There were three parts to this book:
The dark boring part, the dark annoying part and the dark confusing part.
OK, there was a part in the middle of that which was alright, when she was at the training place for Silvers, but that was relatively short.
OK, so picking up this book was a bit of a salute to my younger, horse-obsessed self. Silverhorse. The name jumped out and the small part of me that still squeals when anything horse-related comes up was awakened, and I grabbed the book without even really looking at it, then borrowed it and walked out of the library.
Ehh, big mistake.
First let me explain what I mean by 'dark'. I don't mean gruesome or whatever. I just mean the whole thing lacked any brightness or humour. You can imagine it raining the whole time, without any sunshine. There were no good moments, scenes that make you smile. So that made the whole thing not very enjoyable.
So we start off with Dark Boring Part. Kat lives in an inn with mother, siblings and stepfather (I do admit that the relationship between Kat and her step-father was somewhat interesting). Boring stuff happens. Something vague about a silver horse. Then, out of the blue Kat's mother randomly sends her away. Which brings us to Dark Annoying Part.
DAP was annoying for two main reasons. One was that it had no impact on the story, and was just not neccessary. It was a waste of my time to even read this part. The other reason was that this was where Kat's temper really came into play.
And it was the most bloody annoying thing to read.
She was moaning and complaining about how bad her life was, but it was her stupid fault for losing her temper!! Even small things that no normal person would think twice about seemed to be the greatest insult in history to Kat. It was overly done and it just annoyed me to think that the author actually thought that doing such a thing would help the story along. If the bad temper wasn't quite so bad, and if Kat had personality traits OTHER THAN temper, then maybe. But her temper defined her whole being and it annoyed me.
So in between this Annoying part and the Confusing part, there was a part which was actually OK. It was still a little pointless, but OK.
Then we reach Dark Confusing Part. This is confusing because
A) Kat gets kicked out of the Academy for no real good reason and the whole chapter where she's 'drunk' wasn't really properly explained.
B) After that, the whole thing is just random.
There are two things that would have made this better. If the whole 'World of Breda' thing was at the start, so we understood that only women could own land, and the whole 'family' thing and all that, instead of guessing for the first half and not comprehending what was going on.
And if it was more about the Silverhorses! For crying out loud, I only picked this book up for the horses part of it!! And only about five pages were dedicated to them. Either call your book something else (Kat-Is-An-Annoying-Protagonist) or actually make it about horses!!