Read for SPFBO, this is only my personal opinion - group verdict might wary widely. 🔥
3,5* rounded up
The "Darkness" in the title definitely is well deserved. This book is rather brutal and graphic in a lot of places. Plenty of swearing as well. I would not put it in the grimdark variety, but definitely in the dark fantasy section.
I loved seeing three siblings as central characters, as I always enjoy relationships that are not based in romance. The constant banter between them, padded by absolutely loyalty was a nice change of pace, and made up for other characters that felt a bit flat for me.
There is some romance and a few steamy scenes, but it's a small amount, and actually rather well written. Even I, who usually detest most romance and sex in my fantasy books, didn't mind it.
The two actual main characters are bitter enemies, but actually they are cute from the same sort of wood, as we'd say in Germany. They are very similar, and both of them are far away from being good, or a hero. I do like my characters flawed and on the grey side, but at times I just wished they'd just off each other and be done...
The emotional turmoil we're told about didn't really reflect well in the characters, and while we're told how bad it is, they actually seem to be rather stoic instead. So you see why the sibling constellation had to make up for quite a bit.
The plot felt a bit meandering here and there, and a constant back and forth between now, earlier, now, even, earlier and so on didn't always work perfectly. Some of the switched felt fluent, others grinded a bit. However there was enough action and interactions to keep me interested all the way though anyway.
I'm not really sure how I feel about the ending either. I liked the underlying mystery of the world's magic, and the new direction. Some things just felt a bit over the top again.
Over all this was an interesting read that kept me well entertained all the way through.