" - Terry Pratchett
This quote is as true for Countries as much as it is for people. The only way to know where you come from is through history. Its very important for us to know the history of our country. It's the collective memory of human society. It teaches us the "If you do not know where you come from, then you don't know where you are, and if you don't know where you are, then you don't know where you're going. And if you don't know where you're going, you're probably going wrong" - Terry Pratchett
This quote is as true for Countries as much as it is for people. The only way to know where you come from is through history. It’s very important for us to know the history of our country. It's the collective memory of human society. It teaches us the strengths, weaknesses, good, evils of Human Nature and Society at large. It helps us understands events that lead to the rise and fall of great kingdoms and Civilizations.
India is the oldest country with continuous civilization as far as recorded history is available. Rig veda is the oldest written scripture available in Human history. India is the home of first urban civilization. The history of such a Country would be a fascinating subject of interest and huge inspiration to the people of any country.
One's notion of national identity/ nationalism comes from what he or she knows about his country's history, its origins, its cultural DNA. More often than not, for most of us, this education begins and ends with what our textbooks tell us regardless of the facts unless you pursue history as your career.
Are Indian history text books really a source of inspiration for us? Do they make us aware of the true facts of our civilization? Sadly the answer is “No”. History writing in India has been hijacked by Marxists historians of JNU class who have constantly derided the virtues of Indians/Hindus. In their perennial hatred for Hinduism, they have gone to the extent of praising barbaric rule of Islamic invaders and whitewashed their crimes from history books. History has been distorted and twisted, to suit the political agenda of the socialists. India’s premier historical institutions like ICHR, academic and research facilities, have been dominated from the beginning by leftist historians.
The details of all such inaccuracies and Goebbels propagandist writing are unmasked by “Arun Shourie” in this beautifully written book “Eminent Historians”.
Well as a last resort, the publishers have been pressurised not reprint this book despite the demand. It’s always “out of stock” in flipkart.
Coming back to the initial quote, we are not being told where we came from accurately, so we do not know where we are. And now you know where you are going.
...more

flag 11 likes · Like · see review

Jan 19, 2014 Abhishek Prakash rated it it was amazing

Shelves: history, india, hinduism

I read the Ramayan and wondered how Lord Ram , a man and warrior pining and crying for his wife, who faces all his trials with great fortitude, has been described by leftists as "patriarchial" . It just did not make any sense .

I read the Bhagvad Gita and wondered how this call to duty and actions was called by left wingers as promoting "fatalist and defeatist mindset". I saw how great men read the gita and it inspired them to fight like a tigress (yes. tigress) defending her cubs.

Arun shourie ...more

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Jul 24, 2019 Ajay rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Those who want to know why our history books are biased and distorted in schools and colleges should read this book.

flag 8 likes · Like · see review

Apr 17, 2019 Hariprasad rated it it was amazing

When talking about our devatas shastra says do what they ask you to do, not what they themselves did. The same can be said about Arun Shourie :)

A masterpiece. Must read book.

flag 7 likes · Like · see review

Mar 15, 2018 Aditya Kulkarni rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: indian-history, politics

I have always been a history enthusiast since my childhood. I studied in a CBSE school and whatever forms the history syllabus in NCERT books is written from Delhi's perspective. Not only this, it is completely written from a Marxist view point. I live in Karnataka and I'm a Kannadiga by ethncity. However, there was hardly anything about Karnataka's history in my textbooks. Marxist historians used public institutions like the Indian Council for Historical Research (ICHR) to propagate their ...more

flag 6 likes · Like · see review

Feb 27, 2019 Jaspal Rana rated it it was amazing

Shelves: history-politics, reviewed

It is amusing that the review with highest likes gave Eminent Historians a measly two stars. Besides accusing Mr. Shourie of bigotry and fundamentalism, this particular reviewer notes that despite producing an impressive array of documentary evidence, Mr. Shourie is quite ill-informed and prejudiced, because he is pushing a very specific agenda here. Curiously enough, the reviewer does not offer an iota of evidence or explanation to support his accusations.

