Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Warming Trend

Rate this book
Anidyr Bycall is frozen in her past, regretting words never spoken to the woman she loves and the one impulsive act that cost her all her dreams. Running from the courts of public and academic opinion in Fairbanks, she has landed in Key West. The nights are hot but she is colder than the glaciers she once explored.

Tending bar by night, she spends her days immersed in the research of her only remaining passion in the ice fields of Alaska. But trends may be improving when news from home hints that those she harmed may have moved on, and she can at least recover the papers and books she left behind. The respect and affection she once saw in Eve Cambra's eyes is gone beyond recall.

When a few innocent questions raise Ani's doubts about what really happened three years ago, she realizes she may have a chance to clear her name and reclaim her career. But there's no data to suggest that Eve has thawed and that the fire they once shared can be rekindled.

In this romantic story of the icy north, Karin Kallmaker explores the passion that can melt even a frozen heart.

264 pages, Paperback

First published April 13, 2009

22 people are currently reading
377 people want to read

About the author

Karin Kallmaker

81 books711 followers
Karin Kallmaker has been exclusively devoted to lesbian fiction since the publication of her first novel in 1989. As an author published by the storied Naiad Press, she worked with Barbara Grier and Donna McBride, and has been fortunate to be mentored by a number of editors, including Katherine V. Forrest.

In addition to multiple Lambda Literary Awards, she has been featured as a Stonewall Library and Archives Distinguished Author. Other accolades include the Ann Bannon Popular Choice and other awards for her writing, as well as the selection as a Trailblazer by the Golden Crown Literary Society. She is best known for novels such as Painted Moon, Simply the Best, Touchwood, The Kiss that Counted and Captain of Industry.

The California native is the mother of two and lives with her wife in the Bay Area. You can catch her blogs at Romance and Chocolate: https://kallmaker.com/blog/. Find her on social media by searching for "Kallmaker" - there's only one.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
206 (29%)
4 stars
304 (44%)
3 stars
133 (19%)
2 stars
37 (5%)
1 star
7 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
Profile Image for Kara.
720 reviews1,269 followers
April 9, 2020
“Warming Trend” features two likable MCs, one FANTASTIC secondary character, another enjoyable secondary character, a Disney cartoon villainess, terrific descriptions of Alaskan beauty, and wonderful narration by Abby Craden!

MCs Anidyr (Ana) and Eve are very likable, and they had/have huge chemistry between them. Ani’s university mentor Monica pretty much threw Ani under the bus during an incident, and Ani flees town fearing she’ll have to repay student loans, that Eve’s business will suffer if Ani stays, and worse of all - that Eve doesn’t ever want to talk to her again. Sigh….misunderstandings and miscommunication much?

Working at a cool (hey hey hey) bar in Key West, Florida, Ani is befriended by my favorite character in the book: the flirty, fit, vivacious, intelligent and insightful Lisa. Sigh….be still my beating heart!!!

Believing Eve has moved on, Ani decides to return to Alaska to collect a few belongings she’d left behind. With the bar closed for maintenance, Lisa accompanies her. Yep - assumptions that they’re a couple abound. There are some hilarious moments throughout the story, such as when Lisa insists on fixing Ani’s makeup and hair before Ani goes into the restaurant to see Eve. Also, when Lisa goes to Eve to ask about Tan, Eve decides Lisa is a force of nature!

The details of Alaska and glaciers were captivating. I don’t think the cold is for me! I did laugh at the efforts for four women to pee on a glacier….it reminded me of hiking Yosemite’s Back Country!!

