I kept debating how to rate this book because it made me feel so many things ..Unfortunately they weren’t all positive and there will be ranting with heavy spoilers. The first 30% were a 5 stars read for me , at 60% it dropped at 4 stars and by 70% I was sure it was a 3 stars read. It went up a bit towards the end again because I was very satisfied with that particular ending.
First of all, the writing is excellent,very engaging ;the story flows and the pages fly. I loved Alexei from the first moment. I loved his uniqueness, his solitude and I hurt for him. I loved being in his head much more than in Ben’s. Ben was ok too , I guess but he wasn’t flashed out as well as Alexei, he was rather bland and cheesy. And what bothered me the most was that he was also a big fat liar the entire book. He kept his sexuality hidden,and I understand that you’re not obligated to out yourself when you don’t feel like it but I think keeping it a secret for almost 40% of the book was kind of an asshole move. A vulnerable gay guy , rejected by his family for being gay has the guts to come out to you , to trust you with it and you keep your mouth shut like a weasel and watch him struggle with the guilt for feeling attracted to a straight guy. Asshole move as I said . (No, I don’t care about his reasons). Not only that but he was also quite insensitive.He thrusted Alexei into his family , into his life and he was so ecstatic to be home that he didn’t even stop to ask him if he was ok. Also he hadn’t told him anything about his ex boyfriends , he just took Alexei to see his friends where he had to stay there and listen to said friends calling Ben a slut. Then you leave him alone to go wipe your sister’s tears because she was dumped. He was so weird like ..wtf? You were only gone 2 freaking months,dude , chill the fuck out ! I know you’re mama’s boy but come on, you’re 30, how about you cut that umbilical cord ,eh?
The total lack of communication was what ruined the book for me. Ben received that work offer and he didn’t say a word to Alexei and of course what made up his mind to not go back with Alexei wasn’t even his work nor Alexei , it was again the need to hold his sister’s hand while she went to college. 🙄 Carolina this and Carolina that.. Maybe the author didn’t get the memo but we really don’t give a fuck about Carolina! He sprung the news that he won’t go back with Alexei just like that , with barely an explanation. Wait, no, he did propose a pity date if Alexei was willing. I would have done exactly what Alexei did.
And after all that , when he finally decided to communicate he wrote letters that he didn’t even send. Everything that he should have talked with Alexei he said it in unsend letters. I know that Alexei had his fault too but he needed somebody to love him, to fight for him while Ben put his family, his sister, his plumber and the town’s priest before Alexei. And then he was shocked that Alexei left 🙄 This is where the book became a 3 stars. Also Ben’s friends were OTT and kind of rude .
The ending, the fact that Ben chose to cut the above-mentioned umbilical cord and came to live with Alexei was nice and right (I felt vindicated lol) . So, even though the end was good and satisfying I still can’t make myself to give more than 3 stars to this book. There were a lot of beautiful moments and it is quite a good book but despite the sweetness and the sappiness I found the romance to be …lacking. After the first wonderful 30% I expected mature characters , I expected that Alexei’s inexperience and his inability to communicate to be compensated by Ben’s experience, patience and love . Well, what I I got was a mamma’s boy who was even more incapable than Alexei.