Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Sons of Sinclair #2

Highland Warrior

Rate this book
Joshua Sinclair was once the fiercest and most notorious warrior of the mighty Sinclair clan of Northern Scotland. But now there’s nothing and no one that can make him take up arms again. Except a beautiful woman, it seems.

When Kára Flett, daughter of a fallen Norse chief, finds herself unexpectedly sheltering the strongest, most brutal warrior in the land, she throws together a risky and outrageous plan to bring him to her side. Threats of violence bounce right off him. Offers of gold seem to entice him even less. Desperate enough to use the pleas of the village children to sway him, she’s shocked when he’s completely unmoved. There’s only one tactic left for her: seduction.

Her hasty proposition falls completely by the wayside, though, as she and the Highlander come together in a carnal inferno. But bringing him into her life also brings his enemies to her clan’s doorstep—the very clan Kára is trying to protect. And as their feelings deepen, Joshua will have to decide between duty and love once and for all.

328 pages, Kindle Edition

First published April 27, 2021

106 people are currently reading
2673 people want to read

About the author

Heather McCollum

63 books1,091 followers
I am Heather McCollum, writer of 16th and 17th century Scottish romance full of adventure and intrigue, sprinkled with humor, history, and spice. Brawny Highlanders and feisty heroines are my favorite characters!

I am also a mom of three kids, dog-mom of one rescued geriatric golden retriever, and wife of one 6 foot 4 inch Highlander. When I’m not trying to help my kids make it through the day, baking things I see on The Great British Baking Show, or writing, I’m usually educating women on ovarian cancer (I’m a nine-year survivor).

I love kilted heroes, chai lattes, and eating buttered air-popped popcorn for dinner on Friday nights (my dog loves this one too).

If you’re interested in my new releases, fun historical tidbits, sales, and giveaways, sign up for my newsletter!

Newsletter https://www.heathermccollum.com/newsl...
And you are welcome to stalk me here as well:
Twitter https://twitter.com/HMcCollumAuthor
FB https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Pinterest http://www.pinterest.com/hmccollumaut...


This author also writes under: Eleri Drake

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
421 (43%)
4 stars
344 (35%)
3 stars
160 (16%)
2 stars
30 (3%)
1 star
13 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 153 reviews
Profile Image for Nicole.
1,251 reviews100 followers
April 6, 2021
Joshua Sinclair has spent his life at war, becoming famous and revered throughout Scotland for his skill and ferocity. A recent battle whose victory came at too high a price has soured his desire for warring and left him uncharacteristically craving peace.

When Kára Flett, chief of her small clan of Orkney natives, recognizes Joshua in her village’s pub, she resorts to outrageous methods in an effort to convince him to aid her clan against the tyrannical lord who now claims rule over the isle, the very lord whose men Joshua has been training. When all her efforts fail, she attempts to seduce Joshua into staying to help.

Kára and Joshua come together like fire and ice, but his friends turn enemies and he finds his loyalties shifting as his eyes are opened to the true way of things on the isle. As their feelings deepen, Joshua and Kára must determine if there is any way they can be together and keep her people safe against impossible odds.

This book kept me on the edge of my seat much of the time. Joshua was likeable and easy to root for, especially as he grew and developed as a man with his own notions of right beyond just following the path his father wanted for him. Kára was harder to warm up to, especially when she was blindly stubborn for much of the book and unwilling to listen to Joshua’s sensible suggestions until it was nearly too late. I didn’t really care for her manipulation of Joshua without really trying to talk to him first, but he was a good man and she showed growth as a character as well when she began to think more clearly. I did like these two as a couple; though their HEA wasn’t quite what I was expecting/hoping for, it was still very satisfying and original. Joshua harkens back to the traditional strong, alpha Highland warrior and I almost always love reading them. This was an entertaining, action-packed story and I look forward to the next series installment.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own. Blog link: https://mustreadalltheromance.blogspo...
Profile Image for Lover of Romance.
3,721 reviews1,127 followers
May 24, 2021
I just realized I hadn't reviewed this book and as I received this ARC in exchange for a review I definitely am trying to get caught up on my reviews. I will say that this definitely wasn't my favorite book in any way from this author. Now it had a decent plot in many aspects and I actually found the writing (which I have always found with this author) to be quite engaging and a story I didn't want to put it down.....except for the heroine. She definitely wasn't my cup of tea and came on really too strong in her personality in regards to how she treats the hero. Now I have read plenty of books where the heroine takes against or revenge against the hero. BUT, I think what is key in this circumstance is that she was very antagonistic, contrary and not thinking of the harm she was doing to someone else. Our hero is NOT a bad guy in any circumstance, one that has honor and good intentions and she treats him like he isn't worth polishing her boot and that treatment rubbed me the wrong way and to be honest kept me from fully enjoying this story as I wished to. Because I did enjoy many other aspects of the story and just couldn't get in line with this scenario.

While this book just didn't work for me, if you are a pro feminist who likes the hero being treated in such a manner, than you will probably enjoy how it develops. But this is not attractive to me in a romance and really bothered me on a fundamental level. I definitely plan on reading more of this author though, since I do enjoy her work, I just couldn't quite get on board with this story.
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
3,114 reviews111 followers
March 19, 2023
Joshua Sinclair is marvellous as the Sinclair Brother who’s known as the Horseman of War. He’s been on the Orkney Islands training Lord Robert’s men in defence. He’s going home for Samhain. When he meets Kara Flet the chief of her clan, all that changes. Joshua has never met anyone quite like Kara.
Profile Image for Barbee.
786 reviews21 followers
April 11, 2021

Book: Highland Warrior by Heather McCollum

Series: Sons of Sinclair, Book 2

Publisher: Entangled

Release Date: April 27, 2021

Overall Rating: 5/5 stars


True history: Robert Stuart/ Stewart is the 1st Earl of Orkney and Lord of Zetland was a recognised illegitimate son of James V, King of Scotland, and his mistress Eupheme Elphinstone.

