What do you think?
Rate this book
The Invisible Palestinians: The Hidden Struggle for Inclusion in Jewish Tel Aviv
Within the heart of the Jewish city of Tel Aviv, there is a hidden reality―Palestinians who work, study, and live as an unseen minority without access to equal urban citizenship.
Grounded in the everyday lives of Palestinians in Tel Aviv, The Invisible Palestinians offers an ethnographic critique of the city's self-proclaimed openness and liberalism. Andreas Hackl reveals that Palestinians' access to the social and economic opportunities afforded in Tel Aviv depends on keeping a low profile, which not only disrupts opportunities for true urban citizenship but also draws opposition from other Palestinians. By looking at the city from the perspective of this hidden urban minority, Hackl uncovers a critical opportunity to imagine and build a more inclusive and just future for Tel Aviv.
An important read, The Invisible Palestinians explores the marginalized urban presence of both Palestinian citizens of Israel and Palestinian laborers from the West Bank in this quintessential Jewish Israeli city. Hackl reveals a highly diverse Palestinian population that includes young people, manual workers and middle-class professionals, residents and commuters, students, artists, and activists, as well as members of an underground Palestinian LGBT community who carefully navigate their place in a city that refuses to recognize them.
Grounded in the everyday lives of Palestinians in Tel Aviv, The Invisible Palestinians offers an ethnographic critique of the city's self-proclaimed openness and liberalism. Andreas Hackl reveals that Palestinians' access to the social and economic opportunities afforded in Tel Aviv depends on keeping a low profile, which not only disrupts opportunities for true urban citizenship but also draws opposition from other Palestinians. By looking at the city from the perspective of this hidden urban minority, Hackl uncovers a critical opportunity to imagine and build a more inclusive and just future for Tel Aviv.
An important read, The Invisible Palestinians explores the marginalized urban presence of both Palestinian citizens of Israel and Palestinian laborers from the West Bank in this quintessential Jewish Israeli city. Hackl reveals a highly diverse Palestinian population that includes young people, manual workers and middle-class professionals, residents and commuters, students, artists, and activists, as well as members of an underground Palestinian LGBT community who carefully navigate their place in a city that refuses to recognize them.
230 pages, Hardcover
Published June 7, 2022
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
January 1, 2024
In "The Invisible Palestinians: The Hidden Struggle for Inclusion in Jewish Tel Aviv," the author embarks on a compelling exploration of the multifaceted dynamics within the city of Tel Aviv, seeking to expose the hidden struggles of Palestinian Citizens of Israel, a marginalized population in a city often regarded as a symbol of modernity and progressivism.
The strength of this book lies in its meticulous ethnographic research and intelligent analysis, shedding light on the systemic oppression faced by Palestinian Israelis in what the author consistently labels a “settler-colonial” context. The narrative skillfully navigates the catch-22 Palestinian Israelis face as second-class citizens lacking social and economic equality in their nation of Israel and in Tel Aviv, in particular. For example, they are often forbidden from speaking Arabic in their workplaces, face enormous obstacles in accessing higher education, and often are forced to live double identities to succeed in Tel Aviv while maintaining their cultural traditions and expectations from their traditional home communities. I also watched the movie the author recommended that shines a light on the topic, Bar Bahar (In Between), a 2016 movie by Maysaloun Hamoud, which furthered my understanding of the complex and contradicting loyalties Palestinian citizens of Israel are often forced to face. The movie and the author both provided essential and compelling narratives from women and those who identify as LGBTQIA as well.
However, the book has many notable omissions, including the insufficient exploration of the security fears of Jewish Israelis and how that impacts opportunities for Palestinians from the West Bank seeking work opportunities and Arab communities within Israel, particularly in the face of the existential threats posed by Islamist groups like Hamas. The omission is notable considering a substantial percentage of Palestinians support Islamist groups whose articulated goals are to destroy all Jews and eliminate Israel.