I dare say there is some (read: much) ...more

flag 5 likes · Like · see review

May 09, 2015 Shashishekhar Kashyap rated it it was amazing

Shelves: history

But, for a few good men like Arun Shourie, Sita Ram Goel, S L Bhyrappa generations of Indians would have grown up to hate themselves, their forefathers and their heritage. They form the intellectual backbone of what is derisively called as the 'Right wing'. But it is indeed 'Right'. Their stupendous capabilities have unfortunately been spent on reiterating, researching and dismantling the artifice of falsehoods built by the "Macaulay, Missionary and Marx" guilds in India.

Arun Shourie in this ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Feb 26, 2014 Vivek rated it liked it

This book would have been more relevant 15 years ago when communism was more prevalent. Today communism is but almost out of Indian politics with no real hold in any geographic location of India. The author does over burden the reader with facts, excerpts from various sources, quotes from historians that it feels like you are reading a thesis than a book. Often I was confused as to whether it was the author narrating or was it the quote from a speech from a historian.

But having said all that its ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Oct 30, 2009 Mridul Manohar rated it really liked it

A veil burner, exposing the ill-intentioned mop up by Indian historians (so-called). Medieval history of India from the court of medieval kings. If a journalist can do this much of hard work, I wonder what stops people doing all sorts of PhD's, from exploring this fraud. Would love to read a real in-detail historical analysis of the "facts" presented by Mr Shourie.

Can not give it 5 though as some portion of the book feels like Mr. Shourie settling score with leftist journalists. Also, the book ...more

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Nov 04, 2014 Ronak Patel rated it really liked it

If you are interested in Education & how politics has affected and twisted Educational Policies in India, this book is must read.

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Jun 30, 2020 Madhurya Yadunath rated it it was amazing

This is a masterpiece by Arun Shourie. A must read.

flag 4 likes · Like · see review

Feb 05, 2020 Ayush Kumar rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

What will you do if you intend to brainwash generations........get into the business of defining, writing and reinventing history! This is business because eminent historians started to sell their view point and their "theory" through history writing. The book talks about these historians and their writings and their academic feudalism and how they marched forward even with the inherent inconsistencies in their interpretations of history.

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Oct 18, 2016 Pradeep T rated it it was amazing

Does the modern liberals hate Hindus and demean our scriptures right from the Vedas, the Ramayana, the Mahabharata, the Upanishads and Hindu philosophy ? Then, who is to blame? Does all these secular changes were new to India? Does belittling Hinduism is the new phenomenon? From where does these set of people even come from? Those very answers lies in this exceptionally written book.

Arun Shourie the author turned politician has penned this epic rebuttal to those intellectual terrorists and Does the modern liberals hate Hindus and demean our scriptures right from the Vedas, the Ramayana, the Mahabharata, the Upanishads and Hindu philosophy ? Then, who is to blame? Does all these secular changes were new to India? Does belittling Hinduism is the new phenomenon? From where does these set of people even come from? Those very answers lies in this exceptionally written book.

Arun Shourie the author turned politician has penned this epic rebuttal to those intellectual terrorists and demagogues and ripped apart their lies that they peddled for nearly 4 decades. Communism is not new in India, in fact, the communists supporters are prospering in India since its inception till today. But they do it openly. But, how about those so called intellectuals and historians who subvert the very history of India to please their masters and doing more damage to the national prosperity? Arun Shourie has addressed the very same issue in this book titled Eminent Historians.

The first few pages of the book doesn't seems quite interesting as there only figures of the money that these eminent historians took to complete their writing projects at the expense of tax payers. Shourie has tabulated all those details of each individual who are making a moolah by doing nothing. The scores of these historians are in the likes of Irfan habib, R.S Sharma, Bipan Chandra, Lal, Panikkar, Romila Thapar, Anand, and so on. These people were adorning the highest chairs of Universities in this country and are helping to nurture their proteges by imbibing the same communist ideologies in their pupils. These historians have took all the advantage of government to write something real, but all they did was to subvert the very basic foundations of this country.

As the book progresses further, we get to see from the example of West Bengal government's action plan of editing the history text books for school children. As per accounts exposed by Shourie, all those crimes and robberies committed by the Islamic invaders was deleted from the books at the orders of their existing government at that time. Instead, kids were taught how intolerant that the Hindus and Hindu religion is. There is not an iota of doubt that, the communist champions were the brain behind these.

