Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Cheesy on the Eyes (Slice #5)” as Want to Read:
Cheesy on the Eyes (Slice #5)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Cheesy on the Eyes

(Slice #5)

4.39  ·  Rating details ·  1,121 ratings  ·  294 reviews
Dating is hard. Dating in a small town? Impossible.

Leave it to my little brother to come back home announcing he knocked up his fiancée and the wedding has been moved…to next month.

When he tries to set me up with one of his football buddies, I tell him I’ll be bringing my own plus-one.

Only problem? I’m hopelessly single.

Enter Sullivan Scott, AKA my hero.

We strike a deal: h
Kindle Edition, 239 pages
Published June 4th 2020
More Details... Edit Details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Cheesy on the Eyes, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Cheesy on the Eyes

Community Reviews

Showing 1-30
Average rating 4.39  · 
Rating details
 ·  1,121 ratings  ·  294 reviews

More filters
Sort order
Start your review of Cheesy on the Eyes (Slice #5)
May 27, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2020-four-stars
4.5 stars


Cheesy on the Eyes was such a fun, sweet, and enjoyable read. I think this is my favorite Teagan Hunter book to date, and it's definitely my favorite of the 'Slice' series.
It’s hard to find someone in general, especially after getting your heart eviscerated, but small-town dating? Damn do I have my work cut out for me.

Thea has lived in the same small town all of her life. She runs the family business and has a pro football player for a brother. After a bad breakup, she's been sing
Phuong ✯
This is by far my favorite Teagan Hunter book! It was so much fun to read, especially since it has everything I enjoy in a rom-com.

fake dating
→ easy and witty banter between the main characters ✓
siblings bickering who give each other shit, but are fiercly protective of each other ✓ I mean, if you haven't accused your brother/sister of being adopted once in your lifetime, it's about time you do that.
cute & heartwarming family scenes ✓ Thea's family is hilarious and literally family goal
Heather Navarre
May 27, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Teagan is known for her rom-com abilities. This book rockets out of the sky! Puts her in a league of her own!

Sully and Thea are hilarious! More hilarious than I imagined they would be.

The story starts out innocent enough, ex walks in with new flavor of the day on his arm, of course Thea should just have someone pretend to be her boyfriend. What could go wrong with that?!? Hilariousness-that’s what!

The cheesy dad one liners are great! I laughed out loud so many times while reading. But the lines
Marina Skinner
May 27, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Cheesy on the Eyes is the absolute best romantic comedy story that made me smile so much as I was reading!
Thea and Sully are a match made in pizza heaven or not, as the case may be!! Hands down it made my absolute week!
Thea has absolutely no filter when she says anything and I really want to be her friend! Sully though, is the quiet but rather wonderful man, who I couldn’t help but love! He was charming, funny, rather intense but also endearing!
I loved the witty banter, the amazing friendship
...more ||Elizabeth||
May 25, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Just when I thought this series couldn’t get any better, Teagan Hunter goes above and beyond and makes me fall even more in love with this series. This series continues to be an absolute favorite and I know that will never change. Sully and Thea are perfectly-imperfect perfection. I fell hard and fast for Sully and Thea. They were everything I wanted and didn’t know I needed.

Thea was EVERYTHING! The fact that she dominated a male-dominated profession and genuinely loves her job and doesn’t take
Christine C
May 26, 2020 rated it it was amazing
We have been waiting for what seems like forever for Sully's book, and it does not disappoint! There is so much I loved about this one. It is definitely my favorite of the Slice series.
Thea is amazing. She is a tiny, adorable, 100% unfiltered mechanic who is succeeding in a male dominated industry. She's been burned, though, and afraid to catch feelings again and get her heart broken again. Sully is just perfection. Three books of buildup were absolutely worth the payout here. I adored their rel
Jennifer Kreinbring
May 28, 2020 rated it really liked it
Gah! Every slice in this series tastes a little better than the one before it! I enjoyed this book very much! We FINALLY get that inside look into the very mysterious Sully and get to love his quiet nature even more. He deserved his own story so much and I am so glad his voice came to life! He is smooth and quick witted and he loves with everything he is, and when he steps in to help out a complete stranger that throws him for a loop, his true self is certainly put to the test. Thea is nothing s ...more
Melissa ~ Book Boyfriend and Husband Makes Three
I wish I could give this more than 5 stars.

