Rating: -10 on a scale of -15 to +5.
I doubt that anyone will read this. Before I begin, I will step away to the YouTube. This review made possible by - Doctor Who/They Break My Heart, Red Glasgow, National Centre for Military Intelligence, Agro Squirrel Narrates, Welcome to Ukraine, AllShorts, Kirkpattiecake, LuckyBlackCat, ScaredKetchup, Keffals, The Ritual Kitchen with Laura May, The Discriminating Gamer, Sam's Trains, Mr Zod, Naomi Brockwell TV,
RevolutionarythOt, A Lil Bit Mads, Reads with Rachel, Squire, Northern Narrowboaters, Outlaw Bookseller, Lena Down Under, May's Narrowboat Life, Cruising Crafts, Boat Time, Sailing Melody, Fit 2B Read, Terrible Writing Advice, Kyiv Post, Lily Simpson, Reads With Rachel,
Geo Girl, Novara Media, Combat Veteran News, Myocore, Mythology and Fiction Explained, With Olivia, Abney Park, Broken Peach, CBC News, Gingers are Black, Stanzi, FAFO, Matriarchetype, The Juice Media, Honest Political Ads, Fun Size Reader, KernowDamo, Ivie Anita, Britta Bohler, Fundie Fridays, Alysotherlife,
Central Crossing, Military History Visualised, Hoots, PPR Global, Sci-Fi Scavenger, Cappy Army, Wes O'Donnell, Democratic Penguin Republic, Scallydandling About the Books, Amie's Literary Empire, Dr Ben Miles, Brandon Talks, Nikki's Book Nook, Interesting Times,
Naughty Nana DUZ, KernowDamo, Postmodern Jukebox, Anton Petrov, Cambrian Chronicles, The Great War, Queen Penguin, Dark Brandon, Some More News, Roisin's Reading, Tale Foundry, Nikki Carreon,
Fran Blanche, Kaz Rowe, Yarmak, ScaredKetchup, fig tree, Riverboat Jack, Bart's Book Space, Weirdo Book Club, Book Furnace, Broken Peach, Willow Talks Books, Riverboat Jack, Leena Norms, ATP Geopolitics,Reese Waters, Lurie Daniel Favors,
The Shogunate, Prime of Midlife, Shitty Book Club, Read Rant Review, Eva Schubert, What Vivi did next, Yoyomi, Think Ukraine, Jean's Thoughts, The Military Show, Owen Jones, Brigitte Empire, Michael Lambert, Red Pen, Dana Andersen, Amodelwhosread, Clouds and Sky, Camper Vibe, Acollierastro, Zoe Bee.
I saw an idiot who whilst insulting a very engaging essayist, complain to her that I list other trans creators. The Snowflake (nasty, cowardly, poorly socialised US baby-man) epidemic continues unabated. A trigger warning then.
The channels I list include the miniatures painter, lesbian, Scottish, archaeologist, WOC, anarchist, cis, theoretical physicist, farmer, tall, bi, fashion historian, German, sewist, chess player, mathematician, asexual, socialist, red haired, engineer, intersex, primatologist, trans, Canadian, military historian, blond, queer, architect, model builder, boater, physically challenged, het, science educator, lumber yard worker, paleontologist, Bahamian, military boardgamer, pensioner, economist, political historian and other creators known as Women.
Almost as dangerous are the channels with communist, Ugandan, archaeologist, other BIPOC, model builder, archaeologist, Welsh, chemist, astrophysicist, wood worker, other LGBTQ+, miniatures landscape builder, other fashion historian, Danish, SciFi commentator, game historian, anthropologist, boat restorer, New Zealander, zoologist, neurodivergent, miniatures wargamer, writer, botanist, train hobbyist, zoologist, Australian, book reviewer and other creators known (outside the US) Human Beings.
If the voices persist, I recommend emergency pastoral counselling and/or adopting a hobby (not to include assaulting women, which is mental illness) and/or develop a new skill, such as reading.
My feelings towards these mental members are similar to those of the 13 Ukrainian marines defending Snake Island, when their surrender was demanded by the Russian navy. Their response was "Russian warship, go f@ck yourself". Glory to Ukraine. Glory to the Heroes. Crimea is Ukraine.