The mystery of the notebook was pretty obvious, although there was a surprising twist in the details. I was unhappy that the villainess didn’t pay much of a price, but I was glad for the HEA for Eve and Ani, and for the HFN with Lisa and Tan! Fun story, great narration - get this audiobook!!!! 5*
Profile Image for Kexx.
2,329 reviews100 followers
March 18, 2022
The first chapter sets the tone: it feels too heavy, too depressing and even by the end of the book I couldn't shake off that cloak of despondency, of a wasted life.
Profile Image for Guerunche.
652 reviews35 followers
April 2, 2020
Karin Kallmaker's books take up an entire shelf in my house but I'd never purchased this one. And I'm so glad I was able to experience it for the first time with Abby Craden performing the work! For me, this was one of Kallmaker's best. It was a heartbreaking story and I was dying for it all to be made right. Without re-hashing the premise (since that is readily available) this is primarily about how making one split-second decision can completely change the course of your life - in this case, for the worse. Can you ever come back from that? How? I was so impressed with Kallmaker's research about the glaciers in Alaska. This book is not about geology per se, but MC Ani Bycall is a doctoral student studying to be a glacial geologist so her detailed knowledge made the read so much more real. The other thing that I loved about it was the depth of the love Ani and Eve felt for one another. They were soul mates. Soul mates that had been separated for years by a decision made by a young Ani, who thought she was helping a greatly admired professor. Books can often be made or broken by the narrator. In this case, Craden works her magic. She does vulnerability so beautifully and I love the variations in the voices she uses. I also appreciate that Kallmaker is releasing many of her back catalog on audio, with Craden is narrating many of them. This book was originally published in 2009, and the audiobook just this year. If you haven't read it, I definitely say give the audio version a go. It is terribly romantic and I loved it.
Profile Image for Tara.
783 reviews372 followers
February 17, 2018
Well, this book turned out to be cute as hell. I like how Karin Kallmaker handled going back and forth between the present for Ani and Eve, showing us how they fell in love, what split them up, and how they made their way back to each other. I also appreciated that it wasn't overly angsty, because I find that sometimes second chance romances are just way angstier than necessary.

The characters are super likeable, especially the leads and two supporting characters—Tan and Lisa. I've heard Lisa is in Kallmaker's new release, My Lady Lipstick, and I can't wait to see more of her.

If you're looking for a lovely, gentle read, I'd recommend this one.
Profile Image for TheAvidReader.
98 reviews
March 8, 2020
The issue I had with this book is the plot. So this MC left her home, lover, and dog, because of... WHAT?? And how exactly is someone with a PhD this slow?

Lisa was my favorite person because it took her 30 minutes to figure out who did it. And I love her tenacity. Infact, I wish this book was about her finding her HEA. I was bored. And the conclusion was not satisfactory in the least!

This was my first intro to this author and I'll still read more of her books. This plot though, I didn't like. On to the next.
Profile Image for lauraღ.
2,343 reviews171 followers
April 7, 2022
“I haven’t known where I am ever since I left. Getting lost in you seems the only way to find myself again.”

My first experience with Kallmaker, and I'm a little sad about it, because this was... frustrating. It's a second chance romance set in Alaska between a geology PhD student and a chef. Ani ran from Alaska three years ago after an accident and a bad decision turns into a situation that ruins her academic life and her relationship. Now she's back, discovering things about the events of the past, and attempting to rekindle things with Eve.

Second chance romances aren't my favourite, but I added this to my TBR because I was intrigued by the setting. But the misunderstanding between the two characters overwhelmed the first 60 percent of the book, and it was suuuuuch a slog to get through. I truly wasn't enjoying myself. And I can't put it down to a blanket hatred of the miscommunication/misunderstanding trope, because I recently read a romance where that featured prominently, but I still loved it. Even though the big miscommunication happened in the past, hearing about it in hindsight was just... not gratifying. It didn't feel like the good romance angst that you expect with a second chance romance. I just felt a bit irritated.

Things did pick up a lot in the latter half. I truly adored the secondary characters and the little side romance. Lisa is a delight, and I kinda want an entire book about her and her love interest. The author did a good job of establishing Ani and Eve's past love and their current reconnection. I loved that we got some time on the ice and all the cold weather stuff that you'd normally expect. The plotline with the antagonist was okay, wrt the ways it explored manipulation, but it was a little tiresome, waiting for Ani to catch on to things that reader was made aware of, like, chapters before. The writing was okay, if a bit dated and essentialist at times.