An additional absent narrative is the Jewish Israel perspective that Jews are also indigenous to Israel. Furthermore, the majority of arrivals in the 1900s were not in Israel as “settlers,” but as refugees, ethnically cleansed from countries across Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. The author creates a ‘Black” versus “white” dichotomy between Jewish and Arab Israelis, which erases the wide mosaic of skin colors among the Jewish citizens of Israel. This creates a perceptible gap in the narrative, leaving me to yearn for a more balanced examination of the systemic problems of equality and conflict. While acknowledging the inherent subjectivity of ethnographic work, the responsibility to present alternative perspectives is paramount, and this book falls short of providing Jewish perspectives.
In conclusion, "The Invisible Palestinians" offers a valuable perspective on the struggles faced by Palestinian Israelis in Jewish Tel Aviv. It is an important, informative, and thought-provoking read that can aid in change for peace and equality for all in Israel and Palestine. However, in my opinion, including more Jewish perspectives could aid reconciliation efforts to increase representation and equality. The solution must include peace and sovereignty for Jews and Palestinians alike. Overall, it is a commendable effort that invites readers to engage critically with the complexities of equality and representation within the context of Tel Aviv. I highly recommend it.
The strength of this book lies in its meticulous ethnographic research and intelligent analysis, shedding light on the systemic oppression faced by Palestinian Israelis in what the author consistently labels a “settler-colonial” context. The narrative skillfully navigates the catch-22 Palestinian Israelis face as second-class citizens lacking social and economic equality in their nation of Israel and in Tel Aviv, in particular. For example, they are often forbidden from speaking Arabic in their workplaces, face enormous obstacles in accessing higher education, and often are forced to live double identities to succeed in Tel Aviv while maintaining their cultural traditions and expectations from their traditional home communities. I also watched the movie the author recommended that shines a light on the topic, Bar Bahar (In Between), a 2016 movie by Maysaloun Hamoud, which furthered my understanding of the complex and contradicting loyalties Palestinian citizens of Israel are often forced to face. The movie and the author both provided essential and compelling narratives from women and those who identify as LGBTQIA as well.
However, the book has many notable omissions, including the insufficient exploration of the security fears of Jewish Israelis and how that impacts opportunities for Palestinians from the West Bank seeking work opportunities and Arab communities within Israel, particularly in the face of the existential threats posed by Islamist groups like Hamas. The omission is notable considering a substantial percentage of Palestinians support Islamist groups whose articulated goals are to destroy all Jews and eliminate Israel.
An additional absent narrative is the Jewish Israel perspective that Jews are also indigenous to Israel. Furthermore, the majority of arrivals in the 1900s were not in Israel as “settlers,” but as refugees, ethnically cleansed from countries across Europe, Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. The author creates a ‘Black” versus “white” dichotomy between Jewish and Arab Israelis, which erases the wide mosaic of skin colors among the Jewish citizens of Israel. This creates a perceptible gap in the narrative, leaving me to yearn for a more balanced examination of the systemic problems of equality and conflict. While acknowledging the inherent subjectivity of ethnographic work, the responsibility to present alternative perspectives is paramount, and this book falls short of providing Jewish perspectives.
In conclusion, "The Invisible Palestinians" offers a valuable perspective on the struggles faced by Palestinian Israelis in Jewish Tel Aviv. It is an important, informative, and thought-provoking read that can aid in change for peace and equality for all in Israel and Palestine. However, in my opinion, including more Jewish perspectives could aid reconciliation efforts to increase representation and equality. The solution must include peace and sovereignty for Jews and Palestinians alike. Overall, it is a commendable effort that invites readers to engage critically with the complexities of equality and representation within the context of Tel Aviv. I highly recommend it.
November 17, 2022
incredible ethnography that dives into the reality of Palestinians living in the supposed “safe” and “liberal haven” of Tel-Aviv under settler-colonialism and how their class, speech, and appearance dictates their “conditional inclusion” in the city. definitely a great starting point to learn about how Israel is a settler-colonial state and the realities of the violence and oppression that Palestinians face
January 31, 2024
Incredibly well written, based on a range of impactful truly a must read
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews