What do you think?
Rate this book
Making of a General: A Himalayan Echo
"Making of a General' is the memoir of Lt Gen (Dr) Konsam Himalay Singh who has traced his journey from a small village in Manipur to becoming the first person from North East India to hold the rank of a Three Star General of the Indian Army. The fascinating ways that the author has captured the history and beauty of Manipur makes it an engaging read. The recollection of the Kargil War and the important role that the author had played in it are stark reminders of the sacrifices that the army personnel make to keep the nation's borders safe. The book also throws light on many of the challenges that the commanding officers face while carrying out their duties. "
248 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 2, 2021
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
October 14, 2021
This autobiography is both uplifting and depressing. Uplifting because it recounts the story of a boy from a small village in Manipur in the North-Eastern part of India. The boy by dint of hard work and perseverance went on to become a Lt. General in the Indian army. He also became a path breaker for many other kids from Manipur who followed him into the army. The author was blessed with a loving and loyal wife, from Maharashtra, who more than once put her career on hold to help advance her husband's career. Deeply moving.
Sadly the book makes for depressing reading too. The book recounts in some detail the events leading to the Kargil war (with Pakistan) of 1999. Not only was the Indian army taken by surprise it continued to deny the seriousness of the situation even after all relevant information was before it. The men and younger officers showed great courage in recovering the territory occupied by Pakistan. The senior leadership doesn't come across well. The Corp Commander it appears was not particularly given to visiting the front line to motivate the troops. Terrible.
The author recounts that the soldiers were buying their own shoes since the official supply was sub-standard. That the para military forces were, in some respects, better equipped than the army because the army couldn't get procurements organised. And worse the issues either took years to resolve or haven't been resolved yet. Pathetic.
The book could do with better editing. There are far too many repetitions and a few disconnects. I would however recommend the book to all Indians particularly the decision makers, whether politicians, bureaucrats or army officers .The brave soldiers of this country deserve better.
Sadly the book makes for depressing reading too. The book recounts in some detail the events leading to the Kargil war (with Pakistan) of 1999. Not only was the Indian army taken by surprise it continued to deny the seriousness of the situation even after all relevant information was before it. The men and younger officers showed great courage in recovering the territory occupied by Pakistan. The senior leadership doesn't come across well. The Corp Commander it appears was not particularly given to visiting the front line to motivate the troops. Terrible.
The author recounts that the soldiers were buying their own shoes since the official supply was sub-standard. That the para military forces were, in some respects, better equipped than the army because the army couldn't get procurements organised. And worse the issues either took years to resolve or haven't been resolved yet. Pathetic.
The book could do with better editing. There are far too many repetitions and a few disconnects. I would however recommend the book to all Indians particularly the decision makers, whether politicians, bureaucrats or army officers .The brave soldiers of this country deserve better.
January 10, 2021
Congratulations to the author for a well written book with the aim of motivating our youth - an aspect that very few military leaders have attempted. The journey of life of a young lad from Charangpat (Lake of the Dragonflies)- a remote hamlet in Manipur – ‘the Switzerland of India’, who was, in his own words, physically weak, shy, scared of heights and the darkness, - to becoming a General in the Indian Army and on hanging his uniform, choosing to return to his roots to serve society instead of enjoying his well-earned retirement at any place of his choosing, is well etched. What a great way to impress upon those 'lucky' ones who rose to high positions in their chosen professions, to return to the society to serve those who made that climb possible.
Manipur has the highest per-capita number of officers in India's armed forces. Now, being the Chairman of the Manipur State Public Service Commission, I have a suggestion. While appearing for Canadian citizenship, we were required to clear an examination which had 20% questions from Canada's military history, mostly covering Canada's contribution during the two World Wars. India has a very chequered military history, especially post independence. Through my various blogposts I have been suggesting that the Union Public Service Commission and State Public Service Commissions must have least five percent questions from Independent India's military history. This will enthuse the coming generation and will make them aware of the role and sacrifices of India's Armed Forces. It is sure to make them feel proud.
All through the book, the author's love for nature has been vividly painted, taking the reader through a visionary fete. The description of the author's grandfather 'Even the horses kept silent when he coughed,' kept me thinking for a while. The author’s initiative to recover plastic junk accumulated over the years of army deployment in the Siachen glacier is another example.