Listened to the audiobook as read by Abby Craden: a complete saving grace. I say this all the time, but I truly wouldn't have finished this without her. I don't think this is a bad book, but it got on my nerves a bit too much to really have any fond memories of it. Whenever I try Kallmaker again, I'll go for her newer work.

Content warnings:
Profile Image for Alealea.
648 reviews10 followers
December 10, 2019
I'm binge-reading Karin Kallmaker's books this month.

OMG ... so very sad. So very not credible. If ever characters make me want to shake them like a coconut tree, here they are.

The gal who left : Why the f-word didn't you CAME BACK earlier ??? or wait 5 f-wording-minutes to TALK ???
The gal who was left : Why the f-word didn't you LOOK ?

so very frustrating... because the writing was good and beautiful and minor character were likable

The writer tropes seems to be
> awful birth families
> bereavement
> light miscommunication (HUUUUUDGE!!!)
> lava-hot sex scene
Profile Image for Jae Jae.
Author 126 books3,804 followers
Read
April 22, 2023
This is a solid novel. Karin Kallmaker has been writing for a long time, and it shows. She finds great ways to describe her characters without violating point of view or stopping the plot. I didn’t really like the “It was all just a misunderstanding” plot that separated the main characters years ago, though.
Profile Image for Marie.
106 reviews15 followers
October 17, 2020
4.25 stars.I liked it! But I'll readily admit, I had next to no understanding for MC Ani.
Has she no self respect? At the beginning, I felt empathy for her and for Eve, but as the book progressed, Ani was just acting scared and plain stupid.

At two thirds of the book, the two mains hadn't spoken one word to each other, up to then it was all memories and history, and I got really antsy for something to happen. Admittedly,
this was all well done and engaging, yes, but I had no patience for Ani anymore. Leave the love of her life, her dog, a career she loves, all because of a misunderstanding? I'm glad Lisa was such a fun secondary character, otherwise I probably wouldn't have continued the book...

Anyway... luckily, something did happen eventually. Then the dynamic changed with Lisa, Tan, Eve and Ani, and that was really nice. It became a sort of crime novel but it was fun and I loved it.

All in all, a great book and once again a job tremendously well done by Abby Craden!
Profile Image for chaos.
122 reviews
January 18, 2022
I liked this premise very much—academic fraud, a sexy, manipulative professor, and all the intelligent science-y women are LESBIANS!

It started out a bit slow, the middle section actually tugged pretty hard on the heart strings, and then the ending kind of … lost steam for me.

The setting felt very real and well-researched, and the narration was excellent. Solid 4 stars.
Profile Image for Elaine Burnes.
Author 10 books29 followers
September 6, 2010
In short: Anidyr Bycall [tall, dark, and gorgeous:], a graduate student studying glaciers, flees academic ruin in Fairbanks, Alaska, to tend bar in Key West. The love she left behind, Eve Cambra, [short, blond, and you guessed it...:] can never forgive her, she thinks. Three years later, she goes back to get her stuff from Eve's garage and say the goodbye she hadn't before. So she thinks...

Egad! This is uber Xena!

In the category of a little knowledge is a dangerous thing, I realize I'm no expert on Alaska, but I had a few issues with this book. I'll give it five stars for the heartwarming story of love conquering all. Take away a star for including Eve's point of view. As soon as she opens her mind to us, all the tension is lost. We know how this story will play out, the miscommunication becomes annoying, and the character of Lisa clearly a red herring. (I do not get the need, so common in lesfic, to whipsaw readers back and forth between POVs.) Then take away another star for the lame plot. Like Lisa, I guessed the bad guy in about thirty minutes. And Kallmaker's literary license should be suspended for moving Mount McKinley north of Fairbanks. WTF? And the northern lights are not visible in summer in Fairbanks, where it gets no darker than dusk. A flip through Frommer's would have told her that. If these hadn't been major elements to the story, I could have dismissed them.

I wish she had delved deeper into the science. Did it not strike her as ironic to set a story in the shadow of the Alaska Pipeline, which is never mentioned, while discussing global warming research? I'll leave it with 3 stars because I do like Kallmaker and I give her props for at least attempting a potentially interesting setting, even if it would have fit better someplace like Talkeetna. At one point, I did actually pause to reflect on how neat it was to be reading about women's love for each other.
Profile Image for Bugs.
250 reviews58 followers
May 4, 2018
Must-read & re-read! Original. Funny. Fun. Intense. Thrills. Adventure. Friendship. Love. Romance. Karin Kallmaker's exceptional writing & compelling storytelling will leave you very happy at the end of an emotional roller coaster of a ride.

OMG. Can't remember the last time a book compelled me to have vocal reactions whilst reading it! I was literally screaming into me device - from "You dum-dum!" (to Ani & Eve, separately), "You bloody bitch! How could you?!" (to Monica), to "OMG! Thank YOU, Lisa!! You're my HERO!!" (to Lisa) & ultimately "Oh, thank GOD!".

Honestly, the story was written so flawlessly thrilling that my fingers weren't quick enough to scroll down as my desire to know what happened next reached fever pitch! Literally finished it at fast-and-furious acceleration!

A MUST-READ, HANDS DOWN!!  Defo on me re-read list especially now that I know how it ends without inadvertently cooking my stress levels! 😳
Profile Image for Kaye.
4,339 reviews71 followers
April 10, 2021
Still binge reading older romances. This from 2009 was a pleasant surprise. Ani Bycall, a doctoral student working on glacial ice in Alaska flees after being accused of taking a professors field notes. Three years later while tending bar in Key West she decides to return to Alaska to pick up things from the ex that she thinks has moved on. New friend, and awesome side character Lisa, goes into sleuth mode and tries to solve the mystery what really happened. I liked they mystery, although it was so obvious who was the manipulator. Ani was a little annoying at how insecure and guilty she felt and with the fact it took 3 years to try and reach out to Eve. But overall a fun and surprisingly clean romantic read.
Profile Image for Gaelle Cathy.
Author 25 books22 followers
July 14, 2013
Very good. I love the settings. I love icy lands. Nice story and Lisa has to be one of the best secondary characters I've ever read. Loved her!!!!
Profile Image for Jen.
1,300 reviews2 followers
June 9, 2020
2nd chances at life & love

“Death had taken its fee, she told herself, but life has to go on or death gets more than it ought.”

“She’d disappointed Monica Tyndell, broken Eve’s heart, and Tonk wouldn’t have understood why one day Ani didn’t come back. Dogs only understood hellos, not goodbyes.”

“But maybe she could let go by making sure that Eve had moved on. Say she was sorry, without excuses, own her mistakes, get her stuff and go. Tell Tan not to send her any more boxes and find a life she could embrace with as much love as she had had for her old one.”

“Ani realized, then, a piece of the truth. She had never left. And that’s why she had never moved on.”

“She felt struck by lightning, twice over. Once with the recognition that it was Ani, alive and well, and again with the unanticipated, but unmistakable reaction from the depth of her being: I can live again.”
+ • + • + • +

One single mistake & in that single moment everything you'd worked so hard for & ever dreamed of your entire life is gone in a flash, all plans & visions of your future instantly lost forever.
What if you were given the opportunity to right your wrongs, fix your error & could salvage at least finding peace with yourself & maybe even the possibility of regaining a sliver of what was destroyed —would you? …Could you?
Thanks to the prying, meddling intrusion into her personal life by her new coworker, Lisa, she & Ani are on their way to Alaska, back to the life Ani fled 3 years ago brokenhearted, in shame, disgrace, accusations & scandal, to close the door on the past in the hope she can finally start a new life. But, inconceivably, the prayers for rescue that weren't answered then have been gifted to her the offering of redemption, absolution & forgiveness.
Profile Image for Bella.
336 reviews1 follower
June 1, 2023
I need someone to crown Lisa as the queen of something. I just love her so much. This is Lisa's world and we're all just living in it. Jokes aside, Lisa wasn't just a side character, she was the goddamn most important and lovable character. Without her, I probably somehow got into this fictional world and throttle some people (side eyes 2 dumbasses and a wicked witch). Honestly, Lisa got chemistry with everyone more than any other's chemistry - like I could see her with any of the main characters and the main ship sinks and I would've been ok.
But unfortunately, this book wasn't about Lisa, and while I may want to smash their heads together 90% of the book, I also liked Ani and Eve a lot. Ani being nerdy and a passionate glacial geologist was fun to read about. I liked Eve less, but nevertheless, she was also likable being a reasonable, friendly boss and chef.

The structure of this book was refreshing - the past was unveiled as Ani and Lisa traveled to Alaska, nothing about that part of the story can be changed, but then they arrived and what happens next was unpredictable. The ending was

Overall an enjoyable read with some angst and heartbreaking moments, but it was mostly funny thanks to Lisa.
Profile Image for Diana Nolen.
141 reviews
March 28, 2022
While reading the Frosting on the Cake short story follow up to this story it said it was originally published in 1989 and I can’t believe I didn’t devour it back then. But I have now and it is a lovely story.

I love the main characters Ani and Eve. AND, I absolutely love Lisa, who is rightfully described as a force of nature by one of the other main characters. For a few minutes I didn’t like Lisa, but she not only grows on you, she is the female Columbo that has great instincts to help the story come together. (You can read more of her character in Frosting on the Cake and My LAdy Lipstick, in that order. I’m hoping a FotC 3 comes out soon with her and Tan!)

Of course, the fact that this story is told (not just read out, but truly narrated given life) by Abby Craden is a big bonus.

Another thing I liked about this book is the amazing descriptions of Alaska. But, this book is an enjoyable book, throughout with humor, interesting facts, great character developments and even a mystery that gets solved in the end that has lingered throughout.

Great storytelling throughout.5/5 and highly recommend!
Profile Image for Michele Howell.
207 reviews
January 28, 2020
I just reread this book. I loved it just as much as the first time. The story takes place in Alaska. The scenery descriptions are phenomenal.
Ani goes to a university in Alaska on a scholarship. Eva is a very good chef. Tan works in the administrative branch of the university Ani attends. Lisa met Ani at an ICE BAR in Key West, Florida. They both were bartenders and had to wear snowsuits because the environment mimicked that of Alaska.
During an expedition with the Professor in the geology dept., there is a death and a missing research binder.
Ani becomes suspect and being advised by her Professor she decides to find her way back to the ICE BAR in Key West where Lisa is still tending bar.
Three years go by and Ani decides to take a trip back to Alaska and asked Lisa to come along.
See how a strong love wins in the end and new romace develops.
5 reviews
August 21, 2023
This was my first foray into the Karin Kallmaker universe and I loved it. I chose it because I've been to Alaksa, and Karin's vivid descriptive imagery is incredible. I fell for the characters, and I loved the side-romance between Lisa and Tan. (Lisa is AWESOME! She should totally become a detective or a legal prosecutor). I will definitely be reading more Karin Kallmaker.