I loved Thea; I am Thea. She was too loud, no filter, sarcastic, she wasn’t a girly-girl. She had been told once that she was "too much" and those words were always there lingering in the back of her mind and I have heard that said about me too.

Sully is my new favorite Slice man! From the moment he agreed to go along with her crazy I was addicted, the connection these 2 shared felt different than any romance I have ever read, it felt deeper, stronger. I
Stacie R.
May 27, 2020 rated it it was amazing
I have been waiting for sweet Sully’s book and holy crap did Teagan Hunter DELIVER for my man! Sully has hovered in the background for the first few books and I absolutely love that he got his time to shine. He’s the sweetest soul but so funny and loyal to those who deserve it. His relationship with Foster, Winston, and Porter was pure gold. The back and forth between those four was hilarious and throwing Simon into the mix made it even better.

As for Thea, I think she may be my all-time favorit
May 26, 2020 rated it it was amazing
I need a Dessert Pizza like now! Cheesy on the Eyes was one if my most anticipated reads this year. It did not disappoint. It made me laugh out loud, cry, and it made me so darn hungry. Seriously, this author has a way with words making your mouth salivate just thinking about the fictitious foods she creates.

This book is all about Sully. If you've read the others in the serious, which I suggest you do, then you know Sully. He is the strong, silent type with wisdom beyond his years. I loved read
Halle Reads
5/5 Stars 🌟


Cheesy on the Eyes is the 5th story in the Slice series and follows Sully & Thea. It is a fake dating, strangers to friends to lovers story with enough laughs & heart warming moments to make you never want to leave this town of people Teagan has created.

Sully is a sweet, gentle and soulful guy who has always had the knack for reading people. He is funny, charming, independent, vulnerable and he is by far my favourite guy in this series & I was very much anticapting his story and I
Jun 10, 2020 rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: Teagan Hunter Fans, Romance
4.5 Perfectly Wacky Stars
* * * *1/2 Spoiler Free-A Quick Review
I receive a lot of newsletters from authors. I appreciate the information, the insights I receive about the authors, and just all of the other goodies that I get from them. Many times they highlight another author and their new releases. It is through these highlights I have been alerted to many New to Me authors.

Teagan Hunter's Cheesy on the Eyes was one of those books.
If you asked, I couldn't share which author directed me to the
Melanie Helms
May 29, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Let me preface this with that i think I've loved every one of Teagan's male characters for their individual traits. But Sully might have usurped them all. He has always intrigued me thru Foster, Winston, and Porter's books. So to hear that we were getting his story thrilled me to no end! Because he was the one guy that always left you curious about him. Him being all quiet and soulful should i say... and with this book we got to peel away the layers that made up Sully to see the guy he was under ...more
What happens when your ex-boyfriend walks into the pizzeria where you’re at—alone, no less—with his new girlfriend? Grab the nearest guy to pretend to be your boyfriend, of course. And that’s just how Sully and Thea have their chance encounter. Surprisingly enough, they hit it off great but when they part ways, Sully never uses the phone number Thea gave him to ask her on a date.

But when Thea learns her brother’s wedding is sooner rather than later, and all her family is wondering when on earth
Book Fanatic
Feb 20, 2020 rated it it was amazing





First of all I cannot explain how excited I have been for this book! I loved Sully from the first moment I met him in the previous books. He was an instant mystery. Quiet and soulful sum him up.

However getting Sully's book lets us take a peek into the real man himsel
Jun 09, 2020 rated it really liked it
4.5 Stars!

Sully baby, I knew you would be amazing😭 I've only been waiting for his book for pretty much forever, and I'm so happy I finally got it. I love him even more, and I definitely did NOT expect the dirty talk, so Sully is definitely on par with Foster on being my favorites in this series. He's just so amazing all around.