The impact of handling a weapon by a ten year old; the need to have a dream in life – to dream big and how to pursue it; participate in family activities and chores; care for his mother by buying her salt with all his pocket money; overcoming stage fear; moral fibre, by choosing to throw away that 'chit' carried by him to the examination hall; listening to the English news to enlarge his vocabulary; the importance of reading (even if not comprehended at that age;) the need to remain focussed; the power of pardon and courage to be truthful; his adventurous train journey; the importance of education in the development of any society; the need for hobby - great life lessons that any child will value and benefit from during his growing years.
It was a revelation to me that the game of polo originated in Manipur. His requesting for half a mark to make it to 60 – brought back memories of many of my class mates and also, officers during various courses, begging for a mark or two to make a better grade.
Team spirit and camaraderie instilled in cadets at the National Defence Academy, the lack of facilities and time to enhance individual skills; modification of curricula to incorporate leadership skill development; have been well brought out.
The initial grooming and training of a Young Officer in his Regiment; the need and role of a mentor; the impact of his carrying the additional load of a soldier during a gruelling professional competition; the importance of participating in adventure activities – provide an interesting peek into the development and growth of a military leader.
The need for re-orienting training and educating the soldiers in dealing with the local population - through the eyes of the author - recipient of the adverse effects of lack of empathy by soldiers; the adverse effect of Armed Forces Special Powers Act; effect of movies to turn the youth to violence - have been well explained.
The author has given a first-hand information about the plight of the Bangladeshi Chakma refugees; peace-loving Mizos; the clashes between Meiteis, Naga, Kuki tribes, Manipuri Muslims; religio-communal divide and its present day implications; present cultural and socio-economic situation - the voice of a true son of the soil.
Summiting Kanchejunga rolls out like a movie as one reads, especially the fall of the author into a crevasse, coming out of the jaws of death and the felicitation by the Prime Minister of India that followed.
The conviction of the author to stand up against an unsavoury remark against Manipuris by a General at the Defence Services Staff College and the methodology adopted to make the General retract his words shows the maturity of the author and his adeptness in dealing with 'difficult 'situations.
A tinge of well appreciated subtle humour - panic is fear at highest level of military; the golden epaulettes; gifting of a telephone by a Pakistani soldier.
The first hand details of the attack on Point 5770, mostly unsung, gives the reader goose bumps with each activity explained with brevity. It showcases the leadership traits of the author. My salute to you Sir for the respect you showed to the fallen enemy soldiers in keeping with the highest military values. Not being awarded the Battle Honour - I hope the Indian Army will make amends for the oversight even at this stage. It needed an American author, Marcus P Acosta to bestow the honour the author's Battalion 27 RAJPUT deserved.
The Siachen Glacier experience, the after effects on both the body and mind of the author is well expressed. The dogs Pista and Pisti and the author pinning his commendation on Pisti, concern against euthanasia of aged mules shows the author's love for all God’s creations. His wish to command a brigade in the glacier - that too for a rupee - proves his military leadership traits.
The causes that led to the Indo-Chinese recent stand-off as viewed through the author's eyes is worth a read.
As suggested by the author, the need for a test to assess the psychological and emotional condition of the officers prior to assuming command of units is of utmost importance. If implemented, it will prove to be extremely beneficial to the Army. Also, the case of boots for soldiers - why every piece of the soldier's uniform - were privately bought. There is no worthwhile water-bottle for a soldier since 2000. The author's concern for the soldiers' needs and his moral fibre to convey it to none other than the Defence Minister in the presence of the Chief of the Army Staff shows the author's convictions.
The author has fulfilled his childhood dream - he did not stop there - but went on to become a Lieutenant General of the Indian Army. He has rightfully credited his achievements to his family, his teachers, his superior and subordinate officers of the Indian Army; above all to the soldiers who served under him.
After writing this review, I felt that I missed a great deal in never getting an opportunity to meet or serve under our first General from the North-East - a true soldier and a gentleman. I sign off with a quote from this book:-
Meeting and interacting with thousands of officers and men under my command gave me more faith in the inner strength and capability of our officers to win any situation. Only the Generals have to live up to it.