Orkney Isle, Scotland
1589

The hero: Joshua Sinclair, was the second male born in his family and also known as the horseman of war. He had been trained by his father to put war before anything else, this was due his father grieving his mother’s loss. Now his father was dead and his brother is the clan chief: Joshua previously had been upset by the way his brother is leading their clan as the new chieftain, as Cain ( Book #1) he is bringing peace and solitude to the land instead of planning battles and war to rule all of Scotland. In this you see Joshua’s immaturity and bloodlust for warfare seeing how he only desires power and felt the Sinclair clan was powerful and strong enough to rule all of Scotland! Yet his brother the new Chief is seeing other peaceful alternatives and saving lives.

Unhappy Joshua leaves his clan to become a mercenary, training men for gold in other clans. His current assignment is in the Isle of Orkney, training Robert Stuart’s men to defend themselves and turning into warriors. Also since this was a noble clan Joshua had to be very careful or he could end up having his own head lopped off- due to Robert Stuart’s royal connections. As he is Uncle to King of Scotland King James VI and I.

Now Joshus was starting to see things from his eldest brother’s view especially after a young boy from a recent battle is killed. As his side supposedly won which was giving Joshua a bad taste for war! In addition, he had enough of working for this oppressing Earl, including training side by side with an enemy from his previous battle. This mercenary was nicknamed “the Brute” by the local islanders, but his real name is John Dishington, who never felt any remorse-no matter if it was a man or a child who was killed. It was definitely time for Joshua to leave this life and return to his family at Girnigoe Castle, at the mainland of Scotland.

The. heroine: Kára Flett daughter of murdered Norse King, who is young widow with a nine year old son, Geir. Tára’s son actually tries to steal Joshua’s warhorse, Fuil who loves turnips. She also knew Joshua Sinclair (Horseman of War) was the leader training Robert Stuart’s warriors to butcher her people, as if they hadn’t already done enough against them already!This includes taking their King! So luck comes calling as he comes to their deserted village tavern on his way home. As he wants to be home on the mainland of Scotland in Caithness, at Girnigoe Castle, for Samhain to honor loved ones who had died this year. Joshua wanted to honor his deceased father’s spirit for this occasion. So Kára comes up with an idea to seduce him and get her with a child. It was a way to connect him to her clan, as they are desperate as they recently took King Eric into custody not even knowing if he was dead or alive! Now she must convince him to stay and train her people so they can defend themselves. Robert Stuart and his warriors have destroyed Kára’s clan by starving them by stealing their food, livestock especially their horses and abducting their women. Now they are in ‘hiding and need someone to train them desperately! The problem is Robert has noble family connections which could bring war right to Clan Sinclair’s door. His clan could lose their castle, property and cherished horses. As this would be considered treason!

Joshua is immediately attracted to Kára and finds her very enthusiastic in bed, well she was actually the best bed partner he’s ever had and thinks she’s ruined him for other women. Yet he sees through her manipulation and he does not like being deceived and feels that is it exactly. He is disappointed feeling she is using him like so many other women. Until he realizes it is desperation as he did not realize how Robert Stuart has been mistreating and abusing her people not allowing them to hunt, forcing free labor on his grounds, abducting women, even their healer and stealing their livestock. The treatment of the islanders is horrible so he does show them self defense and makes an offer instead of fighting. Unfortunately that is what they really want for to lead them in this fight. Will he stay or leave? Has a women who never wants to wed captured his heart? Plus Kára as many in her clan wanted her to marry Torben who only wants her for her title. She feels nothing for him plus her heart has been closed since her husband died. Now she is very attracted to Joshua Sinclair besides knowing how to operate her body he seems to answer her mind too. So will she get him to stay or will he catch the next ship to Caithness? Will Kára’s heart be broken when he leaves? Has a warrior Queen finally captured the heart of the Horseman of War? What lengths these two will go to realize love really does conquer all!

This book totally captured my heart-a magnificent read from start to finish. I can’t recommend it enough. One of my favorite reads of 2021. Heather McCollum is one of my go to authors. I have read every book this author has written, but I must say I think “Highland Warrior” is my absolute favorite! Plus the lengths Joshua and Kára go through to save her people and try to find a better life is definitely mind blowing! This includes my favorite style of reading true history with a fictional romance and Robert Stuart, first Earl of Orkney was a real person in history who was an illegitimate son of King James V and had nine legitimate children, including many illegitimate children from mistresses, plus he treated the island people horribly. He definitely was a monster, so not the best role model for his children. So a big BRAVO to author, Heather McCollum for writing an incredible book that really touched this readers heart. Mòran taing which means many thanks in Scottish Gaelic.

This book is definitely one to put on the shelf keeper and to read again. It’s has all the elements that historical readers love from weaving true historical facts with an extraordinary fictional romance. Each chapter starts with a quote from ancient military strategist Sun Tzu. It was filled with a breathtaking setting and dialogue including superb characters but I think it was the plotting that gripped me the most. The plotting I felt was so inventive yet astonishing never knowing when the next bomb was going to explode or where. To me it was what made this book so much fun to read plus the chemistry between Joshua and Kára was off the charts! A book I definitely recommend and one readers do not want to miss!

I can’t wait and look forward for book #3 Gideon Sinclair ‘s story who is the Horseman of Justice.

Disclaimer: I received an advance reader’s copy from Entangled Publishing. I voluntarily agreed to do an honest, fair review and blog through netgalley. All thoughts, ideas and words are my own.

Pre-Order Links


https://www.amazon.com/Highland-Warri...

https://books.google.com/books/about/...

https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/high...

https://entangledpublishing.com/books...

https://www.kobo.com/us/es/ebook/high...

https://www.booktopia.com.au/highland...

https://books.apple.com/us/book/highl...
