The only thing I would have changed about this book is that I would have loved to have seen see Monica Tyndell get more of a comeuppance. I've had a number of narcissists in my life in the past, and she is the most dangerous kind. A clinical, DSM-V grade f**ker that deserves some serious karma. (Sorry, I clearly still have issues around the narcissists that I unfortunately allowed into my life for a number of years).
Profile Image for Sandy.
498 reviews17 followers
May 30, 2020
A 10 year old story that holds up quite well. The author is one of my favorites and she does not disappoint. From Key West to the glaciers of Fairbanks, Alaska, the sights and sounds of the natural world come alive in this story. Having been to both places, it tickles my memories with colors and feels. The Characters in this book feel real and alive. Ani and Eve are young and innocents in a world of Academic deceit revolving around research grants and they end of losing three years because off it. The secondary characters are fun, acerbic and faithful friends who find their own way forward. Really good writing and plot line but the dastardly deed is a bit contrived dropping it one star in my rating. Even so, a very good read.
Profile Image for Joc.
770 reviews198 followers
November 20, 2017
Ani is the bartender at an ice bar in Key West. She's a sullen loner until waitress Lisa comes along and pushes her way into Ani's business. Lisa's persistence has Ani telling her about the heart she broke three years before in Alaska and her subsequent flight caused by her shame and guilt.

This is a thoroughly enjoyable read and so much more than standard story line where the misunderstanding is unraveled with much angst and chest-beating. I enjoyed Lisa as a character felt as though she had been put there almost as though she is the reader with a clear vision through the bullshit. Entertaining dialogue and set in a place with cold, ice and snow - two of my favourite things.
Profile Image for Michelle.
35 reviews1 follower
January 13, 2019
This is a wonderful tale of facing past mistakes and taking a chance on reconciliation and regaining love. Kallmaker incorporates some of the most intense and beautiful descriptions of nature and our relationship with it while describing the Alaskan landscape. I truly felt the connection between Ani and the environment. Kallmaker equally develops the characters creating empathy in the reader, I could truly feel Ani and Eve’s emotions throughout the story. The secondary characters are also amazing, Lisa is insightful and hilarious!
Profile Image for emily.
897 reviews164 followers
September 29, 2021
This was my first book by this author and overall I had a good time. I love this narrator usually, and she did a good job here. I think there was just something that didn’t quite click for me personally in the main romance and the background plot stuff just never quite grabbed me the way i wanted it too. That said, it was still an enjoyable listen!
119 reviews
June 14, 2023
I really like this book, it was short and sweet and also really interesting. I also liked the exploration of power, dynamics and guilt. Unlike some of the other reviews. I don’t judge the main character for reacting in such a hyperbolic way, because sometimes people feel like that is their only choice.
853 reviews2 followers
July 24, 2024
Whats the farthest you can get away from a crush? From Fairbanks Alaska to Key West. Does it keep you apart? Karin Kallmaker takes us back to Alaska for truth, glaciers, research, data and ethical practices. Abby Crayden's voice takes us from watching the northern lights at midnight to romancing on a glacier. Well done Team
Profile Image for Carmen.
103 reviews
August 13, 2024
I enjoyed this. The story was engaging and interesting; mistakes, misunderstandings and misinformation and a love that stands the toughest tests. I liked the main characters Ani and Eve but to be honest my favourite character was the perky and forthright Lisa.
I also liked learning a little about Alaska and glaciers).
31 reviews
December 29, 2024
As Hot As Ever

Karin Kallmaker once again has delivered a richly nuanced tale of living, loving, & learning to become a fuller version of one’s self. Set against the ever-present tangle of politics, power, & truth in Academia, Warming Trend explores the twists & turns of student, professor, & administrator as they seek to go one degree higher, in love and life.
Profile Image for Kerstin.
135 reviews3 followers
February 22, 2018
I liked to read this book, the drama came from typical misunderstanding like it is often seen in romance novels. I really liked the story telling with flashbacks und setting was very unique. It had a little suspense in it to the end other than that it was quite ok.
Profile Image for Gayle Miller.
30 reviews1 follower
May 4, 2023
By far my favourite Karin Kallmaker novel!

Well written. Engaging. I found it hard to step away to do anything else but find out why Ani was ostracised by the community. The plot was woven to perfection!
Profile Image for L.
98 reviews
November 19, 2024
One of the best books I've read this year. Kallmaker's research and immersion into the world of her books is top notch. Here, the glacier came to life in all its vibrancy. Loved the plot which never sagged, the emotional beats which were so sharp and deep, and the gorgeous setting.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.