A major let down. 1.7 stars.
I am not an ARC reader, nor do I know the author. Just a guy who read this book and now have something to say about it. This won't be a SparkNotes story summery like some reviews out there. Those aren't reviews. This will be how I really felt about this book.
I'm tired of reading shitty books about shitty people doing shitty things and the author expecting me to like and believe in the characters by the end. It's not fun. It's not why I read. It does not make for a good or memorable book.
This was almost a DNF. It by all rights should have been but I was already 300 pages and I said just finish it so I can give a full review. There are some spoilers ahead, trying to be vague to keep them from being outright spoilers but I gotta say what I can in order for this to make sense.
Pros.
Like most of the reviews for Flames of Mira, I will say the world building is decent on its face. Unhabitable surface so everyone and everything lives underground. Cool start. Cities built from the bottom up, alright makes sense.
Cool cover art??? Sure, trying to find pros here.
Magic system is interesting in principle.
Cons.
Buckle up.
Characters.
Every character in this book is a piece of shit and does not act how actual people will act, even in the situations they are in. Characters either go on and on about how amazing they think they or another character are when all evidence is to the contrary. A person of high standing in an organization just abandons his post for the flimsiest of reasons. Imagine your Pastor, Boss, Mayor, whatever person in charge of an organization with major responsibilities just flipping deuces one day and going I'll be back maybe someday because this acquaintance of mine asked me to, bye. And then getting little to no actual screentime except to be a source of friction for the MC. Eyerollingly bad. This is weak character building. They are the weakest part of the story and its not even close.
Examples
Jakar/Ig is your MC. He is as interesting as a fart in the breeze and is just as easily swayed. Basically, a puppet whose ownership is as easily transferred as just saying a Word (if you have read it, you know what I am talking about) The attempts to make him sympathetic fall flat on their face and is obviously there for a sense of tension and to try and keep you interested in following his story. He can control elements like some of the vague phantom others in the world that by all rights would not have let this story get off the ground if they are as powerful as the author makes them out to be. Seriously, half of the book wouldn't exist if the people with magical powers stopped things when they initially start. Why am I saying this? Because the author set up this precedent in the book itself. It's in the world's history and yet they are amazingly absent until the final FINAL few chapters and are disposed of as easily as a tissue during flu season. Jakar fights one of these with a fucking stab wound to the chest! Broken bones. And he is all just meh whateves, lets just ride this ice shelf to the bottom. There are things you think are cool, then there is this book. There are no stakes. People get away with whatever, just as long as the plot can move forward.
Efadora. Fifteen and spunky. A girl who won't be caged and can do anything and blah blah blah modern young adult fiction tropes blah blah. This is your other view into this world ladies and gentlemen. I ended up just skimming every chapter from her point of view because I just stopped caring. She idolizes her sister (Who is the weakest character in this book. We'll get to her soon.) until, you know, she doesn't even though she is aware of how terrible of a person she is but no she is also a friend of the common folk (no proof of this is given, just a nickname and hearsay) so she is good, and awesome, and cool, and she will be just like her. Yawn. Even gets a ride off into the sunset moment.
Sara. She has almost as much page time as the other MCs and you would think with that amount of time, she would be a fully fleshed out and complex and... nope. Two dimensional and this just there to be a foil for Jakar. She makes the dumbest decisions that are there to move the plot along and to give Jakar something to fight against. She is easy EASY on betrayers but can mobilize an army of sleezy underworld thugs because (checks notes) reasons. Because she is apparently the champion of the people (again this is never shown just alluded to.) She is also just as wishy washy of a character as Jakar. Does one thing, says something contrary. Has a goal, drops it like a hot plate. Wants power, does nothing with it. She is just there for the edge. She is just there.
Other characters either aren't memorable, convenient for the plot, just exist to validate the action of the mains.
Other issues.
For a world so inhospitable its also super convenient and has everything anyone could ever want as long as you live near the right lake or convenient grove of plant life. Even the big bad beasts talked about only show up for one nighttime fight.
Exposition let's begin. Exposition on a whim. While the world building is decent its not shown well enough the characters have to hold the readers hand through instead of naturally adding it to the story. Characters just mind dump or explain something that characters in that world would already know. There is an attempt at language building that is just super distracting. A translation usually follows or is said out loud right after.
The magic system, while interesting is also really boring in practice. Same with the religions of the world. Wooo, dark cultists and gods straight out of Lovecraft, wooo. A religion that is so against fighting that they literally are in every major engagement but are also so torn about it that it has to be said every time they do. But trust me, they're the good guys. They only fight the bads when it's obvious a character would just get his/her ass handed to them otherwise.
There's more but those are the main cons and I think I made my point.
I was so excited by this book. I really wanted to like. Pulled it right off the shelf at the store. Bought it shortly thereafter and started reading that night. The author's a local. I want to support my local writers. It had an interesting premise. Decent reviews. There was everything going for this book in my mind until I opened the front cover and got after.
By two hundred pages I was bored and willing to give this a three-star review. By three hundred, I was an inch away from DNF'ing. By four hundred I was skimming just to finish. Trust me, I didn't miss much. Even though I rushed the end I think the author did too. One of the weakest court scenes I have ever read. Convenient battles and characters just showing up. Every character seemed to not care anymore. It felt like the author knew he had to wrap the story up and it shows.
There will inevitably be a sequel. I won't be reading it. My local bookstore takes books in exchange for credit. Let's go get another book and try again.