Profile Image for Elodie’s Reading Corner.
2,554 reviews152 followers
April 25, 2021
Highland Warrior
Sons of Sinclair Series #2
Heather McCollum
https://www.facebook.com/HeatherMcCol...
Release Date 04/27/2021
Publisher Entangled Amara
https://www.amazon.fr/dp/B087ZY1XPX/r...

𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯

Joshua Sinclair was once the fiercest and most notorious warrior of the mighty Sinclair clan of Northern Scotland. But now there’s nothing and no one that can make him take up arms again. Except a beautiful woman, it seems.

When Kára Flett, daughter of a fallen Norse chief, finds herself unexpectedly sheltering the strongest, most brutal warrior in the land, she throws together a risky and outrageous plan to bring him to her side. Threats of violence bounce right off him. Offers of gold seem to entice him even less. Desperate enough to use the pleas of the village children to sway him, she’s shocked when he’s completely unmoved. There’s only one tactic left for her: seduction.

Her hasty proposition falls completely by the wayside, though, as she and the Highlander come together in a carnal inferno. But bringing him into her life also brings his enemies to her clan’s doorstep—the very clan Kára is trying to protect. And as their feelings deepen, Joshua will have to decide between duty and love once and for all.

𝗠𝘆 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄

Will she let her fear keep her away from love ...

I do think this is my second read by the author, and the first was the previous book in this series, which introduced the four horseman of apocalypse, well, four brothers their father raised to be the best in their predetermined role.
Joshua is known as the horseman of War, a title he wears proudly and effectively, he is one of the best at his job, he teaches others to defend and attack and when he leads an army, he always plans what to expect and even anticipates any disruption in his well planned schemes. Until one day, he acted too confident and let his guard down, which costed a young man his life. Since he has rethought the art of war. He now no more wants to run headlong in battle, he plots to minimize physical confrontation, to negotiate for fighting to be only the last recourse when everything failed before.
Kára has been shaped by the harsh life she was raised in, it is a costly life in term of being, but it is also what she has only known. So when she crosses path with the warrior known as the Horseman of War, she believes she has the answer to her people’s plight. Alas he won’t be swayed. So she uses all her arsenal, which is very much limited to only herself.
After an early widowhood and a premature birthing, she viscerally hates her liege and his kin for he is no good man, his offsprings follow his path, and use and abuse of their position on her people. But stopping his course is like warranting a death sentence. Yet Kára wants a different life for her son and her clan, but how to persuade a very determined man who wants the opposite of her.
Sure, it is a clash of temper, but as time passes, Joshua sees the other side of the border, how himself had been misled and unknowingly wronged the poor inhabitants of the land surrounding the Earl he worked for. But will his pull to Kára be enough to revisit his own rules.
The chemistry between them is over the top, and is well demonstrated along the plot, scorching many pages with the virulence of their attraction.

The author with this moving non stop action tale reach out to two fiery tempers in need of a shoulder to rest, as whatever they tell themselves, they let loneliness engulf them, and while they are surrounded, their heart had a fence built around to protect them from too deep emotions. But when what began as a basic affinity deepens during the time they get to know one another, what path will they choose, war or retreat...
5 stars

𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen detailed lovemaking scenes.

I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher Entangled, here is my true and unbiased opinion.

https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...

Profile Image for Kimberly.
2,305 reviews97 followers
April 25, 2021
Reviewed for Wit and Sin

Can the Horseman of War ever truly find peace? Joshua Sinclair is certainly going to try. He was raised by his father to be a warrior and to aid his clan in conquering Scotland. After disagreeing with his eldest brother in Highland Conquest, Joshua has set out on his own, training other warriors. But after truly seeing the cost of war Joshua is worn in spirit and looking for peace. It’s unlikely he’ll find it on Orkney Isle. After training the Lord Robert Stuart’s men to defend themselves against the locals, he sets off for home…only to find himself captivated by Kára Flett, Chief of the Orkney people. Kára will do anything to defend her people, including seducing and trying to sway the Horseman of War to her side. Joshua cannot be swayed by anyone. Who will win the battle of wills?

Heather McCollum had a bit of a hard task in Highland Warrior . Joshua was not the most likeable character in the first Sons of Sinclair book. Hot tempered and ready for war, I wasn’t sure he’d make a great hero. I was so glad I was wrong. The Joshua in this book is a wise warrior seeking peace. He has come into his own and is trying to do what’s best. He knows that isn’t working for the evil Lord Robert Stuart but he also knows he needs to extract himself diplomatically as the man is the king’s uncle.

Kára has known so much pain and loss and she still keeps fighting to protect her people. I loved her spirit and determination. She’s doing what she can to save her people and years of pillaging, death, and the threat of rape have not broken her. She and Joshua come together explosively at the beginning of the story and from there things only get more interesting. The two of them make a good pair – each of them is honest, strong, and protective by nature. They aren’t perfect, but they’re doing their best. I liked them together and their love story developed organically.

McCollum weaves fact and fiction together wonderfully in Highland Warrior . She also manages to keep this book moving at a fast pace despite the heavy topics and the threat Kára and her people are under – not an easy feat. I truly wasn’t sure how Kára and Joshua would make it out alive and though I won’t spoil it I will say McCollum made the ending feel earned. I finished Highland Warrior a well-satisfied reader and I’m looking forward to seeing what is coming for the next two Sinclair brothers.


FTC Disclosure: I received this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Profile Image for ✨Briana B..
95 reviews42 followers
April 25, 2021
3.5 stars

I enjoyed the story and the characters. At times though I was speed reading certain passages to get to the action.


I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Teresa.
1,390 reviews3 followers
February 16, 2021
**I received a copy of Highland Warrior from Entangled Publishing and Net Galley in exchange for a voluntary and honest review. My opinions are my own and not solicited in any way.**

Highland Warrior by Heather McCollum is the second book in her Sons of Sinclair series. This is Joshua Sinclair AKA Horseman of War and Kara Flett's story of war and love on the Isle of Orkney.
I love a good Highlander story but this one goes way beyond that showing the other side of Robert Stuart (Stewart) and his sons thirst for everything on Orkney including Kara. This book is well worth 5 stars and more.

