Paper Families: Identity, Immigration Administration, and Chinese Exclusion

Politics, History, and Culture

by Estelle T. Lau

The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 made the Chinese the first immigrant group officially excluded from the United States. In Paper Families , Estelle T. Lau demonstrates how exclusion affected Chinese American communities and initiated the development of restrictive U.S. immigration policies and practices. Through the enforcement of the Exclusion Act and subsequent legislation, the U.S. immigration service developed new forms of record keeping and identification practices. Meanwhile, Chinese Americans took advantage of the system’s children of U.S. citizens were granted automatic eligibility for immigration. The result was an elaborate system of “paper families,” in which U.S. citizens of Chinese descent claimed fictive, or “paper,” children who could then use their kinship status as a basis for entry into the United States. This subterfuge necessitated the creation of “crib sheets” outlining genealogies and providing village maps and other information that could be used during immigration processing. Drawing on these documents as well as immigration case files, legislative materials, and transcripts of interviews and court proceedings, Lau reveals immigration as an interactive process. Chinese immigrants and their U.S. families were subject to regulation and surveillance, but they also manipulated and thwarted those regulations, forcing the U.S. government to adapt its practices and policies. Lau points out that the Exclusion Acts and the pseudo-familial structures that emerged in response have had lasting effects on Chinese American identity. She concludes with a look at exclusion’s legacy, including the Confession Program of the 1960s that coerced people into divulging the names of paper family members and efforts made by Chinese American communities to recover their lost family histories.

Genres: Asian Literature, Nonfiction

232 pages, Paperback

First published February 1, 2006

About the author

Estelle T. Lau is a practicing attorney and an independent scholar. She has a doctorate in sociology from the University of Chicago and a law degree from Harvard University.

Reviews

[Ian Martyn · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lau presents a detailed look into the phenomenon of the paper family. Although I had a passing familiarity of the concept, I didn't know all of the details about it. Lau clears up any misconceptions about the paper family, providing a detailed history of not only paper families themselves but the legislation that led to their creation. Lau explores all aspects of the paper family, and her attention to detail here is really impressive. I was a little less clear about the chapter-based organization of the information, but I feel as though she was still able to disseminate the information in a clear manner. Definitely worth a read, especially for those interested in history.