As advertised, Heroics for Beginners pokes fun at the fantasy genre, and it does so fairly well. The humor sometimes feels contrived, but most of the time it carries the story along and you're chuckling with or at the characters.
But for every two laughs, you'll groan. I can't decide if John Moore is taking this parody thing way too seriously or if the parody angle was just a cover-up for his true agenda: bodice-ripping and softcore porn. These scenes never get explicit, and I can understand why they're there in the first place (this stuff happens in some fantasy), but there are far too many of them and they last much too long. I can see every teen or worse, preteen girl squealing over her love of "fantasy" while closely reading every word, and as far as I'm concerned, that makes Heroics for Beginners no better than Twilight.
Equally horrible is Moore's stereotyping of men and women, and I don't mean hot barbarian swordsman chick and dashing soldier/prince or lord. That's appropriate, given this is an exaggeration of fantasy devices. I mean lines like, "It's okay for women to deceive men because it's good for them," coming from female characters, and every male character tripping over themselves and their fidelity ("Technically we're not engaged yet") no matter how in love they claim to be. Because the sexual temptation is just too much, and it can't be helped when they turn into drooling, babbling idiots. If you live in the real world and aren't a bitter person, then you know these respective depictions of women and men are not accurate or descriptive of every woman and man. I know Moore is just trying to point out how silly fantasy can be, but it doesn't feel that way. For as much as he breaks cliches, he relies on them. The ending, for instance, was so sickeningly sweet and fairy tale that I rushed through it. I do not like to rush through the last page of any book, considering it's the last page and is meant to be savored and thought about for at least a good five minutes afterward. Of any author, only Moore has made me rush through a last page.
Heroics for Beginners isn't all bad. It's actually pretty clever with the way it exposes fantasy tropes and so on. But if it didn't have so much humor, it wouldn't be readable. Thank God this book was so short.