Joshua Sinclair has grown tired of training Lord Robert Stuart plus he wants to go home before winter little does he know that when he stops a young boy from stealing his horse Fuil (Who loves turnips) he'd meet Kara Flett who desperately needs Joshua to help her train her people to fight against The Stuarts. They have taken not only stolen horses, but food and women but will he stay to help or go home to Scotland and his family? Joshua will fall in love with the strength the people of Hillside have when Henry attacks Kara on Samhain. When Kara's son is taken by the Stuart's can either of them trade their lives for a young child?

There will be surprise revelations in the ending that will have you cheering for the village and also for the men that realize Joshua's training also gave him friendship needs during a battle to see right from wrong.
Profile Image for Lady Whitbrooke.
406 reviews16 followers
April 27, 2023
I originally gave this 5 stars but after a re read, well I guess I was in a generous mood when I read the first time. 4 stars this go round but still good enough to read.

alpha males and sword fighting are your thing read on......I really liked this book. I feel like it was better than the first. The first missed the 🔥 in the relationship, this one, well it delivered. The story line was unique 8(1-10) steaminess 8(1–10). It was about a 4.5 star overall but I am rounding up!!!
Profile Image for Carole Burant.
1,277 reviews36 followers
February 23, 2021
This series, Sons of Sinclair, has quickly become one of my very favourite book series and we're only at Book 2!! Heather McCollum once again brings us on quite the adventure, this time on the Isle of Orkney where the Horseman of War, Joshua, meets Kara, the clan chief, and his life is forever changed.

I loved Joshua and Kara's characters, both so strong and wanting to do what is right for the people. She will do anything to convince him to help her and her clan fight the merciless Stuart family who have made their lives miserable. Having known nothing but war, Joshua suddenly finds himself wanting peace and a life with Kara. Their story is filled with danger, twists and turns and heated passions that will fill your heart with emotion. I laughed, I cried, held my breath and sighed....never a dull moment!!

I am still giggling at the one part when Joshua thinks of asking Brenna to neigh while giving birth....that's a scene that will forever stay in my mind, it was so hilarious:) Very well written and definitely a book worth reading, it has everything you'd ever want in a historical romance.

I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Profile Image for Tracy Emro.
2,129 reviews64 followers
April 20, 2021
After the death of his wife in childbirth, George Sinclair lost his mind to grief and believed that end of days were upon them, in his grief he declared his sons the Horsemen of the Apocalypse and raised them to fulfill their callings. This story is of his second-born son, Joshua, dubbed the Horseman of War.

After his elder brother married, Joshua left Girnigoe Castle in Scotland in search of war and in doing so, lost his desire to battle. He ended up on the Orkney Islands training the Earl of Orkney’s men to defend themselves from the local inhabitants, who resented Scotland’s acquisition of their lands. It wasn’t until after he began training that he realized Robert Stuart, the Earl of Orkney and his sons are cruel tyrants and after a few months, Joshua decides to leave and return to his family. But with close familial ties to King James, the earl is a powerful man and Joshua must withdraw carefully, making sure the earl doesn’t take offense and turn the King against the Sinclair clan. He makes his goodbyes and sets out to find passage back to Caithness. He makes his way to a village and enters a tavern, hoping to find a ship sailing out and lodging for the night, but what he finds is trouble – in the form of a beautiful woman.

When Kara Flett learns that the “Horseman of War” is the man in the tavern, she forms a plan to seduce him into helping her people fight against the earl. Since her uncle, King Erik was taken by Robert, her people have looked to her to lead them, but she knows the only way to defeat the earl is to have her people led by a true warrior and hopes that Joshua Sinclair will help them. After a dust-up with some locals trying to steal his horse, Kara takes Joshua back to her “den” to tend his wounds and they spend the night making love. The next morning, she asks him to lead her people against the earl – Joshua feels betrayed and used and refuses – mainly because he cannot risk the earl’s wrath against his family – as the illegitimate son of the previous king, the earl is the King James’ uncle and fighting against him could see his family ruined. But Kara doesn’t give up and asks him to meet her people. After seeing the conditions that they are forced to live in, Joshua offers them refuge with his family and agrees to train her men to defend themselves.

After consideration, many of the islanders agree to move to the mainland and join the Sinclair clan, including Kara. But after a run-in with Robert’s son Henry and the return of her uncle, everything changes and when her son is taken, she refuses to leave without saving him. Joshua knows he must save her son and he also knows that doing so will endanger his family – so he does the unthinkable and cuts ties with his clan to save Kara’s son. But things go from bad to worse and Joshua’s sacrifice may not be enough to save Kara from the earl’s ultimate wrath.

This was a well-written, fast-paced, amazing read and of all the books I have read by this author, this one might be my favorite. This book is a non-stop adventure from the first page to the last, it is filled with action, steamy love scenes, truly evil villains, amazing secondary characters, nail-biting fight scenes, shocking twists and turns, and an ending that is sure to bring a tear to your eye and a smile to your face! I loved this book, it was very intense, and to be completely honest, it is a bit more graphic and steamier than most of the books I have read by this author – that is not a complaint – more of a heads up to readers that might be sensitive to that sort of thing. This is the second book in the series, but it can be read and enjoyed as a standalone title and I highly recommend it!

*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that I requested and was provided to me by NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions in this review are my own. *
186 reviews
April 17, 2021
3.5 stars

Kara Flett, chief of her people, is trying to fight a losing battle against the Stuart family, who are trying to drive them off of their land in Orkney. But when Kara meets Joshua, the Horseman of War, she knows she needs him to help train her people to fight.