This is just an example from the book. You get to read many such cringe worthy details of these communist authors that went ahead and tried to paint a bad image of Hindustan. Shourie emphasizes the fact that, even Russian authors are fair enough in their writings than these communist eminent historians of India. These communist historians are peddling lies after lies and worshiping the likes of Mao, Stalin, Engels, etc.. These are gods and flag bearers of social justice.

Shourie further exposes the lies of those authors who claims that the Hinduism is a new 19th century British created movement and there was no real Hindu religion at all. These authors goes a step ahead to celebrate Jainism and Buddhism. They also mention that, Hinduism has targeted the Buddhists and Jains in India that resulted in the decline of these religion in India. But, they forgot to mention the attacks perpetrated by the Islamic invaders who pillaged the country and ransacked their monasteries. Author has exhumed the truth by giving the right references for each of their lies and exposed them brilliantly.

I guess, more Indians should read this book to understand why there is liberal movement in today's India? Why there is an uproar of modern secularism? Why the universities like JNU (Jawaharlal Nehru University) is breeding anti-nationals in their campuses? Why there are no real historians remained in this country that could teach the real Indian history to its people? And, finally, why this new generation of students who remain closed to the arguments and research, but, believe in the books offered by our governments as curriculum?

The book overall exhumes the truth in the subtle way. There are few section of people who argue that, Arun Shourie has written this book to settle personal scores and animosities with these authors. But, it is not. Try being rational and open up to the arguments presented by the author. It is really an important book for everyone. A collectors gem. Highly recommended. ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Apr 06, 2014 Akshay rated it it was amazing

History writing has been a complex enterprise in India. The first fifty years following Independence in 1947 has seen "influential" historians who have contributed nothing but falsehoods. "Eminent Historians" by Sri. Arun Shourie is an incisive commentary at portraying how historians have succeeded in doctoring history, capturing institutions and promoting themselves. The book maps the ways in which our history textbooks have been doctored by such "influential" historians. There is no doubt that ...more

flag 3 likes · Like · see review

Sep 06, 2015 Sajith Kumar rated it liked it

The cover says it all. An ostrich made of the hammer and sickle burying its head in sand to gloss over inconvenient facts! But there is more to it, as Arun Shourie narrates in very fine detail. Scholars having strong bias towards the Left control our premier institutions and media even to the level of hijacking it. They produce history of India in conformity to Marx ideas stated way back in the 19th century such as the human past is a long story of class struggles. This has gone to ridiculous The cover says it all. An ostrich made of the hammer and sickle burying its head in sand to gloss over inconvenient facts! But there is more to it, as Arun Shourie narrates in very fine detail. Scholars having strong bias towards the Left control our premier institutions and media even to the level of hijacking it. They produce history of India in conformity to Marx’ ideas stated way back in the 19th century such as the human past is a long story of class struggles. This has gone to ridiculous lengths as when one historian lamented that the hardships of village folk were not reproduced in the paintings of Ajanta caves! This book flays them alive, showing their true colours and how they have lost anchor when the socialist system humiliatingly collapsed in the 1990s in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. This book attempts a three-pronged approach to isolate the politicized historians – Shourie calls them ‘eminences’ derogatively, always in inverted commas – for their misuse of public funds earmarked for research, whitewashing of the medieval period in Indian history and reviling the ancient period and thirdly, for blindly following the outdated political ideology of Marx and Lenin. None other than Shourie can produce a work of this sort, which is full of vitriolic but effective diatribe against opponents. Having served as an economist, journalist, parliamentarian and a minister, Shourie’s credentials are impeccable.

The leftist historians and academics act as a clique to malign the country’s cultural heritage and the author tries to expose their stranglehold on the nation’s academic institutions and media. They unabashedly produce work committed to Marxist theories that reek of totalitarianism and irrelevance to Indian conditions. The leftist academics became fashionable during the time of Nehru. Our first prime minister was overly susceptible to the latest intellectual ‘fashions’ in Europe. Unfortunately for India, the latest fad going on in the thinking circles of London was Fabian socialism. So, Nehru anointed these people on the higher echelons of state organizations concerned with education and historical research. The historians thus appointed found it expedient to propagate Marxian propaganda through the text books taught in India’s schools and colleges, thereby poisoning the minds of impressionable childhood and adolescence. The Jawaharlal Nehru University in the capital became a hotbed of armchair revolutionaries in this way. The masters selected and pruned their descendants carefully. Meanwhile, the Congress party which continued its rule in Delhi chose to ignore this contentious phenomenon as the party didn’t have an alternate ideology to put before the people. All this changed with the advent of BJP to power. For right or for wrong, the party has an ideology that is diametrically opposite to that of the communists. The Sangh Parivar wanted to control those institutions which the leftists had made their personal fiefs.

Shourie exposes a typical element of the leftist tirade that may be labeled misinformation. The guiding principles contained in the Memorandum of Association of the Indian Council of Historical Research (ICHR) propose to ‘give a national direction to an objective and rational presentation and interpretation of history’. When the BJP reconstituted the ICHR in 1998, the notification was found to include the word ‘national’ appearing for a second time in place of ‘rational’. This was trumpeted as an affirmation of the Sangh Parivar’s ‘wicked’ attempt to saffronise history. On the first look, it looks like what the critics say is correct. Omission of the word rational could only come about by a deliberate attempt. However, Shourie made a detailed analysis of previous notifications and comes up with the startling observation that the term rational was changed to national in 1978 as the result of a typing error. For two decades, nobody paid any attention till the time when the leftists raised a hue and cry. Communism thrives by selectively masking information or withholding it in its entirety from the public eye.

The so called ‘eminent historians’ show a reverential attitude to Islamic fundamentalism. Shourie produces copies of instructions issued by the West Bengal government’s education department asking teachers not to mention in the classrooms the brutalities committed by medieval sultans and their soldiery like forced conversions and destruction of temples. Historians follow a set procedure to deal with acts of a violent kind. If the sultan had destroyed a temple, it is obviously to get at the jewels and gold heaped there and not for religious reasons. If he imposed Jizya on the Hindus for the right to live as second class citizens in their own motherland, it is for economic reasons the tax would bring to the state treasury. If he forcibly converted Hindus, it is because in a battle, the sultan cannot afford his enemy ranks to swell and not for any religious motives. Thus, the historians find all of their actions quite justified. But what about the wanton destruction of temples and placing the smashed remains of stone idols on the walkway in the nearby mosque so that believers can tread on it every time they worship there? What about desecration of the temples of the defeated by butchering cows inside them? This carnage cannot be explained by economic reasons, so the ‘eminent historians’ choose to censor them and teach a sanitized version. The author reproduces numerous quotes from texts with the original and sanitized versions which prove his case.

Besides these, the ‘eminent historians’ are experts in the grand old art of financial embezzlement. Several occurrences are pointed out where they collected considerable sums from ICHR for producing books on various projects, but end up with neither doing the work nor returning the money. Foreign seminars and conferences form another milch cow for the unscrupulous politicized historians. Since these people form the cream of the hierarchy, such theft could be concealed effectively. It is only when the government effects a major overhaul of the apparatus on radical lines do the chance of exposure arises. One of the reasons for raising the slogan of saffronizing may be this secret agenda of keeping their embezzlement secret. When the project for translating the Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan series on the history and culture of India was initiated, the committee of ‘eminent historians’ distributed the task among themselves and appropriated many lakhs of rupees in the bargain. Even the work of EMS Namboodiripad, a Marxist politician from Kerala was masqueraded as learned opinion, showing the ideological tilt of the nation’s premier institutions on historical research which are expected to steadfastly remain impartial.