Thea on the other hand, although I really liked her quirkiness, her stubbornness was a bit annoying at times, and her constant refusal on sex or "feelings" was a little to
Vanessa ♛Queen Alchemy ϟ Novel Nerd Faction♛
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy at no cost from the publisher/author. All opinions in my review are my own.

This has been my favorite book so far in the Slice series. I absolutely adored this book. Teagan Hunter has got this romcom thing down pat.

Teagan Hunter has a great writing voice. Her narration is smooth and it invites the reader in. She effortlessly weaves in humor and emotion to really hook you into the story. I love her witty lines and her way of tacking amusement into he
“Fate is that sure of us, baby.”

Yesss, Sully!!! I've been waiting for his book since book 1! He was always in the background, really quiet but also so intriguing! I really loved this one.
Sully was definitely a lot more than I expected, he had a bad past and was trying to overcome it and make the best of the situation he was in at the moment.
Thea was also amazing! She's Jonas' sister, from A Slice of Love, and I was really curious about her too.

To see this story unrevealed was amazing! I could no
Larissa Rye
May 28, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Oh. My. God. I have the biggest girl crush ever on Thea!! This couple is hands down my favourite of Teagan’s! They were everything.

Thea was hilarious, & so unbelievably herself that I absolutely love her. Love her! I wish I could be best friends with her. Haha seriously I could go on & on.

Sully... ah sweet, soulful Sully. He’s every girls dream. The thing I loved about him was that there is more to him than meets the eye. 😉

These two together were absolute fire. The chemistry & the back & forth m
Book Obsessions  (Amber)
May 25, 2020 rated it it was amazing
I loved this book SO MUCH!!! Sully was everything I was expecting and more (chapter 12 nearly killed me, hot damn)!

I will read anything this woman writes forever more andI can’t wait to see what she comes up with next!
May 27, 2020 rated it really liked it
I received an advanced copy of this title. It does not impact my review.

This book was so fun! Teagan Hunter excels at laugh-out-loud banter and cute romance and Cheesy on the Eyes was no exception.

Current fans of the Slice series will be happy to see Sully finally get a chance to be leading man. He’s always been a likable character in the series and I really enjoyed getting his POV. Thea is a relatively new character to the series and I mostly enjoyed her, as well. She is a bit of a quirky chara
Julia Griffis - The Romance Bibliophile

Cheesy on the Eyes has honestly been Teagan Hunter’s BEST, FUNNIEST, and SEXIEST romantic comedy to date, and I absolutely LOVED Sully and Thea’s story!

The storyline was excellent and so much better than I anticipated. I also loved Teagan Hunter’s prose and hilarious sense of humor. Sully and Thea’s journey was such a fun, sexy, swoon-worthy, and entertaining ride, and I couldn’t have loved it more. It was just what I needed. :)

The characters were superb, and I adored them with all m
Erica |
May 25, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Officially my favorite of the series! This one has it all!

Full review to follow!

Take the leap and fall!

This story? It has everything. Fake relationship. Humor. Heart. An engaging group of friends. And pizza.

I'm a sucker for a good fake relationship story. And Sully and Thea are just perfect.

What starts out as a ruse quickly turns into a friendship with a whole lot of tension brewing beneath the surface. There are rules and hard lines...but when these two tip over that line? Holy pe
May 25, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Holy crap I freaking loved this book!! It's totally my favorite of this series. I laughed so many times and lost count of all the hilarious quotes I highlighted. If you want to laugh so hard you pee a little, look no further. This is definitely the book for you!

Cheesy is seriously funny but it isn't just packed full of shenanigans and witty banter. It's also full of adorable characters and awesome friendships. I freaking love Thea. She is such a sassy little badass weirdo. And don't even get me
Wendy ⏃: ✦Cheeky Chicks Reviewer✦
4.5 STARS!

Sweet and funny, Cheesy on the Eyes by Teagan Hunter is an adorable fake dating romantic comedy that at moments had me in tears!

Thea Schwartz is this awesome chick who is sassy, outspoken, and loves to fix cars. One night at Slice, Thea gets Sully's attention and pretends that he's her boyfriend to avoid her ex and his new girlfriend. Soon, she convinces Sully to venture into a pretend relationship with her for her brother's wedding. And this is when things get interesting, my friends
May 26, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Teagan Hunter is a romcom master. Seriously. She consistently puts out books that not only make me laugh out loud, but also make me swear that I've just met my favorite MC's that she has ever written. And Cheesy on the Eyes was no exception to those feelings. Sully and Thea will go down as two of my favorite characters of all time.

While Cheesy on the Eyes might not be the most unique story I've ever read, the world that is built around the characters definitely has a magic of its own. The friend
2OCC Reviews
May 26, 2020 rated it really liked it
Shelves: jessica
Sully was as awesome as I knew he would be. He was sweet but at the same time had that air about him that made it to where you wanted to know everything that troubles him. Thea was great. She honestly spoke her mind, rocked a wrench and was just laid back and funny. She was perfect for Sully.
I loved seeing Sully and Thea get to know each other. It was funny to see them so candied with each other and not trying to impress the other one. They really just went with the flow and their romance bloome
May 27, 2020 rated it it was amazing
I have been in love with Sully since we first met him in the earlier books of this series and when I heard he was getting his own story I was so excited, and this did not disappoint. Sully is this laid-back surfer type guy that is very intuitive to those around him and everyone of his friends know him as having “freaky juju” when it comes to being able to read them. He is so laid back that he takes everything with ease except when we find out about his family and the pain it caused him. Thea is ...more
Jun 14, 2020 rated it really liked it
Super fun read! Not exactly laugh-out-loud material to me, but still really fun to read.
Sully is sooo cute.

Love her enough for both of you until she's not scared anymore. Then love her some more.
May 26, 2020 rated it it was amazing
Shelves: teagan-hunter
Well damn, didn't Teagan just go and write another top class book with two main characters who have become my favourite of the series...!?!!!

Fully LOVED IT!!! 🥰

The Slice Series has it all, falling in love with the brother's best friend, epic enemies-to-lovers, single parents getting their hae's, it's all there and I loved every single one of them, but it's this one, Sully and Thea's story that has become my firm favourite ❤️
These two just gel, there's Sully the quiet soulful easy going one, and
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Readers also enjoyed

  • Beautiful Liar (The Reed Rivers Trilogy, #2)
  • Awful Intentions (Celestial Bodies #2)
  • Monster Prick (Screwed, #1.5)
  • Varsity Heartbreaker (Varsity, #1)
  • Bullseye (The Monsters Within Duet, #1)
  • The Air He Breathes (Elements, #1)
  • The Space in Between (The Space in Between, #1)
  • The Gravity of Us (Elements, #4)
  • The Fire Between High & Lo (Elements, #2)
  • The Silent Waters (Elements, #3)
  • Loving Mr. Daniels
  • The Elements Series Complete Box Set
  • The air he breathes -Extrait offert-
  • Legacy of Lies (Empire of Lies, #3)
  • Awful Curse (Celestial Bodies #1)
  • King of Lies (Empire of Lies, #1)
  • Queen of Lies (Empire of Lies #2)
  • Romantically Ever After
See similar books…
I’m a Missouri-raised gal, but currently live in South Carolina with my Marine veteran husband. I spend my days begging him for a cat, and I survive off coffee, pizza, and sarcasm. When I’m not writing, you can find me binge-watching various TV shows, especially Supernatural and One Tree Hill. I like cold weather, buy more paperbacks than I’ll ever read, and I never say no to brownies.


Other books in the series

Slice (5 books)
  • A Pizza My Heart (Slice, #1)
  • I Knead You Tonight (Slice, #2)
  • Doughn't Let Me Go (Slice, #3)
  • A Slice of Love (Slice, #4)

Related Articles

  Some people love books. Some people fall in love. And some people fall in love with books about falling in love. Every month our team...
51 likes · 4 comments