This book is full of action and romance. It was the first I have read by Heather McCollum and I enjoyed it. I was very invested in the main characters, but I found that I didn’t enjoy the way the dialogue was written. Overall though, this was a great story.
Profile Image for A Klue.
1,500 reviews326 followers
May 12, 2021
The Sons of Sinclair certainly have a lot to live up to, my fellow Scottish romance book loving friends. Thanks to their tough hearted daddy's expectations and the unusual declarations he assigned each of them at birth, they are saddled with some OTT big roles to play. Lucky for them (and us) they all are built like Thor and have the same swagger and attitude to back up those unusual labels.

In this instance, Joshua (Horseman of War) has it going on in more ways than I can count. What he wasn't counting on was falling for Kara, the determined clan leader desperate to save her people. We watch up close and personal this main couple's back and forth dance as they try to figure it all out. You'll have to decide for yourself if you think her tactic of seduction strategy was acceptable or not. It certainty set the stage for some verra hot, graphic smexy scenes. I'll keep most of my own musings on that matter to myself, folks, because though it was consensual it kind of belittled both of them in some aspects initially at least, IMHO.

I did ding the stars here a little for Kara not getting with the program fast enough and making what I felt seemed the obvious best choice right away. Sure, she had some pushing her to not grab such a generous life line, but I was dumbfounded at her initial hesitation.

With what appears to be a year between releases, I have to wait awhile to catch up with what Gideon (Horseman of Justice) will get into. Looks like a lovely MacKay law breaking lass is sure to shake up his world, folks.

Romance Safety Gang:

Title: Highland Warrior, Series: Sons of Sinclair (Book 2), Author: Heather McCollum, Pages: 400, pub date: 4/27/21, stand-alone but part of series, determined desperate clan leader heroine, widow married really young has kid heroine, loved her husband, afraid of loss heroine, Thor like hero, verra graphic smex scenes early on, romance safe enough for me, OM wants to marry her, evil villain.

Book 1 - Highland Conquest (Cain), 4/28/20
Book 2 - Highland Warrior (Joshua), 4/27/21
Book 3 - Highland Justice (Gideon), 4/26/22

(I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced reader copy of this book via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own. I was not compensated for this review. There is no relationship or affiliation between this reviewer and the author, publisher, NetGalley, or any PR firm.)
Profile Image for NhaughtyV says Damn the Zon Save the Reviews .
1,289 reviews194 followers
March 4, 2021
“I love you. I need you to know that. I could not imagine the pain of dying without being able to tell you what I have only now discovered in my heart.”

Joshua Sinclair was War incarnate, the second Horseman of the Apocalypse…at least that was what his father raised him to believe. Growing restless, Joshua leaves his home and Clan Sinclair behind to seek out those in need of his talents to train men for battle. But this fierce warrior’s world is about to turn on it’s axis when he stumbles upon a Norse beauty and queen of her people who offers him a night of pleasure that in turn becomes a temptation to help break her people free from the tyranny of the Stewarts.

When setting out to teach the tactics of war, Joshua has met his match in the fair Kara Flett. But when her life is put in jeopardy, there is no fiercer foe than a highlander’s sword and his thirst for vengeance, and if that highlander just happens to be one of the fabled Horseman, let it be known there is no force on earth that will deter the mighty Joshua Sinclair from protecting what is his…“He had never seen anything so beautiful before in his life. He would battle a million wars to keep them safe, or sail a thousand seas to take them to safety, or build a hundred castles to protect them.”

*Happy Dancing* Oh dear Reader, I am sooooo excited that Heather McCollum has returned to her Sons of Sinclair series! These four brothers have been raised by their father believing they are nonother than the four Horseman of the Apocalypse, and each of their stories thus far have matched the hero with a lover that is off the charts in chemistry, and offers them a happily ever after they never dared dreamed to receive. “Love was risky. It could tear one apart, but it could also build one into a mountain of strength. It made life sweeter, brighter, and so worth living.”

While this is the second in the series, it is written well enough to be read standalone with no cliffhangers. If you are a fan of highland romances, I can’t recommend this author enough! Loved loved loved Joshua’s story and sooooo looking forward to the next installment!



**I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book that I received via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own. **
Profile Image for Abigail.
114 reviews1 follower
December 26, 2021
4.5/5

First off, what is up with the horses? They just care so much about the horses, which is not a bad thing, but I just found it a weird quirk of the books and it made the books unique in their own sense.

Wow the names in this book were beautiful and I loved the meaning behind them. Kara means love and Joshua is biblical meaning Jehovah is salvation which I felt really represented their characters in the book. Kara does everything she can for her clan and Joshua being the Horseman of War. Also the attention to every little detail was phenomenal. I felt like I was in 1590 Scotland and I don’t normally feel like this with a book. Plus there were these little hilarious jests that were just delightfully thrown in that would bring in light to a dark situation.

Probably the best thing about this book is that you really see Joshua grow up in a sense. In Highland Conquest, you saw him as very war-hungry and just wanting to jump into battle. However in Highland Warrior, we see him actually trying to move away from war, wanting to go back to his family. I thought that McCollum did such an amazing job on transitioning his character between the two books and his character growth was on point.

Then there was the instant connection between the two characters from the moment they meet until the very end. They were a very refreshing couple and I liked that Kara never gave up on him.

Last thing I am mentioning is the quotes and research. Every chapter at the beginning included quotes from The Art Of War by Sun Tzu. This was a nice little touch that I felt really tied into the book bringing it a lot of character. And the amount of research that went into this book was incredible. At the end it included the true story behind it and the language was just beautiful. This all just made the book tie together oh so perfectly.

Thank you to Entangled Publishing for allowing me to read this advanced copy.
Profile Image for Emily.
276 reviews8 followers
February 18, 2021
So, this is my first foray into the Scottish Highlander historical romance genre...and I am not disappointed. This is a fun, sexy book. I also like the historical time it's set in. Joshua and Kara's relationship is very insta-lust, and I'm here for it. But once you get beyond that, I love that they talk to each other and care about what the other needs, and are able to work through the political situation they are in. The author keeps you captivated and you start to really care for the characters and the situation they are in. I look forward to reading more from this author and more in this genre
Profile Image for Alison.
852 reviews5 followers
March 8, 2021
Highland Warrior
Sons of Sinclair #2
Heather McCollum
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Joshua Sinclair is the second brother of the mighty Sinclair clan of Northern Scotland, and has been raised to love war above all else. He is not happy with his eldest brother who is the new chief as his brother is bringing peace to the land so he decides to be a mercenary on Orkney Island spending months helping Robert Stuart train his men.

Kara Flett desperately needs Joshua's help. She needs his help to train her people to fight against the mighty Stuart's. Robert Stuart and his sons have taken everything from Kara's people and that includes food, horses, and women. The problem is the people don't know how to fight so if Kara can get Joshua to stay and train her people they will at least have a fighting chance.

Will Kara be able to convince the mighty Horseman of war to stay and train her people or will they forever be abused by the Stuart's?

What happens next not only shocked me it had me reading long into the night.

Heather McCollum is absolutely unmatched. This book is fabulous. I don't know another historical romance author who can do what this author does. Ms. McCollum pens a book that is rich with history yet has an air of lightness. I must tell you I was giggling from almost the start when Brenna had her baby. I could not believe what I was reading. I felt like I had traveled back through time and sat on the side lines watching the best movie I could ever have the privilege of watching. Joshua was amazing. He was strong yet light hearted. With a quick smile for those he liked. Kara was every girl's heroine. She was brave and would sacrifice herself in a flash if it meant saving one of her people. All of the characters in this book will forever hold a special place in my heart. She also had no problem drugging Joshua and stealing his clothes and weapons if it meant keeping him on Orkney to help her people. This has been the best book of the year and I can't wait to see what the next Sinclair brother gets up to. Thank you Ms. McCollum for bringing us a book that took me away from my daily life.
Profile Image for Jaime.
1,804 reviews310 followers
April 12, 2021
3 When the Lamb opened the second seal, I heard the second living creature say, “Come!”
  4 Then another horse came out, a fiery red one. Its rider was given power to take peace from the earth and to make people kill one another. To him was given a large sword. 


Joshua Sinclair has lived his life embracing and being one of the biblical Four Horsemen since his mother’s death pushed his father into a grief induced belief that his four sons were the Apocalyptic Four Horsemen from The Book of Revelations. Joshua was deemed The Horsemen of War and was raised to live and breathe all things war. After a disagreement with his older brother Cain, at the end of Book 1 Highland Conquest Joshua sets out on his own for some soul searching or hell raising-whichever he finds first.

His travels bring him to The Orkney Isles where he spends some time training Robert Stuart’s warriors in the Art of War. When he is ready to leave and head back to Caithness where The Sinclair clan resides he stops in a small tavern seeking a warm bed, warm food, and a shelter for his horse, fuil. He doesn’t anticipate meeting the dróttning—chief/queen of the small clan who have been tormented by Robert Stuart, and he surely doesn’t anticipate that he will end up in one of the most important battles of his life. Thank goodness The Horseman of War is always ready to fight and knows when to battle physically, mentally, or both - he may now learn the hardest part of war, when to surrender or retreat.

I really enjoyed this story. The characters and the situations they find themselves in range from humorous to sensual. Joshua is perfectly matched with his dróttning - two fierce warriors who go into every situation like it may be their last. The passion and chemistry between these two was pretty hot and it was nice to not have a fair maiden as the female MC. This book is part of a series, and I guess you could get away with reading it without book one, but I recommend reading the series in order.

Now, I have to patiently wait for the next book in the series....I do really enjoy this authors writing and have read most of her books.

5 Stars for this Highland Warrior—I mean any man from 1589 who can help deliver a baby, deserves 5 stars!!!
Profile Image for The Reading Devil.
162 reviews
March 13, 2021
Review is up on my blog! http://thereadingdevil.blogspot.com/2...

Or read below!

I've been getting right into the historical romance genre lately, and so when I saw this I knew it was something I wanted to read. I was right! This was a fun, sexy read with lots of layers and twists that I wasn't expecting. While this is technically part of a series, it's definitely one that you can read out of order as each book is based on different main characters and written well enough that you don't really feel like you are missing things.

I am new to Heather McCollum, but I must say I am impressed! I thoroughly enjoyed the style of her writing, and loved all of the different elements she was able to incorporate into this book. It was funny, sensual, serious when it needed to be, and just had a really nice overall feeling to it.

The book starts with Joshua leaving Robert Stuart's castle after training his men to fight and guard it. Joshua is on his way home when he meets Kara who decides after seeing him that she must get his help to train her people to fight Robert's tyranny. The book continues with Kara trying to convince Joshua to stay and help the people of Hillside.

I loved the sense of community we see from the people of Hillside - it felt so real and special! They were small in number, but large in heart.

Kara Flett was the main female lead in this book and I found her to be such a great character. She was fiercely loyal to her people and willing to do whatever necessary to save them from Robert Stuart's tyranny. Joshua himself was absolutely hilarious, yet also intimidating and very straightforward. I loved that he always said exactly what came to mind and didn't give a hoot what those around him thought. He was sexy and bold, ruthless when necessary yet a bit of a softie at the same time. It was a great combination and written really well.

The humor thrown into the book was really well placed - it was always at just the right time, and said in just the right way. I found myself snorting out loud in public and getting the oddest looks lol. I always love it when a book can do that, and take me completely off guard! Very interested to read other books by Heather now as I quite enjoyed this one. I will likely start with the first Sons of Sinclair book and then go from there! Definitely recommend it to anyone who loves romance with a Scottish twist xD
Profile Image for Danielle Bush.
1,922 reviews23 followers
March 10, 2021
I didn't think I could love this book as much as the first one.. Joshua was not my favorite person at the end of the last book.. and boy was I wrong. Heather McCollum did an amazing job of turning in to a person we could all root for.