Manipur has the highest per-capita number of officers in India's armed forces. Now, being the Chairman of the Manipur State Public Service Commission, I have a suggestion. While appearing for Canadian citizenship, we were required to clear an examination which had 20% questions from Canada's military history, mostly covering Canada's contribution during the two World Wars. India has a very chequered military history, especially post independence. Through my various blogposts I have been suggesting that the Union Public Service Commission and State Public Service Commissions must have least five percent questions from Independent India's military history. This will enthuse the coming generation and will make them aware of the role and sacrifices of India's Armed Forces. It is sure to make them feel proud.
All through the book, the author's love for nature has been vividly painted, taking the reader through a visionary fete. The description of the author's grandfather 'Even the horses kept silent when he coughed,' kept me thinking for a while. The author’s initiative to recover plastic junk accumulated over the years of army deployment in the Siachen glacier is another example.
The impact of handling a weapon by a ten year old; the need to have a dream in life – to dream big and how to pursue it; participate in family activities and chores; care for his mother by buying her salt with all his pocket money; overcoming stage fear; moral fibre, by choosing to throw away that 'chit' carried by him to the examination hall; listening to the English news to enlarge his vocabulary; the importance of reading (even if not comprehended at that age;) the need to remain focussed; the power of pardon and courage to be truthful; his adventurous train journey; the importance of education in the development of any society; the need for hobby - great life lessons that any child will value and benefit from during his growing years.
It was a revelation to me that the game of polo originated in Manipur. His requesting for half a mark to make it to 60 – brought back memories of many of my class mates and also, officers during various courses, begging for a mark or two to make a better grade.
Team spirit and camaraderie instilled in cadets at the National Defence Academy, the lack of facilities and time to enhance individual skills; modification of curricula to incorporate leadership skill development; have been well brought out.
The initial grooming and training of a Young Officer in his Regiment; the need and role of a mentor; the impact of his carrying the additional load of a soldier during a gruelling professional competition; the importance of participating in adventure activities – provide an interesting peek into the development and growth of a military leader.
The need for re-orienting training and educating the soldiers in dealing with the local population - through the eyes of the author - recipient of the adverse effects of lack of empathy by soldiers; the adverse effect of Armed Forces Special Powers Act; effect of movies to turn the youth to violence - have been well explained.
The author has given a first-hand information about the plight of the Bangladeshi Chakma refugees; peace-loving Mizos; the clashes between Meiteis, Naga, Kuki tribes, Manipuri Muslims; religio-communal divide and its present day implications; present cultural and socio-economic situation - the voice of a true son of the soil.
Summiting Kanchejunga rolls out like a movie as one reads, especially the fall of the author into a crevasse, coming out of the jaws of death and the felicitation by the Prime Minister of India that followed.
The conviction of the author to stand up against an unsavoury remark against Manipuris by a General at the Defence Services Staff College and the methodology adopted to make the General retract his words shows the maturity of the author and his adeptness in dealing with 'difficult 'situations.
A tinge of well appreciated subtle humour - panic is fear at highest level of military; the golden epaulettes; gifting of a telephone by a Pakistani soldier.
The first hand details of the attack on Point 5770, mostly unsung, gives the reader goose bumps with each activity explained with brevity. It showcases the leadership traits of the author. My salute to you Sir for the respect you showed to the fallen enemy soldiers in keeping with the highest military values. Not being awarded the Battle Honour - I hope the Indian Army will make amends for the oversight even at this stage. It needed an American author, Marcus P Acosta to bestow the honour the author's Battalion 27 RAJPUT deserved.
The Siachen Glacier experience, the after effects on both the body and mind of the author is well expressed. The dogs Pista and Pisti and the author pinning his commendation on Pisti, concern against euthanasia of aged mules shows the author's love for all God’s creations. His wish to command a brigade in the glacier - that too for a rupee - proves his military leadership traits.
The causes that led to the Indo-Chinese recent stand-off as viewed through the author's eyes is worth a read.
As suggested by the author, the need for a test to assess the psychological and emotional condition of the officers prior to assuming command of units is of utmost importance. If implemented, it will prove to be extremely beneficial to the Army. Also, the case of boots for soldiers - why every piece of the soldier's uniform - were privately bought. There is no worthwhile water-bottle for a soldier since 2000. The author's concern for the soldiers' needs and his moral fibre to convey it to none other than the Defence Minister in the presence of the Chief of the Army Staff shows the author's convictions.
