3.5 stars rounded up to 4 for GR.
A Season 5 set novel!!
Finally made it to where Paige is a redhead and Cole is now a demon again on the outs with Phoebe.
Even if these novels aren't canon that means that Piper is pregnant!!
Phoebe is working on her Ask Phoebe column when Cole shows up with mochas and uses his newfound powers to stop it from staining Phoebe's new top. Nearby, a fellow colleague at the Bay Mirror spills his own beverage all over the floor while on the phone using a headset.
Phoebe blames it as a side effect from Cole, former demon and Source of All Evil, having gathered so many powers from the Demonic Wasteland. Cole is trying so hard to win Phoebe back because the magic may come from evil, but he isn't. Once Cole leaves inside Phoebe's office by shimmering out, a suspicious way to leave when he walked in through the door, she tries to write her new column but fails.
Leaving, Phoebe slips on the spill and gets a premonition of the reporter coming across a demon ceremony at the docks and being blasted by a fireball just by grabbing his headset. Two interns witness this, but Phoebe brushes the vision off as a sugar low and goes to inform her sisters.
The two interns, however, are actually different demons setting up Phoebe so she and her sisters can vanquish an enemy clan. They are bound to not speak their true names, so they go by Mr. Tremble and Mr. Sigh, and it seems they want to get back at Cole for his distant past as Belthazor, his original demon half.
Piper and Leo are at P3 hosting a 1940s night, but it isn't as hopping as Piper hoped. It seems just right for Leo since he was human back in the 1940s before being killed as a medic in WWII.
They go to find Paige who is taking a genealogy class at Berkley but moved to the library when a handsome classmate named Ben said he could teach her better than the professor. Using the computer, Ben finds an ancestor from Paige's adopted father's family who was an actress back in the late 1930s/early 1940s named Penny Day Matthews.
The woman bears a striking redheaded resemblance to Paige, seeing as she was born a brunette like her sisters. Ben was taking the class because he's adopted too and sparks fly but fizzle (for the moment) when Piper, Leo and Phoebe arrive.
At the dock, The Charmed Ones are ready to fight but find that Cole has been following Phoebe to protect her. Leo is caught by one of the intern demons to keep from protecting them and Cole's powers start creating some sort of vortex as The Charmed Ones chant a Power of Three spell, unable to stop. When Leo finds a way to escape, he returns just in time to see all of them sucked inside the portal.
Leo is left in present time, distraught, while the others are sent back to 1942 Hollywood!
It is WWII era, and the girls still have their powers but unfortunately, Cole doesn't have his. Even though he was a demon in 1942, a witch cursed him by stripping his powers which he eventually got back. Using his knowledge, Cole somehow finds money to get a hotel room for the girls and they resort to selling some of their jewelry to buy new clothes to fit in with the time period since they have no idea how they can get home...they'll need jobs.
Piper finds a job waitressing while Cole stays at the hotel with Paige, who suffered a head injury, and Phoebe is almost ready to take a waitress job until she notices the necklace of a young woman sitting near her. It has a Wiccan symbol, and Phoebe finds herself talking to out-of-town girl Chloe from the Midwest going for a job at the small movie studio, Orion Pictures.
They both get jobs in the wardrobe department and Phoebe is stunned to meet Penny Day Matthews and watch her film a movie. It seems that demons are going around shaking down local businesses as if they were the Mafia and the movie studio is one of them which doesn't sit well with Penny, so she tells Chloe she is planning on leaving.
That is when Cole suggests that Paige can pose as Penny and try to infiltrate the underground ring once she starts feeling better. With Chloe and Phoebe's help, Paige has no trouble slipping into the role of a Hollywood starlet and even begins flirting with the head of the demon's henchmen, going by the name of Ned from Chicago.
Paige, of course, doesn't know this at first and "Ned" and "Penny" are both playing a dangerous game.
Despite some Power of Three/Charmed One moments, Phoebe mostly finds herself dealing with Cole being human again yet tied into the demon underground and then learning he has business with another witch named Theda, yet she may be the same witch who cursed him. Lots of UST that brings to mind those films with Hepburn and Tracy.
Piper's biggest dilemma is that this is the period in time when Leo was still alive and human. His tales of 1940s Hollywood and the stars and the places they frequented are always with Piper and she knows that soon, Leo will be shipped off.
The U.S. has just been thrust into the war after Pearl Harbor so Piper wonders if she can catch a glimpse of him at The Brown Derby and see if their magic is still there. It plays off like a girl having a crush on a boy from afar for so long that you know everything about them but to try and talk to them is like having a mouthful of sawdust and your heart beating like a jackhammer in your chest.
Or...so I've been told. Not having been through anything like that at all you know.
Luck Be a Lady is a book that would have made a good Charmed episode. Things work out with the foursome finding a magical way back home and everything works out fine for Piper being reunited with Leo and Paige giving Ben a call. The bitter side of the bittersweet ending is that Cole has his powers back and Phoebe has to tell him that it can't work out between them.