Joshua has changed alot in this book, after a battle that left him feeling hollow he has decided that fighting isn't the only option.
Joshua has recently been training Lord Roberts men on the best way to defend themselves if they are attacked.. and now hes tired of them.. all he wants to do is go home and see his family.

When he stops for the night he meets Kara, who is a strong independant woman, and the leader of her people. She recognizes who Joshua is right away and starts doing her best to convince him to lead her people againt Robert and his horrible sons.

Joshua and Kara have immediate chemistry, and when he finds out the truth about what has been happening to Karas people he decideds that he will help them stay alive.. Kara will do anything in her power to protect her family and people, and her hope is that Joshua will just lead an army against Roberts. However Joshua knows that no matter how well he trains Karas men, that alot of people will die.. Good people on both sides. All he wants to do talk Kara and her people into coming home with him to Scotland where they can be free, have plenty of food, and be protected by the Sinclair clan.
.
This book has alot of really great steamy moments, and alot of action. and some really great fight scenes. it was just really wonderfully written.. There werent any moments that I wanted to skim or skip over.. I needed to read every single word, and not miss anything that was happening..
.
I absolutely cant wait for Gideons book next and see the woman that he will fall in love with..
.

.
Profile Image for Janet.
5,185 reviews64 followers
April 23, 2021
Joshua Sinclair known as The Horseman of War was once the fiercest and most notorious warrior of the mighty Sinclair clan of Northern Scotland. But now there’s nothing and no one that can make him take up arms again. He travels to Orkney & trains Robert Stuart’s men how to defend the castle if attacked. However he’s disillusioned & leaves to travel home for Samhain. When Kára Flett, leader of some local inhabitants, throws together a risky and outrageous plan to bring him to her side. Threats of violence bounce right off him. Offers of gold seem to entice him even less. Desperate enough to use the pleas of the village children to sway him, she’s shocked when he’s completely unmoved. There’s only one tactic left for her: seduction. Her hasty proposition falls completely by the wayside, though, as she and the Highlander come together in a carnal inferno.
This is the second book in the series & is very easily read on its own. Talk about action packed! It starts at a canter & very soon is galloping to the conclusion, the pages just flew by. I loved the chemistry between Joshua & Kara which was intense & electric. The author does a wonderful job of painting a picture not only of how Kara’s people had to live & the hardships they endured, but of the cruelty a power mad harsh despot could inflict. The characters have depth & you either love them or loath them. In places it's not a comfortable read but it's an engrossing one & I can't wait for the rest of the series. I’m so glad I started this early in the day as no way could I put it down
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Profile Image for Nicole Pelcher.
158 reviews14 followers
November 11, 2022
I didn't like Joshua in the first book so I was nervous going into this... but he surprised me and now I love him.

Joshua was raised to believe himself as the Horseman of War sent from God. Weary of waring he plans to head home. Enter Kara Flett. Desperate to save her dying people she catches Joshua before he can set sail... and she will do anything to convince him to fight for them.

I loved seeing two very strong characters slowly become soft for eachother. Their relationship started very quick and physical fast but throughout the novel they gain more affection and love for eachother.

There is a lot of talk of war in this one (obviously) but not simply in a 'conquer everyone' sort of way. For the Horseman of War he learns that sometimes war isn't the right choice.

Received a copy via NetGalley & the Publisher in preparation for the release of the third novel. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Kathreadsall.
482 reviews17 followers
March 4, 2021
LOVED this historical romance from Heather McCollum!

Joshua is a alpha warrior male, but still kind to the ones he loves. I enjoyed seeing his character growth as he comes to see the truth of what is happening to this land, and makes decisions that will alter his future forever.

I love him with Kara, and I enjoyed having a female lead that is brave and loving. She connects with him and really grows to care for him, and the steamy bits were fabulous.

It had a ton of historical detail, which is great, but I read my romance novels for the romance, so I sometimes felt like it was a bit of an info dump about kings and clans. But still a fantastic and engaging novel!

Thank you Entangled Publishing and Netgalley for this ebook arc in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Margaret.
3,211 reviews33 followers
May 9, 2022
4 1/2 STARS*
Joshua is one of four clan Sinclair brothers named for the four horsemen. He is the Horseman of War. Taking his name as his creed, he never loses in battle. Hired for his fighting ability, he trains soldiers to defend themselves. When seduced to help the people of Orkney Isle fight against Robert Stuart and his castle, Joshua hesitates to start a war. The beautiful woman who entices him will put her life first to protect her people. Can he do any less for the woman he loves? Passionate sexual encounters from the beginning set the relationship between Joshua and Kara amid a violent life of survival. Great read for fans of Scottish medieval romance.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.
Profile Image for Franjessca.
1,693 reviews97 followers
October 25, 2024
Last year, I discovered my passion for Scottish Highlander romance books, thanks to Maya Banks. Since then, I’ve wanted to explore this subgenre further. Earlier this year, I discovered Heather McCollum and her works at a book convention, which led me to dive into her Sons of Sinclair series. I thoroughly enjoyed the first book in the series and was eager to read the second book, Highland Warrior.

Highland Warrior focuses on Joshua Sinclair, who is known to his clan as the fiercest and strongest warrior who is always called into battle, but lately, he craves peace and no longer wants to participate in wars. However, the heroine Kara Flett, who he ends up meeting, wants to convince him to fight in a battle against the lord who claims to rule over her and her people. This is the same lord that Joshua just helped with his own battle, but Joshua is not easily convinced to assist Kara. Kara is determined to win him over, even if it means seducing him.

One of my favorite types of characters is the alpha male, and Joshua was definitely one of those types. I enjoyed reading about his character development, particularly his transformation from a warrior who longed for peace after years of fighting for others. I can’t entirely blame him, especially given how many people used him for his skills, including the heroine of the story, whom I didn’t particularly like. Yes, I had a major problem with Kara the whole time I was reading this book. She knew Joshua didn’t want to get involved, but she kept manipulating him into fighting, and eventually, he caved.

I understood why Kara needed Joshua because she was only trying to help her people, especially being a single mother who lost her husband, but she should have respected Joshua’s wishes. I also didn’t like how she didn’t take his advice and did it her own way, which ended up always going the wrong way. She put herself, Joshua, as well as others in danger.

Another thing that bothered me was I wasn’t convinced about the romantic relationship between Joshua and Kara. I don’t mind reading instant love stories, but as long as I’m convinced both characters are in love with one another. I felt the whole time that Kara only used Joshua and it bothered me the entire time.

Joshua was definitely the main reason I enjoyed this book, along with some of the secondary characters. While the plot kept me engaged and interested, it didn’t grip me the same way the first book did. Overall, I give this book three stars, and I do plan on reading the third book because I’m determined to find out more about the Sinclair family.

Single/Dual POV: Dual POV.

Standalone or Part of Series: It’s an interconnected standalone in the Sons of Sinclair Series.

Would I recommend this book? Even though I rated it low, other readers might enjoy it more. I recommend this book to fans of Heather McCollum and those who enjoy Scottish Highlander romances.

What to Expect:
✓Scottish Highlander Romance
✓Instant Love/Lust
✓Single Mother Romance
✓Widower/Single Mother Heroine
✓Alpha/Warrior Hero
Profile Image for Lori D.
4,080 reviews129 followers
April 30, 2021
Orkney Isle off the Northern Coast of Scotland 1589
Once again, I feel like I have taken a journey to this time and place as Heather weaves her story with her historical knowledge, descriptions and characters that I could see in my mind. Joshua and his warhorse Fuill especially came alive. "Yet he walked forward with only a sash from the end of his kilt over his bare chest.. with tattoos around his muscular arms and across his back. The dark swirls on his arm in the shape of a horse... Joshua was War incarnate, the second Horseman of the Apocalypse, sent from God, to rage and win against his foes."

Joshua had just ended his training of Robert Stuart's men and he was glad to see the last of them. What he didn't expect was running into Kara, who needed him to help save her people of Orkney from the same man he had just left. The attraction between them was like lightning and her plan to seduce him into helping her seemed like it might come to fruition.

Full of emotion, betrayal, secrets, an evil villain, and two people who come together in not the best of circumstances but need each other. I really want to tell you the entire story, but you will just have to read for yourself! This is truly one of my favorite books of the year and I cannot wait for the next in this series!
Profile Image for Cathy Geha.
4,344 reviews118 followers
May 1, 2021
Highland Warrior by Heather McCollum
Sons of Sinclair #2


In days of old
When men were bold
And women even bolder

Came a warrior
To an island
To train soldiers on that land

A fair woman
To save her men
Asked said warrior for a hand

Is he swayed?
Does he help?
Or will he leave them to their fate?


What I liked:
* Kára: strong, smart, steadfast, capable, warrior, widow, mother, leader – great partner for Joshua.
* Joshua: disillusioned, homesick, lethal, warrior, proud, seeking peace, honorable, brother, HOT – great partner for Kára.
* The setting
* That the story was based around historical figures and could have taken place in history
* The idea of underground living as a way to avoid capture
* The outsmarting of the Stuarts
* The horses – hope to see more of them
* The birth scenes and the new way of birthing that I was introduced to
* That Kára was able to defend herself fairly well even against odds that were against her
* The strategic moves and plans that were made to free a kidnapped soul or two and also to save a “couple”.
* Knowing that there are at least two more books in the series to look forward to.

What I didn’t like:
* The Stuarts…all of them…deserve all that happened to them in the book…and in history
* The oppression of people…and knowing it still happens in some parts of the world today
* Having to wait for the next book in the series

Did I like this book? Yes
Would I read more in this series? Definitely

Thank you to NetGalley and Entangled Publishing for the ARC – This is my honest review.

5 Stars
Profile Image for Shelagh.
1,792 reviews25 followers
May 11, 2021
Second in Heather McCollum’s Sons of Sinclair series, Highland Warrior is set largely on Orkney north of mainland Scotland in the year 1589. While this is a romance it is also a story about good triumphing over evil as Joshua Sinclair, Horseman of War, helps Kára Flett lead her people out from under the thumb of tyrannical Robert Stuart and his family. Joshua and Kára are strong characters, both passionate about their beliefs and determined to protect what is dear to them. I couldn’t help but cheer them on as their story unfolded. I loved the attention to detail in this story. The clothing, housing and food all felt very appropriate to the historical period and location as did the weaponry and fighting methods described. I also liked the Sun Tsu thread that carried through the book. It provided a very clever hint at what might be motivating Joshua’s actions. This is the first book I’ve read in this series but it’s intrigued me. It certainly kept me turning the pages as fast as I could so I’m now off to read book one while I wait for book three to come out. If you love good, powerful Scottish historical romance then this book is very definitely for you.
Profile Image for Lady Tea.
1,796 reviews126 followers
February 18, 2025
Rating: *yawns* / 5

So...yeah. I'm not a fan of romances where the hero/heroine already has a child, especially if that's not explained in the summary.

Also, Joshua is exactly what I expected, no more and no less: the big "grr, action, fight, muscles" man that I thought he was from book 1.

For the time being, I'm officially turned off this author as being my cuppa tea in terms of writing style, etc., and therefore will be skipping and passing on another chance for her works in the foreseeable future.
Profile Image for Carol lowkey.bookish.
917 reviews20 followers
April 10, 2022
3.5 rounded up

This was not my favorite in the Sons of Sinclair series. The hero and heroine are interesting characters and the romance scenes are as steamy as I expected. However, I didn’t care for the amount of time the book covered preparing for a battle and the battle itself.

Overall a perfectly steamy novel with interesting characters and excellent setting.

I received a complementary copy of this book from the publisher.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 153 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.