The author has fulfilled his childhood dream - he did not stop there - but went on to become a Lieutenant General of the Indian Army. He has rightfully credited his achievements to his family, his teachers, his superior and subordinate officers of the Indian Army; above all to the soldiers who served under him.
After writing this review, I felt that I missed a great deal in never getting an opportunity to meet or serve under our first General from the North-East - a true soldier and a gentleman. I sign off with a quote from this book:-
Meeting and interacting with thousands of officers and men under my command gave me more faith in the inner strength and capability of our officers to win any situation. Only the Generals have to live up to it.
September 27, 2024
A very inspiring read ....
November 5, 2022
Being first in the league matters and hence matters the life and career of Lieutenant General Konsam Himalay Singh. He is the first lieutenant General from North East and that too after 35 years of service. As per best of my knowledge, most army officers are able to reach the lank of Colonel due to the various rules and combat mortality. To appreciate the magnitude of this achievement, it is important to understand North East and the development (or the underdevelopment of North East), especially in 70s :
1) LG Konsam lived in a modest house in a village in Manipur
2) To reach the capital city of the state, one has to take a bus that used to ply once 2-3 times a week and that too early in the morning around 6 AM
3) The village had only one PRIMARY school let alone secondary and higher studies.
4) Not to forget, the region at that time was infested with insurgent groups (akin terrorists) who threatened villagers against going into mainstream (Education, government jobs, benefits etc. )
Against all these odds, LG Konsam studied and got himself enrolled in army schools and subsequently the NDA Khadakwasla. His subsequent life is a description of his deployment at various borders of India. His biggest challenge came when he was deployed in his home state for fighting the insurgency. It is like fighting against their own people. He vividly describes the Manipuri history and role of stakeholders like erstwhile British rulers, the Chinese governments, and role of local villagers. Perhaps, his biggest challenge and opportunity when he was deployed in J&K for the Kargil war as well as Siachen. It made me cringe when he described how Jawans used to buy their own shoes to survive in extremely cold regions because the equipments they were supplied with were of inferior quality. It shows the deep rooted corruption in the army. His tyrst with pakistani terrorists, local stone pelters and the sympathisers give much more insights into the conundrum that J&K is.
Finally, the heart melting story is of his retirement. While he was adequately felicitated by the army, however, the subsequent corruption he faced while setting up his own home in his home state of Manipur is heart wrenching. An entire life dedicated fighting against external enemies only to see yourself become a victim of internal termites. This book is especially for those complaint boxes who say, 'Oh, I didn't have proper access to facilities or resources or support from parents' or those who say 'System is so bad that nothing can be achieved'.
Well, Lieutenant General Konsam faced all of these and yet he became the Knight and Pride of Manipur.
1) LG Konsam lived in a modest house in a village in Manipur
2) To reach the capital city of the state, one has to take a bus that used to ply once 2-3 times a week and that too early in the morning around 6 AM
3) The village had only one PRIMARY school let alone secondary and higher studies.
4) Not to forget, the region at that time was infested with insurgent groups (akin terrorists) who threatened villagers against going into mainstream (Education, government jobs, benefits etc. )
Against all these odds, LG Konsam studied and got himself enrolled in army schools and subsequently the NDA Khadakwasla. His subsequent life is a description of his deployment at various borders of India. His biggest challenge came when he was deployed in his home state for fighting the insurgency. It is like fighting against their own people. He vividly describes the Manipuri history and role of stakeholders like erstwhile British rulers, the Chinese governments, and role of local villagers. Perhaps, his biggest challenge and opportunity when he was deployed in J&K for the Kargil war as well as Siachen. It made me cringe when he described how Jawans used to buy their own shoes to survive in extremely cold regions because the equipments they were supplied with were of inferior quality. It shows the deep rooted corruption in the army. His tyrst with pakistani terrorists, local stone pelters and the sympathisers give much more insights into the conundrum that J&K is.
Finally, the heart melting story is of his retirement. While he was adequately felicitated by the army, however, the subsequent corruption he faced while setting up his own home in his home state of Manipur is heart wrenching. An entire life dedicated fighting against external enemies only to see yourself become a victim of internal termites. This book is especially for those complaint boxes who say, 'Oh, I didn't have proper access to facilities or resources or support from parents' or those who say 'System is so bad that nothing can be achieved'.
Well, Lieutenant General Konsam faced all of these and yet he became the Knight and Pride of Manipur.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews