The Ring Specific Review: This book is where the downfall of the series truly began for me. The main payoff of the first book was quickly negated within the first chapters of this book. It also introduced the "love" interest that would come to motivate Dain and did so badly. It did continue to flesh out the only good character in the series, Gavril. But again it failed to re-immerse me in any of the magical elements I know were present in the world. The whole book felt like a side story that could have taken up only a few chapters and still gave me as much info and story building the entire book did. Also it finally teased one of the three main artifacts but then took all that back.
The Sword , The Ring, The Chalice Review: This series felt like a bit of a wasted read. There was no pay off in the end. The "love story" that made up much of the motivation for Dain was so underdeveloped, felt ham-fisted, and failed to make me believe in it. Also there was such promise for a magical and mythology side of this series that was just abandoned quickly in the beginning and barely used throughout. For a supposed fantasy book it was more just a realistic middle ages style with little weight or attention given to its, I'll admit, interesting magic and fantasy side. In addition, as a Dain character Dain felt very passive, all his successes were handed to him via plot and never felt like he earned it. Dain himself had little to no character development. Even when the magic came into play it was more an ex machina style last minute undeserved save. As the main artifacts of the books, from which they get their names, were not major players in the series. They got very little attention and were not used to the extent that could have made them great. Even the "grand finale" of the series felt like it was written as an after thought, was rushed, and didn't make me feel any sense of closer. The only thing I think it did well was creating a character that was meant to be hated in Gavril. But even Gavril's characters ultimate end felt flawed; the series spent a lot of time articulating the rivalry between Gavril and Dain but in the end it came to little of import. picked up this series knowing it may be just a generic fantasy world but when I put it down I was still very disappointed