Unto the book, dear friends. Once more. The typical romantasy, troubled girl meets very bad man, the S.A. is done and the love now exists. For character description only sexual identity, hotness, bods and promises of rough sex are the extent. This includes casting women as pick me girlies or emotionally stunted mean girls.
Men are described as various models of hot which transcends any other factor in a main character's view of the male's usually terrifying anti-social personality.
The killer vampire wishes to "date" her, which does not fit this world. Romance in similar societies do not include dating but do include S.A., kidnapping for a period, perhaps murder of the victim.
The main character's roommate is the best friend with whom she has shared her past. She also encourages the MC to do the sex with the vampire assassin.
I bailed at 84%.
Romance genre average writing level is eleven years old but is marketed to adults. This type of story normalised lack of editing, uneven prose, contrivance as plot driver, paper thin background universe, no character development, dialogue to make a writing instructor cry, misogyny, ableism, racism and plot hole.
In all fairness low end US science fiction is more badly written with much the same flaws, insane female representation, toxic masculinity as the main character model and a writing level of perhaps ten years old.
I suspect that fans come away dissatisfied more often than not. A steady diet of these will affect imagination and critical thinking.
I stumbled upon YouTube and then BookTube sometime after. The book and writing channels 😍 host reader communities who challenge current fiction norms. These are curious, thoughtful readers interested in all aspects of the bookish world. They are far different environments to that of Goodreads.
Erotica has historically made interesting reading, especially in granting an insight into the society which produced it. Smut can be highly entertaining and is certainly good for the soul. Print porn can be well written and be much more exciting as a result.
Science fiction from its inception was a description and a criticism of society. Other pasts and possible futures are contrasted with the current social reality. These are the insights which define the genre.
It believe that this trend of the poorly written child's story is a reflection of consumer society. Book Tubers also discuss the topic.
Unlimited and Goodreads drove me away for the first time, from print entirely two years or so ago. By immersing myself in my previously favourite writers and books, I was able to return to print fiction.
A stepaway have bern earned. This next made possible by channels Doctor Who\Be Kind, Guard the Leaf, Lauren the Mortician, Ship Happens, Betty on a Boat, Chem Thug, Octopus Lady, Extinct Zoo, Codeolences, Sabine Hossenfelder, Nerdy Kathi, HIstory of Everything, North of MAGA, Twinshangout, Seizure Girl, Slaggy Book Club,
Feral Historian, Hat Historian, Pinsent Tailoring, Katie Phang, Mancave Models UK, A Different Bias, Novara Media, Katy Montgomerie, No Justice, Patrick(H)Willem, Origins Explained, Julia McCoy, Heather Cox Richardson, Hypohistericalhistory, Modern Historians, Mix -Psychobitches, Barry's Economics, Claus Kellerman POV,
Cheeto, Lisandra Vazquez, Tanya Fiona, Lore Saga AI, Red Viburnam Song, Lorebrary, Amanda's Mild Takes, Graham Scheper Hannah Fry, Brio Shorts, JimmyTheGiant, Deerstalker Pictures, Graham Norton Show, Canadian WW2 Tales, Child Free Cat Lady Jade, Dreamloop Cinema, Global Updates with Sosan, Harry Sisson, Queen Coke Francis.
Consider treating this as hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads discourse does not exist, as the site has two purposes. The first is creation of the consensus regarding low quality writing. The second is to strengthen the Amazon drive towards monopoly.
As example, I wrote a short six or seven sentence negative review of Powers of the Earth by Travis Corcoran. I glanced at his other books which are equally bad.
The story is the tale of a heroic rich twat attempting to overthrow the US government with aid of the military in order that he not pay taxes. It was originally blurbed as similar to a Heinlein classic but is instead a poor retelling of "Atlas Shrugged" set on the moon.
This and similar books are unfortunately a large percentage of Unlimited science fiction. I, a communist found the book and its fellows dangerous, unhealthy and now prophetic.
The writer Travis Corcoran self-described as veteran, proud libertarian (now anarcho capitalist without millions), employee of an unnamed US agency, advocate for the return of chattel slavery (popular US position with current prison labour to be supplemented by forced labour prisons for the unhoused, including van and RV residents. Given US history, current governmental pronouncements and lack of outcry generational enslavement is on the cards), admirer of Putin (other US employees had questions of that last).
My opinion incensed Travis and six fellow patriots. They had no good things to say about that sad book but spent something like a year in comments. It was no surprise that none except the writer had shelved the book, as this was common among stream commenter of my other reviews.
They generously offered insights into my lack of intelligence, evils of socialism, correct understanding of the European males creation of all history, the social good that is slavery past and present, the narcissism inherent in my refusal to engage and more of the usual.
My usual responses over several years were "Have a good day then", "Am glad to have directed you to a book of your liking" and similar. That review forced me to change any response to the "American" idiom. It worked a treat.
Claes Rees Jr aka cgr710 now ka Clayton R Jesse Jr (who no longer identifies as Nazi) wrote a final comment. He after referencing the contents of my last message exchange with a Goodreads friend, declared that They had won (?).
They had launched a veritable flood of truly vile misogynistic, racist, anti-LGBTQI+ and similar comments against apparently every female creator, I mentioned. It continues still.
The Oxford astrophysicist physicist, the canal boating couple, the midteen boater and her mother, games hobbyist, botanist and other creators were unimpressed.
The world's overabundance of ugliness was increased and They had delivered a perfect self-portrait of the snowflake (vicious, cowardly, lacking self-awareness US man-child) to a multinational audience. This must have been Victory.
Goodreads discourse is more energetic than was expected. The above was more wide ranging and especially vicious but otherwise a common reaction to my reviews.
I need to cleanse the spirit for a bit after reliving the above. This next made possible by YouTube Doctor Who \Never Cruel or Cowardly, Lexi aka NewlyNova, Anna from Ukraine, Kyiv Independent, Skip Intro, Ember Green, Books with Brittany, G K Reads, Jadyn Rylee, Sideprojects, SciFi Odyssey, Elena Taber, Olly Richards, Ship Happens, The Narrowboat that James Built, Ben and Emily,
Lynn Saga, Camper Vibe, Knitting Cult Lady, Ukraine Matters, Leeja Miller, Katy Montgomerie, Slaggy Book Club, The Skaldic Bard, Hildegard von Bingin, The Moody Reader, The New Enlightenment with Ashley, Olive's Book Nook, Julia Galef, According to Alina, Caelan Conrad,
The Creative Penn, Hetty and the Jazzalato Band, Kayla Kamper, The EzeeeKat, Bizarre Beasts, Mythology and Fiction Explained, KrimsonRogue. Ash L G., Bernadette Banner, Anton Petrov, Ben Miller, Kat Abughazaleh, Jake Broe, Kyiv Post, Turn Left,
Joe Blogs, The Bitchuation Room, The Sword and the Pen, Dungeon Dad, Dungeons and Discourse, Grungeon Master, Adele Marie, Alina Gingertail, HonestlySophie, Red Viburnam Song, The Juice Media, Mercado Media, Eckharts Ladder,
Supertanskiii, Liz Webster, Jen the Librarian, Anka Daily News, Belle of the Ranch, Book Furnace, The_Miracle_Aligner, Parkrose Permaculture, Book Belle.
Ominous music begins. 😊 The comment gangs are endemic on this site. Their activities extend beyond the uncouth to include the doxxing, stalking, threatening, hacking and more.
Amazon have not acknowledged any incident nor disciplined mental members, punished writers who encourage Them or dismissed employees who enable either.
Kindle/Goodreads gave over my sparse message history to this psychotic crowd. This enabled a request through Pine Gap Centre that Australian Intelligence interrogate the one friend whom I occasionally messaged. That attempt at my personal history failed.
Amazon only became concerned as we publicised that event. With no acknowledgement of Their criminal activity, my page format and options were restored to normal, I am now Allowed to view other's reviews, comments are masked, periodic Kindle interruption of access to internet or services ended and other harassment reversed.
Reads with Rachel had an unfortunate Goodreads experience. She wrote a review critical of anti-human elements of a book. Goodreads labelled it "Hate Speech" and removed it. They threatened to remove her membership. I experienced the same several years ago, They did not try it twice. As is customary in the US, racist, misogynistic, ableist and other anti-human speech or writing is acceptable but addressing them is "Hate Speech".
After uploading her review to her channel, she received her first Goodreads commenter, who suggested that she "should die". US free speech is a marvel.
Fit Danielle Reads also had an unsettling Anazon experience. When she contacted customer service about an obvious double billing error, she was handled badly. When Amex forced corrected billing, she was denied access to her cloud library and her Kindle internet access denied, until she provided a second payment.
Recently a seventh ex-employee of EBay was sentenced for harassment of a couple whose small ecommerce channel had been deemed unkind to EBay. The couple were awarded millions and the ex-employee had been the EBay Chief of Global Security or some such. Given the protection afforded US data firms, the above are things to think about.
Any temporary immunity you might currently enjoy, rests on the whims of a certain type of member and Goodreads employee. Amazon have embedded the cowardly cruelty which is a historical bedrock of US culture.
I suggest precautions. Remove all personal information from profile and avoid messaging. Remove the lurker, those friends who never post. They are likely monitors for gangs or employee dummies, not admirers.
Given the Goodreads penchant for Altering customer pages, the screenshot of the odd, ugly or threatening are invaluable. These should suffice.
Kindle are more serious. Do Not use Kindle Files, Email, Contacts or Calendar. Amazon employees Sign Into customer email addresses without permission or notice. Make of that what you will.
Do Not "purchase" books, as you own only the device and if Kindle that is conditional. Amazon may delete or deny access to cloud stored titles at whim. If already purchased, download all titles immediately. I made the mistake of purchasing several hundred titles as my contempt for Unlimited titles increased. There are BooKTubers to suggest alternative ebook and tablet vendors, as well as alternatives to ebook purchase.
Sadly there are BookTubers who pooh pooh Evil Amazon behaviour. I avoid Amazon shills and minions.
All Silk searches should be innocuous and non-critical.
To implement the above cost nothing, to not might well do. These animals, members and employees alike embrace no non-Randian morality, are the best of them fascist sympathisers and US patriots with all that implies. Ominous music ends. 😊
Be careful and may we all enjoy Good Reading. 🤗
Some of my favourite channels.
Bobbing Along, The Queer Kiwi, TVP News, Nicole Chilaka-Ukpo, Lily Simpson, AllShorts, Honest Government Ads, Anna Cramling, The Gaze, Tom Powell Jr, SciFi Odyssey, Chess Vibes, J. Draper, ThatDaneshGuy,
UATV English, Think Ukraine, What Rae Reads, Prime of Midlife, Cruising Alba, World Science Festival, Science Insanity, The Kavernacle, Silicon Curtain, Cruising Crafts, Bart's Book Space, Wurld, Bookpilled, Ponderful, Octopus Lady, Maggie Mae Fish,
The Russian Dude, Media Death Cult, Lily Alexandre, Lilly's Life, Evie Lupine, Michael Lambert, Dark side of Russia, Eileen, Leena Norms, LydLoves, Jessie Gender, Time Tinkerer, Viva La Dirt League, Dominic Noble, Megalithhunter, Karolina Zebrowska,
Sami and Books, Ukraine Calling, Amanda Rae, Zoe Baker, Yanis Varoufakis, Ukraine News TV, The British Museum, JohnTheDuncan, Renegade Cut, Library Ladder, SandRhoman History, France 24, Alexa Donne, Verilybitchie, Savy Writes Books, Sci-Fi Odyssey, Physics Girl, Gary's Economics, Mr Newberger's AI Funnies,
Engineering with Rosie, Historian's Craft, Dungeons and Discourse, Ministry of Miniatures, Supertanskiii, Natasha's Adventures, The Bands of HM Royal Marines, DW News, NFKRZ, Book Furnace, Widebeam and Wellingtons, Sanctioned Ivan, Steve Shives, Certifiably Ingame.
I wish you a glorious morning, a refreshing afternoon, a pleasant evening, a wonderful night and May we all continue learning.
Denial of Evil, is Complicity.
A reminder to self