The book sums up the issues by revealing the real motive behind such deliberate falsifications. Shourie coins the term ‘religiofication’ to explain the curious case of even intelligent people making a dumb following of the teachings of Marx and Lenin. They demarcated five stages of social development that every society must pass through, such as primitive communism, slavery, feudalism, capitalism and socialism before it reaches the promised land of communism where milk and honey flow. Everywhere in the world, left-leaning historians attribute the history under their study to follow this dictum by the Master, just as in a religious discourse. It has been established that Marx’ observations themselves were on many occasions – such as the extent of slavery in ancient Greece – found to be in error or based on insufficient material, since many later findings from the field have supplemented the edifice of knowledge on this issue. Scholars who follow the party’s official line are not expected to express any divergent opinion, however slight the differences may be. Opinion of those who are believed to be against the party is not taken into account at all. This blind adherence to commands from authority figures is the hallmark of religion and hence the word ‘religiofication’. Shourie hints that the striking resemblance in obedience to the Master may be what prompts the leftists to defer to Islamic hardliners who follow their religious precepts with equal ardour.

A serious drawback of the book is that it has assumed that whatever is severely criticized by the ‘eminent historians’ is inherently good. The charge against them is that they unduly berates the ancient period while keeping mum on the acts of violence perpetrated during the sultanate and Mughal periods. But the remedy to this malfunction is not to eulogize the ancient past, but to continue the investigation with the same critical sense during the medieval period as well. The inquiring mind should be free of slavery to any political or economic ideology. Historians use the term Brahmanic to the ancient period, that is also being taken offense of. However, this may be treated as an attempt to distinguish it from modern Hinduism. Shourie’s assertion that Buddha, like the tenets of Islam, asked the idols of other faiths to be pulverized (p.89) does not seem to be based on solid evidence.

The book is highly recommended.
...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 20, 2020 Hunger Artist rated it it was amazing

"To Historians is granted a talent that even the gods are denied to alter what has already happened!"

I remembered this scornful saying when I finished this book. Arun Shourie has brilliantly exposed the likes of Ram Guha and Irfan Habib. How Mughal history was whitewashed and glorified and how we are taught false history to till day and any attempt of correcting the history is still resisted with the false accusation of "Saffronization of history".

The Nation who does not know her history has ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 26, 2017 Suyash Somvanshi rated it it was amazing

Very important book that should be read for the gravity of the situation it tries to address .
This book as I view is a critique of using Marxist theory or for that matter any theory as a lens to analyse the ancient history of India. How the facts in Indian history have been tweaked to conform with 'Marxist ideas' which are held as gospel truths by our much revered historians is the basis on which author builds up the narrative. Also the idea that Hinduism as a unified religion came into ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Aug 19, 2014 Sailen Dutta rated it really liked it

Shelves: non-fiction, political

A brilliant book by Arun Shourie. Although first published in 1998, it is as relevant now as it was then. Shourie correctly nails the lies that the "eminent" Marxist Historians have been peddling through their hold on institutions as Indian Council of Historical Research (ICHR). He also exposes their doouble speak on matters relating to ancient India, the Islamic rule in India, and matters relating to Hinduism in general. This book is a must read for everyone who cares about our National ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Feb 21, 2016 Harjeet Singh rated it it was amazing

a really well researched work on how the historical and political discourse in India has been hijacked by the left leaning intellectuals. Also provides sound reasoning for the co-opting/alliance between left, congress and so called socialist parties. There is telling commentary on the reasons for rise of socialist movement and close resemblance between islam, marxism and the like ideologies. A must read for anyone interested in Understanding contemporary indian history and get more objective ...more

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jul 12, 2014 Mohit Sharma rated it really liked it

Good book. Shourie does present a lot of good factual data but sometimes he goes overboard with his own rhetoric. Although history is not something we should tamper with, I'm not really sure how prudent it is to teach young impressionable minds about hatred and violence which they bear no relation to.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

Jan 05, 2015 DBV Subbarao rated it really liked it

Shelves: history

Well researched. The approach used by the left wing academics on fabricating history is well presented. Interestingly, there is a warning to the right wing intellectuals not to repeat the follies of their left wing predecessors. Although the book is well written, it becomes a bit of n "overload" at times. Worth a read , if Indian History is of interest.

flag 2 likes · Like · see review

May 31, 2017 Anoop Pattat rated it it was amazing

A must read to those who wonder how the left liberal intelligentsia held complete monopoly on the academia and consequently the thought process of an entire nation . Especially at this time when they feel they are being challenged and are resorting to fear mongering

flag 2 likes · Like · see review